Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-119

1983-119Kanag

Full text

August 9, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 119
Fred W. Johnson
Labette County Counselor
1712 Broadway
Parsons, Kansas 67357
Re: Taxation--Mortgage Registration--Instruments
Subject Thereto and Exemptions Therefrom
Synopsis: (1) A mortgage registration fee must be collected
before any mortgage of real property can be filed
for record in the register of deeds' office.
(2) An executory contract for the sale of real
property which has the characteristics described
in K.S.A. 79-3101 is a mortgage of real property
for purposes of the mortgage registration fee
statutes. Consequently, no such contract can be
filed of record without payment of a mortgage
registration fee. Moreover, since the law does
not permit that to be done by indirection which
cannot be done directly, a document, which incor-
porates by reference, or which gives notice of the
existence of the provisions of an executory contract
for the sale of real property, cannot be filed of
record without payment of a mortgage registration
fee on the executory contract, unless such document
is an affidavit of equitable interest as described
in K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102(5).
(3) To qualify for exemption under K.S.A. 1982
Supp. 79-3102(5), an instrument must be: (A)
an affidavit; (B) signed and sworn to (or affirmed)
by a purchaser of real property under an executory
contract having the characteristics described in
K.S.A. 79-3101; and (C) given solely for the purpose
of providing notification by a purchaser of real
property under an executory contract for the sale
of real property of his or her interest in the
real property.
(4) A written instrument which gives notice of
a purchaser's equitable interest in real property
and which also creates a lien on that equitable
interest is not an instrument described in the
fifth exemption of K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102.
Such an instrument is not given solely for the
purpose of giving notice of a purchaser's equitable
interest in real property.
(5) Since the exemption provided for in K.S.A.
1982 Supp. 79-3102(5) is available only to a
purchaser of real property under an executory
contract for the sale of real property having the
characteristics described in K.S.A. 79-3101, the
exemption is not available to a person who lends
money to a purchaser of real property under an
executory contract for the sale of real property
and claims a lien on the purchaser's interest in
the real property as security for repayment of the
money loaned.
(6) If an instrument by which the purchaser of real
property under an executory contract for the sale
of real property mortgages his or her interest in
the real property references the executory contract
through which the purchaser acquired his interest
in the property, instead of referencing an affidavit
of equitable interest filed by such purchaser, then
the instrument cannot be filed of record without a
mortgage registration fee being paid on both the
mortgage thereby created and on the executory con-
tract through which the purchaser acquired his in-
terest in the real property.
(7) A mortgage of real property may secure both
current indebtedness and future advances. However,
a mortgage of real property which contains a future
advances clause secures only the maximum amount stated
in the mortgage. Consequently, the mortgage reg-
istration fee due on any such mortgage should be
based upon the maximum amount stated in the mortgage.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 58-2221, 58-2336, 79-3101,
K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102, K.S.A. 79-3107.
Dear Mr. Johnson:
You seek our opinion on whether certain written instruments may
be filed of record in the real estate records of the Labette
County Register of Deeds' office, without payment of the
mortgage registration fee. The instruments about which you
inquire involve purchasers of real property under executory
contracts for the sale of real property and financial institutions
that have lent money to those purchasers. One of the instruments
is entitled: "AFFIDAVIT OF EQUITABLE INTEREST IN REAL ESTATE."
It provides, among other things, that if two individuals:
"are unable to complete the financial
transaction for purchase . . . [of certain
real property, the legal description of
which is given], and fall into default
as specified in the purchase contract for
said property; [sic] they assign all rights
held by them necessary to complete said
purchase to . . . [a bank, on whose sta-
tionery these provisions are typed] and
further agree to allow the . . . Bank to
take over any and all pertinent portions
of the contract and agrees [sic] to support
said Bank in any efforts of this endeavor.
"Any interest . . . [the individual purchasers]
may have in the above described real estate
is further assigned and pledged to the . . .
Bank. This interest in the property is pledged
for collateral securing a loan that had pro-
ceeds used for improvements on said property."
(Emphasis added.)
Although entitled "Affidavit of Equitable Interest," this document
does not contain a certification by an appropriate public official
that the statements made therein were given under oath or affir-
mation. Consequently, this document is not an affidavit.
The other instruments about which you inquire are companion
documents which were prepared as part of a single transaction
whereby a lending institution loaned money to a husband and
wife who, prior to obtaining this loan, had entered into an exec-
utory contract for the sale of real property as the purchasers
thereof. Apparently, as a condition of making the loan, the
financial institution required the borrowers to sign a document
entitled: "CONDITIONAL ASSIGNMENT OF VENDEE'S INTEREST IN REAL
ESTATE CONTRACT FOR SALE AND PURCHASE OF REAL ESTATE."
This instrument, in part, provides that, for value received,
the purchasers of the real property "conditionally assign, transfer
and set over," to the financial institution, "all of their right,
title and interest in and to the certain real estate contract,"
dated on a specified date and covering certain real property
which is described. The instrument then prescribes that the
assignment is executed and delivered to the financial institution
"as collateral security to secure indebtedness now due by the
undersigned and to secure such future advancements as may be
made from time to time" to the borrowers.
The other document submitted for filing is captioned "AFFIDAVIT
OF INTEREST." It is a sworn statement by an employee of the
financial institution that the financial institution is "the
conditional equitable purchaser" of the real estate described
in the "Conditional Assignment of Vendee's Interest" (i.e., the
real property being purchased under contract by the borrowers),
and that the affidavit:
. . . is given for the purpose of providing
notification that . . . [the financial insti-
tution] has a conditional equitable interest
in the real estate described above arising by
reason of the conditional assignment . . . of
the interest of Purchaser(s) . . . ." (Emphasis
added.)
This document concludes with a signed, sealed statement by a
notary public that the document was subscribed, sworn to, and
acknowledged before her.
The financial institutions that have tendered these documents
for filing claim that these documents may be filed without pay-
ment of a mortgage registration fee because these instruments are
affidavits of equitable interest and thus come within the fifth
exemption of K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102. You question the claim
of the financial institutions and believe that these instruments
cannot be filed of record without a mortgage registration fee
being paid. You are uncertain, however, as to the amount of
mortgage registration fee that should be paid in regard to these
instruments and ask us to give our opinion on this matter. In
addition, you inquire, generally, as to what constitutes an
affidavit of equitable interest under the provisions of K.S.A.
1982 Supp. 79-3102(5).
Before considering your inquiries under the provisions of the
mortgage registration fee statutes, K.S.A. 79-3101 et sr. / we
feel obliged to first call your attention to K.S.A. -58 - 221.
This statute specifies those instruments affecting real property
which may be filed of record in the real estate records of the
register of deeds' office. The statute, in relevant part,
provides:
"Every instrument in writing that conveys
real property . . . or whereby any real
estate may be affected, proved or acknowl-
edged, and certified in the manner herein-
before prescribed, may be recorded in the
office of the register of deeds of the
county in which such real estate is sit-
uated . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
On numerous occasions, the Kansas Supreme Court has held that,
under the provisions of this statute, only written instruments
that convey or affect real estate, and which are acknowledged or
proved, and certified as required by law are eligible for
filing in the real estate records. See, e.g., Assembly of God v.
Sangster, 178 Kan. 678, 682 (1955) and Horney v. Buffenbarger,
169 Kan. 342 (1950) and the cases cited therein at 347-348.
We note that the document entitled "Affidavit of Equitable
Interest" does not meet the requirements of K.S.A. 58-2221.
Thus, this document is not eligible for recording, even if a
mortgage registration fee in regard thereto is tendered.
Having mentioned this related matter, we turn our attention to
the provisions of the mortgage registration fee statutes. In
K.S.A. 79-3101, the term "mortgage of real property" is defined
as follows:
"The words 'mortgage of real property'
shall include every instrument by which
a lien is created or imposed upon real
property, notwithstanding that the debt
secured thereby may also be secured by
a lien upon personal property. An
executory contract for the sale of real
estate, or a bond for a deed, the complete
performance of which is deferred for a
longer period than ninety days from its
execution, under which the grantee or
vendee is entitled to the possession of
such real estate, by the terms of which
the grantor holds the legal title as
security for the unpaid purchase money,
shall for the purpose of this act be
treated as a mortgage of real property to
secure the balance of the unpaid purchase
price." (Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102, in part, provides:
"Before any mortgage of real property, or
renewal or extension of the same shall be
received and filed for record there shall
be paid to the register of deeds of the
county in which such property or any part
thereof is situated, a registration fee
of twenty-five cents (250) for each one
hundred dollars ($100) and major fraction
thereof, of the principal debt or obligation
which is secured by such mortgage, and upon
which no prior registration fee has been
paid. As used herein 'principal debt or
obligation' shall not include any finance
charges or interest." (Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 79-3107 provides:
"Any mortgage of real property executed
on or after March 1, 1925, on which the
registration fee as herein provided has
not been paid, shall not be filed for
record by any register of deeds, and such
mortgage shall not be received in evi-
dence in any suit, action or proceedings,
and no judgment, decree or order for the
enforcement thereof shall be rendered,
made or entered in or by any court in this
state." (Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102, after providing for the imposition
of the mortgage registration fee, prescribes five exemptions
from payment thereof. This portion of the statute, in part,
provides:
"No registration fee whatsoever shall be
paid, collected or required for or on any
mortgage or other instrument . . . (5) given
in the form of an affidavit of equitable
interest solely for the purpose of providing
notification by the purchaser of real property
of his or her interest therein."
In Attorney General Opinion No. 81-180, we concluded that this
fifth exemption was added to the statute in order to provide a
means whereby a purchaser of real property under an executory
contract for the sale of real property could give notice of his
or her equitable interest in the real property, without being
required to pay a mortgage registration fee. Also, in Attorney
General Opinion No. 82-207, we concluded that the affidavit of
equitable interest provided for in K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102(5)
must be given by the purchaser of real property under an executory
contract for the sale of real property, and cannot be given by
the seller or some other person who is not the purchaser. Id.
at Synopsis. We adhere to our prior opinions and now emphasize
that the fifth exemption clause of K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102(5)
applies only to an affidavit subscribed and sworn to (or affirmed)
by a purchaser of real property under an executory contract for
the sale of real property having the characteristics described
in K.S.A. 79-3101. Additionally, we think the language of K.S.A.
1982 Supp. 79-3102(5) is quite clear in requiring that the purchaser
of real property give the affidavit "solely for the purpose of
providing notification . . . of his or her interest therein."
(Emphasis added.)
The provisions of this clause of the statute provide an exemption
from taxation. Consequently, those provisions must be construed
strictly. See Meadowlark Hills, Inc. v. Kearns, 211 Kan. 35,
Syl. $2 (1973) and First Nat'l Bank v. Lovitt, 158 Kan. 535,
Syl. $1 (1944). As a result, this clause must be construed
as providing that the affidavit is to be given exclusively for
the purpose of giving the notice specified therein. If the af-
fidavit provides notice of anything else, it does not meet the
requirements of this clause, and may not be recorded without pay-
ment of a mortgage registration fee.
Applying these principles to the documents about which you
inquire, it will be noted that while the document entitled
"Affidavit of Equitable Interest" is subscribed by the purchasers
of real property under an executory contract for the sale of
real property, the document is not limited to giving notice
of those purchasers' interest in the real property being purchased.
Thus, it does not meet the "single-purpose" requirement of
K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102(5).
The other document, entitled "Affidavit of Interest" is sub-
scribed and sworn to by a person acting as an agent for a
lending institution. The lending institution, however, is not
purchasing the real property described in the document under an
executory contract for the sale of real property having the
characteristics described in K.S.A. 79-3101. Thus, this document
is not the affidavit of a purchaser of real property under an
executory contract and, therefore, is not within the exemption
provided in K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102(5).
In fact, we share your opinion that these documents are nothing
more than attempts to give notice of a lien claimed by lend-
ing institutions, without said institutions paying the mortgage
registration fee. Other such attempts are revealed in cases
decided by the Kansas Supreme Court. See, e.g., Assembly of God v.
Sangster, supra, holding that an instrument entitled "Certified
Bond Resolution" was, for purposes of the mortgage registration
fee, a mortgage of real property, and National Bank of Tulsa v.
Warren, 177 Kan. 281 (1955), holding that an instrument entitled
Collateral Assignment of Production Payment," likewise, was a
mortgage of real property.
In Sangster, supra, the Court explained:
"Notwithstanding the fact there is a
statute (G.S. 1949, 67-303) [now K.S.A.
58-2303] which sets out a 'short form' of
mortgage, it has been held that in order
to create a mortgage contract no particular
'form' of instrument is necessary and no
particular words are required. The 'form'
of an agreement by which security is given
is unimportant if the purpose plainly
appears. All that is necessary is that
there be a debt and that the instrument
creates a lien on real property as security
for the payment of the debt. [Citations
omitted.]
"As already shown, the statute (G.S. 1949,
79-3101 [now, K.S.A. 79-3101] defines a
mortgage of real property as including
every instrument 'by which a lien is created
or imposed upon real property.'
"The word 'lien' has been variously defined
as being a hold or claim which one has upon
the property of another as security for a
debt or charge, as a tie that binds property
to a debt or claim for its satisfaction, as
a right to possess and retain property until
a charge attaching to it is paid or discharged,
as a charge imposed upon specific property
by which it is made security for the perform-
ance of an act, and as being synonymous with
a charge or encumbrance upon a thing. [Cita-
tions omitted.]" (Emphasis added.) 178
Kan. at 680.
Thus, we believe it settled that, in any financial transaction
involving the creation of a debt and in which the lender, through
any written instrument, claims a lien on real property in which
the debtor has an interest, the written instrument, regardless
of what it is called, is a mortgage of real property for purposes
of the mortgage registration fee. The documents about which you
inquire fit squarely into this category and, in our judgment,
are mortgages of real property.
Having reached this conclusion, it is necessary that we answer
your question concerning the amount of mortgage registration
fee to be paid if these documents are to be allowed to be filed
for record. In this regard, it must be noted that the mortgage
registration "fee," in fact, is a tax upon any debt secured by
a lien on real property. Missouri Pacific Railroad Co. v. Deering,
184 Kan. 283 (1959). Such a debt is created by an executory
contract for the sale of real property. K.S.A. 79-3101.
Under such a contract, the seller is owed an indebtedness and
repayment of that debt is secured by retention of the legal title
to the property. Consequently, a mortgage of real property exists
under such a contract. This mortgage cannot be made a matter of
public record unless a mortgage registration fee is paid upon
the indebtedness owed to the seller (see K.S.A. 1982 Supp.
79-3102 and K.S.A. 79-3107), or such notice is given in an
affidavit of equitable interest as provided in K.S.A. 1982 Supp.
79-3102(5). Because of this, our office has consistently opined
that a register of deeds may refuse to file an executory con-
tract for the sale of real property or a document that incorporates,
by reference, or otherwise gives notice of the provisions of an
executory contract for the sale of real property, unless the
mortgage registration fee has been paid on the executory con-
tract or such notice is given in a proper affidavit of equitable
interest. See Attorney General Opinion Nos. 81-180, 77-202 and
75-447. We also have said that, as a general rule, if an in-
strument is a mortgage of real property and it also gives notice
of the existence of an unrecorded executory contract for the sale
of real property, then two mortgage registration fees are payable
before the instrument may be recorded. One fee is due on the
mortgage of real property and another fee is due on the unrecorded
executory contract. See Attorney General Opinion No. 75-447.
This general rule, however, does not mean that two mortgage
registration fees must always be paid if a purchaser of real
property mortgages his equitable interest in real property.
In a situation where a purchaser of real property under an
executory contract obtains a loan and secures payment of that
loan by granting a lien on his equitable interest in the real
property being purchased, the instrument by which the lien is
granted need not incorporate, or recite, the provisions of the
executory contract for the sale of real property through which
the purchaser obtained his interest in the real property. The
instrument can recite that the purchaser-borrower has an equitable
interest in the real property, as evidenced by an affidavit of
equitable interest which was filed on a certain date in a certain
book and at a certain page in the register of deeds' office of
the appropriate county, and that the purchaser assigns, transfers
and sets-over all of his rights, title and interests in said real
estate, to the lender as security for the loan. Of course, the
purchaser would have to file an affidavit of equitable interest
to give notice of his equitable interest in the real property
prior to completing the instrument by which he mortgages his
interest in the property. But, if such an affidavit is filed
and the instrument by which the purchaser grants a lien on his
equitable interest in the real property contains only the state-
ments indicated above, we are of the opinion that the mortgage
he is giving can be recorded without the purchaser having to pay
a mortgage registration fee on the executory contract for the
sale of real property through which he obtained his interest
in the real property. A mortgage registration fee would be paid
only on the loan being made to the purchaser and secured by his
equitable interest in the real property.
If, however, a procedure other than that described above is
followed, and the instrument by which the purchaser grants a
lien on his equitable interest in the property gives notice of
the existence of the executory contract through which the pur-
chaser obtained his interest in the real property, then a mortgage
registration fee must be paid not only on the loan currently being
made to the purchaser, but also on the principal amount of the
executory contract.
The instruments which you ask us to review, in addition to
granting liens on real property in which the purchasers-
borrowers have an equitable interest, also give notice of
executory contracts through which these purchasers obtained
their interests in the parcels of real property. Consequently,
we are of the opinion that these instruments may not be filed
of record without a mortgage registration fee being paid on
both the amount of the loan currently being made to the purchasers
and the principal amount of the executory contracts. Except as
prescribed in K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102(5), a financial transaction
involving a mortgage of real property cannot be made a matter of
public record without payment of a mortgage registration fee.
K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3102 and 79-3107. Thus, neither the contracts
between the sellers and purchasers of this real property, nor the
mortgages between the purchasers and these lending institutions
can be made a matter of public record without payment of the
mortgage registration fee.
In regard to the amount of mortgage registration fee to be
charged, we, like you, note that one of these instruments recites
that it is made not only to secure indebtedness now due by the
borrowers, but also "to secure such future advancements as may
be made" to the borrowers. Regarding this fact, we note K.S.A.
58-2336, which, in part, provides:
"Every mortgage or other instrument securing
a loan upon real estate and constituting a
lien . . . upon the real estate securing
such loan . . may secure future advances and
the lien of such mortgage shall attach upon
its execution and have priority from time
of recording as to all advances made there-
under until such mortgage is released of
record: Provided, That the lien of such
mortgage shall not exceed at any one time
the maximum amount stated in the mortgage."
(Emphasis added.)
This statute makes it clear that a mortgage of real property
may secure future advances and that the lien of any such mortgage
attaches at the time of the mortgage's execution. This statute
also makes it clear, however, that a mortgage of real property
which contains a future advances clause secures only the maximum
amount stated in the mortgage. This has ramifications under the
mortgage registration fee statutes. Specifically, K.S.A. 1982
Supp. 79-3102 prescribes that the mortgage registration fee is
to be charged on "each one hundred dollars ($100) and major
fraction thereof, of the principal debt or obligation which is
secured by such mortgage." (Emphasis added.) Since the amount
secured by a mortgage containing a future advances clause is
the maximum amount stated in the mortgage, it necessarily follows
that the maximum amount stated in the mortgage is the amount
that is to be used in calculating the mortgage registration fee
due on any such mortgage. This has long been the opinion of this
office. See Attorney General Opinion Nos. 76-280 and 76-191.
Since this opinion has become so lengthy, we summarize it in
accordance with the synopsis of this opinion.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.