Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-115

1983-115Kanag

Full text

August 3, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 115
Dennis W. Moore
Johnson County District Attorney
Johnson County Courthouse
P. 0. Box 728
Olathe, Kansas 66061
Re: Crimes and Punishments -- Trading Stamp Act --
Inapplicable to Certain Coupons and Devices
Personal and Real Property -- Real Estate Brokers
and Salesmen -- Prohibited Acts
Synopsis: The Sears "Home Buyers Savings Program" is not
violative of the Trading Stamp Act, K.S.A. 21-2801
et seq. However, it would be a violation of the
Kansas Real Estate Brokers' and Salespersons'
License Act, K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 58-3034 et seq.,forarealestatelicenseeoritsparentcompany
to offer such program contingent upon the listing,
purchase or leasing of real estate through the
licensee. Cited herein: K.S.A. 21-2801, 21-2803,
K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 58-3034, 58-3035, 58-3062.
Dear Mr. Moore:
You have requested an opinion from this office regarding the
legality of the proposed "Home Buyer's Savings Program" (here-
inafter referred to as "program") to be offered in Kansas by
Coldwell Banker's parent corporation, Sears, Roebuck and
Company (hereinafter "Sears"). Essentially, the program would
entitle purchasers of real estate through Coldwell Banker to
receive a "home buyer's savings book" which would contain
coupons redeemable for discounts at Sears stores. On May 20,
1983, counsel for Coldwell Banker provided this office further
information as to the operation of the program, stating as
follows:
"Subsequent to the closing of a real estate
sale transaction handled by a Coldwell Banker
licensee, the purchaser would receive a let-
ter from Sears congratulating them on their
new home purchase and providing them with an
Idea Book and a Home Buyer's Savings Book.
The Idea Book, a copy of which I have enclosed,
contains suggestions for home improvements.
The Home Buyer's Savings Book, a copy of which
is also enclosed, contains discount coupons
and instructions for their use. You will note
that the Savings Book contains certain refer-
ences to Coldwell Banker sales associates and
areas for their signatures. It is my under-
standing that the Savings Book which would be
used in Kansas would not utilize these refer-
ences or signature requirements. The distri-
bution and redemption of the coupons would be
handled entirely by the Sears organization.
Except for providing Sears with the mailing
list of purchasers through normal business
channels, the Coldwell Banker licensee would
not be involved or assist with the program.
"Under the proposed program, the only involve-
ment which the Coldwell Banker licensee might
have would be first, providing the customer
lists from which. Sears initiates contact with
the purchaser and second, the potential dis-
cussion by Coldwell Banker licensees and their
agents with prospective clients. Providing a
customer list is a normal business activity
which is routinely required by the Sears' or-
ganization. The customer list is valuable to
Sears for a number of reasons totally unre-
lated to the current program. If the program
were in operation, it would be realistic to
expect some discussion to occur between
Coldwell Banker licensees and prospective cus-
tomers even though it was not actively pro-
moted. However, such discussions would nec-
essarily indicate that Sears was offering the
coupons and not the licensee.
"In the program proposed by Sears, the Coldwell
Banker licensee would not be providing or fi-
nancially participating in the coupons which
Sears proposes to distribute and redeem."
First, we examine whether the proposed program may be viola-
tive of K.S.A. 21-2801 et seq., the Kansas Trading Stamp Act.
This Act, which prohibits use of trading stamps in Kansas, is
inapplicable to certain coupons given by retailers. Specifi-
cally, K.S.A. 21-2803(b) provides:
"This act shall not apply to any coupon,
ticket, certificate, card or similar device
which is issued, distributed, furnished or
redeemed:
"(b) By a retailer, when such coupon, ticket,
certificate, card or similar item is redeem-
able by the retailer, with or without accom-
panying cash, for any product which the re-
tailer normally sells in its usual course of
business."
The program contemplated by Sears involves redemption of
coupons, with accompanying cash, for products sold by Sears
in the general and usual course of business. Therefore, in
our opinion, the proposed program is within the scope of
K.S.A. 21-2803(b) and not violative of the Trading Stamp Act.
Cf., State, ex rel. Stephan v. Pepsi-Cola Gen'l. Bottlers,
Inc., 232 Kan. 843 (1983) and State, ex rel., v. American
Savings Stamp Co., 194 Kan. 297 (1965).
Another area of concern involves the Real Estate Brokers' and
Salespersons' License Act, K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 58-3034 et seq.
This Act, which governs licensed real estate brokers and
salespersons, provides in pertinent part, thus:
"No licensee shall-
"(12) Offer or give prizes, gifts or gratui-
ties which are contingent upon a client's
listing, purchasing or leasing property."
According to the description of the program provided by counsel
and quoted supra, Coldwell Banker licensees would not offer
or give the coupons to the purchaser of real estate. Rather,
the offer or gift would originate with a non-licensee, Sears.
The restrictions and prohibited acts set forth at K.S.A. 1982
Supp. 58-3062 extend only to licensees under the Act. Licen-
see is defined at K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 58-3035(f) as "any person
licensed under this act as a broker, associate broker or
salesperson." Sears, Roebuck and Company does not fall with-
in the scope of the definition of licensee. We recognize
that Coldwell Banker is a licensee under the Act and that the
licensee is wholly owned by Sears, Roebuck and Company. How-
ever, we are reluctant to extend the prohibitions at K.S.A.
1982 Supp. 58-3002 to individuals or entities not licensed
under the Real Estate Brokers' and Salespersons' License Act.
However, there seems to be no question that the program
constitutes a gift, prize or gratuity within the meaning of
the Kansas law. Thus, the program, if participated in by a
licensee, would be in direct violation of K.S.A. 1982 Supp.
58-3062(a) supra, since receipt of the coupons by the
purchaser is contingent on purchase of real estate from
Coldwell Banker.
The Coldwell Banker licensee is in a unique and exclusive
position to benefit from the program as an inducement to purchase
real estate, even though the non-licensee, Sears, would
actually conduct the program. Hence, it is our opinion that
in order for the licensee, Coldwell Banker, to avoid com-
mitting a violation of the Kansas real estate licensing law,
both Coldwell Banker and Sears must completely refrain from
advertising, promoting or otherwise using the Home Buyers
Savings Program in connection with Coldwell Banker prior to
the sale, lease or listing of real estate property. Of course,
nothing contained herein, prevents Sears from offering the
Home Buyers Savings Program for its own benefit. It is only
when the gift, prize or gratuity is offered in connection with,
and contingent on, doing business with Coldwell Banker that
the prohibitions of K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 58-3062 are violated.
In conclusion, the Sears "Home Buyers Savings Program" is not
violative of the Trading Stamp Act, K.S.A. 21-2801 et seq.
However, it would be a violation of the Kansas Real Estate
Brokers' and Salespersons' License Act, K.S.A. 1982 Supp.
58-3034 et seq., for a real estate licensee or its parent
company to offer such program contingent upon the listing,
purchasing or leasing of real estate through the licensee.
Very truly yours,
ROBERTT.STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Robert Vinson Eye
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RVE:hle

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.