Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-084

1983-084Kanag

Full text

May 25, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 84
John A. O'Leary, Jr.
Bank Commissioner
700 Jackson, Suite 300
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Banks and Banking -- Banking Code -- Insolvency
Defined
Synopsis: As provided by K.S.A. 9-1902, the State Bank Com-
missioner may deem a bank to be insolvent when,
among other things, the actual cash market value
of the bank's assets is insufficient to pay the
liabilities of its creditors. For the purposes
of this statute, the term "assets" refers to the
bank's capital account, bond and securities ac-
counts, and other liquid items, but does not in-
clude furniture, equipment, buildings or real
estate. Cited herein: K.S.A. 9-901, 9-1101,
9-1902, 9-1903, 9-1905, 9-1907, 9-1908.
Dear Commissioner O'Leary:
As Bank Commissioner for the State of Kansas, you request
our opinion on a question concerning the definition of the
term "insolvency" as it is used in the Kansas Banking Code
at K.S.A. 9-1902. Specifically, you inquire whether the
statutory phrase "actual cash market value of its assets"
includes physical property owned by a bank, such as buildings,
furniture and real estate, or merely the capital account,
bond accounts, and other accounts of similar liquidity. The
question is important in determining whether a bank meets the
insolvency tests of the statute, for the addition of the
physical assets could allow the continued operation of an
institution which would otherwise be subject to receivership.
K.S.A. 9-1902 is part of the original Banking Code adopted
in 1947. As it presently reads, the statute states:
"A bank or trust company shall be deemed to
be insolvent when (1) the actual cash market
value of its assets is insufficient to pay
its creditor liabilities except that for this
purpose unconditional evidence of indebtedness
of the United States of America may be valued,
at the discretion of the commissioner, at par
or cost whichever is the lesser; (2) when it
is unable to meet the demands of its creditors
in the usual and customary manner; (3) when
it shall fail to make good its reserve as re-
quired by this act."
Once the bank commissioner determines that the above condi-
tions exist, he is authorized by law to take charge of the
insolvent bank and all of its "property and assets." (K.S.A.
9-1903) A receiver is then appointed (K.S.A. 9-1905), who
may sell all the "property" of the bank on such terms as the
court approves. If the federal deposit insurance corporation
(FDIC) is involved, it may act as receiver without bond.
(K.S.A. 9-1907.) The FDIC shall then, as receiver, assume
"the possession of and title to all of the assets, business
and property of every kind, including real estate," of the
bank. (K.S.A. 9-1908.)
The above statutes, which are included in the same article
regarding dissolution and insolvency as is K.S.A. 9-1902,
seem to draw a distinction between the "assets" of a failed
bank and its "property." Indeed, K.S.A. 9-1908 includes a
third term, that of the bank's "business." The use of more
than one term in these statutes is, in our opinion, important,
and not merely excess verbiage. As is the case with the in-
terpretation of any statute, effect should be given to each
word and phrase used by the legislature, and it must be pre-
sumed that the legislature consciously chose the words which
appear in the statutes. State ex rel. Stephan v. Unified
School Dist. No. 428, 231 Kan. 579 (1982). In re Armed Forces
Coop. Insuring Assn., 5 Kan.App.2d 787 (1981). Accordingly,
when the Bank Commissioner takes action under K.S.A. 9-1901
et seq., against an insolvent bank, the term "assets" in
K.S.A. 9-1902 must be read in light of the other statutes re-
garding insolvency in the same act, i.e., in pari materia
with them.
While the common meaning of the word "assets" includes any-
thing of value which may be set off against liabilities
[Black's Law Dictionary, 4th rev.ed (1968)], in our opinion
a more restricted use is intended here. In concluding that
the term as used in K.S.A. 9-1902 refers only to liquid
assets in the bank's capital account (K.S.A. 9-901) and to
marketable securities, stock and bonds (K.S.A. 9-1101), we
are mindful of the vital interest of the state in maintain-
ing viable banking institutions. One way this interest is
protected is through statutes such as K.S.A. 9-1901 et seq.,
which set out procedures by which insolvent banks can be dealt
with promptly before further harm is done to their depositors
and stockholders. In making the determination that an insti-
tution is insolvent, thus triggering the drastic steps out-
lined above, there should be as little margin for error as
possible. The inclusion of the bank building itself, the
land on which it sits, and the furniture and fixtures con-
tained therein could give an otherwise insolvent institution
a paper value which would preclude such a determination by
the commissioner, perhaps with unfortunate results later.
Our conclusions are consistent with definitions of insolvency
used by courts in common law determinations of whether a bank
can be reasonably said to be insolvent. In Garrett v. Tunni-
cliffe, 145 So. 213 (Fla. 1933), the court determined that a
bank is solvent so long as it possesses sufficient assets to
pay, within a reasonable time, all its liabilities through
its own agencies. Clearly, a bank which is reduced to sell-
ing the very building in which it does business in order to
pay its liabilities should not be considered as solvent by
the law. Further, since it is the responsibility of a bank
to pay most deposits on demand, the fact that it has assets
which ultimately may be worth as much as the deposits does
not establish that it could (or should) keep its doors open.
In re Franklin National Bank, 381 F. Supp. 1390 (E.D.N.Y.
1974). Finally, as was noted by the court in Smith v. Witherow,
102 F.2d 638, 640 (3rd Cir. 1939), a bank's insolvent status
should not be determined "by the theoretical state of its
balance sheet which may include assets whose actual value is
far less than that at which they are carried on its books."
In conclusion, as provided by K.S.A. 9-1902, the State Bank
Commissioner may deem a bank to be insolvent when, among
other things, the actual cash market value of the bank's
assets is insufficient to pay the liabilities of its credi-
tors. For the purposes of this statute, the term "assets"
refers to the bank's capital account, bond and securities
accounts, and other liquid items, but does not include furni-
ture, equipment, buildings or real estate.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.