Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-005

1983-005Kanag

Full text

January 19, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 5
Arden Ensley
Revisor of Statutes
Office of Revisor of Statutes
Third Floor, Statehouse
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Uniform Commerical Code--Secured Transactions--
Filing; Immunity of Public Officials
Synopsis: As introduced, 1983 Senate Bill No. 7 would amend
K.S.A. 84-9-407, relating to the release of infor-
mation concerning financing statements on file, so
as to grant immunity to public officials from damages
resulting from their negligence in releasing such
information. Such a grant of immunity is permissible
under the Kansas and United States Constitutions, and
would act as an amendment by implication to the Kansas
Tort Claims Act, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-6101 et seq.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 46-901 (repealed by L. 1979,
ch. 186), K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-6101,75-6103, 75-6104,
K.S.A. 84-9-401, 84-9-407, Kan. Const., Bill of Rights,
§18, U. S. Const., Amend. XIV, L. 1981, ch. 357, L. 1981,
ch. 358, 1983 Senate Bill No. 7.
Dear Mr. Ensley:
As Revisor of Statutes, you request the opinion of this office
concerning the constitutionality of a provision contained in
1983 Senate Bill No. 7. At the request of State Senator Neil
Arasmith, you inquire whether Section 4(3), which provides a
limited form of immunity to certain public officials in the
performance of specified duties, is constitutional. While
you do not so specify, we presume that you refer to the question
of whether such a statute would impermissibly grant immunity
from suit in contravention of the principles of equal protection
or due process under either the United States or Kansas Constitutions.
The provision in question is contained in a section of the bill
which amends K.S.A. 84-9-407. That statute, contained in the
Kansas Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), concerns the release
of information by public officials who are designated as filing
officers by K.S.A. 84-9-401. These officials, which include
the Kansas Secretary of State and county registers of deeds, are
required by K.S.A. 84-9-407(2) to release, upon request, information
relating to any financing statements or statements of assignment
which are currently on file that name a specific debtor. This
duty is left intact by Section 4 of the bill, with subsection (3)
limiting an official's liability for providing incorrect information.
There, it is stated:
"Except with respect to willful misconduct,
the state, counties and filing officers, and
their employees and agents, are immune from
liability for damages resulting from errors
or omissions in information supplied pursuant
to this subsection."
An exploration of the history of governmental immunity, as well
as other forms of immunity, would properly be the subject of an
extensive work or treatise, and is not necessary or possible
here. A concise history of two types of immunity (governmental
and charitable) is found in the decision of Brown v. Wichita
State University, 219 Kan. 2 (1976), commonly known as Brown II.
In reversing a portion of the first Brown decision [217 Kan. 279
(1975)], the Brown II holding determined that the Kansas Legislature
could, if it desired, establish governmental immunity by statute
following the abrogation by the court of judicially imposed gov-
ernmental immunity. Further, even if the grant of immunity was
a blanket one, without exceptions, the court found that no provision
of the Kansas Bill of Rights, the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S.
Constitution or any other constitutional provision was offended
thereby. 219 Kan. at 9. However, such was not the case with
charitable immunity, which was held once again to be violative
of Section 18 of the Kansas Bill of Rights. Id. at 10. (See
also Attorney General Opinion No. 81-87.)
In 1979 the legislature acted to reduce the degree of governmental
immunity previously established by the statutes upheld in Brown II,
i.e., K.S.A. 46-901 et seq. (repealed L. 1979, ch. 186). This
change was motivated in part by further judicial limitations
on the governmental immunity concept, most notably Flax v. Kansas
Turnpike Authority, 226 Kan. 1 (1979), where K.S.A. 46-901 was
held unconstitutional as applied to the Kansas Turnpike Authority.
The legislature's response, the Kansas Tort Claims Act, K.S.A.
1981 Supp. 75-6101 et seq., made liability the rule and immunity
the exception for negligent or tortious conduct by government
officers or employees acting within the scope of their employ.
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-6103. Accordingly, unless other provisions
of the Act were determined to be applicable to a particular case,
officers filing UCC documents are subject to liability for their
conduct when such results in damage or injury.
Exceptions to the general liability rule are found at K.S.A. 1981
Supp. 75-6104, which consists of a list of 17 different functions
or activities for which governmental immunity has been reimposed.
While legislative functions, judicial functions and discretionary
functions are but a few of the areas exempted from the general
liability created by the Act, no subsection would appear to presentl
limit the liability of filing officers. However, in our opinion
nothing prevents the Legislature from so acting, as it has previousl
acted in creating the exceptions initially and in subsequent amend-
ments. See, e.g., L. 1981, ch. 357 (injuries to a firemen's relief
association member, abandoned cemeteries taken over by municipality)
L. 1981, ch. 358 (minimum maintenance roads).
It would further be our opinion that, in light of the above, some
revision of the bill as it presently reads would be desirable.
While the bill proposes to amend only statutes contained in the
UCC, the clear effect is to create another exception to the Tort
Claims Act. While the result would be valid as it now reads, an
amendment by implication would be created to the Act. As such
indirect amendments are not favored by the law, perhaps because
of their failure to provide clear notice of the change [State v.
Rural High School Dist. No. 4, 126 Kan. 166 (1928)], a reference
to the change should also be made at K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-6104.
In conclusion, 1983 Senate Bill No. 7 would amend K.S.A. 84-9-407,
relating to the release of information concerning financing state-
ments on file, so as to grant immunity to public officials from
damages resulting from their negligence in releasing such informatio
Such a grant of immunity is permissible under the Kansas and United
States Constitutions, and would act as an amendment by implication
to the Kansas Tort Claims Act, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-6101 et seq.
Very truly yours,
Attorney General of Kansas
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.