Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-235

1982-235Kanag

Full text

November 4, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 235
Jim Pringle
Sumner County Attorney
Sumner County Courthouse
Wellington, Kansas 67152-0497
Re: Counties -- Fire Protection -- Fire District;
Disassociation of Lands From District
Synopsis: K.S.A. 9-3604(b) allows the exclusion of land that
is contained within a fire district, provided that
the owners of at least 10% of the land sought to
be removed sign a petition which is submitted to
the board of county commissioners. If the commis-
sion finds the petition to be sufficient, it may
approve the detachment by resolution, which must
be published once each week for two consecutive
weeks. A petition protesting the resolution may
be filed within 30 days of the second publication,
and, should such petition be signed by the owners
of more than 19% of the affected land, the reso-
lution of detachment is rendered a nullity. Signers
of the original petition may, by signing the coun-
ter petition, act to withdraw their support from
the exclusion. In determining the sufficiency of
the counter petition, the commission shall use the
same standards as it uses in examining the initial
petition. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-3604(b).
*
Dear Mr. Pringle:
As County Attorney for Sumner County, Kansas, you request
our opinion on a question involving the procedure to disasso-
ciate territory from a fire district. Specifically, your con-
cern regards K.S.A. 19-3604(b), which sets forth the proce-
dures for both a petition to exclude certain lands from the
district and, in the event that a resolution approving the
exclusion is passed by the board of county commissioners, a
counter petition opposing such action. Your inquiry stems
from the action of certain landowners in the district (Sumner
County District No. 10), who signed both petitions. You wish
to determine whether such a reversal is permissible. If it
is impermissible for the landowner who signed the petition
for exclusion of territory also to sign the counter petition
opposing such exclusion, thereby eliminating these landowners
as signatories from the latter, the counter petition would
not have signatories representing the required area of land,
leaving the exclusion resolution valid.
We are informed that during this summer a number of landowners
in Walton Township, which is contained in Fire District No.
10, petitioned to be disassociated from the district. Signa-
tures were obtained which represented the owners of approxi-
mately 83% of the land which was sought to be removed. The
petitions were approved by the board of county commissioners,
and the two required publications were made. In all of these
respects, the provisions of K.S.A. 19-3604(b) were met.
Within 30 days of the second publication, a counter petition
was filed in opposition to the resolution. Again, this ac-
tion was in accordance with K.S.A. 19-3604(b), which in per-
tinent part states:
"If within thirty (30) days after the last
publication of said resolution and map, a
petition protesting the inclusion or detach-
ment of such lands, signed by the owners (whe-
ther residents of the county or not) of more
than nineteen percent (19%) of the area of the
lands sought to be included in or excluded
from said fire district is filed with the
county clerk, said resolution shall have no
force or effect, but if such a protest peti-
tion shall not be filed within said time, said
resolution shall become final, and said lands
shall thereupon be deemed attached to or de-
tached from said fire district."
In that the total acreage in the involved area is 30,880 acres,
19% would be approximately 5,867 acres. As the counter peti-
tion contained the signatures of persons purporting to own
7,986 acres, if such were found to be sufficient the resolu-
tion would be of no force and effect.
Numerous questions have been raised concerning the validity
of the counter petition. In particular, owners of well over
3,000 acres signed both the initial disassociation petition
and the subsequent counter petition opposing the action. If
these persons are precluded from signing the second, oppos-
ing petition because of their prior action, the 19% require-
ment would clearly not be met. Although the particular ques-
tion presented by this request has apparently never before
been addressed, either by this office or by Kansas appellate
courts, decisions interpreting analogous statutes provide
some guidance.
In the past, Kansas courts have consistently taken the posi-
tion that the legislature is free to set deadlines for the
filing of petitions protesting an action of a governmental
unit. State ex rel. v. City of Independence, 114 Kan. 837
(1924), Bentley v. Gunn, 125 Kan. 784 (1928) and cases cited
at 790. Within the limits of these deadlines, a signer of a
petition is free to withdraw his or her name from it. Bentley
v. Gunn, supra at 790, State ex rel. v. City of Walnut, 166
Kan. 296 (1949). Only if such period has elapsed is a signer
precluded from seeking to have his or her name removed.
State ex rel. v. City of Independence, supra at 839.
Here, the statute provides that a landowner in the affected
area may enter his protest to the commission's resolution
within 30 days of the second publication. Until this time
has elapsed, the matter is still not final, and may be chal-
lenged. We find nothing in this statute or in case law au-
thorities which would preclude some or even all of the signers
of the initial petition from reconsidering their action and,
in effect, withdrawing their consent by signing the counter
petition within the allotted time. While the statute could
have been drawn to allow only landowners who had not signed
initially to now sign in protest, it was not so worded. In
view of the liberal power to withdraw which the legislature
may grant the signers of a petition, we are not prepared to
limit the effect of K.S.A. 19-3604(b) by inferring that only
landowners who have not signed the original petition may sign
the petition in opposition.
Of course, the commission must determine that the counter
petition actually meets the requisite percentage. This would
be done in the same way that the initial petition was vali-
dated, and would involve checking the legitimacy of the sig-
natures, i.e., does the signer actually own land within the
affected area (and, if so, is the figure given correct), does
he or she have the authority to sign, and is there more than
one signature for the same parcel of land? For example, if
a husband and wife own land in joint tenancy, and both sign,
their acreage may be counted only once. Each individual de-
termination under these guidelines is left by law to the
commission. State ex rel. v. City of Walnut, supra at 297.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 19-3604(b) allows the exclusion of land
that is contained within a fire district, provided that the
owners of at least 10% of the land sought to be removed sign
a petition which is submitted to the board of county commis-
sioners. If the commission finds the petition to be suffi-
cient, it may approve the detachment by resolution, which
must be published once each week for two consecutive weeks.
A petition protesting the resolution may be filed within 30
days of the second publication, and, should such petition be
signed by the owners of more than 19% of the affected land,
the resolution of detachment is rendered a nullity. Signers
of the original petition may, by signing the counter petition,
act to withdraw their support from the exclusion. In deter-
mining the sufficiency of the counter petition, the commis-
sion shall use the same standards as it uses in examining the
initial petition.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.