Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-216

1982-216Kanag

Full text

September 27, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 8 2- 216
Mr. Scott Corsair
Mayor of Bazine
P. O. Box 43
Bazine, Kansas 67516
Re: Cities of the Third Class -- Election, Appointment,
Removal of Officers -- Simultaneous Holding of City
Council and Township Board Offices
Synopsis: The common law doctrine of incompatibility of of-
fices precludes one person from simultaneously
holding the offices of city councilman in a city
of the third class and a township officer in the
township which contains such city. Attorney Gen-
eral Opinion No. 75-50 is withdrawn. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 15-104, 25-1606, 80-1502, L. 1982, ch. 63.
Dear Mr. Corsair:
As Mayor of the city of Bbiine, you have inquired whether it
is lawful for an individual to hold positions on both the
council of the city and the board of Bazine Township simul-
taneously. You state that two of the present members of the
city's five person council are also members of the township
board, having been elected to the latter offices prior to
assuming these on the council. Problems have arisen, you
inform us, in the course of negotiations between the two
bodies over a fire protection agreement by which the city
provides such services to the township, in that the two dual
office holders continue to participate in the discussion as
city council members, thus leaving the township with only
one remaining officer.
There are two principal Kansas cases concerning the incompa-
tibility of offices. In Abry v. Gray, 58 Kan. 148 (1897),
the Court adopted the essential language of 19 American and
English Encyclopedia of Law, 562, as follows:
"'The incompatibility which will operate to
vacate the first office must be something more
than the mere physical impossibility of the
performance of the duties of the two offices
by one person, and may be said to arise where
the nature and duties of the two offices are
such as to render it improper, from considera-
tions of public policy, for one person to re-
tain both.'"
Subsequently, in Dyche v. Davis, 92 Kan. 971 (1914), the Court
held:
"Offices are incompatible when the performance
of the duties of one in some way interferes
with the performance of the duties of the
other . . . . It is an inconsistency in the
functions of the two offices." Id. at 977.
Also, in Congdon v. Knapp, 106 Kan. 206 (1920), the court
ruled that "if one person holds two offices, the performance
of the duties of either of which does not in any way inter-
fere with the duties of the other, he is entitled to the
compensation for both." Id. at 207.
It is apparent from a reading of these cases that the Kansas
Supreme Court has determined that incompatibility of offices
requires more than a physical impossibility to discharge the
duties of both offices at the same time. There must be an
inconsistency in the functions of the two offices, to the ex-
tent that a performance of the duties of one office in some
way interferes with the performance of the duties of the other,
thus making it improper, from a public policy standpoint,
for one person to retain both offices. This rule is in accord
with general authorities.. In 89 A.L.R. 2d 632, it is stated:
"It is to be found in the character of the of-
fices and their relation to each other, in
subordination of the one to the other, and in
the nature of the duties and functions which
attach to them, and exist where the performance
of the duties of the one interferes with the
performance of the duties of the other. The
offices are generally considered incompatible
where such duties and functions are inherently
inconsistent and repugnant, so that because of
the contrariety and antagonism which would re-
sult from the attempt of one person to dis-
charge faithfully, impartially, and efficient-
ly the duties of both offices, considerations
of public policy render it improper for an in-
cumbent to retain both." (Citations omitted.)
Id. at 633.
In reviewing previous opinions of this office on the subject
of incompatibility of offices, we note that Attorney General
Harold Fatzer had occasion to review a situation identical
to that here, i.e. common holding of township and third-class
city council positions. In an opinion dated March 25, 1951,
he stated:
"It is our view that these two offices would
be incompatible and that it would not be pro-
per for one person to serve in both capacities.
It can readily be seen that the performance of
the duties of one of the offices might readily
interfere with the performance of the duties
of the other. This the Supreme Court defines
as incompatible offices and prohibits the
same person from holding both."
In addition to the considerations discussed in that prior
opinion, we also note the reasoning expressed in Attorney
General Opinion No. 79-248, in which we concluded that the
offices of city commissioner of a city of the second class
and board member of a unified school district are incompati-
ble. There, in noting that these offices served overlapping
constituencies, we stated:
"[T]he respective duties and functions of
these two offices are inherently inconsistent
and repugnant, to the extent that one person
cannot faithfully, impartially and efficiently
discharge the duties of both offices. Further-
more, we believe that considerations of public
policy render it improper for an incumbent to
retain both. Even if the incumbent of one of-
fice were to abstain from discussing, partici-
pating in or voting on matters affecting his
or her incumbency of the other office, such
abstention deprives one constituency or the
other of a representative who is free to make
independent judgments on such matters. It is
our opinion that the constituencies of both
offices are entitled, as a matter of public
policy, to an elected representative who can
vote without conflict on substantially all
matters." Id. at 6,7.
In our opinion, the same considerations of public policy ex-
pressed in these two prior opinions are applicable here.
While an opinion issued by Attorney General Schneider (No.
75-50) found no incompatibility between these two particular
offices, in that each has different functions and responsi-
bilities which do not overlap, such a conclusion is clearly
at odds with your experience and our view of Kansas law.
(Attorney General Opinion No. 75-50 is hereby withdrawn.)
Further, we note that in addition to overlapping interests
in the area of fire protection (K.S.A. 80-1502), other con-
flicts could arise in matters involving the intangibles tax
(L. 1982, ch. 63), cemeteries (K.S.A. 12-1401 et seq.) and
hospitals (K.S.A. 80-2113 et seq.).
While it is arguable that a city councilman could avoid any
conflict by abstaining from voting on the matters pertaining
to the township, we believe the public policy considerations
noted in Opinion No. 79-248 negate such argument. In our
judgment, the city councilman's constituency is entitled, as
a matter of public policy, to an elected representative who
can vote without conflict on substantially all matters. Thus,
the councilman's abstention from voting on matters concerning
the township would deprive his or her constituency of a repre-
sentative who is free to make independent judgments on such
matters. In that residents of Bazine are also eligible to
vote for the township officials (K.S.A. 15-104), the same
considerations apply there as well.
Having thus determined the incompatibility of the public of-
fices under consideration, the question arises as to the
effect of such determination. In those Kansas cases where
it has been determined that two public offices held by the
same person are incompatible, the Court has held that such
person's acceptance of the second office ipso facto vacates
the first office held by such person. See, e.g., Gilbert v.
Craddock, 67 Kan. 346, 362, 363 (1903), and Moore v. Wesley,
125 Kan. 22, 24, 25 (1928). The application of this legal
principle here would result in the two involved officials
vacating their positions on the township board, as they as-
sumed these posts prior to being elected to the city council.
Such vacancies would then be filled by the county commission
pursuant to K.S.A. 25-1606.
In conclusion, the common law doctrine of incompatibility of
offices precludes one person from simultaneously holding the
offices of city councilman in a city of the third class and a
township officer in the township which contains such city.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Jeffrey	S.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.