Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-206

1982-206Kanag

Full text

September 20, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82 - 206
James R. Cobler
Director
Accounts and Reports
Department of Administration
First Floor - State Office Bldg.
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Cities and Municipalities -- Public Utilities --
Annual Audit
Bonds and Warrants -- Revenue Bonds -- Annual Audit
of Municipal Utilities
Synopsis: 1980 House Bill No. 3178 (L. 1980, ch. 64) is an
enactment of the legislature which does not uni-
formly apply to all cities. Thus, since K.S.A.
1981 Supp. 10-1208 and 12-866 were sections of
that enactment, a city, pursuant to its constitu-
tional home rule powers, may exempt itself by
charter ordinance from the whole or any part of
these statutes applicable to such city. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 10-1208, 12-866, 13-1243,
13-14d12, 75-1123, 75-1124, Kan. Const., Art. 12,
§5.
*
Dear Mr. Cobler:
You have inquired whether K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 10-1208 and 12-866
are non-uniform in their application, thereby enabling any
city to which these statutes apply to exercise its constitu-
tional home rule powers and exempt itself by charter ordinance
from all or any portion of these statutes.
A city's home rule powers, including the power to adopt char-
ter ordinances, are provided by Article 12, Section 5 of the
Kansas Constitution. Under these powers, a city may exempt
itself by charter ordinance from
"the whole or any part of any enactment of the
legislature applying to such city, other than
enactments of statewide concern applicable uni-
formly to all cities, other enactments appli-
cable uniformly to all cities, and enactments
prescribing limits of indebtedness." (Empha-
sis added.) Kan. Const., Art. 12, §5(c)(1).
The emphasized portion of the above-quoted provisions defines
the scope of this power, i.e., a city may exempt itself from
any non-uniform "enactment of the legislature" (other than
enactments prescribing limits of indebtedness). In City of
Junction City v. Griffin, 227 Kan. 332 (1980), the Kansas
Supreme Court had occasion to consider the meaning of this
language as it applied to the Kansas Code of Procedure for
Municipal Courts (K.S.A. 12-4101 et seq.). Of the 59 sec-
tions of this Code, as originally enacted (L. 1973, ch. 61),
only one of the sections (K.S.A. 12-4105) was non-uniform in
its application, in that it differentiated between cities of
the first class and other cities regarding qualifications of
municipal judges. The Court considered the effect the non-
uniformity of this section had on the remaining sections of
the Code, stating:
"In order to preserve the uniformity of the
code it has been urged that this section be
declared no part of the enactment of the pro-
cedural code. However, this section is one
of the sections included in L. 1973, ch. 61.
It is clearly one of the sections comprising
the enactment. The division into chapter,
article and sections in the Kansas Statutes
Annotated does not have the effect of making
separate enactments of a single bill passed
by the legislature of the State of Kansas.
Marks v. Frantz, 179 Kan. 638, 298 P.2d 316
(1956)." Id. at 335, 336.
From this, the Court concluded that, by virtue of the non-
uniformity of K.S.A. 12-4105, the entire Code was not "appli-
cable uniformly to all cities." Id. at 337. It is clear,
therefore, that a single bill passed by the legislature, i.e.,
a single chapter of the session laws, is an "enactment of the
legislature" for purposes of Article 12, Section 5 of the
Kansas Constitution. Further, as noted in Claflin v. Walsh,
212 Kan. 1, 9 (1973), "[i]n order for a statute to be uni-
formly applicable to all cities there must be no exceptions."
With these principles in mind, we have considered your inquiry.
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 10-1208 and 12-866 were most recently
amended as sections 1 and 2, respectively, of 1980 House Bill
No. 3178 (L. 1980, ch. 64). Both of these statutes were
amended in this bill so as to require an annual audit of cer-
tain municipal utilities by a licensed municipal public
accountant or certified public accountant. We also note
that related amendments were made in K.S.A. [now 1981 Supp.]
13-1243, 13-14d12, 75-1123 and 75-1124 by sections 3, 4, 5
and 6, respectively, of the bill. Collectively, these six
sections contain all of the bill's substantive provisions,
and as required by Griffin, supra, all must be considered in
determining whether House Bill No. 3178 is uniformly appli-
cable to all cities.
In our judgment, the Griffin and Claflin cases compel the
conclusion that, if any provision of 1980 House Bill No.
3178 is non-uniform in its application to cities, the entire
bill must be regarded as an enactment of the legislature that
is not uniformly applicable to all cities. Here, we note
that K.S.A. 12-866 (as amended by section 2 of the bill) is
not uniformly applicable to all cities. Since its enactment
in 1953 (L. 1953, ch. 72, §11), it has been limited in appli-
cation to cities having a population of less than 80,000.
Thus, it is our opinion that 1980 House Bill No. 3178 is an
enactment of the legislature which is not uniformly applicable
to all cities. Hence, a city may exempt itself by charter
ordinance from any of the provisions of said bill which are
applicable to such city.
Although the foregoing conclusion is dispositive of your in-
quiry, and it is unnecessary to consider the remaining sec-
tions of House Bill No. 3178, it requires little discussion
to note that neither K.S.A. 13-1243 nor 13-14d12, as amended
by sections 3 and 4, respectively, of the bill, is uniformly
applicable to all cities. The former was originally enacted
in the Special Session of 1933 (L. 1933, ch. 43, §6) as part
of an act applicable only to cities having a population of
at least 115,000 (see K.S.A. 13-1238). The application of
this act has not changed since its enactment. Similarly,
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 13-14d12 was originally enacted in 1953
(L. 1953, ch. 104) as section 12 of an act applicable only
to certain cities of the first class. This act also has not
changed in scope since its enactment. Thus, the presence of
these statutes in House Bill No. 3178 also renders the bill
non-uniform in its application to cities.
In summary, therefore, it is our opinion that 1980 House Bill
No. 3178 (L. 1980, ch. 64) is an enactment of the legislature
which does not apply uniformly to all cities. Thus, since
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 10-1208 and 12-866 were sections of that
enactment, a city, pursuant to its constitutional home rule
powers, may exempt itself by charter ordinance from the whole
or any part of these statutes applicable to such city.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN"
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
W. Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:hle

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.