Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-176

1982-176Kanag

Full text

August 16, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 176
Jerry Harper
District Attorney
Law Enforcement Center
Lawrence, Kansas 66044
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees --
Open Meetings Law -- Persons Who May Attend
Executive Sessions
Synopsis: A public body subject to the Kansas Open Meetings
Act may not permit individuals or special inter-
est groups, including members of the news media,
to attend executive sessions as mere observers
while excluding the public generally. Individuals
may attend executive sessions of government bodies
subject to the Act upon invitation where such per-
sons are present to provide information to the
body or participate in its deliberations, but may
not attend merely as observers. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 75-4317, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4318, 75-4319,
75-4320a.
*
Dear Mr. Harper:
Your predecessor, Mike Malone, inquired of this office regard-
ing the application of the Kansas Open Meetings Act, K.S.A.
75-4317 et seq., to certain executive sessions held by the
governing board of Unified School District No. 497. Speci-
fically, he desired to know if the Board's long-standing
practice of permitting members of the news media to be pre-
sent during executive sessions, authorized by K.S.A. 1981
Supp. 75-4319(b)(3) and concerning employer-employee negotia-
tions, was lawful. We note those representatives of the media
attending the closed meeting agree not to disclose the details
the board's deliberations.
K.S.A. 75-4317 states the purpose of the Kansas Open Meetings
Act (hereinafter KOMA or Act) as follows:
"(a) In recognition of the fact that a repre-
sentative government is dependent upon an in-
formed electorate, it is declared to be the
policy of this state that meetings for the
conduct of governmental affairs and the trans-
action of governmental business be open to the
public.
"(b) It is declared hereby to be against the
public policy of this state for any such meet-
ing to be adjourned to another time or place
in order to subvert the policy of open public
meetings as pronounced in subsection (a)."
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4318 declares meetings of designated
government bodies to be "open to the public." There is no
question that the Act applies to the school board in question
or to its regular or special meetings. The issue for resolu-
tion concerns closed or executive sessions authorized by the
Act pursuant to K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4319. That section pro-
vides in pertinent part:
"(a) Upon formal motion made, seconded and
carried, all bodies and agencies subject to
this act may recess, but not adjourn, open
meetings for closed or executive meetings.
Any motion to recess for a closed or execu-
tive meeting shall include a statement of
(1) the justification for closing the meeting,
(2) the subjects to be discussed during the
closed or executive meeting and (3) the time
and place at which the open meeting shall re-
sume. Such motion, including the required
statement, shall be recorded in the minutes
of the meeting and shall be maintained as a
part of the permanent records of the body or
agency. Discussion during the closed or
executive meeting shall be limited to those
subjects stated in the motion.
"(b) No subjects shall be discussed at any
closed or executive meeting, except the fol-
lowing:
"(3) matters relating to employer-employee
negotiations whether or not in consultation
with the representative or representatives of
the body or agency;
• • •
"(c) No binding action shall be taken during
closed or executive recesses, and such recesses
shall not be used as subterfuge to defeat the
purposes of this act."
Unfortunately the Act does not address specifically the issue
of whether such "closed" or "executive" meetings or recesses
may include persons who are not members of the governing body
subject to the Act. Certainly, at least two of the six sub-
jects authorized for discussion in executive session imply
the presence of persons other than the board members. K.S.A.
1981 Supp. 75-4319(b)(2) authorizes executive sessions for
"consultation with an attorney for the body or agency which
would be deemed privileged in the attorney-client relation-
ship." (Emphasis added.) Indeed, an attorney must be present
before this exception may be relied upon to close a meeting.
See Kan. Att'y Gen. Op. No. 78-303.
Prior to 1981, the third exception, contained in K.S.A. 1981
Supp. 75-4319(b)(2), authorized government bodies to meet
with their "representative" for consultations involving
employee-employer negotiations. Such executive sessions
were authorized only when the representative was present.
The 1981 Legislature amended this provision to permit discus-
sion of employer-employee negotiations in closed session with
or without the presence of the negotiator. L. 1981, ch. 344,
§1. Yet, the exception, even as amended, still authorizes
executive sessions which include a person other than the members
of the governing body.
Hence, we cannot say that a closed or executive session au-
thorized by KOMA is limited to members of the body subject to
the Act. Consistent with this observation is a prior opinion
of this office adopting the reasoning of courts of other
states which have considered the question of who may attend
executive sessions. In Kansas Attorney General Opinion No.
80-43 we stated:
"So long as the procedural requirements of
that section are followed, the board may in-
clude in its discussions in executive session
those persons selected by the board to be pre-
sent. See Blum v. Board of Zoning Appeals of
North Hempstead, 149 N.Y.S. 2d 5, 8, 1 Misc.
2d 668 (1956), Thomas v. Board of Trustees,
215 N.E. 2d 434, 436, 5 Ohio App.2d 365 (1966)."
Id. at 3.
Both cases cited therein, defined an executive session as
"one from which the public is excluded and at which only such
selected persons as the board may invite are permitted to be
present." Accord, Dathe v. Wildrose School District No. 91,
217 N.W.2d 781 (N.D. 1974), permitting a school superintendent
to attend executive sessions of school board to make recommen-
dations on individual teacher contracts.
We think the statute generally permits public bodies to con-
duct executive sessions as they see fit. Such discretion to
admit others is both required and necessary in some instances
to facilitate the deliberations of the body. This commonly
occurs where the non-members are persons who are providing
information to, and participating in discussions with, the
members of the government bodies. Dathe, supra. However,
we do not think the Act grants unbridled discretion in this
regard.
In the factual situation you pose, members of the news media
are permitted to attend the executive session while the gen-
eral public is excluded. Members of the media are not invited
to participate or inform the government body, rather its mem-
bers are present only as observers, to listen and learn. If
such discrimination between the news media and public is
permitted here, what would prevent government bodies from
permitting the public to attend while excluding the news
media? Likewise, what law would prevent the body from exclud-
ing certain members of either the news media or public? For
a number of reasons we think the practice of permitting the
media to be present at certain executive sessions while ex-
cluding the public generally is contrary to both the spirit
and intent of the Kansas Open Meetings Act.
First, as noted at the outset, KOMA is expressly designed to
encourage an informed electorate. It is the voting franchise
rather than the news-access interests of journalists which is
the primary concern of the Act. Bestowing a preferred status
on journalists in this context is inconsistent with the pur-
pose of our law.
Second, the Kansas Open Meetings Act recognizes no special
classes entitled to access to meetings of government bodies.
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4318 requires meetings to be "open to
the public." Moreover, standing to enforce the provisions
of the Act is granted to "any person." K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
75-4320a.
Third, a meeting, ostensibly described as a closed session,
ceases to be "closed" where any number of persons are per-
mitted to attend merely as observers. Arguably, members of
the media, sitting as observers, are simply representatives
of a subclass of the public at large and their presence makes
the gathering a "public" meeting at which all members of the
public should be entitled to access.
Finally, this practice creates the potential for abuse. While
we do not question the motives of the board of education or
the journalists who attend such gatherings, the practice of
excluding the majority of patrons of the school district from
meetings attended by other patrons strikes us as a dangerous
precedent. Furthermore, the members of the media are present
not only because of their professional interests, but also be-
cause they have agreed not to disclose the information obtained
during the executive sessions. Hence, such persons attend
the executive session by virtue of their compliance with
conditions established by the board. Presumably, journalists
who refuse to make such agreements would be denied admittance,
just as other voters and taxpayers are denied access. Under
a statute which authorizes "public" access to government
meetings, it is ironic that a special interest group, composed
of news reporters, is admitted to closed door meetings on
the condition they not report to the public. Therefore, un-
less there is some implied limitation inherent in the meaning
of the term "executive session," any number of individuals
or special interest groups might be admitted to executive
sessions under a seemingly unlimited array of arbitrary con-
ditions. Such practice is, in our view, contrary to a public
meetings statute.
For the above reasons we do not believe the Act permits such
latitude in determining who may attend executive sessions.
In our judgment, the Act does not allow persons to attend
executive sessions merely as observers. In such a role, the
interests of the person or persons in attendance is indistin-
guishable from those of any other member of the public. Under
such circumstances, persons are not admitted to the meeting
to aid the governing body in its deliberations. Hence, the
admission of some observers at the exclusion of others trans-
forms the so-called executive session into a meeting at which
the public should have access.
Therefore, in our opinion, a public body subject to the
Kansas Open Meetings Act may not permit individuals or spe-
cial interest groups, including members of the media, to
attend executive sessions as mere observers while excluding
the public generally. Individuals may attend executive
sessions of government bodies subject to the Act upon invita-
tion where such persons are present to provide information
to the body or participate in its deliberations but may not
attend merely as observers.
Very truly yours,
3 ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
BradleyJ.Smoot
DeputyAttorneyGeneral
RTS:BJS:hle

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.