Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-066

1982-066Kanag

Full text

March 12, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 66
Patrick J. Regan
Chairman, Kansas Water Authority
503 Kansas Avenue, Suite 303
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Waters and Watercourses -- State Water Plan --
Agreements with. Federal Government for Water
Storage; Permissible Uses
Synopsis: The Kansas Water Authority is empowered to consider
and approve contracts for the purchase of water
held in storage by the state in various reservoirs.
One factor to be considered is whether the con-
tract advances the purposes of the State Water
Plan, K.S.A. 82a-927 et seq. Included in the Plan
are policy determinations as to the purposes of
major reservoirs in Kansas (at K.S.A. 82a-938),
with industrial and municipal uses considered dis-
tinct from irrigation. A sale of water for irri-
gation purposes from a reservoir which has only
the former purposes identified would be inconsis-
tent with the Plan, as well as being in potential
confli with federal statutes authorizing the
initial sale of water to the state. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 82a-927, 82a-928, 82a-932, 82a-933, K.S.A.
1981 Supp. 32a-934, K.S.A. 82a-938, L. 1981, ch.
398, 1961 H - Ise Concurrent Resolution No. 5,
K.A.R. 1981 Supp. 98-5-1, 98-5-3, Kansas Constitu-
tion, Article 11, Section 9, 43 U.S.C.A. 390b.
*
Dear Mr. Regan:
As Chairman of the Kansas Water Authority, you request our
opinion on a question which concerns the ability of the
Authority to approve contracts for the sale of water for
irrigation purposes. Specifically, you inquire whether such
a contract may be entered into for the sale of water from
Marion Reservoir which is held in water supply storage by
the state. Questions have been raised whether the contract,
which has been entered into between a private landowner and
the Kansas Water Office, is permissible under state and
federal statutes.
Prior to an analysis of the particular situation involved,
a brief historical summary of applicable federal and state
legislation would be helpful. A good starting point is 1958,
a year in which Kansas voters approved an amendment to the
state constitution, specifically Article 11, Section 9. This
change amended the internal improvements prohibition so as
to allow the state to be a party to "flood control works and
works for the conservation or development of water resources."
This change opened the door for agreements with the Federal
government for such projects.
Of no less importance was the congressional enactment in the
same year of Public Law 85-500, Section 301, which is cited
as the Water Supply Act of 1958. Under this section (now at
43 U.S.C.A. §390b), a policy statement is made fat subsection
(a)]:
"It is hereby declared to be the policy of
the Congress to recognize the primary respon
sibilities of the States and local interests
in developing water supplies for domestic,
municipal, industrial, and other purposes
and that the Federal Government should parti-
cipate and cooperate with States and local
interests in developing such water supplies
in connection with the construction, mainten-
ance, and operation of Federal navigation,
flood control, irrigation, or multiple pur-
pose projects."
Other relevant language in the section states:
"(b) In carrying out the policy set forth in
this section, it is hereby provided that stor-
age may be included in any reservoir project
surveyed, planned, constructed or to be planned,
surveyed and/or constructed by the Corps of
Engineers or the Bureau of Reclamation to im-
pound water for present or anticipated future
demand or need for municipal or industrial
water, and the reasonable value thereof may be
taken into account in estimating the economic
value of the entire project: Provided, That
the cost of any construction or modification
authorized under the provisions of this sec-
tion shall be determined on the basis that all
authorized purposes served by the project
shall share equitably in the benefits of mul-
tiple purpose construction, as determined by
the Secretary of the Army or the Secretary of
the Interior, as the case may be: - Provided
further, That before construction or modifi-
cation of any project including water supply
provisions for present demand is initiated,
State or local interests shall agree to pay
for the cost of such provisions in accordance
with the provisions of this s ection: And pro-
vided further, That not to exceed 30 per cen-
tum of the total estimated cost of any project
may be allocated to anticipated future demands
where State or local interests give reasonable
assurances, and there is reasonable evidence,
that such demands for the use of such storage
will be made within a period of time which will
permit paying out the costs allocated to water
supply within the life of the project. . . .
"(d) Modifications of a reservoir project here-
tofore authorized, surveyed, planned, or con-
structed to Include storage as provided in sub-
section (b), which would seriously affect the
purposes for which the project was authorized,
surveyed, planned, or constructed, or which
would involve major structural or operational
changes shall be made only upon the approval
of Congress as now provided by law." (Emphasis
added.)
In 1961, the Legislature took another step to develop such
water supply storage by the state. In enacting House Con-
current Resolution No. 5, it stated in part:
"Be it resolved by the House of Representatives
of the State of Kansas, the Senate concurring
therein: That the legislature concurs in the
recommendations made by the Kansas water re-
sources board for inclusion of water supply
storage in Milford, Perry, and John Redmond
reservoirs, and concurs in the requests made
by the cities named in the preamble hereof,
which requests have been supported by the.
Kansas water resources board, for inclusion
of water supply in the Elk City and Council
Grove projects.
"Be it further resolved, That the legislature
recognizes the nonfederal repayment obligations
required relative to the development of water
supply features in federally financed projects
and does hereby assure the chief of engineers
that the state or its political subdivision
will fulfill such obligations, prior to the
use of the water, as they relate to the above-
named projects and as the obligations are
described in Public Law 534, 78th Congress
(the flood control act of 1944), Title III of
Public Law 85-500 (the water supply act of
1958), and such acts as may be supplemental
or amendatory thereto."
The Legislature also directed that a study be prepared to fur-
ther assist in developing programs of state participation in
water conservation storage projects.
As a result of this study, which was prepared by the Legisla-
tive Council with the assistance of the Water Resources Board,
the 1963 Legislature enacted what is now K.S.A. 82a-901, et
seq. A major portion of this act was devoted to setting forth
principles which were followed by the Board in preparing the
actual state water plan, which was enacted in 1965. (K.S.A.
82a-927, et seq.) In its original form, K.S.A. 82a-927 set
forth certain long-range goals and objectives of the state,
among which was
"(1) [t]he development, to meet the anticipated
future needs of the people of the state, of
sufficient supplies of water for beneficial
purposes, including but not limited to pur-
poses that are domestic, stockwater, munici-
pal, irrigation, agricultural, industrial,
streamflow regulation, public recreational
and fish and wildlife, water power, and navi-
gation purposes . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
Additionally, K.S.A. 82a-928 (as originally enacted) listed
among general goals and objectives the following:
"(6) the development by 1975 of at least an
additional 185,000 acre-feet of water to meet
the increasing annual needs of Kansas munici-
palities;
"(7) the development by 1975 of at least an
additional 750,000 acre-feet of water to meet
the increasing annual needs of Kansas indus-
tries;
"(8) the development by 1975 of at least an
additional 1,900,000 acre-feet of water to
meet the increased annual needs of Kansas
irrigators . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
Both statutes, it should be noted, were amended by Chapter
398 of the 1981 Session Laws to substitute broader language
for the detailed subsections quoted above.
Also contained in the plan were sections which authorize the
Board to: (1) enter into negotiations with the federal gov-
ernment (K.S.A. 82a-932); (2) demonstrate a need for conser-
vation water storage features in aky federally-authorized
water project (K.S.A. 82a-933); and (3) enter into agreements
with the federal government for the storage of water in such
projects and payment by the state therefor (K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
82a-934). As a result of the implementation of the plan,
agreements have been entered into by the Board and the federal
government which cover 13 reservoirs constructed by the Army
Corps of Engineers. Five of the projects were those intially
listed in the 1961 House Concurrent Resolution, with 4 more
subsequently constructed and the remainder still in the plan-
ning stage. Marion Reservoir, it may be noted, falls into
the second category, having been completed in 1968.
Yet another component of the plan which should be mentioned
is the table which appears at K.S.A. 82a-938, entitled "Major
Reservoirs of Kansas." In addition to detailing the location,
completion date, storage features and yield capability of 33
Kansas reservoirs (both existing and planned), the table also
sets forth the long-range purposes of the projects. While
all of the projects have flood control, recreation and fish
and wildlife management as purposes, only a portion are
designated for municipal and industrial storage. All of the
nine existing reservoirs noted above fall into this group,
including Marion. At the same time, however, none of the
nine are designated as having irrigation as one of their
goals. As a footnote, the table indicates that reservoirs
with irrigation as one of their purposes (Wilson, Kanopolis,
Kirwin, etc.) are all located in the drier, northwestern por-
tion of the state.
A final component of the statutory framework is found at
K.S.A. 82a-1301 et seq., the state water plan storage act.
The statutes contained therein give the "board" (now the
Kansas Water Authority) to acquire water storage capacity in
the reservoirs named in the Plan. At K.S.A. 82a-1305, the
board is empowered to enter into written contracts for the
sale of such water, provided it find that such sale will ad-
vance the purposes of the Plan. The act was fleshed-out in
1979 by the adoption of K.A.R. 1981 Supp. 98-5-1 et seq.
Included in the definition section, K.A.R. 1981 Supp. 98-5-1,
are the following terms:
"(b) 'Agricultural use' means any use of water
by a person primarily for production of food
or fiber and including any incidental uses.
• • •
"(m) 'Industrial use' means any use of water
by a person primarily for the production of
goods, food, or fiber, or rendering a service
of providing utility services and including
any incidental uses."
"(o) 'Municipal use' means the various uses of
water . . by a municipality, rural water dis-
trict, other water supply district, or group
of householders where water is . . . used for
domestic, commercial, trade, industrial, and
any other related incidental uses for any
beneficial purposes."
At K.A.R. 98-5-3(n), such contracts are required to be sub-
mitted to the board for its consideration and approval. One
of the factors to be considered is whether
"[t]he annual withdrawal and use of the quan-
tity of water contracted 'for] by the person
will advance the purposes set forth in articles
7 and 9 of chapter 82a of Kansas Statutes
Annotated." [K.A.R. 1981 Supp. 98-5-3 (o)(7)]
In examining the instant case, it is our opinion that the
proposed sale of water from Marion Reservoir for irrigation
purposes does not fit within the above statutory framework.
It is common knowledge that irrigation is an application of
water which is designed to increase dry-land yields or make
possible the initial cultivation of a crop used for food or
fiber, i.e. an "agricultural use" as defined by the regula-
tions adopted by the board in 1979. While it is true that
the definition of "industrial use" also makes reference to
the production of food or fiber, we find no justification
in the existing regulations for ignoring the common meaning
of the term irrigation so as to conclude it is an "industrial
use."
Such a result would also be in conflict with statutory uses
of the terms "irrigation" and "industrial use." As indicated
above, one factor used in evaluating such contracts is whether
the use will advance the purposes of article 9 of chapter 82a,
including the State Water Plan. While the use of its water
for industrial purposes is specified, Marion does not have
irrigation listed as one of its purposes by the table contained
at K.S.A. 82a-938. (We note that this table was reproduced
unchanged in the board's 1980 Report to the Legislature.)
This omission is doubtless due in part to language contained
in the Water Supply Act of 1958 quoted hereinabove, namely
that reservoirs constructed by the Corps of Engineers store
water "for present or anticipated future demand or need for
municipal or industrial water." Marion is such a reservoir,
and a use of its water for irrigation purposes would be in-
consistent with the Plan as it now reads. Nor can "irriga-
tion" be reasonably considered to be included within the
term "industrial use", given the numerous distinctions which
the statutes make between the two, as well as the difference
in the commonly-understood meanings of the terms. Grey v.
Schmidt, 224 Kan. 375 (1978).
Furthermore, in reading the agreement which was signed be-
tween the Corps and the Board in 1976 that deals with. Marion,
we note that the storage space contracted for "is to be used
to impound water for municipal and industrial water supply
purposes." [Article 1, Clause (a).] Additionally, Article 4
of the agreement requires the state to utilize the storage
space in a manner consistent with federal and state laws.
In our opinion, this language is yet another indication that
the water stored in this reservoir is intended to be used
for certain enumerated purposes only, and that irrigation
is not among them.
In conclusion, the Kansas Water Authority is empowered to
consider and approve contracts for the purchase of water
held in storage by the state in various reservoirs. One
factor to be considered is whether the contract advances the
purposes of the State Water Plan, K.S.A. 82a-927 et seq.
Included in the Plan are policy determinations as to the
purposes of major reservoirs in Kansas (at K.S.A. 82a-938),
with industrial and municipal uses considered distinct from
irrigation. A sale of water for irrigation purposes from a
reservoir which has only the former purposes identified would
be inconsistent with the Plan, as well as being in potential
conflict with federal statutes authorizing the initial sale
of water to the state.
Very truly your§,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.