Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-095

1981-095Kanag

Full text

April 10, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 8 1-9 5
Mr. Frank H. Jenkins, Jr.
Owen & Jenkins
129 W. Park
P.O. Box 149
Olathe, Kansas 66061
Re: Cities and Municipalities -- Construction Fees --
Waiver of Fees by City Council for a Church Facility
Synopsis: The waiver by the city council of construction-related
fees due a city from a church constitutes a gift of
public funds for a private purpose and is, therefore,
improper.
Dear Mr. Jenkins:
You have inquired as to whether it is proper for a municipality to
waive certain fees incurred by a church for the construction of a new
church facility. You state that the fees in question -- a building
permit fee, a plumbing inspection fee, an electrical inspection fee,
and a park dedication fee, totaling $6,166.50 -- were waived by the
Lenexa City Council as requested by the church's pastor, based upon the
theory that the church works for the betterment of the community.
The building permit and inspection fees exist to cover the expenses
incurred by the city in the performance of its inspection duties, and
the park dedication fee is imposed when no open space is dedicated for
public recreational use. None of the ordinances which establish these
fees provide for exceptions or waiver. The question to be resolved,
then, is whether the waiver of fees by the City Council was an invalid
gift of public funds.
It has long been recognized that governmental expenditures are limited
in that they cannot be for purely private purposes. In Loan Association
v. Topeka, 87 U.S. (20 Wall.) 655 (1874), the city of Topeka issued
bonds totaling $100;000 and contributed the proceeds to a private
company so that it might manufacture iron briges in Topeka. The
Supreme Court there stated that:
"[T]o lay, with one hand, the power of the government
on the property of the citizen, and with the other
to bestow it upon favored individuals to aid private
enterprises and build up private fortunes, is none
the less a robbery because it is done under the form
of a law and is called taxation." Loan Association v.
Topeka, 87 U.S. (20 Wall.) at 664.
The modern rule is, "[a]ny power conferred on a municipality must be
exercised for a public use or purpose as distinguished from a private
purpose." 10 McQuillin Municipal Corporations, §10.31.
The church facility in this case is used for a private and not a public
purpose. "A denominational church is a private institution, and while
building and maintenance of religious institutions are in the public
interest and may be said to promote public welfare, they lie outside
public uses and purposes." Ex Parte Conger, 163 Tx. 505, 357 S.W.2d 740,
742 (1962). Although the modern trend is to expand the class of public
purposes, it has not included private church facilities. 39 McQuillin
Municipal Corporations, §39.19.
While this waiver of fees does not represent an actual expenditure of
public funds, it does constitute a gift to the church. The inspections
and dedication are mandatory, without exception. The inspection fees
are intended to compensate for expenses in providing that service.
This broad view of expenditure in the public purposes context is expressed
elsewhere as follows: "Because the power to tax is limited to tax for
public purposes, there is no power for a municipality to lend its
aid to private enterprises, thereby incurring an indebtedness which
may necessitate the exercise of the power of taxation to liquidate."
64 C.J.S. Municipal Corporations §1835b.
A similar view was applied where work was performed with public resources
for the benefit of private persons. In Ex Parte Conger, supra, private
property was bladed with county owned equipment so that church members
might use the land as a parking lot. The court held that work performed
on private property for church members to park while attending services
was a public expenditure for a private purpose. 357 S.W.2d at 742.
Therefore, we conclude that the waiver of fees due the city is essentially
a gift to the church which constitutes a gift for a private purpose.
The gift violates the prohibition against using public funds for a
private purpose and, thus, the Lenexa City Council acted improperly when
it agreed to waive the fees.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN	AttorneyGeneralofKansas
Brenda L. Hoyt
Assistant Attorney General RTS
: BJS : BLH :may

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.