Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-065

1981-065Kanag

Full text

March 11, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 8 1 - 65
Mr. Wendell J. Barker
Franklin County Attorney
Court Building
Ottawa, Kansas 66067
Re: Counties and County Officers--County Commissioners--
Notice of Letting of Contracts; Bids
Synopsis: Pursuant to the provisions of K.S.A. 19-215 and 19-216,
notice must be published, and plans and specifications
must be filed (with the county clerk), at least thirty
days prior to the date set for letting of a contract
which is subject to the competitive bidding requirements
of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-214 et seq. The plans and spec-
ifications must be sufficiently definite and explicit as
to enable bidders to prepare their bids intelligently
on a common basis. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1980 Supp.
19-214, K.S.A. 19-215, 19-216.
*
Dear Mr. Barker:
You request our opinion as to the legality of the procedure
followed in awarding a contract for interior remodeling of the
Franklin County Courthouse. You state that Franklin County has a
population of approximately 22,000, and that the contract awarded
was in excess of $10,000. You further state that the contract was
awarded on January 12, 1981, after published notice was given in
the Ottawa Herald (on December 29, 1980, and January 10, 1981)
inviting sealed proposals, and you have enclosed a copy of the
notice which was published. Also, you state as follows with regard
to filing of plans and specifications for the proposed work in the
office of the county clerk:
"I was informed that the plans for all of the
proposed improvements to the courthouse were on
file in the Franklin County Clerk's Office more
than thirty days before January 12, 1981. However,
I was also informed that the drawings and spec-
ifications referred to in the advertisement were
not on file in the County Clerk's Office until
January 5, 1981. The architects advised me that
the drawings and specifications referred to in the
advertisement were the working drawings. The
architect further advised me that the earlier plans
which had been filed with the county clerk were
sufficiently detailed to enable any contractor to
make an intelligent bid on the project."
The applicable procedure for the award of the subject contract is
prescribed by K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-214 et seq. The contract must
be at.,.-ded "on a public letting, to the lowest responsible bidder"
(K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-214), and K.S.A. 19-215 requires that notice
be published "in some newspaper printed in the county" (if there
is a newspaper printed in the county), which notice "shall specify
with reasonable minuteness the character of the improvement
contemplated, the time and place at which the contract will be
awarded, and invite sealed proposals for the same." K.S.A. 19-216
relates to filing of plans and specifications, and provides as
follows:
"Before advertising for bids for any contract as
provided in the preceding section, said board
shall cause plans and specifications of the
proposed work or improvement to be prepared,
which plans and specifications shall be displayed
for the inspection of bidders, at the office of
the county clerk at least thirty days before the
time for awarding the contract." (Emphasis added.)
As the underscored portion of the above-quoted statute indicates,
the plans and specifications must be filed with the county clerk
at least thirty days before the date upon which the contract is
awarded. Although no deadline, relating to publication of notice
of the contract letting, is specifically set forth in K.S.A. 19-215,
this office has previously held (letter opinion dated March 1,
1960) that the first publication should be at least thirty days
prior to the date set for letting, for the reason that, otherwise,
the statutory requirement that the plans and specifications be open
to inspection for thirty days would not have any meaning. Since
the facts relating to the subject contract, as set forth above,
indicate that the first publication did not occur at least thirty
days prior to the date set for letting, it is our opinion that the
contract was not awarded in accordance with the applicable procedure
prescribed by K.S.A. 19-214 et seq.
Although what has been said above is dispositive of the question
which has been raised, another issue presented in your letter
relates to the sufficiency of plans and specifications which are
required to be filed under K.S.A. 19-216. In Bridge & Iron Works
Company v. Labette County, 98 Kan. 292, 301 (1916), the provisions
of a statute applicable to the award of contracts for the
construction of bridges was construed as follows:
"The intent of the requirement that a plan and
specifications shall be on file for the inspection
of bidders is that all bidders shall be placed
on an equality, and that each shall know exactly
what is required. . . . [T]he plans and specifi-
cations on file for the inspection of bidders
must, so far as the nature and character of the
proposed work will admit, be sufficiently definite
and explicit as to enable bidders to prepare their
bids intelligently on a common basis. It may be
said as a general rule that plans and specifications
are sufficient if contractors and others skilled
in such matters are able to determine what is
required." (Emphasis added.)
In the same case, the court also stated that:
"None of the cases cited goes so far as to hold
that statutes similar to ours can only be complied
with by filing detailed working plans for the
inspection of bidders . . . . The authorities are
practically unanimous in holding that there can be
no active, intelligent competition among bidders
unless plans and specifications are open to in-
spection which are sufficiently explicit as to
afford to all bidders an equal opportunity to bid
u•on the same project or proposition." Id. at 304.
In the situation you describe,, relating to the award of a contract
for interior improvements to the Franklin County Courthouse, the
facts (as recited in your letter) seem to indicate that the
requirements of K.S.A. 19-216 have been satisfied. If the plans
and specifications filed with the county clerk thirty days prior
to January 12, 1981 (the date on which the contract was awarded),
were "sufficiently detailed to enable any contractor to make an
intelligent bid on the project," then the principles enunciated
in the Labette case, supra, indicate that the county probably has
complied with the provisions of K.S.A. 19-216. However, since an
opinion relative to the sufficiency of the plans and specifications
requires the application of the above-recited legal principles to
factual issues (i.e., the adequacy of the plans and specifications
which were filed andsince said factual issues, if disputed, may
only be decided upon trial before a court, we shall not render a
definitive opinion regarding whether the requirements of K.S.A.
19-216 have been satisfied.
In summary, it is our opinion that the subject contract was not
awarded in accordance with the applicable procedure prescribed
by K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-214 et seq., for the reason that the first
notice of letting was not published at least thirty days prior to
the d a te set for letting. Also, the plans and specifications filed
with the county clerk, more than thirty days prior to January 12,
1981, would be considered adequate to satisfy the requirements of
K.S.A. 19-216 if they were sufficiently definite and explicit as
to enable bidders to prepare their bids intelligently on a common
basis.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansans
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:TRH:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.