Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-039

1981-039Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTO RNEY GENERAL February 10, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 39
The Honorable Robert V. Talkington
P.O. Box 725
20 North Washington
Iola, Kansas 66749
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees--Open
Public Meetings--County Hospital Board of Trustees;
Closed Executive Sessions
Synopsis: Governing bodies subject to the Kansas Open Meetings
Act may not discuss salary schedules for hospital per-
sonnel, hospital budgets, hospital room rates, or other
related financial affairs during closed or executive
session. Salaries for hospital employees may be
discussed during executive session only when such dis-
cussion focuses on individuals. Cited herein: K.S.A.
75-4317, K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-4318 and K.S.A. 75-4319.
*
Dear Senator Talkington:
As attorney for the Board of Trustees of Allen County Hospital, you
request our opinion concerning closed executive sessions of meetings
subject to the Kansas Open Meetings Act, K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq.
You inquire whether meetings may be closed for executive sessions to
discuss the following four matters:-
"1. Hospital budgets and other related financial matters.
"2. Salary schedules for personnel of the hospital including
both supervisory and nonsupervisory personnel.
"3. Hospital room rates.
"4. Salaries for any employees of the hospital whether
discussed on an individual basis or as a group."
The Board of Trustees of Allen County Hospital is organized under
K.S.A. 19-1801 et seq., and is a governing body subject to the Kansas
Open Meetings Act. See K.S.A. 75-4318 and Attorney General Opinion
No. 80-159. The Kansas Open Meetings Act requires that meetings of
this body be open to the public, except to discuss certain exclusive
subjects. These subjects are listed in K.S.A. 75-4319, which states in
pertinent part thus:
"(b) No subjects shall be discussed at any closed or
executive meeting, except the following: (1) Personnel
matters of nonelected personnel;
"(2) consultation with an attorney for the body or
agency which would be deemed privileged in the
attorney-client relationship;
"(3) consultations with the representative of the body
or agency in employer-employee negotiations;
"(4) confidential data relating to financial affairs or
trade secrets of corporations, partnerships, trusts, and
individual proprietorships;
"(5) matters relating to actions adversely or
favorably affecting a person as a student, patient
or resident of a public institution, except that
any such person shall have the right to a public
hearing if he or she so requests; and
"(6) preliminary discussions relating to the
acquisition of real property.
"(c) No binding action shall be taken during closed
or executive recesses, and such recesses shall not
be used as a subterfuge to defeat the purposes
of this act."
We note at the outset that this statute proscribes discussion of any
subjects other than those listed, thus all other matters must be
discussed in open session. Of the subjects exempted for closed or
executive sessions listed above, only the first appears to have any
application to your questions.
Provision is frequently made in open meetings laws for discussions of
personnel matters to permit such discussions to be conducted during
a closed or executive recess. In fact, it is probably the most widely
recognized exception to open meetings laws. See National Association
of Attorneys General, Open Meetings: Exceptions To State Laws (1979)
at 21. This provision is generally included and drafted to protect the
privacy of employees, [see Tacha, The Kansas Open Meetings Act: Sunshine
on the Sunflower State?, 25 Kan.L.Rev. 169, 195 (1977)]; saving personal
reputations, [see Comment, New York Open Meetings Law: A Critical
Evaluation, 41 Alb.L.Rev. 329, 344, (1977)] and encouraging qualified
people to select and remain in the employ of government, [see Note,
Open Meetings Statutes: The Press Fights for the "Right to Know," 75 Harv.
L.Rev. 1199, 1208 (1962)]. Since the exceptions to open meetings laws
are to be narrowly construed, the exception for personnel matters is not
as broad as might be thought. See e.g., Illinois News Broadcasters Ass'n
v. City of Springfield, 22 Ill.App.3d 226, 317 N.E.2d 288 (1974) (referring
to the Illinois open meetings law).
In Attorney General Opinion Letter to Mike Taylor, February 5, 1980,
referring to a discussion by the Wichita City Commission of the executive
reorganization of police and fire departments, the Kansas Attorney
General observed:
"The obvious intent of this provision [the personnel
exception] is to allow discussion regarding individual
employees because of the personal and sensitive nature
of such discussions. The public policy issues inherent
in the structuring or organization of administrative
agencies was not intended to fall within this exception
to the open meetings requirements." Id. at 1.
In Attorney General Opinion No. 80-102 we discussed this excepted
subject in the context of discussions of the Corrections Ombudsman
Board concerning staff members of the Department of Corrections. We
noted there that:
"[I]ndividual members of the correctional staff would
qualify as 'nonelected personnel' within the meaning of
the first exemption. However, this statute should
not be read as allowing discussions about general topics
or groups of staff members or inmates. Rather a closed
meeting should be called only when such discussions will
concern specific staff members and/or inmates."
Generally, this exception should be applied only when the discussion
relates to individuals whose privacy interests might be affected by
a public airing. Under this view salary schedules for hospital personnel
and salaries for employees when discussed as a group could not be consid-
ered during executive session. Discussion of salaries on an individual
basis could be done in closed session where the "individual's privacy
interests could be affected by public airing."
Thus, of the four matters about which you inquire, the first three
may not be discussed in the privacy of an executive session. The
fourth item, dealing with salaries of individual employees or groups
of employees, may be discussed during executive sessions only where
the privacy of individuals is sought to be protected. Discussions
concerning groups of employees which do not infringe upon the individual
are beyond the purposes for which the exception for personnel matters
was created. Although the language of this exception might be broadly
interpreted to permit generalized discussions, such an interpretation
is clearly contrary to the spirit of the Act and our previous interpre-
tations.
To summarize, the governing bodies subject to the Kansas Open Meetings
Act may not discuss salary schedules for hospital personnel, hospital
budgets, hospital room rates, or other related financial affairs during
closed or executive session. Salaries for hospital employees may be
discussed during executive session only when such discussion focuses
on individuals.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Bradley J. Smoot
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BJS:phf

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.