Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-011

1981-011Kanag

Full text

January 14, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 11
Mr. James Lucian
Chairman, Cherokee County
Board of Commissioners
Cherokee County Courthouse
Columbus, Kansas 66725
Re: Taxation--Listing Property for Taxation--Issuance
of Advance Tax Notices and Warrants
Synopsis: K.S.A. 79-319 is applicable only in those cases
where a person is about to remove his or her
property from the county. It is not applicable
in those cases where a taxpayer is about to sell
his or her property, or has sold the same. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 79-319, 79-1420, 79-1422, 79-2109,
79-2110; L. 1899, ch. 248.
Dear Mr. Lucian:
In a letter to Phil Martin, Director of Property Valuation,
you explain that the following situations occurred in Cherokee
County during 1980:
"1. An out of State Coal Mining firm ceased
operation and removed some of the equipment
after being assessed for 1980.
"2. A farmer refused to list his equipment and
later held an auction to dispose of his
farm and machinery.
"3. A retail store held a closing out sale
and ceased operation after turning in a
1980 Commercial Personal Property rendition."
You explain that the county appraiser notified the county
treasurer of each of the foregoing situations, and, in response
thereto, the county treasurer issued an advance tax notice to
each of the taxpayers and also issued tax warrants to be executed
by the sheriff. However, the county attorney advised the sheriff
not to enforce the warrants. You seek our opinion on whether the
tax warrants were properly issued and enforceable in each of the
situations, pursuant to K.S.A. 79-319 "and related statutes."
K.S.A. 79-319 provides:
"When any person is about to remove his or
her property from the county, after the same
has been assessed and before the taxes there-
on have been paid, without leaving sufficient
remaining for the payment of the taxes thereon,
the tax shall at once become due and payable,
and the county treasurer shall forthwith issue
a tax warrant for the collection of the same,
and it shall be enforced as in other cases."
(Emphasis added.)
While perhaps not expressed in the clearest of terms, it is
our opinion the language of this statute prescribes that it
shall be invoked whenever, in the judgment of the county treasurer,
a person is about to remove his or her property from the county,
(1) after the property has been assessed but before the taxes
thereon have been paid, and (2) without leaving sufficient
property in the county to pay taxes. However, we are of the
further opinion that the provisions of this statute may not be
enlarged to include situations where a person is about to sell,
or has sold his or her property. The fact a person is about to
sell or has sold his or her property, in our judgment, cannot be
construed to mean that such person "is about to remove his or her
property from the county."
Our opinion is based upon the fact that, when the provisions
of K.S.A. 79-319 were originally enacted in 1899 (L. 1899, ch. 248),
they were embodied in Section 6 of an act entitled: "AN ACT
providing for the assessment and taxation of property in certain
cases." (Emphasis added.) That act provided separate sections
which were to govern in cases where: (1) property was brought
into the state; (2) a person sold his or her property to one person,
(3) property of a taxpayer was seized by legal process, or (4)
property of a taxpayer was about to be removed from the county.
Therefore, when K.S.A. 79-319 was originally enacted, the
legislature was mindful not only of the tax collection problems
which result when a taxpayer removes property from the county,
but also, when a taxpayer sells property subject to taxation.
These problems, however, were dealt with in separate sections.
Thus, the legislature distinguished the removal of property from
the county from the sale of property by a taxpayer.
Two existing statutes address the sale of property by a taxpayer
after the property has been assessed (i.e., K.S.A. 79-2109 and
79-2110), but these statutes relate only to the sale of all of a
taxpayer's property or all of a class thereof "to any one person."
Thus, those statutes are inapplicable where the property of a
taxpayer, or an entire class thereof, is not sold to one person.
Consequently those statutes appear to be inapplicable to any of
the situations you describe, and we are unaware of any other
statutory provision which authorizes the issuance of an advance
tax notice and a tax warrant in those situations where a taxpayer
sells his or her personal property to more than one person. K.S.A.
79-309, however, provides in relevant part:
"All property shall be listed and valued
on the first day of January in the year
in which the same is assessed, and the
transfer and sale of any taxable personal
property subsequently to the first day
of January shall not authorize any person
to omit the same from the list, although
such list be not made until after the sale
or transfer of such property; but all such
property shall be listed for taxation in
the same manner as if no sale or transfer
thereof had been made." (Emphasis added.)
Thus, it is clear that the sale of personalty after January 1
of the year in which it is assessed does not relieve the obligation
of the taxpayer to list such property for taxation and pay the
tax due thereon. However, due to the lack of statutory provisions
authorizing an alternative collection method, it is our opinion
that taxes due on such property can be collected only in the same
manner as taxes on property which has not been sold are collected.
"The method of collection of taxes is not prescribed in the
constitution but is left to the legislative discretion and control,
and no method exists apart from the statute." (Emphasis added.)
Board of County Commissioners v. Matlock, 192 Kan. 272, syl. 111
(1963).
Based upon the foregoing principles, it is our opinion that
the county treasurer lacked statutory authority to issue advance
tax notices and tax warrants in the latter two situations you
describe, unless the sales involved therein come under the
provisions of K.S.A. 79-2109 or 79-2110, i.e., all of the tax-
payer's property, or an entire class thereof, was sold to one
person. As we have noted, however, the provisions of K.S.A.
79-309 are applicable and the taxpayers who sold their personalty
are liable for the taxes imposed upon such personalty in 1980.
Further, in regard to the taxpayer who refused to list his
property, we call to your attention the provisions of K.S.A.
79-1420 and 79-1422, which impose criminal and civil penalties,
respectively, for the failure or refusal to provide a list of
property for purposes of taxation. Parenthetically, however,
we note the very recent decision of the Kansas Supreme Court in
National Cooperative Refinery Ass'n v. Board of McPherson County
Comm'rs, 228 Kan. 595 (1980), where the Court held that K.S.A.
79-1422, as currently written, does not authorize the imposition
of a penalty against a taxpayer who voluntarily files a list of his
personalty more than 45 days late. Because we have not been
apprised of the precise circumstances surrounding the taxpayer's
refusal to list his property, the application of this decision
to the pertinent facts should be discussed with your county
attorney.
Finally, in regard to the out-of-state coal mining firm that ceased
operations in your county during 1980, it appears to us, under the
facts you have presented, the issuance of an advance tax notice
and a tax warrant were authorized by K.S.A. 79-319. Consequently,
it is our opinion the tax warrant that was issued properly could
have been executed by the sheriff.
Very truly yours
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.