Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1975-475

1975-475Kanag

Full text

December 23, 1975
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 75-475
Mr. Don J. Knappenberger
Assistant County Attorney
Stafford County Courthouse
St. John, Kansas 67576
Re: Uniform Commercial Code--Financing Statements--Duties
of Filing Officer
Synopsis: The register of deeds, as filing officer under the
Uniform Commercial Code, has no duty to make an inde-
pendent search to determine the correctness of the
identification of a record owner of real estate recited
on a financing statement which is presented for filing
and which conforms to K.S.A. 1974 Supp. 84-9-402(5), as
amended by ch. 514, L. 1975. Financing statements
enumerated in that section, and fixture filings, must
be filed in the alphabetical general real estate mortgage
index, and are not required to be filed in the numerical
index. The uniform fee for a financing statement pre-
sented for filing which conforms in its physical dimen-
sions to forms approved by the Kansas Secretary of State
is $1.00.
* * *
Dear Mr. Knappenberger:
You inquire concerning K.S.A. 84-9-402 (1) and (5) as amended by
1975 Senate Bill No. 27, found at ch. 514, § 25, L. 1975.
Subparagraph (1) of this section, as amended, provides in pertinent
part thus:
"A financing statement shall be in a
form prescribed by the secretary of state
and shall give the names of the debtor and
the secured party, shall be signed by the
debtor, shall give an address of the secured
party from which information concerning the
security interest may be obtained, shall give
a mailing address of the debtor and shall
contain a statement indicating the types,
or describing the items of collateral . . . .
When the financing statement covers crops
growing or to be grown, the statement must
also contain a description of the real estate
concerned. When the financing statement covers
timber to be cut or covers minerals or the like
(including oil and gas) or accounts subject to
subsection (5) of section 84-9-103, or when
the financing statement is filed as a fixture
filing (section 84-9-313) and the collateral
is goods which are or are to become fixtures,
the statement must also comply with subsection
(5) ."
Subsection (5) states thus:
"A financing statement covering timber
to be cut or covering minerals or the like
(including oil and gas) or accounts subject
to subsection (5) of section 84-9-103, or
a financing statement filed as a fixture
filing (section 84-9-313) where the debtor
is not a transmitting utility, must show that
it covers this type of collateral, must contain
a legal description of the real estate con-
cerned and the name of the record owner of the
real estate concerned." [Emphasis supplied.]
The underscored language does not apply to a financing statement
covering crops growing or to be grown. A legal description of the
real estate concerned, and the name of the record owner thereof,
is required to be included in financing statements covering timber
to be cut, minerals or the like, including oil and gas, and accounts
subject to K.S.A. 84-9-103(5), and financing statements filed as
fixture filings, under K.S.A. 84-9-313.
It should be pointed out that subsection (1) quoted above requires
that a financing statement covering crops growing or to be grown
to contain "a description of the real estate concerned," whereas
financing statements covering timber to be cut, minerals, and
other collateral enumerated in subparagraph (5) must contain a
"legal description of the real estate concerned and the name of
the record owner of the real estate concerned." A similar
distinction is made in the form set out in subsection (3) of
this section, in items 2 and 3 thereof.
A financing statement covering crops, thus, is not required to
contain a legal description of the real estate, unlike financing
statements described in subsection (5) of K.S.A. 84-9-402 as
amended. It is not clear if the omission to require a legal
description in the instance of crops was intentional or inad-
vertent. Certainly, however, the omission is a consistent one,
reflected in the differing information required in items 2 and
3 of the form set forth in subsection (3) of this section. The
omission is also reflected in the indexing requirements made
specifically applicable to financing statements covering timber to
be cut, minerals or the like, including oil and gas, accounts sub-
ject to K.S.A. 84-9-103, or goods which are or are to become
fixtures. As to these financing statements, new subsection (7)
of K.S.A. 1974 Supp. 84-9-403, as amended, states thus:
"When a financing statement covers
timber to be cut or covers minerals or the
like (including oil and gas) or accounts
subject to subsection (5) of section
84-9-103, or indicates that it covers goods
which are or are to become fixtures and
contains the information required by section
84-9-402, the filing officer, other than the
secretary of state, shall also index the
statement according to the name of the record
owner of the real estate in the general real
estate mortgage index." [Emphasis supplied.]
You ask, first, concerning the duties of the register of deeds
to determine the true record owner. As you point out, the financ-
ing statement must disclose the record owner. You raise the
question, however, whether the register of deeds should accept
the statement on the face of the financing statement, or whether
it is the duty of the register of deeds to search records in
that office and elsewhere, such as in the probate court, to deter-
mine if the recitation is correct and who is the true record
owner. The duties of the filing officer are entirely ministerial.
The register of deeds, as the filing officer, has no duty to make
an independent search to verify the correctness of the identification
of the record owner stated in a financing statement presented
for filing. Any financing statement which is required to contain
that information and which does not may not be accepted for filing.
If that information is included, however, the financing statement
is formally sufficient, so far as that requirement is concerned,
and the filing officer has no duty other than to accept it for
filing.
Secondly, you inquire whether the filing officer must index
fixture filings and other similar filings in the alphabetical
general real estate mortgage index or in the numerical tract
index for mortgages. As indicated above in new subsection (7)
of K.S.A. 1974 Supp. 84-9-403, as amended, quoted in full above,
financing statement subject thereto must be filed in the alpha-
betical general real estate mortgage index according to the name
of the record owner of the real estate. K.S.A. 1974 Supp. 84-9-313
(1)(b), as amended by section 22 of the bill, states thus:
"a 'fixture filing' is the filing in
the office where a mortgage on the real estate
would be filed or recorded of a financing
statement covering goods which are or are to
become fixtures and conforming to the require-
ments of subsection (5) of section 84-9-402."
Thus, filing in the alphabetical general real estate mortgage
index is required, and filing in the numerical index is not. Indeed,
references to the numerical index were deleted from K.S.A. 1974
Supp. 84-9-403(4), and from the form as prescribed in amended form
by subsection (3) of K.S.A. 1974 Supp. 84-9-402 as amended. Careful
search techniques by interested parties should minimize the instances
whereby such filing places an unjustified cloud on the title of
the record owner.
Lastly, you inquire concerning the appropriate fees to be assessed
for filing under K.S.A. 1974 Supp. 84-9-403, as amended, which
provides thus, in pertinent part:
"The uniform fee for filing and index-
ing and for stamping a copy furnished by
the secured party to show the date and place
of filing for an original financing statement,
any amendments thereto or for a continuation
statement shall be one dollar ($Z) if the
statement is in the standard form prescribed by
the secretary of state and otherwise shall be
two dollars ($2) . .11
You question whether, if a financing statement is presented for
filing which does not bear a notation that it has been approved
by the Secretary of State, the register of deeds must charge
$2.00, rather than $1.00. We have discussed this matter with the
Secretary of State, and have construed the phrase "standard form"
to refer to the physical dimensions of the form presented for
filing. If a financing statement is presented for filing which
conforms to the physical dimensions of the form approved by the
Secretary of State, it is our opinion that only $1.00 may be
charged. Thus, the form approved by the secretary of state of
a sister state may be accepted for filing at the $1.00 charge
so long as its dimensions conform to those approved by the Kansas
Secretary of State, and thus require no special handling to be
indexed.
Yours very truly,
CURT T. SCHNEIDER
Attorney General
CTS:JRM:kj
cc: The Honorable Elwill M. Shanahan
Secretary of State
2nd Floor - State Capitol Building
Topeka, Kansas 66612

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.