Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1975-447

1975-447Kanag

Full text

December 4, 1975
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 75- 447
Mr. John E. Fierro
County Attorney
Ford County Courthouse
Dodge City, Kansas 67801
RE: K.S.A. 79-3101 et seq.
Synopsis: A mortgage registration fee is a tax and no tax may
be levied against a U.S. government agency. But
where a second mortgage is undertaken to be recorded
by the Farmers Home Administration, which includes
by reference and recognizes the existence of an
unrecorded first mortgage lien owned by non-exempt
citizens, such portion of the second mortgage should
not be recorded until the Register of Deeds is
furnished sufficient information as to the exact
amount of consideration secured by the first lien
so as to be able to compute and assess against the
mortgagees of the first lien the statutory mortgage
registration fee.
Dear John:
We have your letter of November 28, 1975, attaching an
Exhibit "A" which is a part of a second mortgage offered for
filing with the Register of Deeds. It appears that the sellers
made a contract whereby the buyers agreed to pay a sum certain
in the purchase of a property, but the contract was never re-
corded. Now, the Farmers Home Administration wants to record
a second mortgage against this same property, but in doing so
sets up this sales contract and preserves it as a first lien.
You ask whether the Register of Deeds should require that
a registration fee be paid on the first lien. In our opinion
this instrument does in fact incorporate by reference the
prior existing contract lien, which is a mortgage as defined
by K.S.A. 79-3101. It makes that first lien a matter of record,
and protects the rights of both the buyers and sellers in that
contract,.
A mortgage registration fee is a tax which is normally
paid by the mortgagee. Meadowlark Hill Inc. v. Kearns, 211
Kan. 35, 41, 505 P.2d 1127 (1973).. Kansas shall never tax the
property of the United States. Act for Admission of Kansas
into the Union, Section Sixth.
But it is not suggested that a mortgage registration fee
be assessed on the second mortgage of the Farmers Home
Administration. It is our opinion that by Exhibit "A" an attempt
is being made to record a first and prior lien, not belonging
to an exempt entity, and upon which no registration fee has
ever been paid. The first lien could not have been recorded
without the parties paying the statutory registration fee.
What cannot be done directly cannot be done indirectly. The
Farm Home Administration cannot cast its cloak of exemption over
non-exempt individuals.
We believe that the Register of Deeds should request evidence
of the amount of consideration involved in the first lien contract
and then assess the statutory registration fee required by K.S.A.
79-3101 et seq., or refuse to record "Exhibit 'A'".
Very truly yours,
CURT Y. SCHNEIDER
Attorney General
CTS/CJM/cgm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.