Daniel Charles Reedy, Jr.

In re
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF WYOMING
Daniel Charles Reedy, Jr.
)
)
)
)
)
Case No. 	12-20354
CHAPTER13
Debtor
OPINION ON CONFIRMATION OF THE CHAPTER 13 PLAN
DATED APRIL 16. 2012
This matter came before the court for the telephonic hearing held June 20, 2012,
on Confirmation of the Chapter 13 Plan dated April16, 2012 filed by Daniel Reedy, Jr.
("Debtor") and the objection filed by the Standing Chapter 13 Trustee, Mark Stewart,
("Trustee"). After an examination of the record and review of the parties' arguments, the
court has determined that an evidentiary hearing would not materially assist the court.
Therefore, the court is prepared to rule.
Undisputed Facts
The Trustee objected to confirmation of the plan asserting that the Debtor's Plan
does not propose to apply all of his projected monthly disposable income to pay his non-
priority, unsecured creditors. Specifically, the Trustee argues that the Debtor is claiming
more transportation expenses than he is allowed. By deducting more expenses than he is
allowed, the Debtor is reducing the total amount of disposable income to be paid into the
plan.
On Schedule B, Debtor lists a 2004 Chevy Tahoe with 186,000 miles. The Debtor
also indicates on ScheduleD that the vehicle is encumbered in the amount of$4,900.00.
Case 12-20354 Doc 19 Filed 06/26/12 Entered 06/26/12 10:27:50 Desc Main
Document Page 1 of 5

The court's review of Debtor's Chapter 13 Statement of Current Monthly Income
and Calculation of Commitment Period and Disposable Income ("Form 22C") reflect that
the Debtor claims a vehicle operation expense for one vehicle in the amount of$436.00
(Line 27A) and an ownership expense for one vehicle in the amount of$412.00 (Line
28). Debtor's operating expense is derived from the allowable local standard in the
amount of$236.00 and the additional monthly operating expense of$200.00 generally
allowed for a vehicle over six years old or has reported mileage of75,000 miles or more.
The Debtor claims an ownership expense in the amount of$412.00 on Line 28 ofhis
Form 22C. The Debtor argues that he should be entitled to the ownership expense, the
operating expense and the additional operating expense as an allowable deduction. The
Trustee asserts that under the Internal Revenue Service's National and Local Standards,
the Debtor is not entitled to the additional $200.00 deduction so long as the vehicle is
encumbered.
Discussion
Page2
The Bankruptcy Code states,
"If the trustee objects to the confirmation of the plan, then the court
may not approve the plan unless, as of the effective date of the plan, the
plan provides that all of the debtor's projected disposable income to be
received in the applicable commitment period beginning on the date that
the first payment is due under the plan will be applied to make payments to
unsecured creditors under the plan."1
1 §1325(b)(l)(B).
Case 12-20354 Doc 19 Filed 06/26/12 Entered 06/26/12 10:27:50 Desc Main
Document Page 2 of 5

Upon the enactment ofBAPCPA 2, Congress adopted the means test to help ensure
that debtors who can pay creditors, do pay them. In Chapter 13 bankruptcy cases, the
means test provides the formula to calculate a debtor's disposable income that determines
that amount that the debtor must pay creditors through an approved plan. Above-median
income debtors use the means test to identify which expenses qualify as amount
reasonably necessary to be expended.
The Bankruptcy Code provides, in part, that a debtor's monthly expenses shall be
the amounts specified under the National Standards and Local Standards adopted by the
Internal Revenue Service ("IRS"). 3 The Local Standards include the allowable
transportation expense and divide the expenses into two parts: "Ownership Costs" and
"Operating Costs."
Page3
The IRS' Manual describes the transportation expenses, in part, as relevant:
"Transportation expenses are considered necessary when they are
used by taxpayers and their families to provide for their health and welfare
and/or the production of income. The transportation standards consist of
nationwide figures for loan or lease payments referred to as ownership
costs and additional amounts for operating costs broken down by Census
Region and Metropolitan Statistical Area. Operating costs include
maintenance, repairs, insurance, fuel, registrations, licenses, inspections,
parking and tolls.
• 	Ownership Expenses- Expenses are allowed for purchase or
lease of a vehicle. Taxpayers will be allowed the local
standard or the amount actually paid, whichever is less,
unless the taxpayer provides documentation to verify and
2 Code to Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005.
3 §707(b)(2)(A)(ii)(I).
Case 12-20354 Doc 19 Filed 06/26/12 Entered 06/26/12 10:27:50 Desc Main
Document Page 3 of 5

substantiate that the higher expenses are necessary. Generally,
auto loan or lease payments will not continue as allowed
expenses after the terms of the loan/lease have been satisfied.
However, depending on the age or condition of the vehicle,
the complete disallowance of the ownership expense may
result in a transportation expense allowance that does not
adequately meet the necessary expenses of the taxpayer.
• 	Operating Expenses - Allow the full operating costs portion
of the local transportation standard ...
• 	Additional Expenses - In situations where the taxpayer has a
vehicle that is currently over six years old or has reported
mileage of75,000 miles or more, an additional monthly
operating expense of $200 will generally be allowed per
vehicle.'>~
•
For application purposes, the court finds the example provided in the IRS Manual
to be particularly helpful:
The taxpayer has a 1995 Ford Taurus, with 90,000 reported miles.
The vehicle was bought used, and the auto loan will be fully paid in 30
months, at $300 per month. In this situation, the taxpayer will be allowed
the ownership expense until the loan is fully paid; i.e., $300 plus the
allowable operating expense of $231 per month, for a total transportation
allowance of$531 per month. After the auto loan is "retired" in 30 months,
the ownership expense is not applicable; however, at that point, the
taxpayer will be allowed a $200 operating expense allowance, in addition
to the standard $231, for a total operating expense allowance of$431 per
month. 5
In the facts of the case before the court, the Debtor's vehicle is encumbered. He is
not entitled to claim the $200.00 additional deduction until such time as the debt is
retired.
4 Internal Revenue Manual Part 5.8.5.20.3 (10-22-2010)
5 Supra.
Page4
Case 12-20354 Doc 19 Filed 06/26/12 Entered 06/26/12 10:27:50 Desc Main
Document Page 4 of 5

Conclusion
In conclusion, the court finds that the Debtor is not entitled to the deduction that
he has claimed in the means test. The results is that he is not providing all his projected
disposable income during the applicable commitment period of the plan to make
payments to unsecured creditors. The Trustee's objection to confirmation of the
Debtor's plan dated April16, 2012 shall be sustained.
This opinion constitutes the Court's findings of fact and conclusions oflaw. A
separate order shall be entered pursuant to Fed. R. Bankr. P. 9021.
DATED this 26th day ofJune, 2012.
Service to:
Page 5
Phillip Willoughby
Mark Stewart
By the Court
Case 12-20354 Doc 19 Filed 06/26/12 Entered 06/26/12 10:27:50 Desc Main
Document Page 5 of 5