Telcom Ventures LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al

2:24-cv-00691TxedApr 23, 2026

Full text

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
MARSHALL DIVISION
TELCOM VENTURES LLC,
Plaintiff,
v.
SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD.
and SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS
AMERICA, INC.,
Defendants.
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
CIVIL ACTION NO. 2:24-CV-00691-JRG
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
Before the Court is Defendants Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. and Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.’s (“Samsung”) Motion for Leave to Amend Invalidity Contentions (Dkt. No. 57)
(“Motion”). Samsung’s Motion requests leave to amend its invalidity contentions. Some of the
proposed amendments are opposed; some are unopposed. Having considered the briefing and the
documents cited therein, the Court finds that the Motion should be GRANTED.
I. 	BACKGROUND
Telcom Ventures LLC’s (“Telcom”) complaint asserted Samsung infringed eight patents in
the same family, all directed to performing financial transactions using a smartphone. (Dkt. No. 1.)
Telcom’s infringement contentions identified every claim of every asserted patent, for a total of
118 asserted claims.
Samsung served its amended invalidity contentions about six months after the invalidity
contentions deadline and with about five months left in fact discovery. Additionally, a relevant
Case 2:24-cv-00691-JRG Document 170 Filed 04/23/26 Page 1 of 5 PageID #:
<pageID>
2
timeline leading to Samsung’s Motion to amend its invalidity contentions follows:
• 	January 9, 2025: Samsung subpoenaed Motorola Mobility LLC (“Motorola”) regarding
potential mobile payment prior art. (Dkt. No. 66 at 5.)
• 	February 3, 2025: Samsung served its invalidity contentions that mentioned potential
Motorola prior art and that prior art discovery was ongoing. (Dkt. No. 57 at 5.)
• 	May 27, 2025: Motorola produced documents responsive to the January subpoena. (Id.
at 8.)
• 	July 31, 2025: Samsung informed Telcom of its intention to amend its invalidity
contentions in light of the documents Motorola produced; Samsung provided Telcom
with the disputed updated contentions. (Id. at 9.)
• 	August 29, 2025: Samsung filed the instant Motion. (Id.)
• 	December 18, 2025: Fact discovery closed. (Dkt. No. 44 at 4.)
II. 	LEGAL AUTHORITY
Under the local Patent Rules of the Eastern District of Texas, leave to amend invalidity
contentions “shall be entered only upon a showing of good cause.” P.R. 3-6(b). “‘[G]ood cause’
requires a showing of diligence.” 	O2 Micro Int’l Ltd. v. Monolithic Power Sys., Inc., 467 F.3d
1355, 1366 (Fed. Cir. 2006). 	Courts in this District consider four factors when determining
whether good cause has been shown: (1) the explanation for the failure to meet the deadline; (2)
the importance of the thing that would be excluded; (3) potential prejudice in allowing the thing
that would be excluded; and (4) the availability of a continuance to cure such prejudice. 	S&W
Enterprises, L.L.C. v. SouthTrust Bank of Alabama, NA, 315 F.3d 533, 535–36 (5th Cir. 2003).
Case 2:24-cv-00691-JRG Document 170 Filed 04/23/26 Page 2 of 5 PageID #:
<pageID>
3
III. 	SAMSUNG HAS GOOD CAUSE TO AMEND ITS INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS
FOR THE OPPOSED AMENDMENTS
Samsung 	requests 	leave 	to 	supplement 	its 	invalidity 	contentions 	with 	Motorola’s
contactless mobile payments systems. (Dkt. No. 57 at 7.) Samsung argues that it has good cause
to do so “because the relevant details regarding the [Motorola] system’s . . . operation had not yet
been produced in discovery” before the invalidity contentions due date. 	(Id. at 8.) 	As to the
importance of the prior art, Samsung stresses that the “Motorola systems invalidate all 118 claims
of the eight asserted patents.” (Id. at 10; Dkt. No. 70 at 3.) The prior art discloses relevant lock,
fingerprint, communication, and smart card features, among other features. 	(Dkt. No. 57 at 10;
Dkt. No. 70 at 4.) Allowing Samsung to amend would not unfairly prejudice Telcom because the
amendments occurred with months left in fact discovery; the amendments would not alter claim
construction or necessitate a continuance. (Dkt. No. 57 at 11–12.)
Telcom argues that Samsung was not diligent because it incurred a “six-month delay in
disclosing its new theories” and because “Samsung already possessed publicly available
documents that identified and described the [Motorola] system.” (Dkt. No. 66 at 7–11.) Telcom
also draws attention to an alleged “two-week delay” between Telcom stating its opposition to
Samsung’s Motion and Samsung filing its Motion. (Id. at 9.) The Motorola prior art is allegedly
not “any more important” than Samsung’s other prior art; it is cumulative of Samsung’s other prior
art. 	(Id. at 11–13.) 	Telcom would be prejudiced because it has “spent significant resources
investigating Samsung’s original invalidity contentions” and because Samsung’s supplement came
“just days away from initiating the claim construction process.” (Id. at 13.)
The Court is persuaded that Samsung has good cause to amend its invalidity contentions
with the Motorola prior art. As to diligence, Samsung informed Telcom of the Motorola prior art
in a timely fashion. 	Samsung’s originally served invalidity contentions mentioned potential
Case 2:24-cv-00691-JRG Document 170 Filed 04/23/26 Page 3 of 5 PageID #:
<pageID>
4
Motorola prior art and that prior art discovery was ongoing. (Supra § I.) To be clear, this is not a
case involving an eleventh-hour disclosure of a completely new prior art system.
Samsung, albeit, may have been able to chart the Motorola prior art systems more quickly
than it did. 	However, the Court appreciates that a material part of the delay stemmed from the
time necessary for Motorola to respond to a subpoena and the lack of publicly available
information regarding the Motorola prior art systems. See Gesture Tech. Partners, LLC v. Huawei
Device Co., No. 2:21-CV-0040-JRG, slip op. at 4 (E.D. Tex. Jan. 24, 2022) (“[Samsung] informed
[plaintiff] of the new information in a timely fashion and any delay appears to have been caused
by the inevitable time necessary for third parties to respond to subpoenas and the lack of publicly
available information regarding the prior art systems.”).
As to the importance of the Motorola systems, Samsung’s rote position that they “invalidate
all 118 claims of the eight asserted patents” strains credibility. 	See Optronic Scis. LLC v. BOE
Tech. Grp. Co., No. 2:23-CV-00549-JRG, 2025 WL 1509150, at *2 (E.D. Tex. May 27, 2025)
(“Defendant must present more than mere conclusory statements that the . . . [‘]prior art . . . could
invalidate all of the asserted claims.’”). Nonetheless, the reality that Samsung provided notice of
its amended invalidity theories about five months before the close of fact discovery mitigates
against excessive prejudice. (See Dkt. No. 57 at 10; Dkt. No. 70 at 4.)
All of these facts taken together persuade the Court that granting Samsung’s Motion is
warranted. See Optronic, 2025 WL 1509150, at *3 (granting leave to amend invalidity contentions
when diligence and lack of prejudice weighed in favor of doing so).
Telcom’s remaining arguments do not alter the Court’s analysis. Samsung gave notice of
the amended invalidity contentions with about five months left in fact discovery. 	This weighs
against Telcom’s point that Samsung took too long to give notice—including the alleged two-week
Case 2:24-cv-00691-JRG Document 170 Filed 04/23/26 Page 4 of 5 PageID #:
<pageID>
5
delay between Telcom stating its opposition and Samsung filing its Motion. Also, the Court is not
convinced that Samsung needed to chart the Motorola systems in its initial invalidity contentions
given the confidential inner workings of the Motorola systems and Samsung’s earlier notices of
the Motorola systems.
In sum, Samsung’s understandable effort with third-party discovery and the absence of
prejudice outweigh Telcom’s claims that the Motorola prior art may be cumulative. Further, this
has shown that Telcom’s worries that the Motorola prior art may impact claim construction (Dkt.
No. 66 at 13–14) were speculative at best. A day after filing these arguments, Telcom “agree[d]
that there [were] no disputed claim terms for which either party seeks construction.” (Dkt. No. 67
at 1.)
IV. 	UNOPPOSED AMENDMENTS
Telcom does not oppose Samsung’s request for leave “to make certain ministerial changes
to the cover pleading and to amend the A05 charts re Kyocera and the A12 charts re NFC.” (Dkt.
No. 57 at 13; see also Dkt. No. 66.) Given the unopposed nature, the Court finds that Samsung
has leave to amend its invalidity contentions for these requested and unopposed amendments.
V. 	CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated above, the Court hereby GRANTS Samsung’s Motion for Leave to
Amend Invalidity Contentions (Dkt. No. 57).
.
____________________________________
RODNEY GILSTRAP
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
So ORDERED and SIGNED this 23rd day of April, 2026.
Case 2:24-cv-00691-JRG Document 170 Filed 04/23/26 Page 5 of 5 PageID #:
<pageID>

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.