EireOg Innovations Ltd. v. Cisco Systems Inc.

2:24-cv-00224TxedApr 10, 2026

Full text

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
MARSHALL DIVISION
EIREOG INNOVATIONS LTD.,
Plaintiff,
v.
CISCO SYSTEMS INC.,
Defendant.
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
Case No. 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP
(Lead Case)
MEMORANDUM ORDER
Before the Court is Defendants Cisco Systems, Inc., Fortinet, Inc., International Business
Machines Corporation, and Palo Alto Networks, Inc.’s Motion to Exclude Improper Opinions of
Dr. Michael C. Brogioli. Dkt. No. 204. The motion is fully briefed. See Dkt. Nos. 259, 294, 323.
In the Motion, Defendants seek to exclude Dr. Brogioli’s opinions concerning benefits of the ’777
and Interrupt Patents, both under Daubert and as untimely. They also seek to exclude his opinions
on infringement as untimely. For the reasons set forth below, the Motion is DENIED.
I. 	LEGAL STANDARD
An expert witness may provide opinion testimony if “(a) the expert’s scientific, technical,
or other specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine
a fact in issue; (b) the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data; (c) the testimony is the product
of reliable principles and methods; and (d) the expert has reliably applied the principles and
methods to the facts of the case.” Fed. R. Evid. 702.
Rule 702 requires trial courts to make a preliminary determination, when requested, as to
whether the requirements of the rule are satisfied regarding a particular expert’s proposed
testimony. See Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael, 526 U.S. 137, 149 (1999); Daubert, 509 U.S. at
592–93 (1993). Such courts are given broad discretion in making Rule 702 admissibility
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 1 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
2
determinations. Kumho Tire, 526 U.S. at 152 (“a judge must have considerable leeway in deciding
in a particular case how to go about determining whether particular expert’s testimony is reliable”).
Although the Fifth Circuit and other courts have identified various factors that the court may
consider in determining whether an expert’s testimony should be admitted, the nature of the factors
that are appropriate for the court to consider is dictated by the ultimate inquiry—whether the
expert’s testimony is sufficiently reliable and relevant to be helpful to the finder of fact and thus
to warrant admission at trial. See United States v. Valencia, 600 F.3d 389, 424 (5th Cir. 2010).
Importantly, in a jury trial setting, the Court’s role under Daubert is not to weigh the expert
testimony to the point of supplanting the jury’s fact-finding role; instead, the Court’s role is limited
to that of a gatekeeper, ensuring that the evidence in dispute is at least sufficiently reliable and
relevant to the issue before the jury that it is appropriate for the jury to consider. See Micro Chem.,
Inc. v. Lextron, Inc., 317 F.3d 1387, 1391–92 (Fed. Cir. 2003) (applying Fifth Circuit law) (“When,
as here, the parties’ experts rely on conflicting sets of facts, it is not the role of the trial court to
evaluate the correctness of facts underlying one expert’s testimony.”); Pipitone v. Biomatrix, Inc.,
288 F.3d 239, 249–50 (5th Cir. 2002) (“‘The trial court’s role as gatekeeper is not intended to
serve as a replacement for the adversary system.’ . . . Thus, while exercising its role as a
gatekeeper, a trial court must take care not to transform a Daubert hearing into a trial on the merits”
(quoting an Advisory Committee Note to Fed. R. Evid. 702)). As the Supreme Court explained,
“vigorous cross-examination, presentation of contrary evidence, and careful instruction on the
burden of proof are the traditional and appropriate means of attacking shaky but admissible
evidence.” See Mathis v. Exxon Corp., 302 F.3d 448, 461 (5th Cir. 2002).
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 2 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
3
II. 	DISCUSSION
A. The ’777 Patent
i. 	Reliability of Benefits Opinions
Defendants argue that Dr. Brogioli’s benefits opinions related to the ’777 Patent should be
excluded as unreliable. Dkt. No. 204 at 4–7. Defendants argue that the “Streaming Load/Store”
document, on which Dr. Brogioli primarily relies, is hearsay that is “undated,” “written by an
unknown author,” and EireOg has produced no evidence that it was peer reviewed, published, or
otherwise relied upon by any expert. Id. at 4. Defendants argue no expert would reasonably rely
on such a document. Id. at 5. Defendants argue the document contains no information about who
performed testing, what computer systems were used, the purpose of the testing, or how the testing
was performed. Id. at 5. Defendants argue the document does not state whether the non-temporal
instructions were used on any accused product or Intel processor, or whether such instructions
were used in an accused mode or in a “non-modifying mode.” Id. at 6. Defendants argue that Dr.
Brogioli’s endorsement of the methodology used in the study is insufficient because experts cannot
render their own opinions reliable by approving of their own methods. Dkt. No. 294 at 1.
EireOg argues that Defendants’ complaints about the Streaming Load/Store document go
to the weight rather than admissibility of Dr. Brogioli’s opinions. Dkt. No. 259 at 3. EireOg argues
that reliance on hearsay is allowed and that the proper standard is whether experts in Dr. Brogioli’s
field would rely on it, and it has proferred sufficient evidence that such experts would. Dkt. No.
259 at 3–4. EireOg cites that the document reflects a study conducted by CERN, a reputable
organization in the field, and was found on their website. Id. at 4. EireOg also cites Dr. Brogioli’s
explanation that he would have used the same methodology as the document explained that CERN
used. Id. (citing Dkt. No. 259-3 at 370:1–372:22). EireOg argues that the document contains
sufficient identifying information, including that it was produced by CERN, when it was
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 3 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
4
published, and that a CERN Research Fellow who previously worked at Intel conducted the study.
Id. EireOg argues that Dr. Brogioli explains why the study is relevant, and that the “non-temporal
instructions”—and not the processor, computer systems, or pointers—provide the benefits of the
patented invention. Id. at 5–6. EireOg also argues that the document provides information on the
instructions used in the study, snippets of the code used, explanations of what the code is showing
and what it is used for, and the references to “icc” in the code are references to Intel’s C compiler.
Id. at 6–7 (first citing Dkt. No. 204-9 at 67733–38; and then citing Dkt. No. 259-3 at 281:1–20).
Having considered the briefing, the cited portions of Dr. Brogioli’s opening and
supplemental reports, and the Streaming Load/Store document, the Court finds Dr. Brogioli’s
benefits opinions are sufficiently reliable to survive this Daubert challenge. Experts are allowed
to and routinely do rely on inadmissible hearsay, see Fed. R. Evid. 703; United States v. Portillo,
969 F.3d 144, 170 (5th Cir. 2020), and EireOg has proffered evidence to show that experts in Dr.
Brogioli’s field would rely on it. Notably, Defendants drop the argument that the study methods
were not disclosed in their reply. Dkt. No. 294 at 1–3. Additionally, Dr. Brogioli does not endorse
methods he used, as Defendants seemingly argue, id. at 1, but methods used by the author of the
study, as a reason he reasonably relied upon the study. Dkt. No. 259-3 at 372:15–22. Dr. Brogioli
also sufficiently explains why he believes the 42% figure he used, based primarily on the
Streaming Load/Store document ratios, reflects the benefits of only the patented features. Dkt. No.
204-8 ¶¶ 97–107. Defendants’ other arguments are unpersuasive. Accordingly, the Court finds that
the Motion is denied to the extent it seeks exclusion of Dr. Brogioli’s technical benefits analysis
concerning the ’777 Patent.
ii. 	Timeliness of Infringement Opinions
Defendants argue that Dr. Brogioli’s infringement opinions on the “decoration operation”
limitation of Claim 16 of the ’777 Patent are untimely. They allege that EireOg contended that this
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 4 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
5
limitation was met by “the memory controller perform[ing] the decoration operation . . . on a
location in memory designated by the target address. For example, when an instruction in one
processor core requests to write to memory that is connected to the memory controller on a
different processor core.” Dkt. No. 204 at 8 (quoting Dkt. No. 204-11 at 14). Defendants allege
that Dr. Brogioli’s opinions now focus on a partial write to memory with a “byte enable”
“decoration” that “results in a different operand size,” which is inconsistent with the theory
disclosed in EireOg’s infringement contentions. Id. (quoting Dkt. No. 204-7 Ex. C ¶¶ 104, 144).
While they concede that the contentions mention the VEX prefix, they contest that the contentions
reference operand size and that the cited Intel manual discusses any prefix. Dkt. No. 294 at 3.
EireOg argues that its contentions were sufficient to put Defendants on notice of its
infringement theory with respect to the “decoration operation” limitation. Dkt. No. 259 at 10.
EireOg alleges that its contentions disclosed theories as to both REX and VEX prefixes, and that
the Intel manual cited in its contentions describes both prefixes in the same way that Dr. Brogioli
uses them. Dkt. No. 259 at 10–11 (citing Dkt. No. 259-4 at 4–5, 10–11, 13–14). EireOg alleges
the Intel manual also explains that these prefixes can change the operand size. Id. (citing Dkt. No.
259-4 at 11). EireOg argues that Defendants improperly focus on an example disclosed in its
contentions, to which EireOg’s theory is not limited. Dkt. No. 323 at 2.
The Court agrees that Defendants improperly focus on a non-limiting example provided in
EireOg’s contentions to argue that Dr. Brogioli’s infringement read on the “decoration operation”
limitation is untimely. Having reviewed the briefing, the cited portions of the contentions, and Dr.
Brogioli’s report, the Court finds that Dr. Brogioli’s theory is consistent with the theories disclosed
in EireOg’s contentions. The contentions do allege that the operation instruction “can be decorated
with [either] the REX or VEX prefix to access additional registers,” and that “use of the REX.W
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 5 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
6
prefix promotes operation to 64 bits” rather than “default operation size [of] 32 bits.” Dkt. No.
259-4 at 10–11 (emphasis added). Accordingly, the Court finds that Defendants’ Motion is denied
to the extent it seeks to exclude Dr. Brogioli’s infringement opinions related to the “decoration
operation” limitation of the ’777 Patent as untimely.
B. The Interrupt Patents1
iii. Reliability of Benefits Opinions
Defendants next argue that Dr. Brogioli’s opinions on the benefits of the Interrupt Patents
should be excluded as unreliable. Dkt. No. 204 at 11–13. Defendants’ argument is based on their
understanding that Tu, a 2015 journal article on direct interrupt delivery (“DID”), “does not reflect
the operation of the accused products or the claimed methods of the” Interrupt Patents. Id. at 11.
Defendants argue that, despite Dr. Brogioli’s theory that DID is equivalent to the “posted interrupt”
feature, Tu specifically distinguishes DID from Intel’s APICv technology, which includes that
feature. Id. at 11–12. Defendants argue that Dr. Brogioli fails to explain how DID reflects the
claimed “interrupt packages,” “partition identifiers” and use of a “processor,” or how DID is
practiced by the accused products. Id. at 12–13. Defendants also argue that Dr. Brogioli’s
apportionment analysis is without support because he arbitrarily chooses Tu’s 9.2% benefit for
“application-level CPU saving.” Id. at 13.
EireOg concedes that Tu distinguishes DID from the APICv interrupts but argues that Tu
still bears relevance because APICv/VT-d are more advanced, vendor-specific architectures that
achieve better results than DID. Dkt. No. 259 at 12–13 (citing Dkt. No. 204-16 at 67699, 67701).
In other words, EireOg argues, Tu provides “a conservative estimate” of the benefits of “bypassing
1 EireOg has elected to pursue only the ’777 Patent against Defendant Cisco. Dkt. No. 444 at 1.
Accordingly, although Cisco originally joined in this portion of the Motion, it is now moot as to
Cisco.
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 6 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
7
the hypervisor,” which is what Dr. Brogioli explains is the claimed improvement of the Interrupt
Patents. Id. at 13 (first citing Dkt. No. 204-16 at 67699; and then citing Dkt. No. 259-3 at 176:21–
177:23). As to the 9.2% benefits figure, EireOg argues that Tu provides improvement figures based
on different packets per second rates ranging from 100–600K, and Dr. Brogioli explained that he
chose the 600K figure as a “conservative estimate of the benefits conferred by the Interrupt
Patents” because “the Accused Products use substantially higher rates of packets per second than
600K.” Dkt. No. 259 at 13–14 (citing Dkt. No. 204-8 ¶¶ 115–22).
Having considered the briefing, the Tu article, and the cited portions of Dr. Brogioli’s
opening report, the Court finds Dr. Brogioli’s reliance on Tu and the technical benefits analysis
related to the Interrupt Patents to be sufficiently reliable. While DID is distinguished from the
APICv architecture, Tu does explain that DID allows software-based “hypervisor bypassing,” and,
as a result, that “DID can achieve the same . . . goals of minimizing the VM exits overheads . . .
without requiring advanced vendor-specific hardware support,” like Intel’s APICv. Dkt. No. 204-
16 at 67699, 67701. Dr. Brogioli further ties DID to the accused products and apportions to what
he contends reflects the benefits of only the patented invention. Dkt. No. 204-8 ¶¶ 108–22. Nothing
further is required, and Defendants’ other arguments are unpersuasive. Accordingly, the motion is
denied to the extent it seeks exclusion of Dr. Brogioli’s benefits opinions related to the Interrupt
Patents.
iv. Timeliness of Doctrine of Equivalents Opinions
Defendants argue that Dr. Brogioli’s opinions on infringement of the Interrupt Patents
under the doctrine of equivalents (“DOE”) are untimely. Dkt. No. 204 at 13–15. Specifically,
Defendants contend that EireOg’s contentions only included a DOE theory that “checking the PIR
bits of the currently running VM’s Posted Interrupt Descriptor is equivalent to the current-VMCS
register,” to satisfy the “processing the interrupt package . . . by comparing the . . . partition
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 7 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
8
identifier against at least a . . . stored partition identifier” limitation. Id. at 14. However, Defendants
allege that Dr. Brogioli’s opinions include three DOE theories: (1) that the “interrupt package”
includes a “partition identifier identifying a partition at the processor,” (2) processing an interrupt
“by comparing the . . . partition identifier against at least . . . a stored partition,” and (3) processing
an interrupt using information “retrieved from special purpose registers at the processor.” Id.
Defendants concede that the second theory was sufficiently disclosed in EireOg’s contentions. Id.
EireOg disagrees with Defendants’ characterization of its contentions. Dkt. No. 259 at 15.
EireOg alleges it disclosed that “checking the PIR bits of the currently running VM’s Posted
Interrupt Descriptor is equivalent and interchangeable with comparing the partition identifier
associated with the incoming interrupt to the current VMCS register.” Id. (emphasis in original).
EireOg argues this discloses that PIR bits are equivalent to partition identifiers. Id. EireOg argues
that Dr. Brogioli’s opinions that “the use of PIR bits in a PID to convey partition identity is an
insubstantial difference from the patent’s explicit identifier,” and “when VT-d set[s] a bit in the
[PIR] field of a PID, it is signaling that an interrupt is pending for the partition tied to that PID,”
are thus entirely consistent with this disclosure and not untimely. Id.
Defendants improperly focus on the fact that the DOE theory was within the corresponding
cell of the “processing the interrupt package . . .” limitation of EireOg’s infringement contentions,
and not in corresponding cells related to the two other limitations. Dkt. No. 294 at 4 (citing Dkt.
No. 204-21 at 36; Dkt. No. 204-22 at 26). However, the statement in the contentions that “checking
the PIR bits . . . is equivalent [to] . . . comparing the partition identifier” is sufficient to give notice
of Dr. Brogioli’s theory that the use of PIR bits to convey partition identity is equivalent to
comparison involving the claimed partition identifier. Dkt. No. 204-21 at 36; Dkt. No. 204-22 at
26; Dkt. No. 204-7 Ex. D ¶¶ 143–46; Dkt. No. 204-7 Ex. E ¶¶ 97–100. The complete contentions’
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 8 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
9
statement, that “checking the PIR bits of the currently running VM’s [PID] is equivalent [to] . . .
comparing the partition identifier associated with the incoming interrupt to the current VMCS
register,” is also consistent with Dr. Brogioli’s theory that “the role of the ‘stored partition
identifier’ is satisfied by the processor’s use of the VMCS-to-PIC association” because “[w]hen
VT-d set a bit in the [PIR] field of a PID, it is signaling an interrupt is pending for the partition
tied to that PID.” Dkt. No. 204-21 at 36; Dkt. No. 204-22 at 26; Dkt. No. 204-7 Ex. C ¶¶ 228–29;
Dkt. No. Ex. E ¶¶ 140–41. Accordingly, the motion is denied to the extent it seeks to exclude Dr.
Brogioli’s DOE opinions related to the Interrupt Patents as untimely.
C. Timeliness of Benefits Theories
Defendants argue that Dr. Brogioli’s benefits opinions related to both sets of patents are
untimely because EireOg did not disclose such theories during discovery. Dkt. No. 204 at 7–8, 13;
Dkt. No. 294 at 5. Defendants allege they requested in an interrogatory that EireOg “identify and
describe . . . any performance benefits.” Dkt. No. 204 at 7. Defendants allege that EireOg
responded that it may rely on unidentified “improvements in the accused products’ functionality,”
but never provided any information. Dkt. No. 294 at 5. Defendants allege that EireOg cited the
disputed Streaming Load/Store and Tu documents, along with 150 others, on the last day of
discovery, in response to a different interrogatory. Id. Defendants argue this disclosure was
insufficient to provide notice of Dr. Brogioli’s benefits theories, and that they were prejudiced by
their inability to conduct discovery on such theories. Id.; Dkt. No. 204 at 7.
EireOg argues that it was not required to disclose Dr. Brogioli’s technical benefits analysis
during fact discovery, and its disclosure of the factual basis for Dr. Brogioli’s opinions during fact
discovery was sufficient. Dkt. No. 259 at 7–8. EireOg alleges that it properly answered
Defendants’ interrogatory by responding that the benefits “will likely encompass improvements in
the 	accused 	products’ 	functionality 	and/or 	cost 	savings 	related 	to 	increasing 	processing
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 9 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
10
efficiencies,” and incorporated by reference its response to Interrogatory No. 1, which included
the Stream Load/Store and Tu documents. Id. at 8. EireOg also argues that even if its disclosure
was late, Defendants have suffered no prejudice because they deposed Dr. Brogioli at length
regarding his benefits opinions, and Defendants’ expert, Dr. Witchel, responded to Dr. Brogioli’s
opinions in detail in his rebuttal report. Id. at 9–10.
Having reviewed the briefing, EireOg’s interrogatory responses, and the cited portions of
Dr. Brogioli’s reports, the Court finds that EireOg’s theory was sufficiently disclosed. Dkt. No.
204-1 at 8–10. EireOg responded to Interrogatory No. 1, that, while an expert has not opined yet,
it plans to evaluate “technical benefits . . . via comparison with [NIAs] . . . which will likely
encompass improvements in the . . . functionality . . . related to increased processing efficiencies.”
Id. at 9. EireOg referenced “its response to Defendant’s Interrogatory No. 1.” Id. at 9–10. In that
response—after a similar statement identifying that the benefits theory would likely relate to
increased processing efficiencies—Eirog cited the Streaming Load/Store document and Tu article.
Dkt. No. 259 at 8; Dkt. No. 204-3 at 20. Dr. Brogioli’s benefits opinions are consistent with that
disclosure. Accordingly, the motion is denied insofar as it seeks exclusion of Dr. Brogioli’s
benefits opinions as untimely.
III. 	CONCLUSION
For the reasons provided above, the Court finds that the Motion (Dkt. No. 204) should be
and hereby is DENIED.
.
____________________________________
ROY S. PAYNE
UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
SIGNED this 3rd day of January, 2012.
SIGNED this 9th day of April, 2026.
Case 2:24-cv-00224-RWS-RSP Document 450 Filed 04/10/26 Page 10 of 10 PageID
#: <pageID>

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.