Siras v. Bah et al

3:25-cv-02395PamdDec 22, 2025

Full text

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
CYRIL ANDRE MARCEL SIRAS,
Petitioner,
v.
IDIATOU BAH,
HASSATOU DIALLO and
THIERO DIALLO,
Respondents.
No. 3:25-CV-02395
(Chief Judge Brann)
MEMORANDUM OPINION
DECEMBER 22, 2025
I. 	BACKGROUND
Petitioner Cyril Andre Marcel Siras (“Siras”) brought the instant emergency
petition against Idiatou Bah (“Bah”) and Hassatou and Thiero Diallo (“the Diallos”)
for the alleged secreting of his child, E.J.K.B., from France to the United States. 1
Petitioner alleges violations of the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of
International Child Abduction (“the Hague Convention”) and the International Child
Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”). A show-cause hearing was held on the issue
on this date.
1 	Doc. 1 (Compl.).
Case 3:25-cv-02395-MWB Document 16 Filed 12/22/25 Page 1 of 8
2
At the hearing, the evidence presented showed as follows:
E.J.K.B., currently seven years old, was born to Siras and Bah in the United
States but, since then, has lived her entire life in France. Siras and Bah never married,
but the parties had an informal custody agreement where they “worked it out.” The
parties recently entered custody proceedings for E.J.K.B. in the Versailles Family
Court in France, with both Siras and Bah seeking custody for E.J.K.B. There was a
hearing scheduled for June 2025, but, at Bah’s request, it was postponed until
January 2026. Bah requested permission to leave France with the child; this
permission was denied by Siras and the court officials overseeing the negotiation.
Bah requested permission from Siras to order a new American passport for E.J.K.B.,
which Siras said he “absolutely” denied.
Bah brought E.J.K.B. to the United States in July 2025 for a purported
vacation, a vacation that Siras objected to. Siras discovered that Bah and E.J.K.B.
had left France on July 6, 2025, when he went to Bah’s residence, and Bah told Siras
that they had been on vacation for the past two months. It is undisputed that E.J.K.B.
and Bah at some point visited the Diallos; conflicting evidence was presented as to
how long the child remained with them. Siras took no action to further object to this
“vacation” during this time.
After two months in the United States, Bah informed Siras that Bah had
returned to France, leaving E.J.K.B. with “good people” in the United States. When
Case 3:25-cv-02395-MWB Document 16 Filed 12/22/25 Page 2 of 8
3
Siras requested Bah to return E.J.K.B. to France, she refused. E.J.K.B. was enrolled
in a public school in New York City, but Siras had no knowledge of this and
continued 	to 	believe 	that 	she 	resided 	with 	the 	Diallos 	in 	Monroe 	County,
Pennsylvania. Since Bah left the United States, Elea’s maternal grandparents have
supervised her in the Bronx, New York while Bah resided in France.
II. 	ANALYSIS
“The Hague Convention, Article 1, sets forth its two primary objectives: ‘(a)
to secure the prompt return of children wrongfully removed to or retained in any
Contracting State; and (b) to ensure that rights of custody and of access under the
law of one Contracting State are effectively respected in the other Contracting
States.’” 2 “The Hague Convention does not provide a forum to resolve international
custody disputes, but rather it provides a legal process ‘to restore the status quo prior
to any wrongful removal or retention, and to deter parents from engaging in
international forum shopping in custody cases.’” 3 The aim of the treaty is to “ensure
that custody is adjudicated in what is presumptively the most appropriate forum—
the country where the child is at home.” 4 The United States is a signatory to the
Convention, and has additionally passed ICARA to implement the convention.5
2 	Karpenko v. Leendertz, 619 F. 3d 259, 263 (3d Cir. 2010) (quoting the Hague Convention
Article 1).
3 	Id. (quoting Yang v. Tsui, 499 F.3d 259, 270 (3d Cir. 2007).
4 	Monasky v. Taglieri, 589 U.S. 68, 79 (2020).
5 	Monzon v. De La Roca, 910 F.3d 92, 97 (3d Cir. 2018).
Case 3:25-cv-02395-MWB Document 16 Filed 12/22/25 Page 3 of 8
4
Under the Hague Convention, a child “abducted in violation of ‘rights of
custody’ must be returned to the child’s country of habitual residence, unless certain
exceptions 	apply.” 6 The 	petitioner 	“bears 	the 	initial 	burden 	of 	proving 	by
preponderance of the evidence that the child was habitually resident in a State
signatory to the Convention and was wrongfully removed to a different State as
defined by Article 3.” 7 “Under the Convention, a removal or retention is ‘wrongful’
if it breaches rights of custody ‘under the law of the State in which the child was
habitually resident immediately before the removal or retention’ and those rights
were 	being 	exercised 	or 	would 	have 	been 	exercised 	but 	for 	the 	removal.” 8
Specifically, a petitioner must prove:
(1) when the removal or retention took place; (2) the child's habitual residence
immediately prior to such removal or retention; (3) whether the removal or
retention breached the petitioner's custody rights under the law of the child's
habitual residence; and (4) whether the petitioner was exercising his or her
custody rights at the time of removal or retention. 9
6 	Abbott v. Abbott, 560 U.S. 1, 5 (2010); see also Khan v. Seemab, No. 25-2283, 2025 WL
2582897, at *2 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 4, 2025) (“[T]he Convention ordinarily requires the prompt
return of a child wrongfully removed or retained away from the country in which she habitually
resides.”) (internal quotation omitted).
7 	Id.
8 	Khan v. Seemab, No. 25-2283, 2025 WL 2582897, at *2 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 4, 2025) (quoting
Convention, Article 3; 22 U.S.C. § 9003(f)(2)).
9 	Yang, 499 F.3d at 270-71.
Case 3:25-cv-02395-MWB Document 16 Filed 12/22/25 Page 4 of 8
5
“For purposes of the Convention, ‘rights of custody’ shall include rights relating to
the care of the person of the child, and in particular, the right to determine the child’s
place of residence.” 10
Once the petitioner meets its burden, respondent may prove an affirmative
defense. 11 Such defenses include a “grave risk” that the child’s return would “expose
the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an
intolerable situation.”12 However, even “where a defense applies, the [C]ourt has the
discretion to order the child’s return.” 13
Here, Petitioner Siras has met his burden of proof, and, therefore, the child
shall be temporarily returned to him and then on to France to adjudicate the custody
dispute there. Siras has established first that E.J.K.B. was wrongfully retained 14 in
the United States sometime after July 2025 and that, upon realizing she had been left
10 	Application of McCullough on Behalf of McCullough, 4 F. Supp. 2d 411, 414 (W.D. Pa. 1998)
(quoting Feder v. Evans-Feder, 63 F.3d 217, 220 (3d Cir. 1995)).
11 	Monzon, 910 F.3d at 97.
12 	Feder v. Evans-Feder, 63 F.3d 217, 221 (3d Cir. 1995).
13 	Id. (internal quotation omitted). The ICARA provides a limitation on the Court’s authority,
though, stating that the Court cannot remove a child from “a person having physical control of
the child unless the applicable requirements of state law are satisfied.” Application of
McCullough on Behalf of McCullough, 4 F. Supp. 2d 411, 414 (W.D. Pa. 1998). I find, for the
same reasons that the court in McCullough found, looking to the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil
Procedure and the applicable Pennsylvania laws, that the “extraordinary emergency relief”
sought by petitioner is appropriate under the applicable Pennsylvania and French laws. See
McCullough, 4 F. Supp. 2d at 414.
14 	Bah contends that Siras knew of the vacation and her plans to take E.J.K.B. to the United
States, but the convention protects both against wrongful removal to another country and
wrongful retention in another country. Golan v. Saada, 596 U.S. 666, 670 (2022) (“the
Convention generally requires the ‘prompt return’ of a child to the child's country of habitual
residence when the child has been wrongfully removed to or retained in another country.”)
(quoting the Hague Convention Art. 1(a)).
Case 3:25-cv-02395-MWB Document 16 Filed 12/22/25 Page 5 of 8
6
in the United States and would not be returning from “vacation,” he objected to such
removal. Second, Siras has shown that the child’s habitual residence was in France
until the removal. Third, petitioner has established that the removal of the child
breached his custody rights because parties were in an ongoing custody dispute at
the time of the removal and, pursuant to France’s parental authority laws, the father
has a default right to have a role in the important decisions of the child’s life. 15
Fourth, petitioner was exercising his custody rights at the time of removal; he
communicated with and visited the child on a regular basis, and parties were in the
middle of a custody dispute with Siras seeking custody of E.J.K.B. when the
secreting occurred. Bah has not brought any affirmative defenses to the proceeding
and, therefore, the Court must order the child returned to the non-absconding parent
and her habitual residence of France.
The Court notes that this order is extremely limited in scope; it is not to be
taken as a permanent custody order or any indication about what level of custody
either party should receive of E.J.K.B. The only Order of this Court is to provide
Siras with temporary custody of E.J.K.B. to ensure all parties arrive at the correct
15 	P2 (Title IX, Article 371 and 373) (“Parental authority is a cluster of rights and duties whose
finality is the interest of the child. It is vested in the father and mother until the majority or
emancipation.”) (“Separation of the parents has no influence on the rules and devolution of the
exercise or parental authority each of the father and mother shall maintain personal relations
with the child and respect the bonds of the latter with the other parent.”). See also Article 373-
2-1 (“The parent who does not have the exercise of parental authority shall keep the right and
the duty to supervise the support and education of the child. He or she must be given notice of
the important choices relating to the life of the child.”).
Case 3:25-cv-02395-MWB Document 16 Filed 12/22/25 Page 6 of 8
7
custody dispute resolution forum, namely the upcoming January 2026 hearing at the
Versailles Family Court to be held less than three weeks from now. 16
Petitioner has also asked to hold all three respondents in contempt of court for
allegedly violating the Court’s Order of December 12, 2025.17 The Court is not
inclined to do so, finding insufficient evidence from which to conclude that the
Diallos materially violated the Court’s Order. Indeed, the evidence presented
indicates that the Diallos did not have custody of the child at the time of the Order
and, thus, could not turn her over to Siras. However, the Court will allow Petitioner
Siras to submit post-trial briefing on the issue of whether costs, including attorney’s
fees, should be shifted to Bah under Section 11607 of the ICARA. Petitioner should
do so, if he chooses to, by January 30, 2026.
III. 	CONCLUSION
Petitioner Siras will have temporary custody over E.J.K.B. until all parties
can attend the January 8, 2026 custody hearing to be held in the Versailles Family
Court in the Republic of France. Bah is to turn over E.J.K.B.’s travel documents,
including both her French and American passports, to Petitioner Siras.
16 	See Khan v. Seemab, No. 25-2283, 2025 WL 2582897, at *1 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 4, 2025) (“The
remedies available under ICARA are limited: we may order the return of a child to his or her
country of habitual residence but we may not adjudicate the merits of any underlying custody
dispute.”).
17 	Doc. 5.
Case 3:25-cv-02395-MWB Document 16 Filed 12/22/25 Page 7 of 8
8
An appropriate Order follows.
BY THE COURT:
s/ Matthew W. Brann
Matthew W. Brann
Chief United States District Judge
Case 3:25-cv-02395-MWB Document 16 Filed 12/22/25 Page 8 of 8

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.