Branch v. Dauphin County Recorder of Deeds Office et al

1:25-cv-00812PamdMar 23, 2026

Full text

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
JORDAN A. BRANCH,
Plaintiff,
v.
DAUPHIN COUNTY RECORDER OF
DEEDS OFFICE, et al.,
Defendants.
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
Civil No. 1:25-CV-00812
Judge Jennifer P. Wilson
ORDER
Before the court is the report and recommendation of Magistrate Judge Sean
A. Camoni recommending that the court grant Defendants’ motions to dismiss,
dismiss the amended complaint without prejudice, and deny Plaintiff’s motion for
default judgment. (Doc. 90.) Plaintiff objected to the report and recommendation,
which Defendants opposed. (Docs. 91, 97, 98, 99.) Defendants ONE Abstract,
LLC and Realty One (collectively, “ONE Defendants”) and Defendants Lower
Paxton Township and Officer Morris (collectively, “Township Defendants”) also
filed objections to the report and recommendation. (Docs. 93, 94, 95, 96.)
Plaintiff did not respond to Defendants’ objections. For the reasons that follow,
the court sustains Defendants’ objections, overrules Plaintiff’s objections, adopts
the report and recommendation in part, and dismisses Plaintiff’s amended
complaint without prejudice.
Case 1:25-cv-00812-JPW-SAC Document 100 Filed 03/23/26 Page 1 of 8
2
S TANDARD OF REVIEW
A. Review of a Magistrate Judge’s report and recommendation
When a party specifically objects to a magistrate judge’s report and
recommendation, the district court is required to conduct a de novo review of the
contested portions of the report and recommendation. 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1); Fed.
R. Civ. P. 72(b)(3); Sample v. Diecks, 885 F.2d 1099, 1106 n.3 (3d Cir. 1989).
The district court may accept, reject, or modify the magistrate judge’s report and
recommendation in whole or in part. 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1). The district court may
also receive further evidence or recommit the matter to the magistrate judge with
further instructions. Id. “Although the standard is de novo, the extent of review is
committed to the sound discretion of the district judge, and the court may rely on
the recommendations of the magistrate judge to the extent it deems proper.”
Weidman v. Colvin, 164 F. Supp. 3d 650, 653 (M.D. Pa. 2015) (citing Rieder v.
Apfel, 115 F. Supp. 2d 496, 499 (M.D. Pa. 2000)).
When a party raises only general objections to a report and recommendation,
a district court is not required to conduct a de novo review of the report and
recommendation. Goney v. Clark, 749 F.2d 5, 6–7 (3d Cir. 1984). “To obtain de
novo determination of a magistrate’s findings by a district court, 28 U.S.C.
§ 636(b)(1) requires both timely and specific objections to the report.” Id. at 6.
Thus, when reviewing general objections to a report and recommendation, the
Case 1:25-cv-00812-JPW-SAC Document 100 Filed 03/23/26 Page 2 of 8
3
court’s review is limited “to ascertaining whether there is ‘clear error’ or ‘manifest
injustice’” on the face of the record. Boomer v. Lewis, No. 3:06-CV-00850, 2009
WL 2900778, at *1 (M.D. Pa. Sept. 9, 2009).
For the uncontested portions of the report and recommendation, the court
affords “reasoned consideration” before adopting it as the decision of this court.
City of Long Branch, 866 F.3d at 100 (quoting Henderson, 812 F.2d at 878).
DISCUSSION
In the report and recommendation, Judge Camoni details the background of
this case regarding the complaints filed, proof of service, waivers, and pending
motions. (Doc. 90, pp. 2–4.) He then recommends that the court grant
Defendants’ motions to dismiss because Plaintiff’s amended complaint, which
supersedes the original complaint, fails to allege any facts. (Id. at 6–8.) Instead,
the amended complaint simply lists Defendants and, at most, his prayers for relief.
(Id. at 7.)
Next Judge Camoni recommends that the court deny Plaintiff’s motion for
default judgment because there are no entries of default against Defendants,
Plaintiff never properly served Defendant Dream Home Realty, and default
judgment is not warranted against the ONE and Township Defendants. (Id. at 8–
15.) In this section, the report and recommendation finds that although the ONE
and Township Defendants filed their motions to dismiss two days late on July 28,
Case 1:25-cv-00812-JPW-SAC Document 100 Filed 03/23/26 Page 3 of 8
4
2025, that is insufficient to warrant default judgment against these Defendants.
(Id. at 12–15.) Lastly, Judge Camoni recommends that Plaintiff be granted leave
to amend his complaint, but that the court should require proper service of the
pleadings if Plaintiff elects to file a second amended complaint. (Id. at 15–16.)
Addressing Defendants’ objections first, both the ONE and Township
Defendants argue that Judge Camoni erred in finding that they filed their motions
to dismiss two days after the required deadline. (Docs. 94, 96.) They assert that
they timely waived service of the summons on May 27, 2025, which provided
them with 60 days to respond to the amended complaint. (Doc. 94, pp. 4–5; Doc.
96, pp. 6–7.) The deadline to respond was July 26, 2025, which was a Saturday,
thus, under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 6(a)(1), the ONE and Township
Defendants assert they had until July 28, 2025 to respond to the amended
complaint. (Doc. 94, pp. 5–6; Doc. 96, pp. 7–8.)
The court agrees with the ONE and Township Defendants that their motions
to dismiss were timely under Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 4(d)(3) and 6(a)(1).
Rule 4(d)(3) provides: “A defendant who, before being served with process, timely
returns a waiver need not serve an answer to the complaint until 60 days after the
request was sent.” Here, Plaintiff mailed the amended complaint to the ONE and
Township Defendants on May 27, 2025, therefore, a responsive pleading was due
on July 26, 2025, which was a Saturday. Pursuant to Rule 6(a)(1)(C), if the last
Case 1:25-cv-00812-JPW-SAC Document 100 Filed 03/23/26 Page 4 of 8
5
day of the specified time period is “a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, the period
continues to run until the end of the next day that is not a Saturday, Sunday, or
legal holiday.” Accordingly, the ONE and Township Defendants’ deadline to
respond to Plaintiff’s amended complaint was Monday, July 28, 2025, the day the
motions to dismiss were filed. Therefore, the court sustains the ONE and
Township Defendants objections, and declines to adopt that specific finding in the
report and recommendation.
Plaintiff also filed objections to the report and recommendation. (Doc. 91.)
Therein, Plaintiff reargues the points raised before Judge Camoni, namely, that he
properly served Defendants, Defendants are in default, and he should receive a
default judgment in his favor, and that he properly alleged sufficient facts and
claims against Defendants. (Id.) In arguing that his pleading was sufficient,
Plaintiff appears to rely on his original complaint as well as his amended
complaint. (Id. at 3–10.)
Plaintiff’s objections are general in nature, thus, the court’s review is limited
“to ascertaining whether there is ‘clear error’ or ‘manifest injustice’” on the face of
the record. Boomer v. Lewis, No. 3:06-CV-00850, 2009 WL 2900778, at *1 (M.D.
Pa. Sept. 9, 2009). The court has reviewed Judge Camoni’s report and
recommendation and finds that Plaintiff is simply rearguing his points and
expressing disagreement with Judge Camoni’s analysis. For these reasons, the
Case 1:25-cv-00812-JPW-SAC Document 100 Filed 03/23/26 Page 5 of 8
6
court overrules Plaintiff’s objections, grants Defendants’ motions to dismiss,
denies Plaintiff’s motion for default judgment, and dismisses Plaintiff’s amended
complaint without prejudice. The court gives Plaintiff leave to file a second
amended complaint within 21 days of this order. That said, the second amended
complaint must contain all factual and legal allegations that Plaintiff wishes to
bring against Defendants because an amended complaint “supersedes the original
and renders it of no legal effect.” W. Run Student Hous. Assocs., LLC v.
Huntington Nat. Bank, 712 F.3d 165, 171 (3d Cir. 2013) (quoting New Rock Asset
Partners, L.P. v. Preferred Entity Advancements, Inc., 101 F.3d 1492, 1504 (3d
Cir. 1996)).
Lastly, the court partially declines to adopt the recommendation that Plaintiff
be required to properly serve Defendants if he elects to file a second amended
complaint. All Defendants other than Dream Home Realty returned waiver of
service forms and received the benefit of an extended response period under Rule
4(d)(3). (See Docs. 25, 35, 41.) Importantly, Rule 4(d)(3) provides: “A defendant
who, before being served with process, timely returns a waiver . . . .” Further, Rule
4(d)(4) provides: “When the plaintiff files a waiver, proof of service is not required
and these rules apply as if a summons and complaint had been served at the time of
filing the waiver.” Given these rules, the court cannot conclude that Plaintiff is
required to serve Defendants Dauphin County, Dauphin County Recorder of Deeds
Case 1:25-cv-00812-JPW-SAC Document 100 Filed 03/23/26 Page 6 of 8
7
Office, Lower Paxton Township, Officer Morris, ONE Abstract LLC, ONE Group
Unlimited, LLC, and Realty ONE Group Unlimited. Dream Home Realty,
however, did not provide a waiver of service form and has not been properly
served under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Thus, Plaintiff is required to
serve a second amended complaint, if filed, in accordance with the Federal Rules
of Civil Procedure on Defendant Dream Home Realty.
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated herein, IT IS ORDERED AS FOLLOWS:
1) The ONE Defendants and the Township Defendants objections to the
report and recommendation, Docs. 93 & 95, are SUSTAINED.
2) Plaintiff’s objections, Doc. 91, are OVERRULED.
3) The report and recommendation, Doc. 90, is ADOPTED IN PART as
described in this order.
4) Defendants’ motions to dismiss, Docs. 28, 52, 61, & 63, are
GRANTED.
5) Plaintiff’s motion for default judgment, Doc. 79, is DENIED.
6) Plaintiff’s amended complaint, Doc. 16, is DISMISSED WITHOUT
PREJUDICE.
7) Plaintiff may file a second amended complaint within 21 days of this
order. Should Plaintiff elect to file a second amended complaint,
Plaintiff must effectuate proper service on Defendant Dream Home
Realty in accordance with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. If
Plaintiff does not elect to file a second amended complaint, the Clerk
of Court shall close this case.
Case 1:25-cv-00812-JPW-SAC Document 100 Filed 03/23/26 Page 7 of 8
8
8) This matter is referred back to Magistrate Judge Camoni for further
pretrial management.
s/Jennifer P. Wilson
JENNIFER P. WILSON
United States District Judge
Middle District of Pennsylvania
Dated: March 23, 2026
Case 1:25-cv-00812-JPW-SAC Document 100 Filed 03/23/26 Page 8 of 8

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.