Vega v. Wetzel et al

1:22-cv-00593PamdDec 19, 2025

Full text

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
PETER VEGA,
Plaintiff
V.
DR. BADICK, et al.,
Defendants
CIVIL ACTION NO. 1 :22-593
(JUDGE MANNION)
MEMORANDUM
Presently before the court in this prisoner civil rights case is a motion
to dismiss and motion for summary judgment filed 	by one defendant, 	a
motion for judgment on the pleadings filed 	by 	all 	other defendants, 	and
several other motions. For the reasons set forth below, the motion to dismiss
will be granted in part and denied in part, the motion for judgment on the
pleadings and motion for summary judgment will be denied, and all other
motions will be deemed withdrawn for the failure by the moving parties to file
supporting briefs.
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 1 of 13
I. 	8ACKGROUND 1
Plaintiff, 	Peter 	Vega, 	filed 	this 	case 	on 	April 	22 , 	2022, 	alleging
general ly 	that 	defendants 	were 	deliberately 	indifferent 	and 	committed
malpractice when 	they 	failed 	to adequately treat 	his 	liver, kidney, and
stomach conditions. (Doc. 1). The case was initially assigned 	to 	United
States District Judge Christopher C. Conner.
Following two rounds of motions to dismiss, Judge Conner issued a
memorandum 	and 	order 	on 	March 	11 , 2024, dismissing 	Vega's claims
against 	all 	defendants 	except 	Badick, Bora 	Saikia, Loscalzo, 	Williams,
O'Brien, and Shah. (Docs. 109-10). Plaintiff's amended complaint, filed on
May 4, 2023, remains the operative complaint. ( See Doc. 59). All remaining
defendants have answered the amended complaint. (Docs. 76, 115).
On 	July 	17, 	2023, 	defendant 	Shah , who 	was 	first 	named 	as 	a
defendant in the amended complaint, filed a notice of his intent to move to
dismiss the amended complaint for Vega's failure to file a certificate of merit
1 As discussed below, the court's substantive analysis in this op inion
only proceeds as to t he currently pending motion to dismiss and motion for
judgment on the pleadings. Because both of these motions seek relief based
on plaintiff's purported failure to file a certificate of merit in accordance with
the Pennsylvan ia Rules of Civil Procedure and not based on the sufficiency
of the factual a ll egations in plaintiff's complaint, the court does not include a
summary of plaintiff's allegations in this section in the interest of judicial
economy. A summary of plaintiff's allegations may be found in the previous
opinion issued in this case. ( See Doc. 110).
2
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 2 of 13
as required by Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1042.3. (Doc. 86). In
accordance with that notice, Shah filed a motion to dismiss the amended
complaint on July 2, 2024. (Doc. 123). The discovery deadline passed on
July 	31, 	2024. 	(See 	Doc. 	113). 	Shah then filed 	a motion for summary
judgment on September 27, 2024. (Doc. 131 ). All other defendants moved
for judgment on the pleadings on September 30, 2024, based on Vega's
purported failure to file certificates of merit. (Doc. 133).
On October 15, 2024, defendant Shah moved to strike a request for
admissions that Vega had served on him during the discovery process. (Doc.
138). On November 21 , 2024, defendants Badick, Bora Saikia, Loscalzo,
Williams, 	and 	O'Brien 	("Wellpath 	Defendants") 	filed 	a 	suggestion 	of
bankruptcy and notice of stay, noting that the company that employed them
during 	the 	relevant 	period, 	Wellpath 	LLC, 	filed 	a voluntary 	petition 	for
bankruptcy relief in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern
District of Texas and that the case was therefore subject to an automatic stay
pursuant to 11 U.S.C. 362. (Doc. 143).
On December 27, 2024, Vega filed a "motion for an order of protection
of his civil 	rights 	claims ." 	(Doc. 	151 ). 	The case was 	reassigned 	to the
undersigned on January 21, 2025, following Judge Conner's retirement from
the court. The court then granted Wellpath Defendants' motion to stay the
3
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 3 of 13
case on February 6, 2025, and stayed and administratively closed the case.
(Doc. 155).
On May 28, 2025, Wellpath Defendants provided a status report stating
that 	the 	automatic 	stay 	no 	longer 	applied 	to 	this 	case 	in 	light 	of the
bankruptcy court's May 1, 2025, order approving Wellpath 's Chapter 11 plan
of reorganization . (Doc. 156). The 	court accordingly 	lifted the 	stay 	and
reopened the case on June 26, 2025. (Doc. 157). Vega then filed a motion
for injunctive relief on July 18 , 2025. (Doc. 159). That motion and all other
pending motions are ripe for the court's review and are addressed in this
opinion.
II. 	UNSUPPORTED MOTIONS
At the outset, the court will 	deem several of the 	pending 	motions
withdrawn . Under Local Rule 7.5, a motion must be deemed withdrawn if the
movi ng party fai ls to file a brief in support of the motion within fourteen days.
M.D. Pa . L. R. 7.5. Here, defendant Shah failed to file a brief in support of his
motion to stri ke , and Vega failed to file briefs in support of his motion for
protection and motion for injunctive relief. ( See Docs. 131, 138, 151, 159).
All three motions are accordingly deemed withdrawn 	in accordance with
Local Rule 7.5.
4
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 4 of 13
Defendant Shah's motion for summary judgment will also be summarily
denied without prejudice because he has failed to file a statement of material
facts in connection with the motion as required by Local Rule 56.1. See M.D.
Pa . L.R. 56 .1 ("A motion for summary judgment filed pursuant to Fed. R. Civ.
P. 56, shall be accompanied by a separate, short and concise statement of
the material facts, in numbered paragraphs, as to which the moving party
contends there 	is 	no 	genuine 	issue to 	be 	tried."). 	The 	court's 	analysis
accordingly 	proceeds 	only with 	respect to 	defendant 	Shah's 	motion 	to
dismiss and the other defendants' motion for judgment on the pleadings.
Ill. 	STANDARDS OF REVIEW
A. 	Motion to Dismiss
Federal Rule of Civil 	Procedure 12(b)(6) authorizes dismissal of a
complaint for "failure to state a claim upon which relief may be granted."
Under Rule 12(b)(6), the court must "accept all factual allegations as true,
construe the 	complaint 	in 	the 	light 	most favorable 	to 	the 	plaintiff, 	and
determine whether, 	under any reasonable reading 	of the complaint, 	the
plaintiff may be entitled to relief. " Fowler v. UPMC Shadyside, 578 F.3d 203,
210 (3d Cir. 2009 (quoting Phillips v. County of Allegheny, 515 F.3d 224, 231
(3d Cir. 2008)). While a complaint need only contain 	"a 	short and 	plain
statement 	of 	the 	claim, 	Fed. 	R. 	Civ. 	P. 	8(a)(2), 	and 	detailed 	factual
5
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 5 of 13
allegations are not required , Bell At/. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 555
(2007), a complaint must plead "enough facts to state a claim to relief that is
plausible on its face ." Id. at 570. "The plausibility standard is not akin to a
'probability requirement ,' but it asks for more than a sheer possibility that a
defendant has acted unlawfully. " Ashcroft v. 	Iqbal, 556 	U.S. 	662 (2009)
(quoting 	Twombly, 550 U.S. at 556). "[L]abels 	and 	conclusions" are not
enough , Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555, and a court " is not bound to accept as
true a legal conclusion couched as a factual allegation. " Id.
In resolving a motion to dismiss, the court thus conducts "a two-part
analysis. " Fowler, 578 F.3d at 210. First, the court separates the factual
elements from the legal elements and disregards the legal conclusions. Id.
at 210-11 . Second, the court determines "whether the facts alleged in the
complaint are sufficient to show that the plaintiff has a plausible claim for
relief ." Id. at 21 1 (quotations omitted).
Courts must liberally construe complaints brought by pro se litigants.
Sause v. Bauer, 585 U.S. 957, 960 (2018). 	Pro se complaints, "however
inartfully pleaded, must 	be 	held to 	less stringent standards than formal
pleadings drafted by lawyers ." Erickson v. Pardus, 551 	U.S. 89, 94 (2007)
(quoting Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97 , 106 (1976)).
6
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 6 of 13
B. 	Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings
A motion for judgment on the pleadings is the procedural hybrid of a
motion to dismiss and a motion for summary judgment. Westport Ins. Corp.
v. Black, Davis & Shue Agency, Inc., 513 F. Supp. 2d 157, 162 (M.D. Pa.
2007). Rule 12(c) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provides: "After the
pleadings are closed-but early enough not to delay trial-a party may move
for judgment on the pleadings." Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(c). To succeed on a Rule
12(c) motion, the movant must clearly establish that no material issue of fact
remains to be resolved and that the movant "is entitled to judgment as a
matter of law." Sikirica v. 	Nationwide Ins. 	Co., 416 F.3d 214, 220 (3d Cir.
2005). A Rule 12(c) motion for judgment on the pleadings is decided under
a standard similar to a Rule 	12(b )(6) motion to dismiss. 	Zimmerman 	v.
Corbett, 873 F.3d 414, 417 (3d Cir. 2017). That is, judgment on the pleadings
should be granted only when, accepting as true the facts alleged by the
nonmovant and drawing "all reasonable inferences" in that party's favor, the
movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Id. In deciding motions for
judgment on the pleadings, courts may only consider "the complaint, exhibits
attached to the complaint, matters of public record, as well as undisputedly
authentic documents 	if the complainant's 	claims 	are 	based 	upon these
documents. " Wolfington v. 	Reconstructive Orthopaedic Assocs. II PC, 935
7
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 7 of 13
F.3d 187, 195 (3d Cir. 2019) (quoting Mayer v. Belichick, 605 F.3d 223, 230
(3d Cir. 2010)).
IV. 	DISCUSSION
The 	pending 	motion 	to 	dismiss 	and 	motion 	for judgment 	on 	the
pleadings 	are 	both 	based 	on 	assertions 	that 	plaintiff has 	failed 	to 	file
certificates of merit as required 	by Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure
1042.3. Rule 1042.3 provides that:
(a) 	In 	any 	action 	based 	upon 	an 	allegation 	that 	a licensed
professional deviated from an acceptable professional standard,
the attorney for the plaintiff, or the plaintiff if not represented,
shall file with the complaint or within sixty days after the filing of
the complaint, a certificate of merit signed by the attorney or party
that either
( 1) an appropriate licensed professional has supplied a written
statement that there exists a reasonable probability that the care,
skill 	or 	knowledge 	exercised 	or 	exhibited 	in 	the 	treatment,
practice or work that is the subject of the complaint, fell outside
acceptable professional standards and that such conduct was a
cause in bringing about the harm, or
(2) the claim that the defendant deviated from 	an 	acceptable
professional standard is based solely on allegations that other
licensed professionals for whom this defendant is responsible
deviated from an acceptable professional standard, or
(3) expert testimony of an appropriate licensed professional is
unnecessary for prosecution of the claim.
8
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 8 of 13
Pa. R. Civ. P. 1042.3(a). Separate certificates of merit must be filed as to
each licensed professional named as a defendant. Pa. R. Civ. P. 1042.3(b).
Several procedural rules govern when a defendant may seek dismissal
for 	a 	plaintiff's 	failure 	to 	file 	a 	certificate 	of 	merit. 	Specifically, 	under
Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1042. 7, a defendant "may dismiss an
action only if four conditions are met: (1) there is not a pending motion (a) for
a determination that a COM is unnecessary in the first place or (b) seeking
to extend the time to file a COM ; (2) a COM was not filed before dismissal
was sought; (3) the defendant has attached proof that he served notice of
the deficiency upon the plaintiff; and, as is relevant here, (4) thirty days has
elapsed between the notice of deficiency and the defendant's attempt to
terminate the action ." Schmigel v. Ucha/, 800 F.3d 113, 118 (3d Cir. 2015)
(citing 	Pa. 	R. Civ. 	P. 	1042.7). 	Both 	Rule 	1042.3 and 	Rule 	1042.7 are
substantive rules of state law that must be applied by federal courts when
applying 	Pennsylvania 	law. 	Id. 	at 	119-20; 	Liggon-Redding 	v. 	Estate 	of
Sugarman, 659 F.3d 258, 264-65 (3d 	Cir. 	2011 ). 	The certificate of merit
requirement, however, only applies to state law claims; claims of deliberate
indifference to a serious medical need 	in violation of a plaintiff's federal
constitutional rights do not require a certificate of merit. Crawford v. McMillan,
660 F. App'x 113,116 (3d Cir. 2016).
9
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 9 of 13
The motion for judgment on the pleadings filed by defendants Badick,
Bora 	Saikia, Loscalzo, Williams , and 	O'Brien will 	be 	summarily denied.
These defendants acknowledge that their motion does not comply with the
notice requirements of Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1042. 7 because
they did not provide notice of their intent to seek to move to dismiss for the
absence of a certificate of merit prior to filing the motion to dismiss. (Doc.
134 at 13 n.2). Their motion is appropriately denied based on this failure to
comply with Rule 1042.?'s notice requirement. Schmigel, 800 F. 3d at 124.
Turning to defendant Shah's motion , the court will first grant the motion
to the extent that it seeks to dismiss Vega's state law claims for negligence
or malpractice. As Shah correctly notes, Vega has not filed any certificate of
merit with respect to his claims against Shah: his certificates of merit were
filed on June 6, 2022- 	before Shah had been named as a defendant. ( See
Docs. 10-1 , 10-2, 10-3, 10-4 ). 2
2 Although Vega's currently operative complaint contains a section
titled "Certificate of Merit ," it cannot be liberally construed as an independent
certificate of merit. ( See Doc. 59 at 5). The text of the section makes clear
that Vega is simply noting that he previously filed certificates of merit and not
that he is intending the section as a new certificate of merit. (See id. ("On or
about June 2, 2022, after concluding his research , Plaintiff filed with the Clerk
of Court a Certificate of Merit for each Doctor and/or Physician Assistant
mentioned 	herein ." )) . Furthermore, although the section suggests that a
certificate of merit was filed with regard to the claims against Shah on June
2, 2022, Shah was not named as a defendant until the current amended
complaint was filed on May 4, 2023.
10
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 10 of 13
Vega offers three arguments to the contrary, none of which have merit.
His first argument is that Shah 's motion fails to comply with Rule 1042.7
because he filed his motion to dismiss more than thirty days after his notice
of intent to seek dismissal of Vega's claims. (Doc. 127 at 3-4 ). This argument
misunderstands Rule 1042. 7. Vega reads the rule as requiring the motion to
be filed within thirty days of the notice, but the rule states the opposite,
requ iring the motion to be filed " no less than thirty days" after the notice. Pa .
R. Civ. P. 1042. 7(a)(4). In other words, the rule specifies the earliest possible
date the defendant may seek dismissal, it does not, as Vega asserts, specify
the latest possible date the defendant may seek dismissal.
Vega's 	second 	argument 	is 	that 	Shah 	should 	be 	precluded 	from
advancing th is argument because he has previously argued the absence of
a certificate of merit. (Doc. 127 at 4 ). The docket of the case refutes this
argument. The previous motion advanci ng an argument based on Vega 's
failu re to file a certificate of merit was filed by the other defendants and not
by defendant Shah. ( See Docs. 90-91 ).
Final ly , Vega notes that he previously filed certificates of merit with
respect to the other defendants and notes "[i]n fairness" that Shah "was
named in the already filed Pro Se Certificate of Merit as a contributing factor
to Plaintiff's claims. " (Doc. 127 at 6). This argument is meritless. Rule 1042.3
11
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 11 of 13
requires a separate certificate of merit to be filed as to each defendant the
plaintiff is suing. Pa . R. Civ. P. 1042.3. A passing reference to Shah in a
certificate of merit relating to claims against a different defendant is 	not
sufficient to satisfy this rule.
The court will accordingly dismiss Vega's state law claims against
defendant Shah based on his failure to file a certificate of merit as required
by Rule 1042.3. The motion to dismiss will be denied , however, to the extent
that Shah seeks dismissal of Vega 's federal civil rights claim 3 for his failure
to file a certificate of merit because a certificate of merit is not required for
that claim . Crawford, 660 F. App'x at 116.
V. 	CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons , the court will grant defendant Shah's motion
to dismiss in 	part and deny it in part, deny defendant Shah's motion for
summary judgment without prejudice, deny t he other defendants' motion for
judgment on the pleadings, and deem all other pending motions withdrawn.
The court wil l additionally set a deadline for the filing of all dispositive motions
3 Shah previously sought dismissal of this claim for Vega's failure to
allege that he acted under color of state law, but Judge Conner denied this
motion , finding 	that 	development of a factual 	record 	was 	necessary to
determi ne whether Shah was acting under color of state law. (See Doc. 110
at 19-20).
12
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 12 of 13
in light of the closing of pleading and discovery. An appropriate order shall
issue.
Mannion
s District Judge
Dated:
22-593-01
13
Case 1:22-cv-00593-MEM-LT Document 163 Filed 12/19/25 Page 13 of 13

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.