MANGHAM v. DELTA SELF STORAGE LLC

2:22-cv-04145NjdFeb 27, 2026

Full text

NOT FOR PUBLICATION
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
RAYSHAWN MANGHAM,
Plaintiff,
v.
DELTA SELF STORAGE LLC and PHIL
O’HARA,
Defendants.
Civil Action No. 22-4145
MEMORANDUM ORDER
CECCHI, District Judge.
Before the Court is plaintiff Rayshawn Mangham’s (“Plaintiff”) appeal of Magistrate Judge
Leda Dunn Wettre’s June 24, 2025, memorandum opinion and order, ECF No. 95 (“Recons. Op.
& Order”), denying her motion for reconsideration, see ECF No. 105 (“Moving Br.”). Defendants
Delta Self Storage LLC (“Delta”) and Phil O’Hara (“O’Hara”) (collectively “Defendants”)
opposed the appeal. ECF No. 112 (“Opp’n Br.”). The Court decides the appeal without oral
argument. Fed. R. Civ. P. 78(b); L. Civ. R. 78.1(b). For the reasons stated below, the Court will
affirm Judge Wettre’s June 24, 2025, memorandum opinion and order.1
WHEREAS on June 19, 2022, Plaintiff filed this employment discrimination suit against
her former employer Delta and one of Delta’s employees, Mr. O’Hara. ECF No. 1. In particular,
Plaintiff—an African American woman—alleges that she was “harassed, discriminated against,
and retaliated against . . . based on race, ethnicity, color, sex, gender, disability, medical/health
impairments, medical leave(s)[,] and legally protected complaints” in violation of the Americans
1 Defendants correctly note that Plaintiff’s filing is styled as “objections,” not as an “appeal as to
a non-dispositive motion.” Opp’n Br. at 12; see L. Civ. R. 72.1(a)(1); compare Fed. R. Civ. P.
72(a), with id. 72(b). However, the Court will excuse this oversight and consider Plaintiff’s filing
to be an appeal of Judge Wettre’s June 24, 2025, memorandum opinion and order.
Case 2:22-cv-04145-CCC-LDW Document 114 Filed 02/27/26 Page 1 of 8 PageID:
<pageID>
2
with Disabilities Act, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, 42 U.S.C. § 1981, New Jersey’s Law
Against Discrimination, and the Family and Medical Leave Act. Id. ¶¶ 1, 3, 20, 114–322; and
WHEREAS the Parties commenced fact discovery in July 2023. Recons. Op. & Order at
1. And though they “were [originally] required . . . to complete fact discovery” by February 2024,
Judge Wettre granted the Parties several extensions for a total of twelve months. Id. at 2. As a
result of these extensions, the Parties’ final fact “discovery deadline was February 27, 2025.” Id.;
and
WHEREAS despite this extensive discovery period and Judge Wettre’s significant
involvement, the Parties still had discovery issues in February 2025. Id. Accordingly, Judge
Wettre ordered the Parties to advise the Court of “all remaining discovery issues.” ECF No. 71.
Relevant here, Plaintiff filed a letter contending that Defendants still had not disclosed “documents
related to [Plaintiff’s] similarly situated coworkers, including Chris Vasquez . . . , whom
Defendants [allegedly] gave accommodations to that they denied to [Plaintiff] after her legally
protected complaints.” ECF No. 72 at 2. Plaintiff was (and remains) focused on Vasquez, because
she claims that another Delta employee, Fadia Zahiryeh, “had testified previously at [a] deposition
that [Delta] had accommodated the disability of . . . [Vasquez], a non-African-American employee,
whereas [P]laintiff argued that she, an African-American employee, had not been accommodated.”
Recons. Op. & Order at 3; and
WHEREAS according to Plaintiff, “[d]espite receiving Plaintiff’s repeated demands for
this discovery . . . and despite Defendants’ promises to produce it on a rolling basis ‘piece by
piece,’ Defendants suddenly announced . . . that they would not produce any of it.” ECF No. 72
at 4. As a result of this alleged refusal to produce this discovery, Plaintiff requested the opportunity
to depose Vasquez, stating that “[d]eposing Vasquez is vital to Plaintiff’s case in chief and to
Case 2:22-cv-04145-CCC-LDW Document 114 Filed 02/27/26 Page 2 of 8 PageID:
<pageID>
3
responding to the asserted defenses.” Id. at 2; see id. at 4 (“Here, because Defendants outright
refused to produce documents regarding Chris Vasquez, despite having testified to the existence
of such documents under oath, reasonable notice has been given to depose Chris Vasquez in order
to depose him immediately.”); and
WHEREAS in response, Defendants stated that Vasquez’s file did not indicate that he was
“given a different type of accommodation” from Plaintiff. ECF No. 73 at 1. As such, Defendants
argued that Plaintiff’s discovery requests were “simply not relevant to this matter.” Id. Moreover,
Defendants disputed that Plaintiff had an “immediate need to depose Vasquez.” Id. at 2; and
WHEREAS Judge Wettre held a hearing on March 19, 2025, “to resolve all final fact
discovery disputes.” Recons. Op. & Order at 2. Judge Wettre made several rulings, two of which
are relevant to this appeal. First, Judge Wettre directed Defendants to “serve a
response . . . pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 34 to formalize their position that no
further responsive documents exist other than those previously produced.” ECF No. 75 (“Disc.
Order”) ¶ 1. Judge Wettre stated that this response would “resolve any and all issues as to requests
for documents.” Id.; see ECF No. 76 (“Hr’g Tr.”) at 23:5–14. Second, Judge Wettre rejected
Plaintiff’s request to depose Vasquez. Disc. Order ¶ 3; Hr’g Tr. at 30:9–33:4. However, in lieu
of Vasquez’s deposition, she permitted Plaintiff “to serve a single comprehensive interrogatory on
the subject of [Delta’s] accommodation of Vasquez’s medical condition.” Disc. Order ¶ 3; Hr’g
Tr. at 30:9–33:4. At the hearing, Judge Wettre explained that this course would be “better” than a
deposition, because Defendants would be required to “state their position . . . on what the company
did regarding Mr. Vasquez’s accommodation” and then would be “locked in” to their position.
Hr’g Tr. at 32:9–16 (“What Mr. Vasquez testifies to will not bind the company. He’s an
individual.”); and
Case 2:22-cv-04145-CCC-LDW Document 114 Filed 02/27/26 Page 3 of 8 PageID:
<pageID>
4
WHEREAS on March 28, 2025, Plaintiff served Defendants with this interrogatory, which
contained over a hundred sub-questions. See ECF No. 82-2; Recons. Op. & Order at 3 at n.2 (“The
Court observes that plaintiff served an Interrogatory that was not in compliance with what the
Court had permitted. . . . . Had Delta objected to this Interrogatory, the Court certainly would have
sustained the objection.”). Defendants responded on April 3, 2025. ECF No. 82-2. Plaintiff then
moved for Judge Wettre to reconsider these rulings based on Defendants’ response to the March
28 interrogatory, ECF Nos. 84–85, a request Defendants opposed, ECF No. 87. Judge Wettre
denied Plaintiff’s motion for reconsideration, Recons. Op. & Order at 1, and Plaintiff now appeals
that decision; and
WHEREAS Magistrate Judges may “may hear and determine any non-dispositive pretrial
[motions] pending before the Court.” Stallman v. First Unum Life Ins. Co., No. 23-20975, 2025
WL 3749611, at *2 (D.N.J. Dec. 29, 2025) (citing 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1)(A)). Local Civil Rule
72.1 allows a party to appeal a Magistrate Judge’s “determination of . . . a non-dispositive motion”
to the presiding District Judge. L. Civ. R. 72.1(a)(1); see also Fed. R. Civ. P. 72(a). A District
Judge may “set aside any portion of the Magistrate Judge’s order found to be clearly erroneous or
contrary to law.” L. Civ. R. 72.1(c)(1)(A); see Jackson v. Chubb Corp., 45 F. App’x 163, 166 n.7
(3d Cir. 2002). A Magistrate Judge’s ruling is “clearly erroneous” “when[,] although there is
evidence to support it, the reviewing court on the entire evidence is left with the definite and firm
conviction that a mistake has been committed.” EXP Grp., LLC v. Fres Co., LLC, No. 23-3180,
2024 WL 1928448, at *2 (D.N.J. Apr. 29, 2024) (citation omitted). And a Magistrate Judge’s
ruling is “contrary to law” “if the [M]agistrate [J]udge . . . misinterpreted or misapplied [any]
Case 2:22-cv-04145-CCC-LDW Document 114 Filed 02/27/26 Page 4 of 8 PageID:
<pageID>
5
applicable law.”2 Id. Finally, the party filing the appeal bears the “burden of showing that a ruling
is ‘clearly erroneous or contrary to law.’” Ebert v. Twp. of Hamilton, No. 15-7331, 2016 WL
6778217, at *1 (D.N.J. Nov. 15, 2016) (citation omitted); and
WHEREAS as an initial matter, Plaintiff’s appeal is untimely. If a litigant wishes to appeal
a Magistrate Judge’s decision, the litigant must do so within 14 days of service of the decision.
See L. Civ. R. 72.1(c)(1); Hightower v. Ingerman Mgmt. Co., No. 17-8025, 2022 WL 19266266,
at *3 (D.N.J. May 4, 2022). Here, Plaintiff filed her appeal 233 days after Judge Wettre issued her
memorandum opinion and order. See Recons. Op. & Order; Moving Br. Thus, Plaintiff’s appeal
is barred under Local Civil Rule 72.1. See Hightower, 2022 WL 19266266, at *3; Am. Health
Sys., Inc. v. Liberty Health Sys., No. 90-3112, 1991 WL 193456, at *1 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 24, 1991);
and
WHEREAS even putting aside this fatal deficiency, the Court finds no reversible error.
As Judge Wettre correctly noted, “Plaintiff [sought] reconsideration solely on the basis of alleged
new evidence—the Interrogatory Response—that was served after the Court issued its rulings.”
2 Moreover, in appeals involving discovery disputes such as this one, courts often apply the more
deferential abuse of discretion standard of review. See, e.g., Celularity Inc. v. Evolution Biologyx,
LLC, No. 23-2135, 2025 WL 3140818, at *3 (D.N.J. Nov. 10, 2025); Smith v. City of Bayonne,
No. 17-4831, 2023 WL 2500678, at *2 (D.N.J. Mar. 13, 2023) (“A magistrate judge commits an
‘abuse of discretion’ if the Court’s action ‘is arbitrary, fanciful or unreasonable.’” (citation
omitted)). Under this line of cases, “[w]hen a [M]agistrate [J]udge’s decision is on a highly
discretionary matter, . . . the clearly erroneous standard implicitly becomes an abuse of discretion
standard.” Saldi v. Paul Revere Life Ins. Co., 224 F.R.D. 169, 174 (E.D. Pa. 2004). Because the
Court finds no reversible error under the “clearly erroneous” standard,” the Court also finds no
abuse of discretion. See EXP Grp., 2024 WL 1928448, at *2; Black-Meadows v. Deptford Twp.,
No. 20-6951, 2022 WL 16695191, at *2 (D.N.J. Nov. 3, 2022) (“Compared to the ‘clearly
erroneous’ standard, the ‘abuse of discretion’ standard is considered ‘even more deferential.’”
(citation omitted)).
3 The Court notes that before filing this appeal, Plaintiff filed a second reconsideration motion,
which Judge Wettre terminated because “the Local Civil Rules do not provide [a litigant] with a
second opportunity for reconsideration.” ECF No. 103. Judge Wettre further noted that “[i]f
plaintiff intended to file an appeal to the District Judge of the Court’s order denying
reconsideration, it should be filed as such.” Id.
Case 2:22-cv-04145-CCC-LDW Document 114 Filed 02/27/26 Page 5 of 8 PageID:
<pageID>
6
Recons. Op. & Order. at 2. After reviewing Plaintiff’s arguments, Judge Wettre found that
“Plaintiff ha[d] not demonstrated any new evidence to justify the discovery [Plaintiff] . . . seeks.”
Id. at 5; and
WHEREAS the Court agrees. The Court sees nothing in Defendants’ April 3 response to
Plaintiff’s interrogatory that would justify reconsideration (i.e., that undermines Judge Wettre’s
original order dealing with final discovery issues); and
WHEREAS for instance, Plaintiff argues that “Defendants’ . . . interrogatory responses
purporting that Chris Vasquez somehow had no issue with mobility [responses to 1(i) and (k)]
were discredited by . . . Zahriyeh’s prior . . . deposition testimony that Vasquez ‘hurt his foot’”
and received a disability accommodation. Moving Br. at 22. Accepting for argument’s sake that
these two pieces of evidence conflict, that fact would in no way undermine Judge Wettre’s original
discovery order; in fact, that was exactly the point. Judge Wettre explained that an interrogatory
would “lock” Defendants into a position on Vasquez’s purported accommodations. Hr’g Tr. at
32:9–16. Plaintiff may attempt to “exploit . . . on summary judgment” any contradiction between
Defendants’ position and Zahriyeh’s testimony. Recons. Op. & Order. at 4 (“[I]f Delta’s
Interrogatory response is contradictory to the testimony of Delta’s employee Zahiryeh, then
plaintiff may exploit that disparity on summary judgment and at trial on the existing record.”).
Moreover, the Court notes that Judge Wettre found that this alleged inconsistency did nothing to
alter the extent to which Vasquez’s deposition would be relevant to Plaintiff’s claims given her
analysis of the complaint. See Id. at 3–4. Nonetheless, she found that “even if the topic of
[Vasquez’s] accommodation is relevant, his deposition [would] certainly not [be] proportional
under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26 given that [P]laintiff already has had the opportunity to
Case 2:22-cv-04145-CCC-LDW Document 114 Filed 02/27/26 Page 6 of 8 PageID:
<pageID>
7
take depositions on this subject and serve a very broad contention interrogatory on Delta.” Id. at
4; and
WHEREAS in addition, Plaintiff asserts that Defendants’ April 3 interrogatory response
“also mention[s] several months of non-verbal communications” regarding Vasquez’s
accommodations. Moving Br. at 28; see id. at 7. On this issue, Plaintiff points to Defendants’
statement that
Vasquez readily volunteered information about his health condition in a timely
manner without any variations from the truth at least ten times. Phil O’Hara was
verbally advised on April 30, 2024[,] of Vasquez’s injury and similar updates
voluntarily came from Vasquez to O’Hara approximately, and at a minimum, nine
(9) times over the following seven months. The reasons why the updates were
provided is Vasquez followed defendants’ policies and procedures as he would
voluntarily (and without the need for a request) provide information about his
medical information and status in an effort to keep his employer informed thus
allowing for an interactive dialogue. Vasquez would, at times, contact O’Hara
almost as soon as he left the doctor’s office to provide updates.
ECF No. 105-1 at 9. Plaintiff appears to argue that this response shows that Defendants have
previously undisclosed responsive documents in their possession, custody, or control, and
therefore additional discovery is warranted. See Moving Br. at 28. Defendants’ response,
however, does not refer to documents; it addresses verbal communications. Thus, Plaintiff’s
assertion that Defendants have failed to provide responsive documents is entirely speculative. See
In re Valsartan N-Nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA) Contamination Prods. Liab. Litig., 405 F. Supp.
3d 612, 619 (D.N.J. 2019) (“Speculation does not justify discovery.”); and
WHEREAS Plaintiff also seeks review of Judge Wettre’s supposed error “in not imposing
attorneys’ fees and related remedies.” Moving Br. at 28. Judge Wettre denied this request for
sanctions as “baseless.” Recons. Op. & Order at 5. Given that Plaintiff has not identified any
discovery-related misconduct by Defendants, the Court will affirm Judge Wettre’s denial of
Case 2:22-cv-04145-CCC-LDW Document 114 Filed 02/27/26 Page 7 of 8 PageID:
<pageID>
8
sanctions. See Yoder v. Wells Fargo Home Mortg., No. 11-7503, 2012 WL 6562837, at *1 n.1
(E.D. Pa. Dec. 17, 2012).
Accordingly, IT IS on this 27th day of February 2026;
ORDERED that the Plaintiff’s appeal (ECF No. 105) is DENIED and Judge Wettre’s June
24, 2025, memorandum opinion and order (ECF No. 95) is AFFIRMED.
SO ORDERED.
/s/ Claire C. Cecchi
CLAIRE C. CECCHI, U.S.D.J.
Case 2:22-cv-04145-CCC-LDW Document 114 Filed 02/27/26 Page 8 of 8 PageID:
<pageID>

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.