ADAMS et al v. DMG PARK, LLC et al

2:21-cv-17442NjdJan 29, 2026

Full text

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
Chambers of
Leda Dunn Wettre
United States Magistrate Judge
Martin Luther King Federal
Building
& U.S. Courthouse
50 Walnut Street
Newark, NJ 07101
(973) 645-3574
January 29, 2026
To: 	All counsel of record
LETTER OPINION
Re: 	Adams et al. v. DMG Park, LLC, et al.
Civil Action No. 21-17442 (MCA) (LDW)
Dear Counsel:
Before the Court is plaintiff Gerald Adams’ response (ECF 247) to the Court’s Order
requiring him to show cause why he should not be sanctioned for violating several Court Orders.
(ECF 244). 	Prompted by submissions from defendants DMG Park, LLC and DMG Investments,
LLC (collectively, “Developer Defendants”), the Court ordered Adams to set forth why he should
not be sanctioned for: (1) failing to provide information ordered by the Court necessary to
determine whether he was entitled to a Protective Order with respect to his deposition; and (2)
violating the Court’s Order to submit discovery disputes solely by joint letter. 	(See ECF 239,
243, 244).
For the reasons set forth below, the Court determines sanctions are justified. 	The Court
therefore stays this action as a discovery sanction under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37 until
Adams complies with the Court’s Order concerning his deposition. 	The Court exempts from the
stay only Developer Defendants’ pursuit of responses to the subpoena they served on Adams’
former employer, Adidas America, Inc. (“Adidas”).
BACKGROUND
Throughout this action, plaintiff Adams has impeded the progress of discovery. 	A history
of Adams’ litigation conduct is outlined more fully in the Court’s Opinion and Order denying his
motion to amend, which the Court incorporates here by reference. 	(See ECF 245). 	The present
obstacles created by Adams to the completion of fact discovery are his failure to appear for
deposition or show grounds for a Protective Order, and his repeated disregard of the Court’s Order
to submit discovery disputes by joint letter to ensure that the meet-and-confer prerequisite of Local
Civil Rule 37.1 had been satisfied. 	(See ECF 244 (referencing ECF 239 and 243)). 	The Court
Case 2:21-cv-17442-MCA-LDW Document 257 Filed 01/29/26 Page 1 of 7 PageID:
<pageID>
2
briefly reviews the factual background as to each offense.
I. 	Plaintiff Adams’ Deposition
In contravention of a notice of deposition and Court Order, Adams has not yet submitted
to deposition. 	Developer Defendants noticed his in-person deposition to take place in New Jersey
on August 27, 2025. 	(ECF 222-4 at 3–4). 	In the days leading up to the deposition, however,
Adams contended that special conditions would be required for him to appear (see ECF 222-5),
forcing Developer Defendants to seek the Court’s intervention. 	(ECF 222). 	Adams sought,
inter alia, to have his deposition conducted “via Zoom,” although it had been noticed to be taken
in person. 	(See ECF 223 at 2). 	The Court, after reviewing the parties’ letters and finding no
basis to impose the conditions sought by Adams, ordered on August 22, 2025 that the in-person
deposition go forward as noticed by Developer Defendants. 	(ECF 224).
On August 26, 2025, the day before the scheduled deposition, Adams sought a Protective
Order for his deposition to proceed remotely. 	(ECF 226). 	He claimed that “travel for deposition
attendance [from his new residence in Texas] would pose significant risks” to his health,
“including potential cardiac events, stroke recurrence, or other life-threatening complications.”
(Id. at 1). 	In support of his request, Adams included an “excuse slip” from a Dr. John Yu, which
asked that Adams be “excuse[d]” from “any further flying or travel until further notice.” 	(Id. at
6).
The Court then ordered all counsel to appear at a September 10, 2025 case management
conference to address Adams’ deposition and other discovery issues. 	(See ECF 228). 	During
that conference, the Court explained that the excuse slip from Dr. Yu was “not sufficient . . . to
ascertain a host of questions germane to the requested protective order.” 	(ECF 256 at 53:14–16).
The Court identified several specific questions Adams needed to address with supporting medical
evidence, including: whether he could travel to New Jersey for deposition by means other than
flight, given that Dr. Yu’s note specifically precluded air travel; whether he could be deposed in-
person in Texas without threatening his health; and when an update as to his cardiac condition
would be provided, assuming the condition was temporary. 	(See id. at 53:16–54:3). 	The Court
ordered Adams to provide information in response to these questions on or before September 25,
2025. 	(ECF 236 ¶ 11).
Adams did not provide the information ordered by the Court. 	Instead, on September 30,
2025, his counsel submitted another “excuse slip” from Dr. Yu stating that Adams was restricted
from flying for sixty days, but providing none of the additional information ordered by the Court.
(ECF 240 at 3). 	In his show-cause submission, Adams simply reiterates that he suffers from
unspecified “cardiovascular and cerebrovascular conditions that have materially affected his
ability to travel.” 	(ECF 247 at 9). 	He thus has not provided the information the Court ordered
for the purpose of ascertaining when and under what conditions Adams can be deposed consistent
with his health conditions.
II. 	The Joint Letter Requirement
During the course of discovery, Adams’ counsel has submitted numerous discovery dispute
Case 2:21-cv-17442-MCA-LDW Document 257 Filed 01/29/26 Page 2 of 7 PageID:
<pageID>
3
letters in violation of Local Civil Rule 37.1’s meet-and-confer requirement. 	See L. Civ. R.
37.1(a)(1) (“Counsel shall confer to resolve any discovery dispute. 	Any such dispute not
resolved shall be presented by telephone conference call or letter to the Magistrate Judge.”).
Adams’ letters failed to reflect that counsel had even met and conferred, much less reached
impasse, before his counsel wrote the Court seeking relief. 	(See, e.g., ECF 203, 205).
Having spent an inordinate amount of time addressing such improper letters during the
course of discovery, the Court issued an Order on August 6, 2025 requiring all future discovery
letters from Adams to be submitted jointly. 	(ECF 207). 	Specifically, the Court ordered as
follows:
Due to plaintiff Adams' counsel's frequent noncompliance with the Court Rules,
this Court has been unduly burdened by this action for quite some time. 	Going
forward, the Court will not consider any discovery dispute from plaintiff Adams
that is not presented by joint letter of counsel and that is in full and complete
compliance with Local Civil Rule 37.1. 	Deviations from this Rule without prior
Court leave may result in the imposition of sanctions. 	The Court will not consider
any of the matters contained in any of the aforementioned letters filed by any party
unless and until they are presented as prescribed.
(Id.).
Adams’ counsel submitted the first of multiple letters in violation of that Order within three
weeks of its issuance. 	Several were submitted as unilateral letters, and did not address why they
were not submitted jointly. 	(ECF 225, 231). 	One is labeled a “joint letter” but is not; it merely
attaches an email between counsel and designates the email as the adversary’s position. 	(ECF
241). 	And most disturbingly, Developer Defendants contend that one letter Adams’ counsel
represented to be “joint” contains a position attributed to them which they did not draft and had
never seen prior to its submission to the Court. 	(ECF 251 (referencing ECF 248)). 	Another
defendant levies similar accusations against Adams. 	(ECF 250 (referencing ECF 249)).
Adams has also misused the joint letter requirement to block discovery he resists. 	On
September 3, 2025, Adams improperly submitted a non-joint letter objecting to a subpoena
defendants served on his former employer, Adidas. 	(ECF 231). 	In response, the Court
instructed the parties “to submit a joint letter regarding the discovery dispute” over the Adidas
subpoena, and to advise Adidas “not [to] respond to the subpoena until the Court” ruled on the
dispute. 	(ECF 232). 	When Developer Defendants contacted Adams for his input on the joint
letter, however, Adams refused to participate, claiming that the subpoena dispute was not before
the Court. 	(See ECF 239-4). 	It was only after Developer Defendants raised Adams’ refusal
with the Court (ECF 239) that he purported to seek their position for a joint letter. 	(See ECF 241
at 7). 	No joint letter was ever submitted, however.
When the Court asked Adams’ counsel why he had submitted non-joint letters in violation
of the August 6, 2025 Order, counsel was utterly unable to provide any satisfactory response. 	His
only explanation was that Adams’ “litigation team” had violated the Court’s joint letter
requirement (repeatedly) “out of haste.” 	(ECF 255, Transcript of November 4, 2025 Telephone
Case 2:21-cv-17442-MCA-LDW Document 257 Filed 01/29/26 Page 3 of 7 PageID:
<pageID>
4
Conference at 6:7–20).
The Court now considers the appropriate remedy for the conduct described above.
DISCUSSION
Before the Court is the unpleasant question of whether to impose sanctions on Adams for
his discovery misconduct. 	While sanctions are always a tool of last resort for the Court, they
become necessary when the Court’s lesser tools of ensuring compliance with Rules and Orders—
reminders, warnings and “last chances”—have been exhausted without any improvement in a
litigant’s conduct. 	Such is unfortunately the case here. 	Adams’ litigation conduct and that of
his counsel has been vexatious and defiant throughout discovery. 	Respect for the Court’s
authority would be diminished if such conduct were permitted to continue without consequence.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37 provides a panoply of remedies for the conduct at bar.
It “was designed to protect courts and opposing parties from delaying or harassing tactics during
the discovery process.” 	Cunningham v. Hamilton Cnty., Ohio, 527 U.S. 198, 208 (1999). 	The
Rule provides a list of potential sanctions for failure to comply with discovery orders or appear for
deposition. 	See Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(b)(2)(A); Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(d)(1)(A)(i). 	These range from
“dismissing the action or proceeding in whole or in part” to “staying further proceedings until the
order is obeyed.” 	Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(b)(2)(A)(iv)–(v); see also Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(d)(3).
Whether and what sanction to impose “is generally entrusted to the discretion of the district court,”
so long as the chosen sanction is “just” and “specifically related to the particular claim . . . at issue”
in the pertinent discovery order. 	Clientron Corp. v. Devon IT, Inc., 894 F.3d 568, 580 (3d Cir.
2018) (internal emphases, quotations, and citations omitted). 	In exercising that discretion, courts
in this Circuit have prevented claims from moving forward—including through dismissal—when
a plaintiff refuses to submit to deposition. 	See, e.g., Dover v. Diguglielmo, 181 F. App’x 234,
237 (3d Cir. 2006) (affirming dismissal based on plaintiff’s refusal to answer questions during
deposition); Naik v. Bos. Consulting Grp., 14-CV-3097 (LDW), 2017 WL 424902, at *6 (D.N.J.
Jan. 12) (recommending dismissal with prejudice for refusal to comply with Court orders,
including to submit to duly noticed deposition), report and recommendation adopted by 2017 WL
401944 (D.N.J. Jan. 30), appeal dismissed, 2017 WL 7796288 (3d Cir. Sept. 21, 2017).
In addition to their authority under Rule 37, district courts have the “inherent power to
police litigant misconduct and impose sanctions on those who abuse the judicial process.” 	Reilly
v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc., 670 F.Supp.3d 126, 140 (D.N.J. 2023) (internal quotations and
citations omitted). 	“‘[A] district court must ensure that there is an adequate factual predicate for
flexing its substantial muscle under its inherent powers, and must also ensure that the sanction is
tailored to address the harm identified.’” 	Wachtel v. Health Net, Inc., 239 F.R.D. 81, 100 (D.N.J.
2006) (quoting Republic of Philippines v. Westinghouse Elec. Corp., 43 F.3d 65, 74 (3d Cir.
1994)). 	Thus, a court exercising its inherent power to sanction must first “explain why the
conduct in question warrants a sanction,” and then “explain why it has chosen any specific sanction
from the range of identified alternatives.” 	Nikolaeva v. Sparta Twp. Bd. Of Educ., 21-CV-19977
(JSA), 2025 WL 3093833, at *4 (D.N.J. Sept. 30), report and recommendation adopted by 2025
WL 3090195 (D.N.J. Nov. 5, 2025).
Case 2:21-cv-17442-MCA-LDW Document 257 Filed 01/29/26 Page 4 of 7 PageID:
<pageID>
5
I. 	Plaintiff Adams’ Refusal to Submit to In-Person Deposition
The Court first considers whether to impose sanctions for Adams’ conduct concerning his
deposition. 	For this case to proceed past the prolonged fact discovery stage, it is imperative that
Adams give his deposition. 	He has made wide-ranging factual allegations that require
exploration by defendants at deposition. 	(See, e.g., Second Amended Complaint, ECF 63 ¶ 22
(claiming that defendants’ “harassment and discrimination against the Plaintiffs includes but is not
limited to denying Plaintiffs building services, failing to respond to their complaints, failing to
provide Plaintiffs with requested information, making false allegations against the Plaintiffs” and
more)). 	The Court has previously opined, and here reiterates, that such a deposition should take
place in-person to be most effective. 	That view finds support in the Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure, which provide that depositions be taken in-person absent stipulation or Court order to
the contrary. 	See Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(b)(4). 	And the presumptive rule as to deposition locale is
that Adams’ deposition be taken in New Jersey, where he filed suit. 	See, e.g., Song v. Zhang, 21-
CV-17918 (RLS), 2025 WL 566193, at *3 (D.N.J. Feb. 20, 2025) (citing S. Seas Catamaran, Inc.
v. Motor Vessel Leeway, 120 F.R.D. 17, 21 (D.N.J. 1988)). 	In order to rebut these presumptions,
Adams must make “a showing of unreasonable hardship or the presence of exceptional
circumstances,” or otherwise “demonstrate good cause” sufficient to justify the “issuance of a
protective order” under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26. 	Diaz v. Demane, 05-CV-2280
(CCC), 2008 WL 11383767, at *2 (D.N.J. Feb. 28, 2008) (internal quotations and citations
omitted).
Adams claims that a cardiac condition prevented his in-person participation in the August
27, 2025 deposition (see ECF 226) and continues to prevent him from sitting for an in-person
deposition in New Jersey. 	(See ECF 247 at 9). 	But, in disregard of the Court’s Orders, he has
not provided the substantiation and details of how his condition impacts his ability to be deposed.
Adams has not indicated whether he could travel to New Jersey by means other than flight. 	(See
ECF 256 at 53:16–20). 	Nor has he answered the Court’s question whether he could sit for an in-
person deposition so long as he did not have to travel. 	(See id. at 53:21–25). 	The last update
from Dr. Yu—the September 30, 2025 excuse slip—merely states that Adams could not fly for
sixty days from that date. 	(See ECF 240). 	But those sixty days have elapsed without Adams
having provided any additional information from Dr. Yu or any other medical expert in response
to the Court’s specific inquiries. 	Adams’ failure to provide basic information regarding the effect
of his purported condition on his ability to be deposed renders him unable, on the current record,
to defeat the presumption that he be deposed in-person, in New Jersey. 	See Diaz, 2008 WL
11383767, at *2. 	Nor can the Court fashion any form of Protective Order without the required
information as to how his cardiac condition affects his ability to sit for deposition.
Adams’ intransigence with respect to his deposition is yet another unfortunate example of
his apparent view that discovery is a one-way street, in which he takes but does not provide
discovery. 	Indeed, during the period he was noncompliant with the Court’s Order to provide
further medical information, Adams proactively sought to compel further discovery from
defendants. 	(ECF 248, 249). 	The Court finds it amply warranted, then, to preclude Adams from
advancing his interests in this action until he testifies at deposition. 	He should not be permitted
to prosecute his claims while refusing to allow examination of the extensive allegations underlying
those claims. 	The Court will accordingly stay this action as a Rule 37 sanction until Adams gives
Case 2:21-cv-17442-MCA-LDW Document 257 Filed 01/29/26 Page 5 of 7 PageID:
<pageID>
6
his deposition in New Jersey, as ordered, or seeks with supporting evidence a Protective Order
setting appropriate conditions for deposition. 	Such a sanction is squarely within the Court’s
authority and is amply justified. 	See Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(b)(2)(A)(iv); Dover, 181 F. App’x at 237;
Naik, 2017 WL 424902, at *6; Lee v. Sunrise Senior Living, Inc., 09-CV-5720 (AET), 2011 WL
13366288, at *3 (D.N.J. June 15, 2011).1
While the Court is cognizant that such a stay will temporarily prevent Adams’ co-plaintiff
Julia Jones from advancing her claims, and defendants from pursuing discovery, that result is
unavoidable given the intertwined nature of the allegations and claims. 	As this Court has
explained, “Adams’ and Jones’ legal claims are identical, as are the majority of the factual
allegations on which those claims are based.” 	(Letter Order Denying Motion to Sever, ECF 246
at 2; see also ECF 63 ¶¶ 134–157 (asserting all five claims on behalf of both plaintiffs)).
Accordingly, Adams’ testimony is just as crucial to the prosecution and exploration of Jones’
claims as his own. 	In short, it is not just or practical for this case to proceed as to any party until
Adams complies with this Court’s Orders and makes himself available for deposition.
II. 	Plaintiff Adams’ Submission of Unilateral Discovery Dispute Letters
The Court next considers whether to sanction Adams or his counsel for their consistent
failure to submit discovery disputes via joint letter, as required by the Local Civil Rules and this
Court’s Orders. 	The Court instructed Adams in no uncertain terms in its August 6, 2025 Order
that any further discovery dispute presented to the Court be submitted jointly. 	(See ECF 207).
It reiterated that instruction in its subsequent Order requiring the parties to present their dispute as
to the Adidas subpoena via joint letter. 	(See ECF 232). 	Nevertheless, Adams has violated those
Orders repeatedly. 	(See ECF 225, 231, 241, 248). 	Worse, Adams’ counsel has dubbed at least
two unilateral submissions “joint” letters and claimed to have conferred with defense counsel prior
to filing (ECF 248, 249), even though defense counsel contend they did not contribute to and were
wholly unaware of the submissions. 	(See ECF 250, 251). 	Adams’ counsel has provided no
adequate excuse for these violations of the Court’s Order requiring him to submit discovery
disputes by joint letter. 	(See ECF 255 at 5:7–23, 6:7–20).
The Court will not impose monetary sanctions on Adams or his counsel at this time, despite
their conduct having cost defendants unnecessary time and money responding to unpermitted
applications. 	The Court will, however, disregard Adams’ unilateral submissions because they
violate its clear Orders to present discovery disputes jointly. 	Cf. Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(b)(2)(A)
(empowering courts to sanction parties for failing to obey discovery orders); Clientron Corp., 894
F.3d at 580 (noting that Rule 37 sanctions left to court’s discretion). 	The Court will therefore
disregard Adams’ applications at ECF 231, 241, 248, and 249.2
For all such future violations, however, the Court intends to issue an Order to Show Cause
1 	Indeed, the cited cases are all examples of a plaintiff’s claims being dismissed due to their
failure to submit to deposition, a much harsher sanction than the Court imposes here.
2 	The Court has already addressed the dispute raised in the letter at ECF 225 in its Order
memorializing the September 10, 2025 case management conference. 	(See ECF 236).
Case 2:21-cv-17442-MCA-LDW Document 257 Filed 01/29/26 Page 6 of 7 PageID:
<pageID>
7
why plaintiff and/or his counsel should not be sanctioned. 	Further, the Court intends to address,
after the stay is lifted, defendants’ accusations that Adams and his counsel fabricated their
positions in submissions to the Court. 	(See ECF 250, 251). 	Allegations of such serious
misconduct cannot and will not be ignored.
III. 	Adidas Subpoena
Although the Court will stay this action in all other respects, it will allow Developer
Defendants to proceed in seeking responses to the subpoena they served on Adidas. 	As set forth
above, Adams failed to avail himself of the opportunity to present his objections by joint letter
while the Court stayed Adidas’ response to the subpoena. 	(See ECF 239-4). 	Instead, he
apparently sought to use the temporary stay of Adidas’ time to respond to the subpoena—time
meant to allow for the adjudication of Adams’ objections—as a means to table Developer
Defendants’ pursuit of the subpoena indefinitely by preventing the dispute from being presented
to the Court. 	(See id.).
Given this history, the Court finds it appropriate to lift its stay of the Adidas subpoena and
for this discrete issue to be litigated while the case is otherwise stayed. 	If Adidas or either
plaintiff seeks to oppose the subpoena, they may file formal motions to quash on or before
February 13, 2026. 	Developer Defendants shall inform Adidas that it has until February 23,
2026 to respond to the subpoena, subject to any intervening motion to quash. 	Motions to quash
filed after February 13, 2026 will not be considered.
CONCLUSION
For the reasons set forth above, this action will be stayed, with the exception of the Adidas
subpoena, until plaintiff Adams complies with the Court’s Orders requiring him to either sit for an
in-person deposition in New Jersey, or submit competent proofs as to why he cannot do so and
under what conditions he can be deposed. 	While Developer Defendants’ requests to seek
sanctions for misrepresentation and spoilation (ECF 251, 252) are currently stayed, the Court will
address any aspects of those requests not addressed in this Opinion once the stay is lifted. 	For
now, the Court notes that those submissions should have been filed as pre-motion leave letters, not
as formal motions, and will direct the Clerk to terminate the motions at ECF 251 and ECF 252.
An Order consistent with the foregoing will be separately entered by the Court.
s/ Leda Dunn Wettre
Hon. Leda Dunn Wettre
United States Magistrate Judge
Orig: 	Clerk
cc: 	Counsel of Record
Case 2:21-cv-17442-MCA-LDW Document 257 Filed 01/29/26 Page 7 of 7 PageID:
<pageID>

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.