Fremont Telcom Co. v. Kyle Enterprises, LLC

9:25-cv-00084MtdJan 12, 2026

Full text

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA
MISSOULA DIVISION
FREMONT TELECOM CO., d/b/a
BLACKFOOT COMMUNICATIONS,
Plaintiff, Case No. 25-84-M-JTJ
vs.
KYLE ENTERPRISES, LLC, d/b/a MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
MILLENNIUM,
Defendant.
I. Introduction
Plaintiff Fremont Telecom Co. d/b/a Blackfoot Communications (Fremont) is
a Missoula-based corporation that provides residential and commercial
telecommunication and Internet services. Fremont filed a Complaint against Kyle
Enterprises, LLC d/b/a Millennium (Millennium), a Wisconsin-based limited
liability company that supplies fiber optic network materials. The Complaint alleges
breach of contract, breach of implied warranty of merchantability, breach of the
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 1 of 13
2
implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose, breach of the implied covenant
of good faith and fair dealing, unjust enrichment, and constructive fraud. (Doc. 1).
The claims center on Fremont's allegation that Millennium delivered defective,
nonconforming, and unusable fiber optic cable. (Id. at ¶5). Fremont alleges it paid
Millennium more than $400,000.00 for the defective cable. (Id. at ¶4).
Millennium has filed a Motion to Dismiss and Transfer Fremont's Complaint
pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) or forum non conveniens, along with supporting
briefs. (Docs. 5, 6, and 20). Millennium contends the parties entered a binding
contract containing a valid, mandatory forum-selection clause requiring all disputes
to be brought in a state or federal court with jurisdiction in Walworth County,
Wisconsin. Fremont opposes the Motion. (Doc. 15). The Court heard oral argument
on December 9, 2025.
II. Legal Standard
In federal court, federal law applies to the interpretation of forum selection
clauses. Doe 1 v. AOL LLC, 552 F.3d 1077, 1081 (9th Cir. 2009). The appropriate
way to enforce a forum selection clause pointing to a state or foreign forum is
through the doctrine of forum non conveniens. Atl. Marine Const. Co. v. U.S. Dist.
Court for the W. Dist. of Texas, 571 U.S. 49, 60 (2013).
Under federal law, forum selection clauses are prima facie valid and should
be enforced unless the resisting party shows enforcement would be "unreasonable."
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 2 of 13
3
M/S Bremen v. Zapata Off-Shore Co., 407 U.S. 1, 10 (1972). When a contract
contains a valid forum selection clause, a court must uphold the clause unless
extraordinary circumstances unrelated to the convenience of the parties clearly
disfavor a transfer. Atl. Marine Const. Co., 571 U.S. at 52. These extraordinary
circumstances exist only where: (1) the clause is invalid due to fraud or
overreaching; (2) enforcement would contravene a strong public policy of the forum
in which suit is brought, whether declared by statute or by judicial decision; or (3)
trial in the contractual forum will be so gravely difficult and inconvenient that the
litigant will for all practical purposes be deprived of their day in court. M/S Bremen,
407 U.S. at 15; Gemini Techs., Inc. v. Smith & Wesson Corp., 931 F.3d 911, 915
(9th Cir. 2019). In all but the most unusual cases, therefore, the interest of justice is
served by holding parties to their bargain. Atl. Marine Const. Co., 571 U.S. at 66.
III. Discussion
A. Freemont is bound by the forum selection clause in the 2016
Credit Agreement between Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative and
Millennium
1. Parties' Positions
It is undisputed that Fremont Telecom Co. placed three orders with
Millennium in late 2021 and early 2022 for the purchase of fiber optic cable.
Millennium contends that these purchases are subject to a forum selection clause
contained in a 2016 Credit Agreement between Millennium and Blackfoot
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 3 of 13
4
Telephone Cooperative because Fremont and Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative
should be treated as the same entity. (Docs. 6 and 7). Millennium argues that
Fremont is subject to the Credit Agreement’s forum selection clause because
Fremont uses the assumed business names d/b/a Blackfoot Communications and
Blackfoot Communications d/b/a Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative. During oral
argument, Fremont clarified the corporate relationship between Fremont and
Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative. Specifically, Fremont advised that it is a wholly
owned subsidiary of BTC Holdings, and BTC Holdings is a wholly owned
subsidiary of Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative. Nonetheless, Millennium maintains
its position.
Fremont argues that the 2016 Credit Agreement does not apply to it because
the Credit Agreement made no mention of affiliates or subsidiaries, and the 2021-
2022 purchases between Fremont and Millennium were made pursuant to separate
purchase agreements. (Doc. 15, p. 6). Fremont argues that the 2021-2022 purchases
involved Millennium sending Fremont a quotation, which Fremont advised it would
accept by sending a purchase order referencing the quotation. Millennium then
confirmed acceptance of the order by sending an order acknowledgment, and after
the order, Millennium sent Fremont an invoice. Fremont would then send a check
referencing the invoice. (Id. at pp. 8-11).
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 4 of 13
5
Finally, Fremont contends that the 2016 Credit Agreement did not contain
material terms for every future purchase agreement between the parties, such as the
products, quantities, and prices of those future purchase agreements. Therefore,
Fremont argues, the 2016 Credit Agreement cannot be specifically enforced as to
the 2021 and 2022 purchase agreements at issue in this case because these
agreements are separate and have no reference or relationship to the 2016 Credit
Agreement and do not arise out of or relate to it. (Id. at pp. 17-21).
Millennium counters that Fremont makes a sophistical argument about the
distinctions between the corporate entities. (Doc. 20, p. 5). Millennium contends the
entities are one and the same and are all bound by the 2016 Credit Agreement’s
forum selection clause. (Id.). Additionally, Millennium contends that Fremont
cannot dispute that the 2021 and 2022 purchases were billed using the line of credit
that originated with the 2016 Credit Agreement. (Id. at p. 7). Further, Millennium
notes that the email exchanges between it and Fremont regarding the 2021 and 2022
purchases have a link to the terms and conditions, which also contains a forum
selection clause. (Id. at p. 9).
2. Totality of Circumstances
In determining whether Fremont, as a non-signatory to the 2016 Credit
Agreement, is bound by its forum selection clause, the Court is guided by other
decisions that have considered the issue. The Ninth Circuit has upheld a forum-
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 5 of 13
6
selection clause against non-signatories when the alleged conduct of the non-
signatories was so closely related to the contractual relationship that it was
foreseeable the non-signatory would be bound by it. Manetti-Farrow, Inc. v. Gucci
America, Inc., 858 F.2d 509 (9th Cir. 1988).
Courts considering whether a non-signatory is sufficiently "closely related" to
the contract to be bound by a forum-selection clause must apply a common sense,
totality of the circumstances approach that essentially inquires into whether, in light
of those circumstances, it is fair and reasonable to bind a non-party to the forum
selection clause. Oregon-Idaho Utilities, Inc. v. Skitter Cable TV, Inc., 2017 WL
3446290, at *9 (D. Idaho Aug. 10, 2017) (quoting Synthes, Inc. v. Emerge Medical,
Inc., 887 F. Supp. 2d 598, 607 (E.D. Pa. 2012)). This approach places emphasis on
whether it should have been reasonably foreseeable to the non-signatory that
situations might arise in which the non-signatory would become involved in the
relevant contract dispute. Id.
In reviewing the totality of the circumstances, the Court notes that Fremont's
Complaint avers that Blackfoot Communication has "regularly conducted business
with Millennium for its Montana operations since at least September 2016." (Doc.
1, ¶ 14). This assertion supports Millennium's contention that the three purchase
orders referenced in the Complaint were billed using the line of credit that originated
with the 2016 Credit Agreement. (Doc. 20, p. 8). The fact that Fremont did not have
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 6 of 13
7
to pay for the fiber optic cable up front further supports Millennium's contention that
the three purchase orders in the Complaint were made pursuant to this line of credit.
Additionally, a review of the record supports Millennium's position that its
business relationship with Fremont is closely related to Blackfoot Telephone
Cooperative’s 2016 Credit Agreement. The August 24, 2016, "General Information
for Credit and Purchase Agreements" submitted as part of the 2016 Credit
Agreement (Doc. 7, Exhibit A, p. 9), uses the name Blackfoot Telecommunications
Group on its letterhead. The affidavit submitted by Fremont from Beau Bailey
(Document 15-4, ¶ 2) states that he is the "Director of Finance for various entities
using the name Blackfoot Communications, including Fremont Telecom Co.," and
that Fremont Telecom Company's former d/b/a name was Blackfoot
Telecommunications Group.
Accordingly, at the time Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative entered into the
2016 Credit Agreement with Millennium, it used the same assumed business name
or d/b/a name, Blackfoot Telecommunications Group, that Mr. Bailey states
Fremont Telecom Co. formerly used as its assumed business name or d/b/a. Both
Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative and Fremont now use the d/b/a Blackfoot
Communications. Therefore, at the time Fremont placed its orders with Millennium,
it was using the same d/b/a as its parent company, Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative.
Although the use of the same assumed name or d/b/a does not automatically bind
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 7 of 13
8
Fremont to the 2016 Credit Agreement, it supports Millennium's belief that it was
dealing with the same customer.
Moreover, the record shows that the same address - 1221 N. Russell Street,
P.O. Box 16600, Missoula, Montana 59805 - was used in both Blackfoot Telephone
Cooperative's 2016 credit application with Millennium (Doc. 7, Exhibit A, p. 5) and
in the order acknowledgments for the 2021 and 2022 purchases Fremont made from
Millennium. (Docs. 15-1, p. 4; 15-2, p. 4; and 15-3, p. 4). The order
acknowledgments further show that Millennium billed Blackfoot
Telecommunications Group for Fremont’s purchases at the same Missoula address
listed on the 2016 credit application and shipped the materials to Blackfoot
Telecommunications Group at the address 100 E. Main Street, Saint Anthony, Idaho
83445, the same address Fremont lists on its purchase orders. (Docs. 15-1, p. 3; 15-
2, p. 3; and 15-3, p. 3).
Additionally, the letterhead on Fremont's purchase orders uses the name
Blackfoot Communications. As noted above, Fremont admits Blackfoot
Communications is now the assumed d/b/a name for Blackfoot Telephone
Cooperative (Bailey affidavit, Doc. 15-4), replacing the prior assumed name
Blackfoot Telecommunications Group. The registration of assumed name filed with
the Montana Secretary of State shows that Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative and
Blackfoot Communications use the same Missoula address. (Doc. 20, Exhibit 2).
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 8 of 13
9
All of the above facts—including that Fremont's 2021 and 2022 purchases
were placed under the same d/b/a as Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative; billing was
sent to Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative's address, with no objection from Fremont;
and credit was extended to Fremont—illustrate that the purchases at issue are closely
related to Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative's 2016 Credit Agreement and that
Fremont and Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative acted as the same entity regarding
their business interactions with Millennium. Under the totality of the circumstances,
Fremont is bound by the 2016 Credit Agreement’s forum selection clause. This
conclusion is consistent with the UCC's course of performance and course of dealing
principles set forth in Mont. Code Ann. § 30-1-205 and is consistent with the concept
of equitable estoppel.
Even if the Court were to conclude Fremont was not bound by the Credit
Agreement signed by its parent company, Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative, the
Court also finds the forum selection clause contained in the "terms and conditions"
linked in the order acknowledgments between Fremont and Millennium for the three
purchase orders at issue also applies. Fremont's acceptance of those
acknowledgments by performance and without objection, combined with the parties'
course of dealing using the same d/b/a, constitutes objective assent to this forum
selection clause. UCC § 2-207(2)(b)-(c).
B. The forum selection clause is valid and enforceable
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 9 of 13
10
"When the parties have agreed to a valid forum-selection clause, a district
court should ordinarily transfer the case to the forum specified in that clause." Atl.
Marine Construction Company, 571 U.S. 49, 62 (2013). The narrow exception to
this general rule applies if the plaintiff can demonstrate "extraordinary
circumstances" unrelated to the convenience of the parties that clearly disfavor a
transfer. Id.
In determining whether extraordinary circumstances exist, the plaintiff must
make a strong showing that (1) the clause is invalid due to "fraud or overreaching";
(2) enforcement would contravene a strong public policy of the forum in which suit
is brought, whether declared by statute or judicial decision; or (3) trial in the
contractual forum will be so gravely difficult and inconvenient that the litigant for
all practical purposes will be denied their day in court. Yei A. Sun v. Advanced China
Healthcare, Inc., 901 F.3d 1081, 1088 (9th Cir. 2018).
Fremont argues that if the forum selection clause from the 2016 Credit
Agreement applies, it is invalid and unenforceable as a matter of Montana law and
public policy based upon Mont. Code Ann. § 27-1-412(5). (Doc. 15, p. 22). This
section provides that "an agreement the terms of which are not sufficiently certain
to make the precise act which is to be done clearly ascertainable" cannot be
specifically enforced.” Fremont contends that it is impossible that the terms of all
future orders between Millennium and Fremont from 2016 to the present were
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 10 of 13
11
"sufficiently certain" or clearly ascertainable in 2016. The products, quantities, and
prices of every future purchase agreement (material terms to an agreement for the
sale of goods) were in no way determined by the 2016 Credit Agreement. (Id.).
Millennium contends that Fremont misapprehends the effect of Mont. Code
Ann. § 27-1-412(5). This statute relates to obligations that cannot be specifically
enforced, and Millennium is not attempting to enforce specific performance of the
contract. (Doc. 20, p. 17). Further, Millennium contends that the Court cannot read
the 2016 Credit Agreement in isolation, as "several contracts relating to the same
matters, between the same parties and made as part of substantially one transaction
are to be taken together." Mont. Code Ann. § 28-3-203. (Id.).
The Court agrees with Millennium. Fremont's reliance on Mont. Code Ann. §
27-1-412(5) is misplaced. This provision expresses no public policy directed at
forum selection clauses. It addresses contracts whose terms are insufficiently certain
to permit a court to compel performance of a “precise act.” A forum selection clause
does not impose an obligation to perform a specific act subject to specific
performance. Rather, it is a procedural agreement allocating the forum in which
disputes will be resolved and is enforced through motions to dismiss or transfer, not
through an order compelling performance. Since Fremont has not shown that
enforcement of the forum selection clause would contravene a strong public policy
in Montana, and this is the only argument Fremont makes as a basis for applying the
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 11 of 13
12
exception to enforcement of the forum selection clause, the Court finds the forum
selection clause valid and enforceable.
IV. Conclusion
In 2021 and 2022, after Fremont's parent company, Blackfoot Telephone
Cooperative, entered into a 2016 Credit Agreement with Millennium that contained
a forum selection clause, Fremont submitted orders to Millennium using the same
d/b/a. Millennium's order acknowledgement forms in response to Fremont's
purchase orders incorporated terms and conditions containing essentially the same
forum selection clause as the 2016 Credit Agreement.
Fremont received the order acknowledgments, accepted delivery of fiber optic
cable, and accepted billing at Blackfoot Telephone Cooperative's address without
objection. Fremont's acceptance of the order acknowledgments and continued
performance constitute objective manifestations of assent to the incorporated terms
and conditions, including the forum selection clause. The parties' repeated
transactions under the same d/b/a establish a course of performance and course of
dealing demonstrating agreement to the forum selection clause. Fremont has failed
to show how enforcement of the forum selection clause violates public policy.
Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED that Millennium's Motion to Dismiss and
Transfer Fremont's Complaint pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) or forum non
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 12 of 13
13
conveniens (Doc. 5) is GRANTED. This action is DISMISSED WITHOUT
PREJUDICE pursuant to the doctrine of forum non conveniens.
The Clerk of Court is directed to close this action.
DATED this 12th day of January 2026.
Case 9:25-cv-00084-JTJ Document 27 Filed 01/12/26 Page 13 of 13

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.