Belanus v. Knudsen et al

6:16-cv-00104MtdFeb 11, 2026

Full text

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA
HELENA DIVISION
DUANE RONALD BELANUS,
Petitioner,
vs.
WARDEN JIM SALMONSEN,
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF THE
STATE OF MONTANA,
Respondents.
Cause No. CV 16-104-H-JTJ
ORDER
Petitioner, Duane Ronald Belanus, seeks leave of the Court to file a second
amended petition seeking federal habeas corpus relief under 28 U.S.C. § 2254,
(Doc. 88), and further requests that these proceedings be stayed so that he may
attempt to fully exhaust his claims in the state court. (Doc. 89.) Respondents
object to both motions.
Belanus’s journey through this Court has been long and winding. His initial
pro se filings were voluminous and consisted of over four thousand pages; they
contained many handwritten supplements, were duplicative in nature, and did not
comply with the requisite filing standards. Belanus was ordered to file an amended
petition. See e.g., (Doc. 32.) Prior to the filing of the amended petition, Belanus’s
Case 6:16-cv-00104-JTJ Document 90 Filed 02/11/26 Page 1 of 5
2
proceedings were then stayed in order to allow him to pursue relief with the
Montana Sentence Review Division. (Doc. 41.)
Given that Belanus is presently serving a life sentence without the possibility
of parole, and in consideration of the overarching interests of justice, counsel was
appointed to represent Belanus and present his claims in a concise manner. (Doc.
52.) An amended petition was filed in March of 2022. The State filed its Answer
and Belanus filed his reply in 2023.
Belanus has identified a new overarching claim, specifically that the jury
instructions given in his case failed to require the jury to determine his guilt on
three counts- Sexual Intercourse without Consent, Aggravated Kidnapping, and
Burglary, beyond a reasonable doubt as required by In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358
(1970). Belanus cites recent Montana Supreme Court decisions1 in which jury
instructions similar to those given in Belanus’s case resulted in the reversal of
convictions because it was found that the instructions violated due process and/or
implicated a defendants’ right to a fair trial. See e.g., (Doc. 88 at 7.) Accordingly,
Belanus seeks to add a due process claim and two corresponding ineffective
assistance of counsel claims in his proposed second amended petition. See, (Doc.
88-1.)
1 See e.g., State v. Hamernick, 545 P. 3d 666 (Mont. 2023); State v. Davisson, 580 P. 3d 82
(Mont. 2025).
Case 6:16-cv-00104-JTJ Document 90 Filed 02/11/26 Page 2 of 5
3
Further, Belanus contends that the new claims he seeks to advance “relate
back” to a number of claims raised in Belanus’s amended petition. (Doc. 88 at 8-
10.) Belanus asserts this is the case because they arise out of the same operative
facts as they relate to Belanus’s mental state at the times the offenses were
committed. Accordingly, Belanus asks that he be granted leave to file his second
amended petition.
Relying upon Rhines v. Weber, 544 U.S. 269 (2005), Belanus then asserts
good cause exists asks this Court to stay the instant proceedings and allow him to
return to the state courts and attempt to exhaust the new claims. (Doc. 89 at 3-7.)
Under Rhines, 544 U.S. at 277, a federal district court may stay a mixed
habeas petition, that is one containing both exhausted and unexhausted claims and
allow the petitioner to return to state court to litigate the unexhausted claims. See,
Jackson v. Roe, 425 F. 3d 654, 660 (9th Cir. 2005). Stay and abeyance under
Rhines is appropriate only where the court determines “there was good cause for
the petitioner’s failure to exhaust his claims first in state court.” Rhines, 544 U.S.
at 277. In Mena v. Long, 813 F. 3d 907 (9th Cir. 2016), the Circuit extended the
rule of Rhines, allowing a district court the discretion to stay and hold in abeyance
petitions containing only unexhausted claims. Mena, 813 F. 3d at 912.
A petitioner qualifies for a Rhines stay, so long as he can: (1) show good
cause exists for failure to have first exhausted the claims in state court; (2) explain
Case 6:16-cv-00104-JTJ Document 90 Filed 02/11/26 Page 3 of 5
4
and demonstrate how the claims at issue potentially have merit; (3) describe the
status of any pending state court proceedings dealing with the claims at issue; and
(4) establish he has diligently pursued the claims. Rhines, 544 U.S. at 277-78.
As stated above, of particular concern in Belanus’s case is the life sentence
that he is serving. Moreover, while Belanus may have been overzealous in this
Court with his pro se filings, it cannot be said that he was not diligent. Following
appointment, counsel acted diligently on Belanus’s behalf. Moreover, if this Court
declined to grant a stay, Belanus could potentially be pursuing state relief on the
unexhausted claims, while simultaneously proceeding in this Court. Judicial
economy would best be served by having Belanus’s claims fully exhausted, to the
extent possible, so that this Court may complete a full review of this matter and
not proceed in a piecemeal fashion.
While the Court is not necessarily agreeing with the additional legal
arguments presented by Belanus, he has shown good cause to file his second
amended petition and a legitimate basis to support his request for a stay. There is
nothing in the record to suggest that Belanus has engaged in abusive tactics or
intentional delays. Further, at this juncture there is inadequate information to make
a determination that the unexhausted claims are plainly meritless; the Rhines
requirements are satisfied. Accordingly, this Court exercises its discretion and will
grant Belanus’s motion for stay and abeyance. See Jackson, 425 F. 3d at 661
Case 6:16-cv-00104-JTJ Document 90 Filed 02/11/26 Page 4 of 5
5
(noting that where Rhines prerequisites are satisfied, “it likely would be an abuse
of discretion for a district court to deny a stay.”).
Based on the foregoing, the Court enters the following:
ORDER
1. Belanus’s Motion for Leave to File a Second Amended Petition (Doc.
88) is GRANTED. Belanus shall file a clean copy of the second amended petition
and attach all relevant exhibits.
2. Belanus’s Motion to Stay (Doc. 89) is GRANTED.
3. This matter is STAYED in order to allow Belanus to attempt to
exhaust his three new claims in the state courts. The Clerk is directed to amend the
docket accordingly.
4. Within 10 days of a dispositive order being issued by the Montana
Supreme Court, counsel for Belanus must notify the Court.
DATED this 11th day of February, 2026.
/s/ John Johnston
John Johnston
United States Magistrate Judge
Case 6:16-cv-00104-JTJ Document 90 Filed 02/11/26 Page 5 of 5

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.