Sparks v. BlackDiamond Restaurant LLC et al

8:24-cv-00353MddNov 26, 2025

Full text

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND
(SOUTHERN DIVISION)
EBONI DESIREE SPARKS, 	*
*
Plaintiff, 	*
*
v. 	* 	Civil Action No. TDC-24-353
*
BLACKDIAMOND RESTAURANT 	*
LLC, et al., 	*
*
Defendants. 	*
*
*******
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS – ATTORNEYS’ FEES AND COSTS
This “Report and Recommendations” addresses the “Plaintiff’s Motion for an Award of
Attorney’s Fees and Costs” and memorandum of law in support thereto (collectively, “the
Motion”) filed by Plaintiff Eboni Sparks (“Ms. Sparks” or “Plaintiff”). (ECF Nos. 19, 19-1). In
the Motion, Ms. Sparks moves for a judgment of attorneys’ fees and costs against BlackDiamond
Restaurant LLC (“BlackDiamond”) and Emmanuel Mbah (“Mr. Mbah”) (collectively, “the
Defendants”). (Id.). No response has been filed to the Motion, and the time for responding has
passed. See Local Rule 105.2 (D. Md. 2025). I have considered that fact, and the fact that the
Defendants have not taken any action to defend against Ms. Sparks’ Complaint during the life of
this case.
Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 636 and Local Rule 301, the Honorable Theodore D. Chuang
referred this matter to me to author a report and to make recommendations. (ECF No. 20). I do
not believe that a hearing is necessary. Local Rule 105.6 (D. Md. 2025). For the reasons set forth
below, I ultimately recommend that the Motion, (ECF No. 19), be granted in part and denied in
part.
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 1 of 18
2
I. 	FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Factual Background
Mr. Mbah is a founding member and owner of the restaurant BlackDiamond, a limited
liability company with its headquarters located in Silver Spring, Maryland. (ECF No. 1,
“Complaint,” ¶¶ 2, 4).
On September 1, 2023, Mr. Mbah hired Ms. Sparks as a cocktail waitress at BlackDiamond.
(Complaint, ¶¶ 1, 2, 8). Ms. Sparks was employed by Mr. Mbah at the BlackDiamond for a little
over two months, until her employment ended on November 15, 2023. (Complaint, ¶¶ 1, 8).
Throughout the relevant period of her employment at BlackDiamond (September 1, 2023 through
November 15, 2023), Ms. Sparks was paid exclusively from gratuities (i.e., tips), and was not paid
a minimum hourly wage. (Complaint, ¶¶ 4, 8, 9, 11, 19, 26).
Defendants had a policy and practice of offsetting a cocktail waitress’ compensation when
a customer fails to pay his/her dining bill. In effect, the cocktail waitress was held responsible to
pay the full amount of any unpaid dining bill by means of a deduction to their wages/gratuities.
(Complaint, ¶ 13). On September 30, 2023, Ms. Sparks earned gratuity in the amount of $1,224.00.
(Id.). However, because the customers at a table failed to pay their bill, Defendants deducted
$344.00 from the $1,224.00 that Ms. Sparks had earned, paying her a reduced gratuity. (Id.). On
November 15, 2023, Ms. Sparks earned gratuity in the amount of $594.00. (Id.). However, because
customers at a table failed to pay their bill, Defendants withheld Ms. Sparks’ gratuity in its entirety.
(Id.). In sum, Defendants withheld $938.00 in gratuities from Plaintiff. (Complaint, ¶ 14).
B. Procedural Background
On February 2, 2024, Ms. Sparks filed a Complaint against the Defendants seeking payment
of unpaid wages. In particular: Count I alleges violations of the Fair Labor Standards Act (“FLSA”),
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 2 of 18
3
29 U.S.C. §§ 201-216(b), specifically violation of the “tip credit” rule; Count II alleges violations of
the Maryland Wage and Hour Law (“MWHL”), Md. Code. Ann., Labor & Empl. §§ 3-401, 3-419,
specifically violation of Maryland’s “tip credit” rules; and Count III alleges violations of the Maryland
Wage Payment and Collection Law (“MWPCL”), Md. Code Ann., Lab. & Empl. §§ 3-501, 3-503,
specifically failure to pay her gratuities that she earned on two dates. (Complaint, ¶¶ 15-36).
On April 16, 2024, summonses were returned as executed, having been properly served on
the Defendants on April 4, 2024. (ECF Nos. 4, 5). Thus, the deadline for Defendants to file a
responsive pleading within the 21-day period provided by Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 4 and
12(a)(1)(A)(i) was April 25, 2024.
On May 1, 2024, Judge Chuang issued an Order directing the Plaintiff to file and serve on
the Defendants, within 14 days of the date of the Order, a motion for Clerk’s entry of default
pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 55(a) or to show cause as to why such motion would be inappropriate.
(ECF No. 6). On May 2, 2024, the Plaintiff filed motions for Clerk’s entry of default against the
Defendants pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 55(a). (ECF Nos. 8, 9). Plaintiff represented that on April
4, 2024 the Defendants were served via private process server at their “place of business.” (Id.).
On May 7, 2024, the Clerk of the Court granted the motions by entering an order of default and
issuing notices of default as to the Defendants. (ECF Nos. 9 - 11).
On June 10, 2024, Judge Chuang issued an Order directing the Plaintiff to file and serve
on the Defendants a motion for default judgment or show cause as to why such motion would be
inappropriate. (ECF No. 12). On June 24, 2024, the Plaintiff timely filed the “Plaintiff’s Motion
for Entry of Default Judgment as to All Defendants,” (“Motion for Default Judgment”). (ECF No.
13). On June 25, 2024, Judge Chuang referred the Plaintiff’s Motion for Default Judgment to the
undersigned to author a report and make recommendations. (ECF No. 14).
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 3 of 18
4
On February 10, 2025, the undersigned issued her “Report and Recommendations” and
Letter Order related to the Plaintiff’s Motion for Default Judgment. (ECF Nos. 15, 16). On
February 17, 2025, the Plaintiff filed a Certificate of Service reflecting that a copy of the Report
and Recommendations was mailed to the Defendants. (ECF No. 17). The 14-day deadline for any
party to make a written objection passed without any filing.
On February 28, 2025, the district court issued an Order adopting the undersigned’s Report
and Recommendation as an Order of the Court. (ECF No. 18). Specifically, the motion for default
judgment was granted in part and denied in part, and Plaintiff was awarded $11,794.76: (a) unpaid
wages in the amount of $4,021.38, under the FLSA, MWHL, and MWPCL; (b) unpaid gratuities
in the amount of $938.00, under the FLSA, MWHL, and MWPCL; (c) liquidated damages in the
amount of $4,021.38, under the FLSA; and (d) treble damages in the amount of $2,814.00, under
the MWPCL. (Id.).
On March 14, 2025, Plaintiff filed “Plaintiff’s Motion for an Award of Attorney’s Fees and
Costs,” (“the Motion”). (ECF No. 19). On March 20, 2025, the district court referred the Motion
to undersigned to author a report and make recommendations. (ECF No. 20).
On April 4, 2025, Plaintiff filed the “Plaintiff’s Motion to Reduce Award of Damages to a
Judgment.” (ECF No. 21). On April 8, 2025, the district court issued an Order granting the motion
and entered judgment against Defendants, jointly and severally, in the amount of $11,794.76. (ECF
No. 22).
On April 25, 2025, Plaintiff filed the “Plaintiff’s Notice of Supplemental Authority Related
to Her Motion for Attorneys’ Fees and Costs.” (ECF No. 23). To date, Defendants have never filed
a response or an opposition, nor have they otherwise defended against this case.
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 4 of 18
5
II. 	ATTORNEYS’ FEES AND COSTS SOUGHT
The Motion requests attorneys’ fees in the amount of $7,398.70 and costs in the amount of
$835.95. (ECF Nos. 19, 19-1). Attached in support of the Motion are: (1) “Melehy & Associates,
LLC’s Schedule of Attorneys’ Fees” (“the Schedule”); (2) Declaration of Omar Melehy (“Melehy
Declaration”); (3) Declaration of Nicholas Woodfield (“Woodfield Declaration”); (4) a document
entitled “Summary of Costs;” and (5) a document entitled “2021 Real Rate Report from Wolters
Kluwer.” (ECF Nos. 19-3 through 19-7). The request for $7,398.70 is predicated on a total of 23.3
hours of work. (ECF No. 19-3).1 The Motion identifies the following events, hours, and fees
requested:
Description of Event 	Total Hours 	Fees Requested
Pre-Filing Investigation 	3 	$1,276.50
Pleadings 	2.6 	$1,330.50
General Case Management 	5.3 	$1,331.00
Motion for Default
Judgment 7.9 	$1,887.00
Settlement 	0.7 	$228.00
Fee Petition 	3.8 	$1,365.00
TOTAL INCURRED
(prior to “exercising billing
judgment”)
23.3 	$9,376.50
TOTAL SOUGHT
(after “exercising billing
judgment”)
17.62 	$7,398.00
1 The undersigned notes that 0.3 hours were recorded for Mr. Veras, but counsel is not seeking reimbursement for his
services. (ECF No. 19-3, p. 2). In addition, Mr. Veras is not identified as a timekeeper in the Melehy Declaration. (See
ECF No. 19-4).
2 A total of 5.7 hours were not billed. 23.3 - 5.7 = 17.6 hours. (See ECF No. 19-3).
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 5 of 18
6
Counsel asserts that they exercised “billing judgment” and made deductions to “entries that
were duplicative, redundant or unnecessary, or were clerical in nature,” which they allege reduced
the amount of fees sought from $9,376.50 to $7,398.00. (See ECF No. 19-4, ¶ 27). 3
Regarding costs, the summary chart identifies five different categories of reimbursement
sought: photocopies; postage; online research; filing fee; and service of process. (ECF No. 19-6).
The specific dollar amounts associated with each category is identified, totaling $835.95. (Id.).
After filing the Motion, the Plaintiff filed “Plaintiff’s Notice of Supplemental Authority
Related to Her Motion for Attorneys’ Fees and Costs,” citing to the Fourth Circuit’s April 15, 2025
decision in De Paredes v. Zen Nails Studio, LLC. (ECF No. 23).
III. 	DISCUSSION
Both the FLSA and the MWPCL allows for a prevailing plaintiff to be awarded reasonable
attorney’s fees and costs if wages were not legitimately withheld by an employer as a result of a
bona fide dispute. 	See 29 U.S.C. § 216(b)4; Md. Code Ann., Lab. & Empl. § 3-507.2(b). 	A
plaintiff is a “prevailing party” if he/she succeeds “on any significant issue in litigation which
achieves some of the benefit […] sought in bringing suit.” Hensley v. Eckerhart et al., 461 U.S.
424, 433 (1983). Because judgment has been entered in Plaintiff’s favor, she is indisputably the
“prevailing party” entitled to attorney’s fees.
The amount awarded for fees and costs is discretionary. Burnley v. Short, 730 F.2d 136,
141 (4th Cir. 1984); see also Randolph v. Powercomm Construction, Inc., 715 Fed. App’x 227,
230 (4th Cir. 2017).
3 The 5.7 hours of non-billable work comes to a sum of $1,978.50 of non-billable fees. $9,376.50 - $1,978.50 =
$7,398.00. A reduction of approximately 21%.
4 In an FLSA action, “[t]he court . . . shall, in addition to any judgment awarded to the plaintiff or plaintiffs, allow a
reasonable attorney’s fee to be paid by the defendant, and costs of the action.” 29 U.S.C. § 216(b).
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 6 of 18
7
A. Attorneys’ Fees
It is well settled that “the amount of attorney’s fees to be awarded in any case is “left to the
discretion of the [court].” Johnson v. O’Connell & Laurence, Inc., Civ. No. DKC-21-2468, 2022
WL 1620014, at *2 (D. Md. May 23, 2022). 	To calculate the award of attorneys’ fees, a court
must first determine the lodestar amount, which involves two steps. First, a court analyzes the
“reasonable hourly rate,” and second, the court considers that rate and then “[multiplies it] by the
hours reasonably expended.” Grisson v. The Mills Corp., 549 F.3d 313, 320-21 (4th Cir. 2008);
see also Hensley, 461 U.S. at 433. The lodestar amount is determined by applying several factors.
The Fourth Circuit has found that a court’s discretion in finding the reasonable hourly rates and
hours expended should be guided by the following twelve factors, which were articulated in
Johnson v. Georgia Highway Express, Inc. 488 F.2d 714,717-19 (5th Cir. 1974), overruled on
other grounds, Blanchard v. Bergeron, 489 U.S. 87 (1989)):
(1) the time and labor expended; (2) novelty and difficulty of the
questions raised; (3) the skill required to properly perform the legal
services rendered; (4) the attorney’s opportunity costs in pressing
the instant litigation; (5) the customary fee for like work; (6) the
attorney’s expectations at the outset of the litigation; (7) the time
limitations imposed by the client or circumstances; (8) the amount
in 	controversy 	and 	the 	results 	obtained; 	(9) 	the 	experience,
reputation, and ability of the attorney; (10) the undesirability of the
case within the legal community in which the suit arose; (11) the
nature and length of the professional relationship between attorney
and client; and (12) attorneys’ fees awards in similar cases.
Robinson v. Equifax Info. Servs., LLC, 560 F.3d 235, 243 (4th Cir. 2009).
1. 	Hourly Rates: The Law
To determine the reasonableness of an attorney’s hourly rate, courts analyze whether the
rate sought is consistent with the rate that prevails in the community for “similar legal services by
lawyers of reasonably comparable skill, experience and reputation.” Blum v. Stenson, 465 U.S.
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 7 of 18
8
886, 890 n.11 (1984). While a court may rely upon affidavits from attorneys opining on the
reasonableness of requested rates, see, e.g., Poole ex. Rel. Elliott v. Textron, Inc., 192 F.R.D. 494,
509-10 (D. Md. 2000), a court may also, as part of its analysis, rely upon its knowledge of the
Maryland market. De Paredes, 134 F.4th 750, 754 (4th Cir. 2025).
In this District, courts often begin their analysis with “United States District Court for the
District of Maryland: Local Rules, Appendix B, Rules and Guidelines for Determining Attorneys’
Fees in Certain Cases (“the Guidelines” or “Loc. R. App. B”). The Fourth Circuit has recently held
that a court “may consider, but is not bound by” the Guidelines. De Paredes, 134 F.4th at 754 (4th
Cir. 2025)(citing Newport News Shipbuilding & Dry Dock Co. v. Holiday, 591 F.3d 219, 229 (4th
Cir. 2009)). Thus, when a court is faced with a fee petition and is determining whether a fee rate
is “reasonable,” it may not treat the Guidelines as “‘presumptively reasonable’ and require special
justification to deviate from [them].” 	De Paredes, 134 F.4th at 754 (4th Cir. 2025) (further
citations omitted). Rather, a court “must consider all relevant evidence to determine ‘the prevailing
market rates in the relevant community’. . . including lawyer affidavits, fee awards in similar cases,
general surveys, fee matrices, and even its ‘own personal knowledge.’” (Id.).
2. 	Hourly Rates
The Schedule identifies work performed by two senior attorneys (Mr. Omar Melehy and
Ms. Suvita Melehy), an associate attorney (Mr. Andrew Balashov), and paralegals (Ms. Emily
Wilson, Ms. Abril Tingey-Espinosa, and Mr. Felipe Veras).
a. 	Omar Vincent Melehy
The undersigned finds that Mr. Melehy has been practicing law for more than 38 years,
and has extensive experience in the field of employment law, including wage and hour violations.
(Melehy Declaration, ¶¶ 1-16, 22). Mr. Melehy’s hourly rate for this case is $675.00, and is
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 8 of 18
9
$200.00 above the high end of the current applicable range in the Guidelines. See Loc. R. App.
B., ¶ 3e.
b. 	Suvita Melehy
The undersigned finds that Ms. Melehy has been practicing law for more 29 years, and has
extensive experience in the field of wage and hour law. (Melehy Declaration, ¶ 18). Ms. Melehy’s
hourly rate for this case is $625.00, which is $150.00 above the highest rate in the applicable range
of the current Guidelines See Loc. R. App. B., ¶ 3e.
c. 	Andrew Balashov
The undersigned finds that Mr. Balashov has been practicing law for 9 years, and has
experience in the field of wage and hour litigation and employment discrimination. (Melehy
Declaration, ¶ 17). Mr. Balashov’s hourly rate for this case is $450.00, which is $100.00 higher
than the current applicable range in the Guidelines. See Loc. R. App. B., ¶ 3c.
d. 	Paralegals
The undersigned finds that two paralegals billed hours related to this case: Emily Wilson
and Abril Tingey-Espinosa. (Melehy Declaration, ¶¶ 19, 20). Ms. Wilson is a Senior Paralegal,
who has been employed by the Melehy’s firm since August of 2021, and has a bachelor’s degree.
(Id. at ¶ 19). No information was provided as to how many years Ms. Wilson has worked as a
paralegal. Ms. Wilson’s hourly rate for this case is $240.00, which is $90.00 above the highest
number in the range applicable for paralegals. See Loc. R. App. B., ¶ 3f.
Ms. Tingey-Espinosa was employed by the Melehy’s firm as a bilingual Paralegal from
October of 2023 until August of 2024, and has a bachelor’s degree. (Melehy Declaration, ¶ 19).
No information was provided as to how many years Ms. Tingey-Espinosa has worked as a
paralegal. Ms. Tingey-Espinosa’s hourly rate for this case is $240.00, which is $90.00 above the
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 9 of 18
10
highest number in the range applicable for paralegals. See Loc. R. App. B., ¶ 3f.
e. 	Analysis
The undersigned 	has analyzed 	the Johnson 	factors, 	the supporting 	documentation
submitted by Plaintiff, the hourly rates set forth in the Guidelines, and the relevant caselaw.
Because the undersigned cannot “require special justification” for rates deviating from the
Guidelines, the undersigned declines to recommend that the district court lower the hourly billing
rates for Mr. Melehy, Ms. Melehy, or Mr. Balashov. See De Paredes, 134 F.4th at 754.
However, because no information has been provided about the number of years that Ms.
Wilson and Ms. Tingey-Espinosa have worked as paralegals, the undersigned cannot assess
whether they possess skills and experience comparable to other paralegals within this District. See
De Paredes, 134 F.4th at 754. 	Thus, the Court cannot find their rates to be reasonable.
Accordingly, the undersigned recommends that their hourly rates be reduced from $240.00 per
hour to $150.00 per hour.
3. 	Hours Expended: The Law
As held above, at the second step of the lodestar process, a court must determine whether
the number of hours worked by counsel and the paralegals is reasonable.
The Motion is supported by a detailed spreadsheet itemizing all legal tasks performed and
billed, and there is the declaration of Omar Melehy, Esq. (ECF Nos. 19-3, 19-4). In addition, the
Plaintiff’s Motion is supported by the declaration of Nicolas Woodfield, who reports familiarity
with the Melehy law firm, and the prevailing market rates in this locality. (ECF No. 19-5).
4. 	Analysis of Hours Billed
As a preliminary matter, the undersigned takes into consideration counsel’s representation
that 5.7 hours of legal work were not billed, which equals $1,978.50 and amounts to a reduction
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 10 of 18
11
of approximately 21% in attorneys’ fees.5
Next, the undersigned applied the pertinent Johnson factors to the facts of this case. As
further outlined below, the undersigned is largely satisfied that the requested attorneys’ fees are
reasonable and appropriate, with one exception. See Section III.A.4.e.
Finally, the undersigned recommends adjustments to the hourly rates claimed due to
insufficient information about the paralegals’ experience. See Section III.A.2.e.
a. 	Pre-Filing Investigation
Plaintiff requests a fee in amount of $1,276.50 related to “pre-filing investigation.”
Counsel asserts the hours expended (3 hours) were in relation to investigating the viability of the
Plaintiff’s claims and the “nature and extent of the wage violations.” (Motion, pp. 10-11).
The undersigned finds that the entries in this category are descriptive enough and appear to be
reasonable. However, the undersigned recommends that the hourly rate associated with Ms.
Tingey-Espinosa should be reduced from $264.00 to $165.00 (by $99.00), reflecting the reduced
hourly rate of $150.00 per hour. Multiplying 1.1 hours times the adjusted rate results in an amount
billed of $165.00, and ultimately results in a final amount of $1,177.50.
b. 	Pleadings
Plaintiff requests a fee in amount of $1,330.50 related to “pleadings.” Counsel asserts the
hours expended (2.6 hours) were in relation to drafting the Complaint. (Motion, p. 11). The nine-
page Complaint was filed on February 2, 2024. (ECF No. 1).
5 See, supra, n. 2, n.3.
Timekeeper 	Date 	Hours
Expended
Hours
Billed
Amount
Billed
Omar Melehy 	12/8/2023 	1.6 	1.5 	$1,012.50
Abril Tingey-Espinosa 	12/12/2023 	1.4 	1.1 	$264.00
Total Amount Billed 	$1,276.50
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 11 of 18
12
The undersigned finds that the well-pled Complaint relates only to one plaintiff and is not
particularly complex. Thus, it is appropriate that only one attorney timekeeper participated in
drafting the pleading. The undersigned further finds that the entries in this category are descriptive
enough and appear to be reasonable. However, the undersigned recommends that the fees awarded
for Ms. Wilson (0.2 hours) should be reduced from $48.00 to $30.00 (by $18.00), reflecting the
reduced hourly rate of $150.00 per hour. Multiplying 0.2 hours times the adjusted rate results in
an amount billed of $30.00, for a total fee in the amount of $1,312.50.
c. 	General Case Management & Client Communication
Plaintiff requests a fee in the amount of $1,311.00 related to general management of the
case and communication. Counsel asserts that the hours expended (5.3 hours) includes handling
of “routine matters connected with client communication […] and other matters necessary for the
effective administration of the case.” (Motion, p. 11).
Timekeeper 	Date 	Hours
Expended
Hours
Billed
Amount Billed
Omar Melehy 	12/8/2023 	1.2 	1.2 	$810.00
Abril Tingey-Espinosa 	12/11/2023 	0.2 	0.0 	$0.00
Omar Melehy 	12/29/2023 	0.7 	0.7 	$472.50
Emily Wilson 	2/1/2024 	0.4 	0.2 	$48.00
Emily Wilson 	2/2/2024 	0.1 	0.0 	$0.00
Total Billed by Attorney(s) 	$1,282.50
Total Billed by Paralegal(s) 	$48.00
Total Amount Billed 	$1,330.50
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 12 of 18
13
The undersigned finds that the entries in this category are descriptive enough and appear to be
reasonable. However, the undersigned recommends that the fees awarded for Ms. Wilson (1.4
hours) should be reduced from $336.00 to $210.00 (by $126.00), reflecting the reduced hourly rate
of $150.00 per hour. Multiplying 1.4 hours times the adjusted rate results in an amount billed of
$210.00, for total fee in the amount of $1,185.00.
Timekeeper 	Date 	Hours
Expended
Hours
Billed
Amount
Billed
Omar Melehy 	1/23/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$67.50
Emily Wilson 	2/2/2024 	0.2 	0.0 	$0.00
Emily Wilson 	2/13/2024 	0.5 	0.3 	$72.00
Andrew Balashov 	2/22/2024 	0.3 	0.0 	$0.00
Emily Wilson 	2/22/2024 	0.3 	0.3 	$72.00
Andrew Balashov 	2/27/2024 	0.2 	0.2 	$90.00
Andrew Balashov 	2/28/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$45.00
Andrew Balashov 	2/29/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$45.00
Suvita Melehy 	2/29/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$62.50
Andrew Balashov 	3/1/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$45.00
Andrew Balashov 	3/6/2024 	0.2 	0.2 	$90.00
Andrew Balashov 	3/8/2024 	0.1 	0.0 	$0.00
Andrew Balashov 	3/11/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$45.00
Andrew Balashov 	3/18/2024 	0.2 	0.0 	$0.00
Emily Wilson 	3/18/2024 	0.7 	0.7 	$168.00
Andrew Balashov 	4/2/2024 	0.2 	0.1 	$90.00
Emily Wilson 	4/2/2024 	0.2 	0.0 	$0.00
Andrew Balashov 	4/5/2024 	0.1 	0.0 	$0.00
Emily Wilson 	4/16/2024 	0.1 	0.0 	$0.00
Suvita Melehy 	5/1/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$62.50
Emily Wilson 	5/2/2024 	0.1 	0.0 	$0.00
Emily Wilson 	5/15/2024 	0.1 	0.0 	$0.00
Andrew Balashov 	5/16/2024 	0.1 	0.0 	$0.00
Suvita Melehy 	5/17/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$62.50
Andrew Balashov 	6/11/2024 	0.1 	0.0 	$0.00
Emily Wilson 	9/11/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$24.00
Andrew Balashov 	2/10/2025 	0.2 	0.2 	$90.00
Andrew Balashov 	2/11/2025 	0.1 	0.1 	$45.00
Andrew Balashov 	2/12/2025 	0.3 	0.3 	$135.00
Emily Wilson 	2/18/2025 	0.1 	0.0 	$0.00
Total Billed by Attorney(s) 	$975.00
Total Billed by Paralegal(s) 	$336.00
Total Amount Billed 	$1,311.00
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 13 of 18
14
d. 	Motions
Plaintiff requests a fee in amount of $1,887.50 related to the Plaintiff’s motions for Clerk’s
entry of default and default judgment. Counsel asserts the hours expended (7.9 hours) were in
relation to drafting the motions for Clerk’s entry of default and motion for default judgment, and
all attachments thereto. (Motion, p. 11).
The undersigned finds that the entries in this category are descriptive enough and appear
to be reasonable. Paralegals handled 3.5 of the 7.9 hours expended. Motions for Clerk’s Entry of
Default were filed on May 2, 2024. (ECF Nos. 7, 8). The Motion for Default Judgment was filed
on June 24, 2024. (ECF No. 13). The undersigned also finds that the motions 	for default and
default judgment were not particularly complex, so it is unclear why two attorney timekeepers
needed to be involved. However, the undersigned only recommends that the fees awarded for Ms.
Wilson (2.8 hours) be reduced from $672.00 to $420.00 (by $252.00), reflecting the reduced hourly
rate of $150.00 per hour. Multiplying 2.8 hours times the adjusted rate results in an amount billed
of $420.00, for total fee in the amount of $1,635.00.
Timekeeper 	Date 	Hours
Expended
Hours
Billed
Amount Billed
Andrew Balashov 	5/1/2024 	0.1 	0.1 	$45.00
Emily Wilson 	5/1/2024 	0.3 	0.3 	$72.00
Emily Wilson 	5/2/2024 	0.2 	0.0 	$0.00
Andrew Balashov 	5/7/2024 	0.2 	0.0 	$0.00
Omar Melehy 	5/7/2024 	0.2 	0.2 	$135.00
Emily Wilson 	6/12/2024 	1.2 	1.2 	$288.00
Emily Wilson 	6/14/2024 	0.9 	0.8 	$192.00
Andrew Balashov 	6/19/2024 	1.4 	0.0 	$0.00
Andrew Balashov 	6/21/2024 	0.2 	0.0 	$0.00
Andrew Balashov 	6/24/2024 	2.3 	2.3 	$1,035.00
Emily Wilson 	6/24/2024 	0.9 	0.5 	$120.00
Total Billed by Attorney(s) 	$1,215.00
Total Billed by Paralegal(s) 	$672.00
Total Amount Billed 	$1,887.00
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 14 of 18
15
e. 	Settlement
Plaintiff requests a fee in amount of $228.00 related to a settlement demand that was
prepared and sent to the Defendants. Counsel asserts the hours expended (0.7 hours) were in done
“in hopes of obviating the need for further litigation.” However, “Defendants did not respond.”
(Motion, p. 11). At the time that the settlement demand was being prepared (June 24 – June 26,
2024), Plaintiff knew that the Defendants had been unresponsive, and that Notices of Default had
been sent to the Defendants. (ECF Nos. 10, 11). In addition, Plaintiff has just filed her Motion for
Default Judgment on June 10, 2024. (ECF No. 13). Thus, the undersigned recommends a full
reduction of fees related to settlement in the amount of $228.00.
f. 	Fee Petition
Plaintiff requests a fee in amount of $1,365.006 related to the Plaintiff’s Motion for
Attorney’s Fees. Counsel asserts the hours expended (3.8 hours) were in relation to drafting the
motion and supporting documentation, including “a systematic review of the billing records […]
and exercising billing judgement.” (Motion, p. 12).
The Motion was supported with declarations and billing information. The undersigned does not
find the amount of time spent drafting the Motion to be unreasonable. However, the undersigned
6 As a preliminary matter, the motion requests $1,887.00, but the correct figure is $1,365.00.
Timekeeper 	Date 	Hours
Expended
Hours
Billed
Amount Billed
Felipe Veras 	4/19/2024 	0.3 	0.00 	$0.00
Andrew Balashov 	6/25/2024 	0.2 	0.2 	$90.00
Andrew Balashov 	2/19/2025 	0.8 	0.8 	$360.00
Andrew Balashov 	3/14/2025 	1.5 	1.5 	$675.00
Emily Wilson 	3/14/2025 	1.0 	1.0 	$240.00
Total Billed by Attorney(s) 	$1,125.00
Total Billed by Paralegal(s) 	$240.00
Total Amount Billed 	$1,365.00
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 15 of 18
16
recommends that the fees awarded for Ms. Wilson (1 hour) be reduced from $240.00 to $150.00
($90.00), reflecting the reduced hourly rate of $150.00 per hour. Multiplying 1 hour times the
adjusted rate results in an amount billed of $150.00, for a total fee in the amount of $1,275.00.
B. Subtraction of Fees for Unsuccessful Claims
Plaintiff was awarded $11,794.76 of the $14,878.13 sought in the Motion for Default
Judgment. (See ECF Nos. 13, p. 1; 18). Based on these facts, the undersigned does not recommend
that a further reduction is warranted.
C. Degree of Success
Plaintiff has been successful is seeking entry of default and default judgment in this case.
(See ECF Nos. 9 - 11, 15, 18). Based on these facts, the undersigned does not recommend that a
further reduction is warranted.
D. Summary of Reductions
In sum, the undersigned recommends reductions as reflected below:
The undersigned recommends that the district court award Plaintiff attorneys’ fees in the amount
of $6,585.00.
Description 	Fee Requested 	Amount of
Reduction
Recommended
Fee Award
Pre-Filing Investigation 	$1,276.50 	$99.00 	$1,177.50
Pleadings 	$1,330.50 	$18.00 	$1,312.50
General Case
Management & Client
Communication
$1,311.00 	$126.00 	$1,185.00
Motions 	$1,887.00 	$252.00 	$1,635.00
Settlement 	$228.00 	$228.00 	$0.00
Fee Petition 	$1,365.00 	$90.00 	$1,275.00
Totals 	$7,398.00 	$813.00 	$6,585.00
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 16 of 18
17
E. Allocation of Fee Award
On April 8, 2025, the Court entered Judgment against the Defendants, jointly and severally.
(ECF No. 22). The undersigned recommends that the district court allocate the award of attorneys’
fees across the Defendants, jointly and several.
F. Costs
In an FLSA case, a prevailing party may also recover costs, but “only for reasonable
litigation expenses.” Jones v. Dancel, 792 F.3d 395, 404 (4th Cir. 2015)(quoting Daly v. Hill, 790
F.2d 1071, 1084 (4th Cir. 1986)); see also Spell v. McDaniel, 852 F.2d 762, 771 (4th Cir.
1988)(costs that may be taxed against a losing defendant include reasonable out-of-pocket
expenses incurred by the attorneys).
An award of costs “must adequately compensate counsel without resulting in a windfall.”
Daly, 790 F.2d at 1084 n.18. Courts within the Fourth Circuit have the same discretion in awarding
costs as they do when awarding attorneys’ fees. Roy v. Cnty. of Lexington, S.C., 141 F.3d 533, 549
(4th Cir. 1998). In addition, federal law and the Local Rules provide for certain reimbursable
expenses. See 28 U.S.C. § 1920; Loc. R. App. B, ¶ 4.
The following are examples of the categories of costs that have been charged to losing
defendants: “necessary travel, depositions and transcripts, computer research, postage, court costs,
and photocopying.” Almendarez v. J.T.T. Enters. Corp., Civ. No. JKS-06-68, 2010 WL 3385362,
at *7 (D. Md. Aug. 25, 2010) (citing Vaughns v. Bd. of Educ. of Prince George's County, 598 F.
Supp. 1262, 1289–90 (D. Md. 1984)).
Plaintiff seeks costs in the amount of $835.95. To substantiate her costs, Plaintiff submitted
a 	Summary 	of 	Costs 	plus 	supporting 	documentation. 	(ECF 	No. 	19-6). 	Plaintiff 	seeks
reimbursement for photocopies ($47.00), postage ($11.98), online research ($11.97), the filing fee
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 17 of 18
18
($405.00), and fees incurred for service of process upon the Defendants ($360.00). The
undersigned finds that the costs are compensable under Almendarez, the Local Rules (Loc. R. App.
B., ¶¶ 4a., c.), and the United States District Court for the District of Maryland: Guidelines for
Bills of Costs, Sections II.A., G.-H. and III. The filing fee for the Complaint is compensable. See 28
U.S.C. § 1920(1); see also Guidelines for Bills of Costs, Section II.B.
Accordingly, the undersigned recommends that the district court award Plaintiff costs in
the amount of $835.95.
IV. 	CONCLUSION
In sum, I respectfully recommend that the district court:
1) 	GRANT IN PART AND DENY IN PART, Plaintiff’s Motion for Award of
Attorney’s Fees and Costs, (ECF No. 19); and
2) 	AWARD the Plaintiff attorneys’ fees in the amount of $6,585.00, and costs in the
amount of $835.95.
Date: November 26, 2025 	/s/
The Honorable Gina L. Simms
United States Magistrate Judge
Case 8:24-cv-00353-TDC Document 24 Filed 11/26/25 Page 18 of 18

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.