A. Perry Designs & Builds, P.C. v. J. Paul Builders, LLC

1:23-cv-00828MddDec 23, 2025

Full text

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND
A. PERRY DESIGNS & BUILDS, P.C.,
Plaintiff,
v.
J. PAUL BUILDERS, LLC, et al.,
Defendants No. 23-cv-828-ABA
LEVIN/BROWN ASSOCIATES, INC.,
Crossclaim/Third-Party Plaintiff,
v.
CTLC, LLC, et al.,
Crossclaim/Third-Party Defendants
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER ON
GRIERS’ MOTIONS TO DISMISS
Plaintiff A. Perry Designs & Builds, P.C. (“Perry”) is an architectural firm that in
2014 was hired to design a home in Glenelg, Maryland for Sandra and Michael Grier.
The Griers (through their entity CTLC, LLC) and Perry parted ways in 2019. CTLC then
hired a different builder and architect to continue with the project: J. Paul Builders, LLC
and Levin/Brown Associates, Inc. (“Levin/Brown”), respectively. Perry has sued J. Paul
Builders, Levin/Brown, and CTLC for copyright infringement and related claims (ECF
No. 62). Levin/Brown, in turn, has sued CTLC and the Griers for fraud, breach of
contract and indemnification (ECF No. 83).
The Court previously ruled on J. Paul Builders and Levin/Brown’s motions to
dismiss the claims against them. ECF No. 78. Since then, Levin/Brown has at least
attempted to serve its complaint on the Griers, together with summonses that the Court
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 1 of 12
2
had issued on December 10, 2024. ECF Nos. 85, 100 & 101. The declarations of service
state that on September 10, 2025, service was made “by serving Sandra Grier, wife of
Michael Grier, a person of suitable age and discretion, who stated that he/she resides
therein [at 6101 Tilghman Drive, Laurel, Maryland 20724] with Michael Grier.” ECF No.
100 at 2; see also ECF No. 101 at 2. Both declarations further describe service as follows:
On this occasion, I parked my vehicle down the street from the
residence at 7:50 AM. There were two cars parked in the
residence’s driveway. I observed Mr. Grier step outside onto
his front porch, then head back inside. I walked up to the
residence and rang the doorbell. Mr. Grier saw me through the
front window. I waved to him, but his son answered the door
instead. He asked how he could help me, to which I replied
that I had a delivery for his parents. He stated he was not 18
years old and could not accept them. I asked if his father
would come to the door to receive the documents, but he
closed the door. I waited in my vehicle outside the residence
until 8: 10 AM, when a Mercedes SUV began to back out of the
garage. I exited my vehicle and stood next to the SUV. Mrs.
Grier appeared to be driving her son to school. I explained that
I had a delivery for her, but she kept backing the SUV out of
the driveway. I then placed the documents on the SUV’s hood,
and she sped out of the driveway.
ECF No. 100 at 2; ECF No. 101 at 2.
The Griers have now moved to dismiss Levin/Brown’s claims against them. ECF
Nos. 102 & 105. They argue that Levin/Brown’s claims should be dismissed for four
reasons set forth below. Having reviewed those motions, along with the briefs filed in
opposition (ECF Nos. 104 & 106), the Court will deny those motions.
First, the Griers seek dismissal because the third-party complaint and
summonses were not served within 90 days of the filing of the third-party complaint.
ECF No. 102-1 at 8–10; ECF No. 105 ¶¶ 5–13. Rule 4(m) of the Federal Rules of Civil
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 2 of 12
3
Procedure provides that, “[i]f a defendant is not served within 90 days after the
complaint is filed, the court—on motion or on its own after notice to the plaintiff—must
dismiss the action without prejudice against that defendant or order that service be
made within a specified time.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(m). But it goes on to state that “if the
plaintiff shows good cause for the failure, the court must extend the time for service for
an appropriate period.” Id. Here, Levin/Brown argues that good cause exists for the
delay because the case was stayed between December 17, 2025 (ECF No. 86) and March
25, 2025 (ECF No. 90). The Griers point out that, even accounting for the stay,
Levin/Brown did not request re-issuance of summonses until August 28, 2025 (ECF
Nos. 97 & 98) and then served the original summonses that had been issued in
December 2024. See ECF No. 102-1 at 9. But none of these arguments justify dismissal
under Rule 4(m). In light of the stay, and because discovery had not begun in this case,
and in light of the direction in Rule 1 that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure “be
construed, administered, and employed by the court and the parties to secure the just,
speedy, and inexpensive determination of every action and proceeding,” Fed. R. Civ. P.
1, Levin/Brown has shown good cause for not serving the summonses and third-party
complaint earlier.
Second, the Griers argue that even if service was timely (or untimeliness is
excused), delivery of the complaint and summonses on the hood of Ms. Grier’s car at the
Griers’ home did not constitute service “at the individual’s dwelling or usual place of
abode with someone of suitable age and discretion who resides there” as required under
Rule 4(e)(2)(B) (emphasis added). See ECF No. 102-1 at 11; ECF No. 105 ¶¶ 16–16.1 The
1 Ms. Grier’s motion contains two paragraphs numbered 16.
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 3 of 12
4
argument seems to be that, even though Ms. Grier was inside the car and clearly was the
intended recipient of the package, the materials were left “with some[thing]” (i.e., the
car) as opposed to with Ms. Grier herself. The Griers have not identified any authority
for interpreting Rule 4(e)(2)(B) as requiring that the documents be delivered in Ms.
Grier’s hands as opposed to directly on the vehicle being operated by Ms. Grier in front
of her home. The Court concludes that service by that means was adequate to satisfy
Rule 4.
Third, the Griers argue service was insufficient because although the service
package included the summonses and Levin/Brown’s third-party complaint, it did not
include other filings from the docket of this case to date. ECF No. 102-1 at 10. That
argument is premised on Local Rule 103.7(b), which provides that “[u]nless otherwise
ordered by the Court, a third-party plaintiff shall serve upon a third-party defendant
copies of all documents (other than notices of previously held depositions) which the
parties have previously served upon one another and shall make all previously-
conducted discovery materials available for review by the third-party defendant.” But
Local Rule 103.7(b) does not modify Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4. Service of
process here was effectuated by service of the summons and third-party complaint. And
although Local Rule 103.7(b) does separately require service of all documents that the
parties other than the Griers previously served upon each other, the Court hereby rules
that in this case the rule only requires service of documents that are not available on
CM/ECF.
Fourth, Mr. Grier argues that, in the alternative and at minimum, Levin/Brown’s
claim for fraudulent inducement (Count 1 of the third-party claim) should be dismissed
for failure to state a claim on which relief can be granted. ECF No. 102-1 at 11–13. Ms.
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 4 of 12
5
Grier has not asserted this argument. As Mr. Grier recognizes, the elements of the tort of
fraudulent inducement are “that (1) the defendant made a false representation to the
plaintiff, (2) the falsity of the representation was either known to the defendant or the
representation was made with reckless indifference to its truth, (3) the
misrepresentation was made for the purpose of defrauding the plaintiff, (4) the plaintiff
relied on the misrepresentation and had the right to rely on it, and (5) the plaintiff
suffered compensable injury as a result of the misrepresentation.” Hoffman v. Stamper,
385 Md. 1, 28 (2005). Mr. Grier argues that Levin/Brown’s allegations are too
“conclusory” and not pled with particularity. ECF No. 102-1 at 12.
To withstand a motion to dismiss, a complaint’s “[f]actual allegations must be
enough to raise a right to relief above the speculative level” and state a facially plausible
claim for relief. Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 555, 570 (2007). “A claim has
facial plausibility when the plaintiff pleads factual content that allows the court to draw
the reasonable inference that the defendant is liable for the misconduct alleged.”
Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 678 (2009). When considering such a motion, the Court
“must accept as true all of the factual allegations contained in the complaint and draw
all reasonable inferences in favor of the plaintiff.” King v. Rubenstein, 825 F.3d 206, 212
(4th Cir. 2016). And although Levin/Brown’s fraud claim must “state with particularity
the circumstances constituting fraud or mistake,” matters such as “intent, knowledge,
and other conditions of a person’s mind may be alleged generally.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 9(b).
Here, Count 1 of the third-party complaint adequately states a claim for
fraudulent inducement. The complaint specifically alleges that CTLC represented to
Levin/Brown that CTLC was “the copyright owner” of the original design (referred to in
the CTLC-Levin/Brown agreement as the “Instruments of Service”), ECF No. 83 at 10 ¶
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 5 of 12
6
10, that Mr. Grier “had personal knowledge of the Griers’ ownership interest in the
design documents developed by Plaintiff and of the actions taken by the Griers to
effectuate the transfer of that copyright ownership from the Griers to CTLC,” id. at 11 ¶
15, that insofar as CTLC was not authorized to transmit the original design to
Levin/Brown, the Griers knowingly “authorized CTLC to falsely warrant to LBA
[Levin/Brown] the possession copyright ownership over the design documents
developed by Plaintiff,” id. at 12 ¶¶ 19, 22–23, that those allegedly false statements
“induced LBA to enter into the CTLC/LBA Agreement,” id. at 13 ¶ 24, and that “[b]ut for
the false representations made by the Griers and CTLC, LBA would not have used any
design documents provided by the Griers and/or CTLC in furtherance of completing its
services,” id. at 13 ¶ 27. As Levin/Brown puts it in its opposition to the motion to
dismiss, consistent with the allegations in its complaint against the Griers, “If A. Perry
proves that the Griers did not pay all amounts due under their contract for the Work
Product, then A. Perry will have proven that the Griers knew or should have known that
they did not possess any right to use the Work Product.” ECF No. 104 at 10. These
allegations in support of Count 1 of Levin/Brown’s complaint against CTLC and the
Griers are sufficient to state a claim for fraudulent inducement on which relief can be
granted.
CONCLUSION AND ORDER
For the reasons explained above, the Court hereby ORDERS as follows:
1. 	The motions to dismiss filed by third-party defendants Michael Grier (ECF
No. 102) and Sandra Grier (ECF No. 105) are DENIED;
2. 	Local Rule 103.7(b) is waived with respect to any documents that are
available on CM/ECF;
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 6 of 12
7
3. 	The Griers shall file answers to the third-party complaint (ECF No. 83)
within 14 days of this Order (see Fed. R. Civ. P. (a)(4)(A));
4. 	Discovery on all claims (including cross-claims and third-party claims)
may now commence, and any remaining stay is hereby LIFTED; and
5. 	The Court directs the parties to the proposed Scheduling Order filed
contemporaneous with this Order; please review it, confer, and within 14 days of this
Order file a joint status report stating whether you: 1) request any changes to the dates
in the proposed Scheduling Order; 2) would like to participate in a settlement
conference and, if so, the phase of the case in which you propose that a conference be
scheduled (e.g., promptly, or after the conclusion of discovery, etc.); 3) unanimously
consent to proceed before a United States Magistrate Judge; 4) anticipate exchanging
discovery of electronically stored information (ESI), and, if so, whether you presently
anticipate any disputes regarding ESI-related discovery; and 5) propose to defer any of
the expert discovery until after summary judgment motions are resolved.
Date: December 23, 2025 	________________________
Adam B. Abelson
United States District Judge
/s/
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 7 of 12
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND
A. PERRY DESIGNS & BUILDS, P.C.,
Plaintiff,
v.
J. PAUL BUILDERS, LLC, et al.,
Defendants No. 23-cv-828-ABA
LEVIN/BROWN ASSOCIATES, INC.,
Crossclaim/Third-Party Plaintiff,
v.
CTLC, LLC, et al.,
Crossclaim/Third-Party Defendants
[PROPOSED] SCHEDULING ORDER
This scheduling order is being entered pursuant to Local Rule 103.9. 	This scheduling
order supersedes any prior scheduling order in this case and applies to all claims currently
pending in this case. Any inquiries concerning the schedule should be directed to my chambers,
not to the Clerk's Office. 	Any party who believes that any deadline set forth in this Scheduling
Order is unreasonable may request in writing a modification of the Order or that a conference be
held for the purpose of seeking a modification of the Order, and any such request must be made
on or before the first date set forth in Paragraph I below. 	Thereafter, the schedule will not be
changed except for good cause.
This case is subject to electronic filing. Please familiarize yourself with the procedures for
electronic filing available at: www.mdd.uscourts.gov. You must use the electronic filing system
for filing documents with the Clerk and sending case related correspondence to chambers.
I. DEADLINES
January 6, 2026: 	Deadline for requests for modification of initial
Scheduling Order
January 6, 2026: 	Joint request for early settlement/ADR conference
(This request will not postpone discovery unless
otherwise ordered.)
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 8 of 12
2
January 6, 2026: 	Report about deposition hours
January 6, 2026: 	Initial report whether there is unanimous consent
to proceed before a United States Magistrate
Judge
January 6, 2026: 	Deadline 	for 	conference 	about 	discovery 	of
electronically stored information. 	(If either or
both parties intend to take such discovery, before
the 	conference 	counsel 	should 	review 	the
Principles for the Discovery of Electronically
Stored Information in Civil Cases prepared by a
joint 	bench/bar 	committee 	published 	on 	the
court’s website.)
February 6, 2026: 	Moving for joinder of additional parties and
amendment of pleadings
February 23, 2026: 	Plaintiff’s Rule 26(a)(2) disclosures
March 23, 2026: 	Defendant’s Rule 26(a)(2) disclosures
April 6, 2026: 	Plaintiff’s rebuttal Rule 26(a)(2) disclosures
April 13, 2026: 	Rule 26(e)(2) supplementation of disclosures and
responses
May 7, 2026: 	Discovery deadline; submission of status report
June 8, 2026: 	Dispositive pretrial motions deadline
II. DISCOVERY
Initial Disclosures
This is an action in which Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(1) disclosures need not be made.
Discovery Conference
This action is exempted from the requirements of Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(d)(1) and from Fed.
R. Civ. P. 26(f). However, you are encouraged to confer with one another immediately in order
to: (a) identify the issue(s), (b) set a discovery plan, (c) determine if the case can be resolved before
your clients incur further litigation expense, (d) discuss any issues about preserving discoverable
information, and (e) establish a cordial professional relationship among yourselves.
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 9 of 12
3
Procedure
All the provisions of Local Rule 104 apply, including the following:
a. 	All discovery requests must be served in time to assure that they are
answered before the discovery deadline. An extension of the deadline will not be
granted because of unanswered discovery requests.
b. 	The existence of a discovery dispute as to one matter does not justify delay
in taking any other discovery. The filing of a motion to compel or a motion for a
protective order will not result in a general extension of the discovery deadline.
c. 	No 	discovery 	materials, 	including 	Rule 	26(a)(1) 	and 	Rule 	26(a)(2)
disclosures, should be filed with the court.
d. 	Motions to compel shall be filed in accordance with Local Rule 104.8 and
applicable CM/ECF procedures.
e. 	Please be familiar with the Discovery Guidelines of this Court which are
Appendix A to the Local Rules. 	Appendix D contains guidelines for form
discovery requests and confidentiality orders that may be helpful to you.
Deposition Hours
Please confer with one another immediately concerning the number of hours of depositions
which you believe are appropriate. If I have not heard from you by the date set forth in Section I
of this order, each side shall be limited to 15 hours of depositions of fact witnesses (including
parties). (If you agree to another number of deposition hours and notify me of your agreement,
you may consider your agreement approved unless you hear from me to the contrary within 10
days.) If there are two or more parties on a particular side, they must share the deposition time
allotted to their side unless upon your request I otherwise rule. 	Any colloquy engaged in by
counsel shall be counted against his/her client's deposition time.
III. STATUS REPORT
The parties shall file on the day of the discovery deadline a status report covering the
following matters:
a. 	Whether discovery has been completed;
b. 	Whether any motions are pending;
c. 	Whether any party intends to file a dispositive pretrial motion;
d. 	Whether the case is to be tried jury or non-jury and the anticipated length of
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 10 of 12
4
trial;
e. 	A certification that the parties have met to conduct serious settlement
negotiations; and the date, time and place of the meeting and the names of all
persons participating therein;
f. 	Whether each party believes it would be helpful to refer this case to another
judge of this court for a settlement or other ADR conference, either before or after
the resolution of any dispositive pretrial motion;
g. 	Whether all parties consent, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 636(c), to have a U.S.
Magistrate Judge conduct all further proceedings in this case, either before or after
the resolution of any dispositive pretrial motion, including trial (jury or non-jury)
and entry of final judgment.
h. 	Any other matter which you believe should be brought to the court's
attention.
IV. DISPOSITIVE PRETRIAL MOTIONS
If more than one party intends to file a summary judgment motion, the provisions of Local
Rule 105.2.c apply.
After motions and responses thereto have been filed, I will advise you if a hearing is to be
scheduled.
V. STATUS AND PRETRIAL CONFERENCES
I will set a scheduling conference after the status report has been filed, unless that report
indicates that one or more of you intends to file a dispositive pretrial motion. In the latter event I
will not set a scheduling conference until after I have ruled upon the motion (or the dispositive
pretrial motion deadline passes without the anticipated motion being filed).
At the scheduling conference:
a. 	I will set a deadline for submitting the pretrial order, motions in limine,
proposed voir dire questions and proposed jury instructions;
b. 	I will set a pretrial conference date and a trial date; and
c. 	I will ask you whether a settlement or other ADR conference with a judicial
officer would be useful, and whether all parties would consent to trial (jury or non-
jury) before a U.S. Magistrate Judge. Please confer with your client about these
matters before the conference so that you are in a position to respond.
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 11 of 12
5
VI. ATTORNEYS’ FEES
In any case where attorneys’ fees may be sought by the prevailing party, counsel must be
familiar with the provisions of Local Rule 109.2 and the Rules and Guidelines for Determining
Attorneys’ Fees in Certain Cases which are Appendix B to the Local Rules.
VII. COMPLIANCE WITH LOCAL RULES AND CM/ECF PROCEDURES
The court will demand compliance with the Local Rules and CM/ECF procedures. If you
need to obtain a copy of the Local Rules or the CM/ECF procedures, they are available on our
website at www.mdd.uscourts.gov.
VIII. COMPLIANCE WITH PRIVACY PROTECTION RULE
Counsel are reminded that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure were amended, effective
December 1, 2007, with the addition of a new Rule 5.2 which has detailed requirements requiring
the redaction of filings with this court that contain an individual's social security number, tax payer
identification number, or birth date, the name of an individual known to be a minor, or a financial
account number. It is essential that counsel comply with this rule and with the revised version of
the Judicial Conference Privacy Policy adopted in March 2008. 	For further information on the
Judicial Conference Privacy Policy see:
http://www.mdd.uscourts.gov/news/news/privacy_memo.pdf.
Date: December 23, 2025
Adam B. Abelson
United States District Judge
Case 1:23-cv-00828-ABA Document 111 Filed 12/23/25 Page 12 of 12

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.