IN RE: Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, on September 11, 1982

p. 1
Le : Can UE LE LGA LON
REA 555 ~~ In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, on
oo ‘September	11, 1982
83/05/26 1 MOTION, BRIEF, SCHEDULE, CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE -- Pltfs.
Karin Trumpfheller, et al. and Birgit Brock, et al. (cds)
" SUGGESTED TRANSFEREE COURT: E.D. Pennsylvania
SUGGESTED TRANSFEREE JUDGE:
83/05/31 2 LETTER/RESPONSE -- The Boeing Co. w/svc. (ds)
83/06/06: Appearance -- JAMES J. MCCARTHY, ESQ. for Ursula J. Schoenborn,
etc., et al. (ds)
83/06/24 HEARING ORDER -- Setting motion for Panel Hearing in Portland,
Maine on July 28, 1983 (cds)
83/07/21 HEARING APPEARANCE -- ALL PARTIES WAIVE 7/28/83 HEARING
IN PORTLAND, ME. (rew)
83/08/05 - CONSENT OF TRANSFEREE JUDGE -- Assigning litigation to the
: Hon. Charles R. Weiner, E.D. Pa., for coordinated or
consolidated pretrial proceedings pursuant to 28 U.S.C.
. §1407. (ds)
83/08/05 . TRANSFER ORDER -- transferring A-1 and A-3 to the E.D. Pa.
for pretrial proceedings. Notified involved
© Judges, clerks, counsel and misc. recipients. (ds)
83/10/28 "HEARING APPEARANCES: WILLIAM F. KOEGEL, ESQ. for Merrill Lynch,
Pierce, Fenner & Smith, Inc.; MARSHALL PATNER, ESQ. for
© Wallace M. Rudolph; ROBERT J. WOODY, ESQ. for Blyth Eastman
Pain Webber, Inc. (cds)
83/10/28 WAIVERS OF ORAL ARGUMENT: Central Lincoln PUD, Clatskanie PUD,
| Northern Wasco County PUD, Tillamook PUD, City of Cascade Locks,
. City of Canby Utility Board; PUD No. 1 of Chelan County, WA,
© PUD No. 1 of Clallam County, WA, PUD No. 1 of Douglas County, WA,
oo i PUD No. 2 of Grant County, WA, PUD No. 1 of Snohomish County, WA,
+ City of Richland, WA; City of Seattle; Dr. Joseph Harris:
Chemical Bank; David Gold and Marvin Frankel; Pacific Power
& Light; Henry Puchall; City of Bandon, et al.; Big Bend
Electric Cooperative, Inc., et al.; City of Ellensburg, et al.
(cds)
84/08/30 ~ CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY -- B-45 Leo: B c ny, W.D. Michigan, C.A.	~ Schoenborn, et al. v. The Boeing Company,
No. G84-810-CA. Notified involved counsel and judge (rh)
84/09/11 APPEARANCE: VALARIE HURLEY TWANMOH, ESQ. for Leo Schoenborn,
et al. (rh)
AN | \ y
Ny N ” .
“ } g

JPMI FORM 1A p-2
DOCKET ENTRIES
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
OCERT NO. _555-— _In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, Oh mmm.
September 11, 1982
Ton TE TT Ploading beseriptionee te SOAP A Pome pitti
CS ee TTT TEL Tam EEene CL OO err TLLI I I LILTTT
84/09/12 3 | vorTcE OF OPPOSITION -- B-45 Leo Schoenborn, et al. v. The
j | Boeing Company, W.D. Mich., C.A. No. G84-810-CA -- filed by
|pltf. Leo Schoenborn, et al. (rh)
34/09/27 Sy MOTION TO VACATE CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER (B-45 Leo
Schoenborn, et al. v. The Boeing Co., W.D.Mich., #G84-810-CA)
-- pltfs. Leo Schoenborn, et al. -- w/cert. of service (cds)
84/09/27 | CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY (7 actions, B-46 =~
: B-52 listed below) -- NOTIFIED INVOLVED JUDGES AND COUNSEL
| (cds) B-46 Pritz Ruchti, et al. v. The Boeing .D.Ark.| 84-5134
| Co. no : aters
| -
B-47 Karl-Heinz Aulenbacher, et al. v. .D. Ark}84-5135
] The Boeing Co. aters '
| B-48 Georg Trumpfheller, et al. v. The .D. Ark|}B84-5136
| Boeing Co. LC . aters	B-49 Horst Exle v. The Boeing Co. .D. Ark}84-5137
| : aters
B-50 Harry Gern, et al. v. The Boeing Co. .D.Ark.} 84-5138
: aters
B-51 Werner Dingert, et al. v. The Boeing .D.Ark.| 84-5139
’ Co. . ) aters
B-52 | Ranier Berkenfeld, et al. v. The h.p.arx. | 84-5140
Boeing Co. aters
| :81/10/11 | 5 | RESPONSE/BRIEF (to pldge. 4) -- The Boeing Co. =-- w/cert. of
| sve. (emh)	sU4/16/15 CONDITIONAL TRAMSFER ORDERS FINAL TODAY (Ri=-U46 - p=52, LISTED
| BELOW) -- HOTIFIED INVOLVED JUDGES AND CLERKS (cds)	. B-46 Fritz Ruchti, et al. v. The Boeing .D.Ark.| 84-5134
. Co. -. . laters
| oe Karl-Heinz PE et al. v. .D. Ark}84-5135	The Boeing Co. laters
| B-48 |Georg Trumpfheller, et al. v. The .D. Ark}84-5136 'Boeing Co. .. laters
B-49 Horst Exle v. The Boeing Co. .D. Ark|84-5137
| laters
1 | 3-50 Harry Gern, et al. v. The Boeing Co. .D.Ark.| 84-5138	| : . aters
| | B-51 Werner Dingert, et al. v. The Boeing D.Ark. 24-5239	: Co. . ] aters
| - :
; B-52 [Ranier Berkenfeld, et al. v. The .D.Ark. | 84-5140
| oo Boeing Co. laters

SPML FORM 1A p-3
DOCKET ENTRIES
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DGCKET NO. 555 ~- _In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim,	Germany, on September 11, 1982...
| |
84/10/19) 6 SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE (to pldg. 5) -- Boeing Company --
| w/cert. of svc. (emh)84/12/14 HEARING ORDER -~ Setting motion for transfer of B-45 for Panel
Hearing in New Orleans, Louisiana on January 24, 1985 (rh)
85/01/22 | HEARING APPEARANCE BARRY gr REENGORD mrs FOr BO ITC emnfmdesy [LWA VED
85/01/22 | WAIVERS OF ORAL ARGUMENT: Leo Schoenborn, et al.; pltfs. Schoenborn,
| Edwards, Sutton & Cruz (cds)i
85/02/05 TRANSFER ORDER -- transferring B-U45 Leo Schoenborn, et al. v.
The Boeing Company, W.D. Michigan, C.A. No. G84-810-CA to the
! E.D. Pennsylvania for pretrial proceedings pursuant to 28
U.S.C. §1407. Notified involved clerks, judges, counsel and
! misc. recipients (rh)
85/02/12! CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY -- B-55 Iris Elke Inge
Tusche, et al. v. The Boeing Co., N.D. California, C.A. No.
C84-6164-MHP -- Notified involved counsel and judge (rh)
85/02/28 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- B-55 Iris Elke Inge
Tusche, et al. v. The Boeing Co., N.D. Cal., C.A. No.
| C84~-6164-MPH. Notified involved clerks and judges. (ds) :
|
|
|
i
|
Co:

JPML Form 1 p. [@D B
Revised: 8/78
DOCKET NO. 555 -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
CAPTION: In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, on September 11, 1982
SUMMARY OF LITIGATION ;
7/28/83 - -
Dates Filed Type Citation District Name of Judge Assigned From
8/5/83 TO (unpublished)	E.D. Pa. Charles R. Weiner
Special Transferee Information
fo
DATE CLOSED: /- 30-84

JPML FORM 1 LISTING OF INVOLVED ACTIONS p- J
DOCKET NO. 555 —-= In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, on September 11, 1982
Intra- District Civil rans feredbate of
Office and Action ransfer| Docket [Dismissal
Number Caption ITudge Number Date Number lor Remand Misc.
' . . 25k = RZ HOY Ohl L-	A-1 Birgit Brock, et al. v. The Boeing .D.Cal.|83-2448-TEH Bats / EO fled.
Company endersol | CooL
A-2 Ursula J. Schoenborn v. The Boeing .D.Pa. [82-4339 4 ’
Company einer |
| 2, ; ~, es % 1.
A-3 Karin Trumpfheller, et al. v. The .D.cal.|83-2467-sC 2)5]i5 83-3758 S° 4 Ai Boeing Company Conti bore og
Xyz-4 Alice E. DeVault, etc. v. The E.D.Pa. | 83-0969 130-860Boeing Co. Weiner LL
XYZ-5 Cheryl A. Eschler, etc., et al. v, E.D.Pa. | 89-4589 )= 30-8607The Boeing Co. Weiner Pe oe
XYZ-6 Susan Sutton v. The Boeing Company E.D.Pa. | 82-4539 J-30- EL.
XYz2-7 Sheila Cruz v. The Boeing Company E.D.Pa. | 82-4540 ‘ YECAPEN TY) IC Co )
He 4 % 5g
XYZ-8 Ursula J. Schoenborn, et al. v. The
Boeing Company E.D.Pa. | 82-4541 bye IDEN A
12-22%	@:
XYZ-9 Cheryl A. Eschler, et al. v. The : N g2
Boeing Company E.D.Pa. | 82-4589. | /- 30-8 CoaJey	- Ba
XYZ-10 Barbara D. Scott, et al. wv. The § nN.
Boeing Company ~ |E.D.Pa. | 83-0970 J —30- de "2 oe	te hot 7
XYz-11 Milada Ruchti, et al. v. The Boeing |E.D.Pa. | 83-971 ,. 20-564 Lane 4dCompany / WEEE SCAR I
XYZ-12 Teresa L. Stewart v. The Boeing E.D.Pa. { 83-1548 J 30-5 SE
Company ; PE
XYZ-13 Nola Fonfe v. The Boeing Company E.D.Pa. | 83-1604 0 1-30 - yl] Sov

Case MDL No. 555 Document 1 Filed 06/02/15 Page 6 of 12
JBEML, FORM 1 -- Continuation e ss ,
Listing of Involved Actions -- p.
DOCKET NO. 555 —- In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, on September 11, 1982
Intra- Distric Civil : Date of
Office and Action TransferflransfereePismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date Docket No.pr Remand Misc.
i i J I — Jefeolsy D	XYZ-14 |[Christaine Schuber, et al. v. The E.D.Pa. |83-1606— !
Boeing Company
XYZ-15 |Brenda Helen Raymond v. The Boeing E.D.Pa. [83-1850 HOA
Company ce 2d
P30 L6L
XYZ-16 [Joan Doris Porter v. The Boeing Co. E.D.Pa. {83-1851	— NR I~	Go 208 A
XYZ-17 | Peter George Kibblewhite v. The E.D.Pa. {83-1852 /o30-860
Boeing Company C FER
XYZ-18 | Frank Bertram Coombs, et al. v. The E.D.Pa. [83-1853 /-52 LI SeadooBoeing Company res bg
XYZ-19 | Susan Laura Shiers v. The Boeing Co. E.D.Pa.|83~1854 Vi 30 bile tpi	’ - os da
XYZ-20 | Ronald Gordon Green v. The Boeing Co. |E.D.Pa.|83-1855 “30 74) DETTE	FANGEL EEL - oH Wh 4
<. ENA :
XYZ~-21 | Otto Schindler, et al. v. The Boeing E.D.Pa.|83-1856 PRPS 82Company fos d dui iesaee
: (EAN 2 b 5
XYZ-22 | Peter Harold Ridgewell, et al. v. The |E.D.Pa.|83-1857 J 38 (ofBoeing Company S30 RA LAT 4
XYZ-23 | Karen Hazell, et al. v. The Boeing Co.}E.D.Pa. {83-1858 fo ID EGY ion au
. Vos FD
XYZ-24 | Anne Marie Bloch, et al. v. The Boeing| E.D.Pa.|83-198%.-- | 2losy =
: Company i
XYZ-25 | Henry Boulay, et al. v. The Boeing E.D.Pa.|83-1982 dohofez Dd
Company
| TLS
XYZ-26 | Sylvain Biret, et al. v. The Boeing E.D.Pa.| 83-1983 SEE 12[20]82 1
Company
. /2 o[g2D	XYZ-27 | Jacqueline Regnaud v. The Boeing Co. E.D.Pa.| 83-1984 =) 2f & >
XYZ-28 | Jean Eugene Combaz, et al. v. The E.D.Pa.| 83-1985 1224/8 3Boeing Company
XYZ%-29 | Pierre Audraine, et al. v. The Boeing | E.D.Pa.| 83-1986 {2[20[g2D	Company !

BMI cas AN 685 Document1 Filed 06/02/15 Page, 7 of 12 |J FORM 1 eddiek Listing of Involved Actions -- pJ
DOCKET NO. 555 =-- _In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, on September 11, 1982
EE	—
Intra-— Distric Civil : Date of
Office and Action TransferfTransfereePismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date Docket No.pr Remand Misc.
. . 12/5 olesXYZ-30 |Pierre Salsou, et al. v. The Boeing E.D.Pa.| 83-1987
Company
XYZ-31 | Paul Lopez, et al. v. The Boeing Co. E.D.Pa.| 83-1988 12): 0)8%
XYZ-32 |Paul Gajda, et al. v. The Boeing Co. E.D.Pa.| 83-1989 12[20122D	. §
XY%Z-33 |.Joseph Sassy, et al. v. The Boeing Co.|E.D.Pa.| 83-1990 a Ah
XY%Z-34 {Joseph Crimi, et al. v. The Boeing Co.|E.D.Pa.| 83-1991 12 foo
XYZ-35 | Jules Benvenutti, et al. v. The Boeing|E.D.Pa.| 83-1992 bo faite
Company pRFEG
XYZ-36 |Mariano Comitogianni, et al. v. The E.D.Pa.| 83-1993 1220 £5
Boeing Company
XYZ-37 |Michel Pierret, et al. v. The Boeing [|E.D.Pa.| 83-1994 /-30-¥& = .
Company TPE $2
XY7%-38 | Clement Maistre, et al. v. The Boeing |E.D.Pa.| 83-1995 10/0
Company
XYZ-39 |Jean Saget, et al. v. The Boeing Co. E.D.Pa.| 83-1996 r2fr0 Gl
XYZ%-40 | Philippe Capdevielle v. The Boeing Co.|E.D.Pa.| 83-1997 fle sed
I
XYZ-41 | Victor Stoka, et al. v. The Boeing Co.|E.D.Pa.| 83-1998 12 20/62
XYZ-42 |Magdeline Prette Hellou v. The Boeing |E.D.Pa. 83-1999 j2[e0/93)
Company
XYZ-43 | Kathryn Suzanne Hudson v. The Boeing E.D.Pa.| 83-3163} - —%) cb
Company | / 30 5 [PIETY SRE
© XYZ-44 Alice E. devault v. The Boeing Co. E.D.Pa.| 83-4831 -|-- - 30 6 CF PSE
1754 > 72/45 y=, 2% SBA pool 73

BMT Ca Document1 Filed 06/02/15 Page 8 of 12
J FORM 1 == Colleinllaeion Listing of Involved Actions =-- p-
DOCKET NO. 555 ha In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim,	Cermany,—oh-September—11	1982
reer	r— ey
Intra- Distric Civil : Date of
Office] ~ and Action TransferflransfereePismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Remand Misc.
B-45 Leo Schoenborn, et al. v. The Bgeing W.D.Micl G84-810-CA [}- Sg ys 9</ /- 30 gels}, > of J -
Company 4 Lod ls Spgs Milesy S19 |[[<30 5k
B-46 Fritz Ruchti, et al. v. The Boeing .D.Ark.| 84-5134 10/i5 [84 §9-5" 79 pO
Co. 9/218 aters gy-S193 |/-30 5Gh.
} 16/15 [85 \C-20	B-47 Karl-Heinz Aulenbacher, et al. v. .D. Ark} 84-5135
The Boeing Co. 9/2 &Y aters
a - lol } ooo ASE dL
ro)i5	85 |3Y-5192 [730 EC peB-48 Georg Trumpfheller, et al. v. The .D. Ark} 84-5136 {ACI !
Boeing Co. 9/=27/8% aters S19) |, -z0-564 |
| ofises 99-511) (1-50-86 LC
B-49 Horst Exle -v. The Boeing Co-q/ 7/9Y .D. Ark|84-5137 : EE CRA|	: 2 aters
B-50 Harry Gern, et al. v. The Boeing Co. .D.Ark.} 84-5138 j0fis|4 y EAT OS “i27/5 aters
5/8 ~30 fp
B-51 Werner Dingert, et al. v. The Boejn .D.Ark.| 84-5139 10)i5/5% 34 7 | T oo Pao
Co. 275 aters FERENCE
34-S|96 | /-32-f@ , _.
B-52 Ranier Berkenfeld, et al. v. The .D.Ark.| 84-5140 10]i5/8% IN py
Boeing Co. q, 27/8% aters rood
7 30 F610
xyz=53 Dr. Ernst Schaaf, et al. v. The Boeing Co. E.D.Pa. [84-3959 )i
XYZ-54 Iris Tusche, etc. v. The Boeing Co. E.D.Pa. [84-4313 ECR ENT
hg Ko x AQ va AY 6

1 Case MDL No. 555 Document 1 Filed 06/02/15 Page 9 of 12 :	BMI. FORM - i i . . , .
J Continuation e Listing of Involved Actions -- NEDOCKET NO. 558 -— In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, on September 11, 1982
Intra- Distric Civil : Date of
Office and Action TransferflransfereepPismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Remand Misc.
B-55 Iris Elke Inge Tusche, et al. v. .D.Cal c84-6164-mrp 8/5” gS -1S7¢ KIC piThe Boeing Co. ARE batel 2 ye
iy /755 — 72; ZI XY) py» »
; ” Cl } Co ~
Se : or [as * . ; . . ae
¥ . - Ne
| | |

JPML Form 4
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 555 =-- In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany,
on September 11, 1982
BIRGIT BROCK, ET AL. (A-1)
KARIN TRUMPFHELLER, ET AL. (A-3) THE BOEING CO.
Thomas G. Smith, Esquire a 14Sterns, Smith, Elstead & Walker Barry J. Relngol.d, Esq.
490 Paeifie Avenue 80 Ujah Street Perkins, Coie, Stone, Olsen	: : : & Williams
San Francisco, California 94133 1110 Vermont Avenue, N.W.
Suite 1200
URSULA J. SCHOENBORN (A-2) Washington, D. C. 20005
James J. McCarthy, Esquire
1801 Avenue of the Stars; ee
Suite 810
Los Angeles, California 90067
LEO SCHOENBORN, ET AL. (B-45)
valarie Hurley Twanmoh, Esquire
Cholette, Perkins & Buchanan
600 01d Kent Bank Bldg,
Grand Rapids, Michigan 49503
FRITZ RUCHTI, ET AL. (B-46)
KARL-HEINZ AULENBACHER, ET AL. (B-47)
GEORG TRUMPFHELLER, ET AL. (B-48)
HORST EXLE (B-49)
HARRY GERN (B-50)
WERNER DINGERT, ET AL. (B-51)
RANIER	BERKENFELD,	ET AL. (B52)
Boyce R. Davis, Esquire
P.O. Box I
Lincoln, Arkansas 72744
IRIS ELKE INGE TUSCHE, ET AL. (B=55)
Gerajpd C. Sterns, Esquire
Thorfas G. Smith, Esquire
Law| Gq a A) —/	St A, pmi Wa
4 Utah Street
‘an Francisco, California 94103

JPML Form 4 :
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST |
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. _555-- _ In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, on
eptember 1 1982
NOTICE OF OPPOSITION
LEQ SCHOENBORN, ET Al. (B45)
valerie Hurley Twanmoh, Esq.
Cholette, Perkins & Buchanan
600 01d Kent Bank Bldg.
Grand Rapids, Michigan 49503

. JPML FORM 3 :
: p. _L
COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST =-- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 555 -- In re Air Crash Disaster at Mannheim, Germany, on Sept. 11, 1982
Name of Part Named as Party ip Following, Aftions ee
AI, A-2, 3-3 Z 5 \oo EE
The Boeing Company -
=
a.