IN RE: Shopping Carts Antitrust Litigation

1:80-F-00451JpmlMay 19, 2015

Full text

JPMI, FORM 1A
DOCKET ENTRIES
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDIZTRICT LITIGATION
SOOKET MO. 451 -- In re Shopping Carts Antitrust Litigation =
| | |
80/12/08 1 | MOTION, BRIEF, SCHEDULE, CERT. OF SVC.; ! of Certain Plaintiffs.
| | Suggested Transferee District: S.D.N.Y. & N.D. Illinois
| | Suggested Transferee Judge: } (ds)	80/12/19 2 RESPONSE /MEMORANDUM -- p1tT. (A-29) Giant Eagle Markets,
3 Inc. w/cert. of svc. (ds)
80/12/14 APPEARANCES -- Raymond P. Hernacki for Raley's:
| J. Garett Kendrick for Arden-Mayfair, Inc., et al.:Josef D. Cooper, Esq. for Safeway Stores, Inc.:;
| | Francis O. Scarpulla for Busy Boy Markets, Inc., et al.;	| James B. Sloan, Esq. for Plesing Super Mart, Inc.;
Lowell E. Sachnoff, Esg. for Penny's Supermarkets, Inc.;
| James S. Gordon, Esq. for Buy Low, Inc., et al.;; | Robert D. Puul, Esq. for The Stop and Shop Co., Inc., et
i | al.; Harold Brown, Esq. for Great Scott Food Markets,	Inc.; David J. Bershad, Esq. for Resjefal Corp.:
Ira Postel, Esq. for Toy R Us, Inc.; Jerry S. Cohen, Esq.
[ for Chatham Supermarkets; Stephen P. Hoffman, Esq. for
Alexanders Markets, Inc.; Robert N. Kaplan, Esq. for
! Eastside Foods Inc.; Arthur N. Abbey, Esq. for Pik N Pak;
] Howard B. Weinreich, Esq. for Shopwell, Inc.;
David Jaroslawicz, Esq. for Lomark Discount Drugs, Inc.;' o
| Allen D. Black, Esq. for Martin Perlov, et al.:;
i | Ronald Litowitz for Pick Quick Foods, Inc.;
| | Stanley L. Kaufman, Esq. for PSK Food Corp, et al.;
Henry A. Brachtl, Esq. for Zayre Corp.; Bernard M. Gross
| for C.E.S. Operating Co., Inc., et al.;Seymour Kurlang, Esq. for Davisville Center, Inc., et al.;
Bernard D. Marcus, Esq. for Giant Eagle Markets, Inc.;
! { Stephen D. Susman for Schepps Grocery Company;
: "| Douglas V. Rigler, Esq. for Godfrey Company;Gary Senner
| for Unarco Industries; Albert M. Appel, Esq. for
: Roblin Industries, Inc.; J. Edd Stepp, Jr. for Gleason
| Corp., et al.; David S. Acker, Esq. for Tote-Cart Co.,
Inc. (ds) :
80/12/18 3 RESPONSE/MEMORANDUM AND EXHIBITS ONE THRU $ --
pltf. (A-5) Busy Boy Markets, Inc., etal w/cert. of svc.(ds
80/12/89 g MOTION, BRIEF, Cert. of Svc. for transfer of 34 related	¢ actions to the Northern District of Illinois. Schdule A
| included. (Motion encompasses same actions as pleading
: No. 1) -- BUY-LOW, ET AL. (No additional notice
; being mailed to counsel). (rew)
BO/12/22 5 ESPONSE -- ZAYRE CORP. w/MEMO. AND CERT. OF SVC.
80/12/22 APPEARANCE -- Lawrence H. Eiger, Esq. for Mechanical (rew)
| | Rubber & Supply, Inc. (rew)i
H
451
80/12/22 6 RESPONSE /MEMORANDUM -- Safeway Stores, Inc. -- w/cert.
of service. (emh)
80/12/22 7 RESPONSE /MEMORANDUM -- Roblin Indusries, Unarco, Ind.,
Gleason Corp., Technibilt, and Tote-Cart Co. w/cert
of Svc. (rew)
80/12/30 8 REBLY ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF'S EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE AND ALL
PLAINTIFF'S IN A-1 thru A-3, A-5 thru A-10, A-13 thru
A-26 and A-28 thru A-30 w/cert. of sve. (ds)+
81/01/02 9 REPLY -- pltf. (A-4) Safeway Stores, Inc. w/cert. of
svc. (ds) : ]
81/01/02 10 REPLY -- defendants w/cert. of sve. (ds)-
81/01/12 11 MOTION, BRIEF, EXHIBITS A and B -- Named Defendants -- wn PE
: (A-35) —- w/cert. of service (cds)
81/01/16 12 RESPONSE -- Plaintiff Sam Dunlap, et al. -- w/brief and
cert. of service (cds)
81/01/26 PANEL HEARING: Setting Motion to Transfer for Panel
Hearing on February 26, 1981 in San Antonio, Texas (cds)
81/02/03 13 ~ REPLY/MEMORANDUM -- Defts. Roblin Industries, Inc.,
Unarco Industries, Inc., Gleason Corp., Technibilt Corp.,
Tote-Cart Co. -- w/cert. of svc. (emh)
81/02/09 14 LETTER -- Behalf of Defendants signed by Albert Appel —-
w/sve. (emh)
81/02/18 15 LETTER -- signed by Francis 0. Scarpulla -- w/copy of
an order remanding A-5 Busy Boy Markets v. Roblin
Industries, N.D.Calif., 80-4140 to Superior Court (emh)
81/02/24 HEARING APPEARANCES -- Lowell E. Sachnoff, Esq. for Plaintiffs’
Executive Committee, Marvin J. Rosenblum, Esq. for Buy Low
" Inc., et al., Albert M. Appel, Esq. for Roblin Industries,
Inc., J. Edd Stepp, Jr., Esq. for Gleason Corp. and Technibilt
Corp., David S. Acker, Esq. for Tote Cart Co., Inc.,
Gary Senner, Esq. for Unarco Industries, Inc., Bernard	M.
. Gross, Esq. for CES Operating Co. T/A Great Scott Markets,
Judah I. Labovitz, Esq. for Plaintiffs' Executive Committee,
Douglas V. Rigler, Esq. for Godfrey Co., Bernard D. Marcus,
Esq. for Giant Eagle Markets, Inc., I.Walton Bader, Esq.
for Sam Dunlap (ds)
RXXRZAIE
: , pe. 3
INL FORM OIA
DOCKET ENTRIES
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
socveT so. 451 -— In re Shopping Carts Antitrust Litigation =
81/04/07, | CONSENT OF TRANSFEREE COURT for assignment of litigationto the Honorable Charles L. Brieant, S. D. New York (emh)
81/04/07 TRANSFER ORDER -- transferring A-1 thru A-4, A-©6 thru
| A-13, A-29 thru A-34 to the S.D. New York pursuant to
| 28 U.S.C. §1407. Order also DEFERRED transfer of
! A-35 Dunlap, et al. v. Roblin Industries, Inc., et al.,
| | N.D. Miss., C.A. No. EC80-340-WK-P, until the motion
| to remand this action to Mississippi state court isresolved. (emh)
81/04/20] CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY --B-36 The Fed-Mart Corp. v. Roblin Industries, Inc., et ; .
al., S.D. Calif., C.A.No. 81-0169-E(H)
| { NOTIFIED INVOLVED COUNSEL AND JUDGES. (emh)
81/05/04 | | CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY —-—- B-38 Hartfield- en
| zodys, Inc. v. llnarco Industries, Inc., et al., C.D. '
California, C.A. No. 81-1698-AAH(Xx). Notified involved .
i counsel and judges. (ds) a
81/05/06 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- B-36 The Fed-Mart
; Corp. v. Roblin Industries Inc., et al., S.D. California, :
| C.A. No. 81-0169-E(H). Notified-invoitved counsel and
| judges~—-{ds}- Notified involved clerks and judges (ds)
81/05/12 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY -- B-39 Albertson's,
Inc., et al. v. Technibilt Corp., et al., D. Utah, C.A.
| No. C81-0239W -- NOTIFIED INVOLVED JUDGES AND COUNSEL cds81/05/20 | CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY —-- B-38 Hartfield-
! Zodys, Inc. v. Unarco Industries, Inc., et al., C.D.
| California, C.A. No. 81-1698-AAH(Xx). Notified involved
clerks and judges. (ds)
81/05/28 (coNDTTIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- B-39 Albertson's, ,	! Inc., et al. v. Technibilt Corp., et al., D. Utah, C.A.
| No. C81-0239W. Notified involved clerks and judges. (ds)81/06/03 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY -- B-40 Mayfair
| Super Markets, Inc. v. Unarco Industries, Inc., et al.,
! D. New Jersey, C.A. No. 81-940. Notified involved-Exx
| counsel and judges. (dsY=948s==Neottfted=invoived=e-
T | 81/06/19 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- B-40 Mayfair
; Super Markets, Inc. v. Unarco Industries, Inc., etal.,
| D.N.Y., C.A.No. 81-940. Notified involved clerks
| & judges. (eaf)
\ |
|
;
!
|
| ||
JPML, FORM 1A
DOCKET ENTRIES
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDIsURICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 451 -- In re Shopping Carts Antitrust Litigation ==
| bate (Retr. | Pleading Description
— a mr LL em nr ————
81/07/23 | CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY -- C-43 First Nat'l :	i Supermarkets, Inc. v. Roblin Industries, Inc., etal.,
i ! N.D.Ohio, C.A.No. C81-1324 -- Notified involved counsel
and judges
81/07/30 cos RANSFHR ORDER FILED TODAY —- C—44 Dayton: Hudson Corp., etal. v. Roblin Ind., Inc., etal., D.Minn.
| 3-81-401 ~- Notified involved counsel and judges. (eaf)81/08/10! | CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- C-43 First
| ! National Supermarkets, Inc. v. Roblin Industries, et al.,
| : N.D.Ohio, C.A. No. C81-1324 -- Notified involved judges
| and clerks (cds)
) 81/08/17, CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- C-44 Dayton
Hudson Corp., et al. v. Roblin Ind., Inc., et al.,
; D. Minn., 3-81-401 -- NOTIFIED INVOLVED JUDGES & CLERKS
| |
81/09/4 | |ORDER DENYING TRANSFER OF A-35 Dunlap, et al., v. Roblini : Industries, Inc., et al., N.D. Mississippi, C.A. No.
EC 80-340-WK-P. Notified involved judges, clerks and
| counsel. (ds)
82/03/05) CONDITIONAL TRANSFER FILED TODAY — D-46 Certified Grocers
| of Ill., Inc. v. Roblin Industries, Inc., etal., N.D.Ill.	C.A. No. 82-C-0945 -- Notified involved counsel and
| judges. (eaf):
82/03/23 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- D-46 Certified
i Grocers of Ill., Inc. v. Roblin Industries, Inc., et al.,
: N.D.Il1l., C.A.No. 82-C-0945. Notified involved clerks
! | & judges. (eaf)
| |{
|
i }
| | |
]
!
|
Lo
:
JPMIL: Form 1
Ll .
Revised: 8/78
DOCKET NO. 451 —- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
CAPTION: IN RE SHOPPING CARTS ANTITRUST LITIGATION
I —
ttt	i SE EC ——— —————————— EEE E————————————SSS
p
SUMMARY OF LITIGATION :
2/26/81 :
N + | Dates Filed Type Citation District Name of Judge . Assigned From
. 4/7/81 TO Urs cet S.D. N.Y. Hon. Charles L. Brieant
Special Transferee Information
9 iS RET
‘/ XIE Cd DATE CLOSED: 7 208
pee Teil to Aeicomns) p
CC 2-024
21-27
fo PA ER
JPML FORM 1 | LISTING OF INVOLVED ACTIONS
DOCKET NO. 451 —-- In re Shopping Carts Antitrust Litigation
—_— ee	——
cata Pistrict Civi rans feregpate of
Number Capt i an Action ransfer| Docket [Dismissal
| Caption Judge Numbex Date Number jr Remand Misc.
Ap : ye PRI
A-1 Joseph B. Goldberg, etc. v. Roblin c.D.cal 80-4085 ARR vi od} 5 Sen Be
Industries, Inc., et al. Williamg
A-2 Raley's v. Roblin Industries, Inc., Cc.D.Cal 80-4083 APR " 1981 5/9 oho d >
et al. Tashima
LJ) ry \ In ¥ 2 py ;
A=3 Arden-Mayfair Inc., et al. v. c.D.cal 80-4993 APR T1815 207 | EMC
Technibilt Corp., et al. Tashima —
P 0 4 - /s Z >A-4 Safeway Stores v. Roblin Industries, |N.D.Cal 80-4077 APR 7 wh 57-02 || 220%Inc., et al. Schwarzer
A~5 Busy Boy Markets, Inc., ®f al. v. ~D.Cal 80434014. Tit rat
Roblin Industries, Inc., et ats bya g <-oo R ty / SF co
A-6 The Food Seller, Inc., v. Roblin N.D.I1l 80-4984 FR 71981 8 40> fT eyIndustries, Inc., et al. Crowley
, , NER INIA-7 Mechanical Rubber & Supply Inc. N.D.I1l] 80-4986 |APR 7 1881 5/-0	fe [fo
| v. Roblin Industries, Inc., et al. Crowley |. 0 ITY ars 50 Fey
2 A~8 Plesing Super Mart, Inc. v. Roblin N.D.T11] 80-5002 APR 71981 5-2/7 0
- Industries, Inc., et al. Crowley ||
- IPS | YEW VASA!
A-9 Penny's Supermarkets, Inc. V. N.D.I11] 80-5054 #PR 7 1981 5/-¢ 21% ols 0)Unarco Industries, Inc,, et al. Crowley
A=-10 Les On Retail Systems, Inc. Vv. N.D.I1ll 80-5072 PR 8 1981 5-279 10/3 oles) .Roblin Industries, Inc., et al. Crowley
BMI Ca DL 4 Document 1 Filed 05/19/15 Page 7 of 16
wr J FORM 1 Eol{tinligeisn Listing of Involved Actions -- p.2
DOCKET No. _451 -—- In re Shopping Carts Antitrust Litigation
ee ——————— rrr ———
Intra-| . District Civil ‘ Date of
Office} and Action TransferffransfereepPpismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date Pocket No.pr Remand Misc.
t- “ {)
A-11 Buy Low, Inc., et al. v. Roblin N.D.I1ll.] 80-4958 APR 7 198 5/-A2272 J/ /8 8
Industries, Inc., et al. Crowley oo,
i. . fo 7,
A-12 |The Stop & Shop Co., Inc., et al. D.Mass. | 80-2203APR 7 1981 g)-222) | [OTE
v. Roblin Industries, Inc., et al. Mazzone
[oo
A-13 |Great Scott Food Markets v. Unarco D.Mass. | 80-2415-APf 7 1981 $7 ARB ipf30/88. Industries, Inc., et al. Garrity
_A-14 Resjefal Corp. Vv. Unarco Industries, S.D.N.Y.| 82-5076 wefsolselInc., et al. Duffy TR
Soden es p
A-15 |Toys "R" Us, Inc., v. Roblin S.D.N.Y.| 80-5092 per tans
Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy
sels -A-16 Chatham Supermarkets, Inc. v. Roblin S.D.N.Y.] 80-5103
Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy
A-17 |Alexanders Markets, Inc. v. Roblin S.D.N.Y.| 80-5108 pels
Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy
A-18 Eastside Foods, Inc. v. Roblin S.D.N.Y.{: 80-5140 0200560)
Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy
. . I. NE : -
A-19 Pik N Pak v. Roblin Industries, Inc., |S.D.N.Y.} 80-5181 po /500
et al. Duffy
B . fee ~~
A-20 |Win-Holt Equipment Corp. Vv. Roblin S.D.N.Y.| 80-5258 yof20/8
Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy
A-21 Murray's of Baderwood, Inc. v. Roblin (S.D.N.Y.| 80-5259 Jol3/55Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy
i
i
Case MDL No. 451 Document 1 Filed 05/19/15 Page 8 of 16
JBEML FORM 1 -- Continuation e Ca , 3
Listing of Involved Actions -- p.
DOCKET NO. 5] -
Intra- Distric Civil : Date of
Office and Action TransferflransfereepPismissal
Number: Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Remand Misc.
: 0/30 SO	A-22 Shopwell, Inc. v. Roblin Industries, S.D.N.Y 80-5253 as
Inc., et al. Duffy
ols JES >
A-23 Lomark Discount Drugs, Inc. Vv. S.D.N.Y 80-5269 RE
Unarco Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy
A-24 | Martin Perlov, et al. v. Roblin S.D.N.Y}, 80-5260 plz O :
Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy }
A-25 | Pick Quick Foods, Inc. v. Roblin S.D.N.Y} 80-5334 0 fof ’
Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy :
A-26 PSK Food Corp., et al. v. Roblin S.D.N.Y. 80-5445 0305)Industries, Inc., et al. Duffy
A-27 Zayre Corporation v. Roblin S.D.N.Yl 80-5737 \&/ IVYIndustries, Inc., et al. Connor a reviled
A-28 CES Operating Co. t/a Great Scott S.D.N.Yl 80-6088 olor 1.Markets v. Roblin Industries, Inc., Duffy Be fois£2 a
et al.
A-29 Giant Markets, Inc., v. Roblin E.D.Pa.| 80-3491 #R 5 gy 5/225 Joliofss pIndustries, Inc.,.	et al. Fullam » ; ;
. . /5 ia )
A-30 Davisville Center, Inc., et al. v. E.D.Pa. 80-3526 ARR 71981 §/ 2°22¥ 12:%¢ i
Roblin Industries, Inc., et al. | Fullam
A-31 Giant Eagle Markets v. Roblin W.D.Pa. 80-1472fipR 7 5) 523 << Thole DIndustries, Inc. Rosenberg 198 tt
A-32 Schepps Grocery Company v. Roblin s.D.Texl. H-80-209AFR 7 1881 §/-22° jofsefssidIndustries, Inc., et al. Bue
| | | |	: I i
Case MDL No. 451 Document 1 Filed 05/19/15 Page 9 of 16 -
JBML FORM 1 -- Continuation e Ces . 4
Listing of Involved Actions -- p.
DOCKET NO. 451 -- In re Shopping Carts Antitrust Litigation | |
. RK ‘
Intra- Distric Civil : Date of
Office and Action TransferflransfereepPismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Remand] Misc.
A-33 Char-Pac, Inc., d/b/a/ Foodland v. S.D.Tex] H-80-210APRK 71981 sade gov
Roblin Industries, Inc., et al. Singletdn
- or Fe” / 3 7 ty 5 i 5
A-34 | Godfrey Co., v. Roblin Industries, E.D.Wis 80-979 ARR VIR TIVA] IE
Inc., et al. Evans
Va . toed
A-35 Sam Dunlap, et al. v. Roblin In- N.D.Missl. EC 7340, | 07 } ya ’
dustries, Inc., et al. rant gh Ae (Q - YE	gs Ly
| | lg -a9eq |Ael 0
B-36 | The Fed-Mart Corp. v. Roblin Industriep S.D.Ca 81-0169-E (15 4/5] i
Inc., et al. 4/R¢/a/ Enright
. 4 / J
XYz-37 The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co.,|S.D.N.Y| 81 Civ 465[t 70h un
Inc. v. Unarco Industries, Inc., ’
et al. ' ;
B-38 Hartfield-Zodys, Inc. Vv. Unarco C.D.Cal]| 81-1698-AA IP E- of 5047
Industries, Inc., et Re Hauk S51 h wT i ~» ele lr ese TRIED] |
B-39 Albertson's, Inc., et al. v. TechnibilyD.Utah C81-0239W [R38 §/ 51-3560 4Corp., et al. ERY Winder
B-40 [Mayfair Super Markets, Inc. v. Unarco |D.N.J. 81-940 w)ii/sl mooTyL 7 fosIndustries, Inc., et al. G35 Biunno Fs sl)
Lpetcr SI 2 av ic XY> 5 5 “z (A Prats cel Lio 0 Linepaved	; » Los 0
Xyz-41 The Kroger Co., et al. v. Roblin 5.D.N.Y.|81 Civ 3628] * « 7/2457Industries, Inc., et al. |
: : \ 2 hola,XYZ-42 Food Fair, Inc., et al. v. Roblin .D.N.Y.|81 civ 2673 LYIETD
Industries, Inc. iy
Cc-43 First National Supermarkets, Inc. v. N.D.Ohip C81-1324 shif gi § lee se 2057Roblin Industries, Inc., et al. Contie
Sz Lr)
;
oo Ns E |
Case M L451 Document 1 Filed 05/19/15 Page 10 of 16
JEML FORM 1 EM Eira eish { Listing of Involved Actions == p.5
DOCKET NO. ¥571 -—
UU
Intra- . Distric Civil : Date of {|
office and Action TransferfTransfereepPismissal
Numbex Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Bemand Misc.
Cc-44 Dayton Hudson Corp., et al. v. Roblin |D. Minn. 3-81-401 Tix Ri=3A397 |Z, 29/¢ L)
Industries, Inc., et al. ) Renner	Jug @
<< nf205 13}XYZ-45 F. W. Woolworth Co. v. Roblin S.D.N.Y,81 civ 5527
Industries, Inc., et al.
D-46 Certified Grocers of Illinois Inc. v.|{N.D.,Il11l} 82~C-0945 5/33/3 fa-190 hols ®	i ’ Roblin Industries, Inc., et al. Kocoras AR
MAR 5 1962 >»	. P 5 ; J spp # y PR 7 ) Py - ya
t re y J o 2 psy 7K] / [ X v2, / V4 BV ) A yy Ve 7 .
po ley THD A ae	J Forty
XYZ-47 Pickwell Fine Foods Supermarkets, INC}S.D.N.Y {80-5270 rome ummmsop mmm sms 013, 5S
v. Roblin Ind., Inc., et al. ’
an A So i Lr
HH2C / THO | ad / Se NS SO IRS = i ;
XY7Z-48 Federated Department Stores, Inc. v. (S.D.N.YJ8l Civ. 3223 /, ololyUnarco / . > .
£5 7 3 J ed ~ rd
} / /4g gA = / X ¥ 2 =? Sai 7 Ve r= piI"
A | 4 J es’ 4
J 2 74
JPML Form 4
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 451 -- In re Shopping Carts Antitrust Titigation =
SS
J. Briént Pretrial Order No. 1 filed 7/¢/81
LIAISON COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFFS LIATSON COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANTS
Judah I. Labovitz, Esquire Albert M. Appel, Esquire
Pomerantz, Levy, Haudek & Block Webster & Sheffield
295 Madison Avenue 1 Rockefeller Plaza
New York, New York 10168 New York, New York 10020
Robert A. Skirnick, Esquire
Wolf, Popper, Ross, Wolf & Jones
845 Third Avenue
New York, New York 10022
Henry A. Brachtl, Esquire
Lowey, Dannenberg & Knapp, P.C.
747 Third Avenue
New York, New York 10017
PLAINTIFFS COMMITTEE PLAINTIFFS COMMITTEE (Continued)
Seymour Kurland, Esquire Jerry S. Cohen, Esquire
Wolf, Block, Schorr & Solis-Cohen Kohn, Milstein & Cohen
Twelfth Floor Packard Building 1776 K Street, N.W.
Philadelphia, Pa. 19102 washington, D. C. 20006
Stephen D. Susman, Esquire H. Laddie Montague, Esquire
Susman & McGowan Berger & Montague
806 Main Street 1622 Locust Street
21st Floor Philadelphia, Pa. 19103
Houston, Texas 77002
Lowell E. Sachnoff, Esquire Joel C. Meredith, Esquire
Sachnoff, Schrager, Jones, Meredith & Cohen
Weaver & Rubenstein 1405 locust Street
One IBM Plaza, Suite 4700 Philadelphia, Pa.
Chicago, Illinois 60611
T.eonard Barrack, Esquire
Barrack, Rodos & McMahon
2000 Market Street
philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103
JPML, Form 4
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. v. In re Shopping Cart Antitrust Litigation )
———————————
JOSEPH B. GOLDBERG, ETC. (A-1) PLESING SUPER MART, INC. (A-8)
Corinblit Shapero & Seltzer James B. Sloan, Esq.
3700 Wilshire Boulevard . Sloan and Connelly, P.C.
Suite 820 (No app. Rec'd) 111 West Washington Street
Los Angeles, California 90010 Chicago, Illinois 60602
RALEY'S (A-2) PENNY 'S SUPERMARKETS, INC. (A-9)
Raymond P. Hernacki, Esq. (Lovell E. Sachnoff, Esq.Brandlin & McAllister Sachnoff, Schrager, Jones, Weaver
10960 Wilshire Blvd., Ste. 2220 & Rubenstein, Ltd. \
Los Angeles, Califwrnia 90024 One IBM Plaza, Suite 4700
Chicago, Illinois 60611
ARDEN-MAYFAIR INC,, ET AL. (A-3)
J. Garrett Kendrick, Esq. LES ON RETAIL SYSTEMS, INC. (A-10)
Kendrick, Netter & Bennett |Leonard Barrack, Esq. -
612 South Flower Street, Ste. 600 X Barrack, Rodos & McMahon (No app. rec'd)
Los Angeles, California 90017 2000 Market Street oo
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103%
SAFEWAY STORES (A-4)
Josef D. Cooper, Esd. BUY LOW, INC., ET AL. (A-11)
Suite 600 James S. Gordon, Esd.
300 Montgomery Street 140 South Dearborn Street
San Francisco, California 94104 Suite 404
Chrieage:, “Flo iam.60603
BUSY BOY MARKETS, INC., ET AL. (A=5)
Francis ©. Scarpulla, Esq. THE STOP & SHIO CO., INC, ET AL..(A-12)
Scarpulla & Garlock Robert D. Paul, Esdg.
| 601 Montgomery Street Goodwin, Procter & Hoar
| Nineteenth Floor 28 State Street
San Francisco, California 94111 Boston, Massachusetts 02109
THE FOOD SELLER, INC. (A-6) REAT SCOTT FOOD MARKETS (A-13)Perry Goldberg, Esq. Harold Brown, Esq.
Specks & Goldberg, Ltd. Brown, Prifti, Leighton & Cohen
180 North LaSalle Street 66 Long Wharf
Suite 2316 (No app. Rec'd) Boston, Massachusetta 02110
Chicago, Illinois 60601
MEEHANICAL RUBBER & SUPPLY INC. {A-7)
Lawrence H. Eiger, Esq.
Much, Shelist, Freed, Denenberg, Ament
& Eiger, P.C.
135 South LaSalle Street, Ste. 2323
Chicago, Illinois 60603
(No. app. rec'd)
JPML: FORM 4A -- Continuation
Panel Attorney Service List -- p. ol)
DOCKET NO. 457 - -—
RESJEFAL CORP. (A-14) SHOPWELL, INC. (A-22) 7
David J. Bershad, Esq. Howard B. Weinreich, Esq.
Milberg, Weiss, Bershad & Specthrie Rosengarten & Weinreich
1 Pennsylvania Plaza « : 400 Walnut Avenue
New York, New York 10119 Bronx, New York 10454
BOYS "R" US, INC. (A-15) LOMARK DISCOUNT DRUGS, INC. (A-23)
Ira Postel, Esq. David Jaroslawicz, Esq.
Shea & Gould 2 Lafayette Street
330 Msdison Ave. New York, New York 10007
New York, New York 10017
MARTIN PERLOV, ET AL. (A-24)
CHATHAM SUPERMARKETS, INC. (A-16) Allen D. Black, -Esqg.
AKJerry S. Cohén, 'Esg.” Fine, Kaplan and Black
Kohn, Milstein & Cohen 1845 Walnut Street
1776 K Street, N.W. i 23rd Floor
Washington, D.C. 20006 | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103>
ALEXANDERS MARKETS, INC. (A-17) PICK QUICK FOODS, INC. (A-25)
Stephen P. Hoffman, Esq. Ronald Litowitz, Esq.
Pomerantz, Levy, Haudek & Block Kreindler & Kreindler
__ 295 Madison Avenue | 99 park Avenue
New York, New York 10017 | New York, New York 40016
EASTSIDE FOODS, INC. (A-18) | DSK FOOD CORP.,	ET AL. (A-26)
Robert N. Kaplan, Esq. Stanley L. Kaufman, Esq.
--Kkaplan, Kilsheimer & Fley 475 Park Avenue.South
122 E. 42nd St. : New York, New York 10016
New York, New York 10168 id °
ZAYRE CORPORATION (A-27)
PAIK N PAK (A-19) Henry A. Brachtl, Esq.
Arthur N. Abbey, Esq. Lowey, Dannenberg. & Knapp, P.C.
212 East 39th Street 747 Third Avenue
New York, New York 10016 New York, New York 10017
WIN-HOLT EQUIPMENT COPR. (A-20) CES OPERATING CO. t/a GKEAT SCOTT
Joseph A. .Ruskay, Esq. MARKETS (A-28)
4 Godfrey Lane Bernard M. Gross, Esq.
Westport, Conn. "06880. Gross & Skiar, P.C.
(SEE A-21 FOR ADDRESS)
MURRAY'S OF BADERWOOD, INC. (A-21) ~
Bernard Gross, Esq.
Gross and Sklar, P.C. GIANT MARKETS, INC. ( A-29)
v 1630 Locust Street - Ce XH. Laddie Montague, Jr., Esdg.
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103 Berger & Montague, P.C.
1622 Locust Street
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103
|
3 . oo >.
JPML Form 4
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 451 -- In re Shopping Carts Antitrust Litigation
DAVISVILLE CHEN TER, INC., ET AL. (A-30) UNARCO INDUSTRIES Eo
Seymour Kurland, Esq. Gary Senner, Esq.
. Wolf, Block, Schorr & Solis-Cohen Sonnenschein, Carlin, Nath &
< Twelfth Floor Packard Building Rosenthal
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19102 8000 Sears Tower
Chicago, Illinois 60606
GIANT EAGLE MARKETS (A=-31)
Bernard © Marcus, Esq. ROBLIN INDUSTRIES, INC.	itus, Marcus	& Shapira Albert M. Appel, Esq. }
624 Oliver Building Webster	& Sheffield @
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15222 1 Rockefeller Plaza
New York, New York 10020
SCHEPPS GROCERY COMPANY. (A-32)
(Stephen D. Susman, Esq. GLEASON CORPORATION© Susman	& McGowan TECHNIBILT CORPORATION
806 Main Street J. Edd Stepp, Jr., Esq.
21st Floor Gibson, Dunn	& Crutcher
Houston, Texas 77002 515 South Flower Street
Los Angeles, California 90071
CHAR-PAC, INC., d/b/a/ FOODLAND (A-33) -
John Blazier, Esq. TOTE-CART COMPANY, INC.
Blazier & Laney (No app. rec'd) David S. Acker, Esq.
400 American Bank Tower Winston & Strawn
Austin, Texas 78701 One First National Plaza
no Chicago, Illinois 60603
GODFREY CO. (A-34)
Douglas V. Rigler, Esq. THE FED-MART CORPORATION (B-36)
Michael Fischer, Esq. Robert C. Wright, Esquire
Foley, Lardner, Hollabaugh & Jacobs © el ° ght, d
1775 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W. : Sullivan, Jones & Archer
Washington, D.C. 20006 1400 Financial Square
y : . on 600 B Street
SAM DUNLAP, ET AL, (A-35) San Diego, California 92101
, I. Walton Bader, Esd. :
/ Bader	& Bader HARTFIELD-ZODYS, INC. (B-38
J 69 Court Street J. Larson Jaenicke, EsquireWhite Plains, New York 10001 Kaplan, Livingston, Goodwin,
Berkowitz & Selvin
450 South Roxbury Drive
- Beverly Hills, California 90210
JPML, FORM 4A -- Continuation :
Panel Attorney Service List -- p.
| DOCKET No. _451 -—_
RS IRichard W. Glauque, Esq. | Randy Miller Lebedoff, Esq.
~~ Gary F. Bendinger, Esq. 1300 Northwestern Bank Bldg.
/ Giauque, Holbrook, Bendinger & Minneapolis, Minn. 55402
Gurmankin
500 Kearns Building
Salt Lake City, Utah 84101 CERTIFIED GROCERS OF TLL., INC. (D-46)
MAYFAIR SUPER MARKETS, INC. (B-40) Jay A. Cael, Esq.
Jay Je Rice, Esquire » Rudnick & Wolfe	in, Davis wee
485 U.S. Rt. 1 South 30 N. LaSalle Street
Woodbridge, New Jersey 07095 Suite 2800 Co| Chicago, Illinois 60602
PARKER METALS, INC. (deft. in B-40)
parker Metals, Inc. EG) i :
Post Office	®gx 561 / ~ |
Metuchen, New Jersdy - |
GENERAL MERCHANDISE CORP., INC. |
(deft. in B-40) |
General Merchandise Corp., Inc.
130 Marion Avenue i, i
Linden, New Jersey
UNITED STEEL & WIRE CORP., INC.
(deft. in B-40)
United Steel & Wire Corp., Inc.
371 Little Falls Road ID
Cedar Grove, New Jersey
REHRIG INDUSTRIES, INC. (deft. in
B-40)
Rehrig Industries, Inc. .
4010 E. 26th Street =
Los Angeles, California
FIRST NATIONAL SUPERMARKETS, INC.
(c-43)
John D. Leech, Esd.
Calfee, Halter,& Griswold
1800 Central National Bank Bldg.
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
JPML FORM 3
| : Pp. 1
COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 451 -- In re Shopping Carts Antitrust Litigation
Named as Party in Following Actions_
[7 = AZ 8-5 A-0o. 4-7 0-7, 5,10 a~ll___p-/3,
a Lf: 7 - 3, ns
Roblin Industries, Inc. |Foas iia aie IAAL	a	G5"CXS HY pgp	reo
Unarco Industries, Inc. LA, A333 A-3L 35 Ap 77, FE 31,0840 | ’
FRZEL IV.	[AAA	SR AC
EE
EE CA rEWE TAL SSA 28Gleason Corporation 728. 4-33, F-DY A 35 fF 3le ny 4 (2-0
FEEL DY |AA	A A AR
ee	|
P]ATP	AL ITZ IEI0 JT
Technibilt Corporation [yg F33534 | °° 2 ap 37 HI] CPx |
S15, 81,2 RAZA PTT aap
Tote-Cart Company TI a5 dag I 0 zk 37 g2Ef, 01 C75
EA IPR	AAR	AY SRE
rer
% Asfnlew Jhl2ln,/ 7
JAE —
5 — — 1A
Gncvak. PoolrdiffEE——————————
(p —Sad -—
= ~~ J --»-J0 OO	O00]
2 A	—
; —	——————————Cen pe -—
—pYe
ao. ”" 7
[phy FriuliApc —
—

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.