IN RE: Airport Car Rental Antitrust Litigation

1 printed pages contain little extracted OCR body text; searchable legal-body completeness has not been established for those pages.

OCR transcription for search; preserved printed pages are authoritative

JPML FORM 1A

DOCKET NO.

338

DOCKET ENTRIES

JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION

—- IN RE AIRPORT CAR RENTAL ANTITRUST LITIGATION

Date

No.
Code

1/23/78

1

MOTION, BRIEF, SCHEDULE OF CASES, CERT, OF SVC., EXHIBITS -- Plaintiffs:

Budget Rent-A-Car Co. of Florida, Inc.,; Diversified Services, Inc.;

Budget Rent-A-Car of New Orleans, Inc.; Wesbau Corp.; Budget

‘Rent-A-Car of Washington, Inc.; Budget Rent-A-Car of Broward, Inc. ;

BbBUagGEeET RENT-A-CalLl Distributors, Inc.,7 and Buaget Rent-A-Car

of Maryland, Inc. (ea)

SPRANGHHE SUGGESTED TRANSFEREE DISTRICT: N. D. CALIFORNIA

SUGGESTED TRANSFEREE JUDGE: (ea)

2/2/78

RESPONSE -- Budget Rent a Car of Washington-Oregon, Inc., et al.,

w/cert. of svc. (ea)

2/3/78

APPEARANCES -- Alan S. Ward, Esq. for Avis Rent a Car System, Inc.

James.S. Ramsey, Jr., Esq. for Hayes Leasing Co., Inc.

Arthur H. Kann, Esq. for The Hertz Corp.

Danret-R> 7 ; erntat

James J. Kenny, Esq. for Budget Rent A Car Co. of

Florida, Inc., et al.

Joseph M. Alioto, Esq. for Dollar Rent A Car System, Inc.

Robert R. Salman, Esq. for Budget Rent A Car Corp., etal.

Jacob K. Stéin, ESq. for Byrnic, Inc., d/b/a Buaget

Renta €er of warren, _6trro, et at;

Michael D. Donahue, Esq. for Budget Rent a Car of

Washington-Oregon, Inc., et al.

James V. Hammett, Jr., Esq. for Texas Auto Svc., Inc. (ea)

2/3/78

HEARING ORDER - Setting A-1l thru A-6 for hearing - Feb. 24, 1978

in Miami, Florida (ea)

2/6/78

MOTION, BRIEF, CERT. OF SERVICE, EXHIBITS A, B -- BUDGET RENT A CAR

OF WASHINGTON - OREGON, INC.

Suggested Transferee District -- N.D. Calif. (rew)

2/6/78

RESPONSE -- TEXAS aUTO SERVICES, INC. w/cert. of service

2/7/78

RESPONSE -- Hayes Leasing Co., - MOTION to remand claims against

Hayes Leasing Co., to the W.D. Texas, BRIEF w/cert. of svc. (ea)

278778

REQUEST FOR FILING -- Dollar Rent-A-Car System, Inc. w/cert. of

Svc. ° “GRANTED (éay

2/8/78

_|BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR TRANSFER -- Dollar Rent-A-Car System,iInc

w/cert. of service. (ea)

278778

REQUEST FOR FILING -- Hertz,Corp., Avis Rent A Car System, Inc.,

and National Car Rental System, Inc. w/cert. of svc. GRANTED (ea)

2/8/78

MEMORANDUM CONCURRING IN MOTION FOR TRANSFER -- Plaintirtf Byrnic, I,¢c.

6t_ al. w/Gért. Of SVC. (Ea)

2/8/78

JOINT RESPONSE -- Defendants The Hertz Corp., Avis Rent A Car

System, Inc., and National Car Rental System, Inc. w/cert. of

svc. (ea)

2/22/78

WAIVER OF ORAL ARGUMENT -- Texas Auto Services, Inc. for hearing

held on February 24, 1978 in Atlanta, Georgia.

AUTHENTICATED

JPML FORM 1A - Continuation DOCKET EHTRIES -- pe. 2
DOCKET NO. 338 —— In re Airport Car Rental Antitrust Litigation
No. ee
Date Code
| 3/28/78 | | CONSENT OF TRANSFEREE COURT —- Assigning litigation to the
| LC Honorable Charles B. Renfrew for coordinated or # consolidated :
| Co] pretrial proceedings pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1407. (ea)
| 3/28/78 ] OPINION AND ORDER -- transferring A-1, A-4, A-5 and A-6 to be
consolidated with A-2 and A-3 for pretrial proceedings in the
lL BiGE N. D. California. fea)
3/29/78 | [B-1 DRC Industries, Inc., et al. v. The Hertz Corp., et al., S.D. N.Y.,
CC C.A. No. CIV 4
CC] CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY -- Notified involved judges
CC and counsel (cds
4/14/78 | | B-1 DRC Industries, Inc., et al. v. The Hertz Corp., et al., S.D. N.Y.
Co C.A. No. 77 CIV 2524
| CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- Notified involved judges
| | and clerks (cds)
5/8/78 | | APPEARANCE~-- John N. Hauser, Esq. for Avis Rent A Car System, Inc. (emh)
6/27/78 | | B-2 Dollar Rent A Car Systems, Inc., et al. v. The Hertz Corporation,
| et al., D. Hawaii, C.A. No. 78-0197
IE CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY -- Notified involved judges and
Co counsel (cds k
7/10/78 | |NOTICE OF OPPOSITION (B-2) Dellar Rent A Car Systems, Inc., et al. v.
] The Hertz SaioEation et al., D. Hawaii, C.A. No. 78-0197 --	| plaintiff BEORRR Rent A Ca EFL se |
EKA (X3XXXXPD ERS XRX ood $0 toon oi RD RR RA FR RRR BRE ETEK
IE PEE COCO BOCES OOL CULV IZCOTOO FCECOCLCE 0 01 DRS £66200 NO
]
7/24/78 9 | MOTION TO VACATE CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER -- Plaintiffs Budget Rent A
IE Car, et al.; Dollar Rent A Car Systems, Inc.; Budget Rent A Car
CC] of Florida, Inc., et al.; Byrnic, Inc., et al.; Budget Rent A
CC Car of Washington-Oregon, Inc., et al.; Texas Auto Services, Inc.
CC] and BRC Industries, Inc., et al. —-- W/BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
FC and w/cert. of service. (cds)
8/7/78 | 10 |RESPONSE (TO PLEADING #9) ~-- Plaintiffs in Dollar Rent A Car Systems,
IR Inc., et al. (C.A. No. 78-0197 -- w/cert. of service (cds)
8/8/78 | 11 RESPONSE/BRIEF -—- Defendants The Hertz Corp., Avis Rent A Car System,
CC] Inc., and National Car Rental System, Inc. -- w/cert. of service
9/1/78 |____HEARING ORDER —- setting B-2 for hearing insN-mBlRtid#id#Chicago,	T11.
| 9/29/78, (ea)
9/29 filed in Open Court -- Motion fited the Discricit of Hawaii
] 0 dismiss Co-Plaintiff. (ea)
IN	NN,	TN TTT
NTNA	LN.	J NS TN TN
NAL | NS	NTN	TTR
Xl 0XNTT	RKTT
C—O NALS	NN | 7 NN	TTT 7X
IN| J ON TTY XA ‘
LX

JPML, FORM 1A - Continuation DOCKET ENTRIES -- p._ #3
@
DOCKET NO. 338 —— IN RE AIRPORT CAR RENTAL ANTITRUST LITIGATION
Date Pleading Description
11/15/78 OPINION AND ORDER -- Transferring (B-2) Pacific Auto Rental
Corp., etc. v. The Hertz Corp., et al., D. Hawaii,
#C78-0197, under 28 U.S.C. §1407 —- Notified involved
clerks, judges and counsel (cds)
Noted in last paragraph of opinion and order is Judge
Roy W. Harperx Dissenting.
5/14/79 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY --
B-3 Pacific Auto Rental Corp., etc. v. State of Hawaii,
Dept. of Transportation, et al. D. Hawaii, #o-0146
NOTIFIED INVOLVED COUNSEL AND JUDGES. (emh)
5/30/79 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY. (B-3) Pacific Auto
Rental Corp., etc. v. State of Hawaii, Dept. of Trans-
portation, et al.,D. Hawaii, C.A.No. 79-0146. Notified
involved clerks and judges. (ea)
2 79 a DITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY. B-4 J.J. Brooksbank
6/25/79 Co., Inc., etc. v. The Hertz Corp.,etal.,D.Minn.,C.A.No.
4-79-270. Notified involved counsel and judges. (ea)
7/11/79 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY. B-4 Brooksbank Co., In¢.,
v. The Hertz Corp., et al., D. Minn., C.A. No. 4-79-270.
Notified involved clerks and judges. (ea)
8/10/79 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY. B-5 Budget Rent A Car
of Reno v. The Hertz Corp., et al., c.D.Ccal.,C.A.No. Cv-79-
02129-RMT. Notified involved counsel and judges. (ea)
8/28/79 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- B-5 —- Notified in-
volved judges and clerks (cds)
80/05/07 ORDER REASSIGNING LITIGATION to the Hon. Stanley A. Weigel
Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1407 (ds)
80/08/19 ORDER REASSIGNING LITIGATION to the Hon. William W.
: Schwarzer pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1407. (emh)

JPM, Form 1 opInToN AND GRSERMBPLING 338sPosumef¥e Filed05/5/51	Bage 4 of 9 —_
hs j294 <D
DOCKET No. _338 -— LINYEAS PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION _ =
| => X=CAPTION: IN RE AIRPORT CAR RENTAL ANTITRUST LITIGATION < —
Summary of Panel Actions = SS
Date(s) of Hearing(s) 2/24/78 — —
Consolidation Ordered 3/28/78 : Consolidation Denied —
Opinion and/or Order 3/28/78 1[(5 [78 a
- Citation 4g FSupgr 272 4549 ESugm. /OC © —Starley-A--Weitgel
Transferee District N, D. California Transferee Judge €Ekharles-Bs-Renfrew
WITT	W Schwarer
Intra- District Civil Date of
Office and Action TransferfITransfereepPismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Remand Misc.
A-1 Budget Rent-A-Car Co. of Florida, Inc.S.D.FL. 77-3467-Civ ~LPA-C RR 5
et al. v. The Hertz Corp., et al. Atkins AE 7% C78 é ‘ 7/f<D
. /. :
A-2 Dollar Rent-A-Car Systems, Inc. V. N.D.CA,|C-75-2650~CBR—— _ 12/3/54 v
Hertz Corp., et al. Renfrew J .
A-3 Budget Rent-A-Car Corp., et al. Vv. N.D.CA. |Cc-77-0876-CBR- mT Js a2
The Hertz Corp., et al. Renfrew ¢ /	[2 78 00 575%.
A-4 Byrnic, Inc., et al. v. The Hertz S.D.OH. |C-1-77-594 587% § 7 44
Corp., et al. porter
A-5 Budget Rent-A-Car of Washington-Oregon, C.D.CA.|77-3967-DWW YAY R75 067-0 5/7/% OInc., et al. v. The Hertz Corp., et all.Williams )
g/. “ q g- - 5774%A-6 Texas Auto Services, Inc. v. The Hert iD A-77-CA-200 7 % e78 é R v7 D. Corp., et al. XRT
~ -g(SeB8R 573/54	D
B-1 |DRC Industries, Inc., et al. v. The |S.D.N.Y{ 77 CIV 2524 J)%7 c7¢Hertz Corporation, et al. ; Haight
CT 3Rie[78 —N 24s	"etsy LOAl Atl ets . , 4 Lo 7475B-2 Foc foe, Ghote Kin eal et D. Hawaii 78-0197 115]7% el8-r6 9 > val.	v. The Heytz Corporation, et al. King
Sa C4 ot &fo2/78 i
N.D.Cal.[79-0285CBR Alas 24/87)X¥7Z-3 Trans Rent=A-Car, Inc. v. The Hertz Mal ’ v
Corp., et al. Renfrew |
pA JIS 5 pe. « 4 ; / yz C2 EE (|

JBEML, FORM 1 -CacemilinbtwtiB3R Document1 Filed 05/05/15 Page	5 of 9
DOCKET NO. 338 ~— In re Airport Car Rental Antitrust Litigation -- P.
Intra- Distric Civil Date of
Office and Action TransferflransfereePismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Daje Pocket No.pbr Remand Misc.
B~3 | Pacific Auto Rental Corp., etc. v. D. Hawalli 79-0146 5/30 J 129-1276 v & yw J
State of aes or of Transporta— King rr Sty	— tion, et al. SY 79 BN Eau! I I En RS
TO = Ta BM2.5 1-7sd = F/ 5 |
| » 5/75	#4
B-4 J. J. Brooksbank Co., Inc., etc. v. [D. Minn.| 4-79-2270 (4 699-174 S 2
The Hertz Corp., et al. 0/57/27 Alsop
B-5 Budget Rent a Car of Reno v. The C.D.CAL cvio-ozi2ovgt 1/79 NG-AL22 _5/7/5	Hertz Corp., et al.AUGR 10 1979 Takasug [oJ E) /
So 2 PE EE =
by SE	— BN 7
0, VE 2 70 — 4 SG |	y Le . | .
% / 7s
ily 1757 = Me [2 22g

JPML Form 4
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 338 -- IN RE AIRPORT CAR RENTAL ANTITRUST LITIGATION
AVIS RENT A CAR SYSTEM, INC.
John N. Hauser, Esq. BUDGET SEAT CAX CO. OF FLORIDA,
McCauchen, Doyle Brown	& Enersen TY
Three Embarcadero Center elly, Rlack “Black & Kenny, P.A.
San Francisco, California 94111 Yogi oils duPont Building	Te — yami, Florida 33131
HAYES LEASING CO., INC,
James S. Ramsey, Jr., Esq. DOLLAR RENT A CAR SYSTEM, INC. (A-2)
Crutcher, Hull, Ramsey & Jordan Joseph M. Alioto, Esq.
28th Floor, 2001 Bryan Tower Alioto & Alioto
Dallas, Texas 75201 111 Sutter Street, Suite 2100
San Francisco, California 94104
THE HERTZ CORPORATION
Arthur H. Kahn, Esq. BUDGET RENT A CAR CORP., ET AL. (A-3)
Schnader, Harrison, Segal & Lewis Robert R. Salman, Esq.
1719 Packard Building Phillips, Nizer, Benjamin, Krim
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19102 & Ballon
40 West 57th Street
NATIONAL CAR RENTAL SYSTEM, INC. New York, New York 10019
Daniel R. Shulman, Esq.
Gray, Plant, Mooty, Mooty & Bennett BYRNIC, INC., 4/b/a BUDGET RENT-A-CAR
300 Roanoke Building OF WARREN, OHIO, ET AL. (A-4)
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402 Jacob K. Stein, Esq.
Paxton & Seasongood
1700 Central Trust Tower
BUDGET RENT-A-CAR } Cincinnati, Ohio 45202Richard J. Lucas, Esquire
Orrick, Harrington, Rowley BUDGET RENT A CAR OF WASHINGTON-
& Sutcliffe OREGON, INC., ET AL. (A-5)
600 Montgomery St. Michael D. Donahue, Esq.
13th Floor 10880 Wilshire Boulevard
. : : Suite 1115
San Francisco, California 94111 Los Angeles, California 90024
TEXAS AUTO SERVICES, INC., (A-6)
James V. Hammett, Jr., esq.
P.O. Box 2286
Austin, Texas 78768

JPML FORM 4A -- Continuation
Panel Attorney Service List -- p. ___	2
DOCKET NO. 338 —— IN RE AIRPORT CAR RENTAL ANTITRUST LITIGATION
DRC INDUSTRIES, INC., ET AL. (B-1) BUDGET RENT A CAR OF RENO (B=5)
John F. Triggs, Esq. Michael D. Donahue, Esq.
Glass, Greenberg, Irwin & Pellman Richard N. Rust
540 Madison Avenue Jonas & Fern
New York, New York 10022 10880 Wilshire Boulevard
Suite 1115
DOLLAR RENT A CAR SYSTEMS, INC., ET AL. Los Angeles, California 90024
8-2 0000000000000 :
14 del " Josef Diamond, Esq.
2105 Davies pacific center | Lycette, Diamond & Sylvester
841 Bishop Street 4th Floor, Hoge Building
Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 : Seattle, Washington 98104
PACIFIC AUTO RENTAL CORP., ETC. (B-3)
Ronald Ss. Adelman, Esq.
STATE OF HAWAII, DEPT. OF TRANSPORTATION
DEPT. OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES
SUSUMO ONO
MOSES KEALOHA
STANLEY HONG
ROLAND HIGASHI
THOMAS S. YAGI
TAKEO YAMMOTO
RYOKICHI HIGASHIONNA
Wayne Miniami, Esquire
Attorney General
415 Ss. Veretania Street
Honolulu, Hawaii 96813
J. J. BROOKSBANK CO., INC. (B-4)
Sidney Barrows, Esquire
Leonard, Street and Deinard
1200 National City Bank Bldg.
510 Marquette Avenue
Minneapolis, Minn. 55402 :
/’

JPML FORM 3
p. 1
COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET No. 338 __ IN RE AIRPORT CAR RENTAL ANTITRUST LITIGATION
22° ot BR AARP RT Ah ehlaAL ANTITRUST LITIGATION LLL
Named as Party in Following Actions
A-1, A-2, A-3, A-4, A-5, A-6__ [3-1 B-2 HA-3 HY|	4
yA
The Hertz Corp. =
[A-1, A-2, A-3, A-4 a-5 a. B-1 B-2 B-3 Aq]AVIS RENT-A-CAR SYSTEM, INC. &L~$ ~~ ~~~ ——— 7m — Tem
V YY
, A — + A= , A= ? A-4, A-5 A-6 R-] B-2 K a A,
. System, Inc.
ee]
Hayes Leasing Co., Inc. ee
&-2 4-5 202000 0
LTD. d/b/a/ NATIONAL, CAR — ———
< 4
BUDGET RENT-A-CAR SYSTEMS, [Bede Hel —INC. I
AS
|£52
State of Hawaii
Dept of Transportation eT
| 4-s00000
Dept. of Land and Natural [
Resources ee
“s-3	00000	om
Susumo Ono I
fS~3
Moses Kealoha
2-z

Roland Higashi

a.

Thomas S. Yagi

Wee s

Takeo Yamamoto

Ryokichi Higashionna