IN RE: Hawaiian Hotel Room Rate Antitrust Litigation

JPML. FORM 1A DOCKET ENTRIES
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 303 -- IN RE HAWAIIAN HOTEL ROOM RATE ANTITRUST LITIGATION
Date Code
4/8/77 MOTION w/SUPPORTING BRIEF -- Jointly by defendants Cinerama Hawaii
] Hotels, Inc., Flagship International, Inc., Interislanad
] Resorts, Ltd., Island Holidays, Ltd., The Sheraton Corporation,
CC] Western International Hotels Co., and Hilton Hotels Corp. --
Co w/complaints attached as Exhibits A, B, and C, and Exhibit D
] are relevant exhibits and affidavits filed in Berger Action
in E.D. N.Y., Also attached is affidavit of service on clerks
] of court and involved counsel.
CC REQUESTED TRANSFEREE FROUM: District of Hawaii
4/18/77 | | APPEARANCES
Co] Plaintiff Berger, Etc. by Douglas P. Null, Esq.
Plaintiff Diplomat Travel Svc., Inc.,etal by Roslyn M. Litman, Esq.
CC] Plaintiff Schanker, et al.,etc. by Jerry S. Cohen, Esq.
] Hilton Hotels Corp. by Richard E. Sherwood, Esq.
Western Internat'l Hotels Co. by E. Judge Elderkin, Esq. ]
Co The Sheraton Corp. by Maxwell M. Blecher, Esq.
lL Island Holidays, Ltd. by Peter D. Byrnes, Esq.
Co Tntérisland Resorts, Ltd., Intér-island Travel Service Ltd., :
FC] awaii Unlimited, Trade Wind Tours of Hawaii by Burnham H.
] sreeley, Esq. :
] Flagship Internat'l, Inc. by Andrew C. Hartzell, Jr., Esq.
CC] inerama Hawaii Hotels, Inc. by Harry B. Swerdlow, Esq.
] fawaiian Hotel Assn. by Gaylord A. Virden, Esq.
IE Tawaiian Holiday Tours, Inc., Hawaiian Holidays, Inc. by Thomas
CC H. Baer, ksqg.
CT Internat Travel Brokers, Inc. by Lawrence B. Kahn, Esq.
IE Ryoya, Ltd. by Arthur K. Goto, Esq.
4/25/77 | |REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF TIME -- Plaintiffs -- GRANTED TO ALL TO
LC] AND INCLUDING MAY 9, 1977
5/10/77 | 2 |IMOTION, BRIEF, Cert. of Service, Exhibit A and B. =-- All plaintiffs
Co in A-1, A-2, A-3 and B-1 and B-2 to add actions (B-1 and B-2
CC] to the motion and Suggested the C.D. California as the transferee
CC] district
| REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO REPLY TO PLAIN RESPONSEZ MOTION
CC Defendants Hilton Hotel -- GRANTED TO
5/26/77 REPLY -- Defendants w/cert. of service
0 In ARTNG ORDER _—- Setting A-1 through A-3 and B-1l and B-2
] for hearing -- June 24, 1977, Washington, D.C.
9/27/77 CC] CONSENT OF TRANSFEREE COURT -- litigation to handled by Judge Samuel P.
lL] King for coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings pursuant
| to 28 U.S.C. §1407.
9/27/77 | | OPINION AND ORDER -- Transferring A-1, A-2, B-1 and B-2 to the
CC District of Hawaii for coordinated or consolidated pretrial
] proceedings pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1407.

JPML Form 1 OPINION ASiBSOMIMRNCo 299 /PocunfFFL wiles Qmiofds |Page 2 of6
DOCKET NO. 303 - JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
CAPTION: IN RE HAWAIIAN HOTEL ROOM RATE ANTITRUST LITIGATION
Summary of Panel Actions
Date(s) of Hearing(s) June 24, 1977
Consolidation Ordered Sept. 27, 1977 Consolidation Denied
Opinion and/or Order Sept. 27, 1977 a
Citation
Transferee District District of Hawaii Transferee Judge _ Samuel P. King
Intra- District Civil Date of
Office and Action TransferflransfereeDismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Remand Misc.
le
A-1 Susan Berger, etc. v. Sheraton E.D.N.Y. 937/77 mm 12/7	Corporation of America, et al. Neaher 76C 2278
A-2 Diplomat Travel Service, Inc., etc. N.D.Cal. JM 9/3707 JR 2 4	v. ITT Sheraton Corporation of IBALL C—77-0304 <n
America, et al.
A-3 Charles K. Schanker, et al., etc. v. [Hawaii — 2/e 7pThe Sheraton Corporation, et al. King 77-0082
B-1 James S. Baer v. The Sheraton N.D. Ill 77C1313 9477) 77-00% 12 Ji fos	Corp., et al. Crowley
B-2 Packer Society Hill Travel Agency, C.D,CHL, 77-1493-MM 977 ~ 1afe fo vdInc. v. ITT Sheraton Corp. of Lucas 1. BR
America, et al. Eee
27 A
| lk<C dé Ad / 7	Vd Vd . / v4 } if	. , i 34 N
7

JPML Form 4
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET No. 303 -- _IN RE HAWAIIAN HOTEL ROOM RATE ANTITRUST LITIGATION
SUSAN BERGER, ETC. (A-1) INTERISLAND RESORTS, LTD.
Douglas P. Null, Esq. Burnham H. Greeley, Esq.
Null and Pincus, P.C. Carlsmith, Carlsmith, Wichman & Case
600 01d Country Road Post Office Box 656
Garden City, N.Y. 11530 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809
DIPLOMAT TRAVEL SERVICE, INC.,ETAL (A-2) FLAGSHIP INTERNATIONAL, INC.
Roslyn M. Litman, Esq. Andrew C. Hartzell, Jr., Esq.
Litman, Litman, Harris & Specter, P.A. Debevoise, Plimpton, Lyons & Gates
Grant Building 299 Park Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15219 New York, New York 10017 .
CHARLES K. SCHANKER, ET AL., ETC. (A-3) CINERAMA HAWAII HOTELS, INC.
Jerry S. Cohen, Esq. Harry B. Swerdlow, Esq. ) )
Kohn, Milstein & Cohen Swerdlow, Glikbarg & Shimer
1776 K St., N.W.., #708 9601 Wilshire Boulevard .
Washington, D.C. 20006 Beverly Hills, California 90210
HILTON HOTELS CORP. HAWAIIAN HOTEL ASSN.
Richard E. Sherwood, Esq. Gaylord A, Virden, Esq.
O'Melveny & Myers Suite 2020 Davies Pacific Center
611 West Sixth Street 841 Bishop Street
Los Angeles, California 90017 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813
WESTERN INTERNATIONAL HOTELS CO. HAWAIIAN HOLIDAY TOURS, INC.
E. Judge Elderkin, Esq. HAWAIIAN HOLIDAYS, INC.
Brobeck, Phleger & Harrison Thomas H. Baer, Esq.
1 Market Plaza, Spear St. Tower Baer & McGolderick
San Francisco, California 94104 460 Park Avenue
New York, New York 10022
THE SHERATON CORPORATION
Maxwell M. Blecher, Esq. INTER-ISLAND TRAVEL SERVICE LTD.
Blecher, Collins & Hoecker HAWAII UNLIMITED
612 South Flower Street, Suite 1250 Burnham H. Greeley, Esq.
Los Angeles, California 90017 (See Above Address)
ISLAND HOLIDAYS, LTD. INTERNATIONAL TRAVEL BROKERS, INC.
Peter D. Byrnes, Esq. Lawrence B. Kahn, Esq.
Bogle & Gates 11 Grace Avenue
The Bank of California Center Great Neck, New York 11021
Seattle, Washington 98164

JPMIL, FORM 4A -- Continuation
Panel Attorney Service List -- p. 2
DOCKET NO. -
ee
KYOYA, LTD,
Arthur XK. Goto, Esq.
Kashiwa & Kanazawa
302 Town Tower, Harbor Square
Honolulu, Hawaii 96813
TRADE WIND TOURS OF HAWAIT
Burnham H. Greeley, Esq.
(See address on p.l)
PACKER SOCIETY HILL TRAVEL AGENCY
INC., ETC. .
Arnold Levin, Esquire
. Adler, Rarish, Daniels
Levin & Creskoff
2nd Floor, Rohm & Haas Bldg.
6th and Market Streets
Philadelphia, Pa. 19106
JAMES S. BAER
Michael J. Freed, Esquire
: Much, Shelist, Freed,
Denenberg & Ament
105 W. Madison 19th Floor
’ Chicago, Illinois 60602

JPMI, FORM 3
Pe.
COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 303 -- IN RE HAWAIIAN HOTEL ROOM RATE ANTITRUST LITIGATION
Named as Party in Following Actions
Sheraton Corp. of America
N
Hilton Hotels Corp. A
\ EE ——————| A-1 A-2 A-3 pH-] VAs
Western International
Hotels Co. ee
NF—
Cinerama Hawaii Hotesl, Inc, —m—
Nfe————————————————
: a7 AD A-3 Hho BF
1.
Flagship Intermational, Inef
N—————————————————1,
7 Pa A383 B-] Hr
Interisland Resorts, Ltd. | _ __ ~~
7]
7
NF
pf Lod 23 pT rom	Island Holidays, Ltd. d/b/a
\ —z/
7
a.,
Hawaiian Holidays Tours,Incy—————— ———
Vv errr]» ) 7
Hawaiian Holidays, Inc.
\ ee-7
Inter-island Traverl sve.,|
Ltd. d/b/a Trade Wind Tour$

Pp. I
A
International Travel
Brokers, Inc. “
N
7
EE.
Hawaii, Unlimiated ee
h a
KJOYA, LTD, EE.
Nr — —
ee
ee
ee
ee
a
ee] .
eee
ee
ee
: —_——_—e—e—ee—e———
’ ee
ot ee]
ee
oo]
. ee
ee
ee
i
ee
ee
ee
VVee
ee
ee
oo]
ee
=