IN RE: Falstaff Brewing Corporation Antitrust Litigation

he
} = f
EO.
=+ - PN _—
HI _—
Date a -
s s i MOTION & SUPPORTING BRIEF	—-- Pltfs, Falstaff Brewing Corp. and Paul
BECP — FS Sr Tp pp
i noting stage of ATTICA quel LEAH £3 DIstY1cC
= Courts in Rhode Island, Eastern Pennsylvania, Eastern Louisiana,	and	Eastern Missouri re: filing of motion w/Panel (also Northdrn
oF] alifornia)) attaching	copy of motion thereto for filing; and
_— ertificate ofservice	on involved counsel.REQUESTED TRANSFEREE FORUM: Northern District of California
6/29/76 — APPEARANCES-- JOHNH. BOONE, ESQUIRE --FalstaffBrewing Corp. andee Paul Kalmanovitz
— JOEN	F. WHLRLG, IX, TEQUIRE -- First National Bank of
FE] ee Commerce, New Orleans, La
}— EDVARDW.MULLINIX, ESQ. FIRST PENNA. BANK N.A.	i } GIRVAN PECK, ESQ. N. Y. Ins. Co.
: | THOMAS A. H. HARTWELL, ESQ. -- The Mutual Life Ins.
: : EE Co. of New York _
i 1 ROBERT S. ALLEN, ESQ. -- Boatmen's National Bank of
j St. Louis
EE , JOHNH. BLISH, ESQ. -- Industrial National Bank of R.I.	GRAHEM B. MOODY, JR. —- Haskin & Sells
| ROBERT E. GOODING, JR., ESQ. -- Gutting, McClellan, EXIEEEA
ta ah ou Shomer 4nd HOC- |} HXEEXEKNXBXXKX
IN HARRY	B. WILSON -- William J, Healy and John D. Calhoun6 12	IRESPONSE —- BOATMEN'S NATIONAL BANK OF ST. LOUIS w/cert. of service
71/2/76 | IHEARING ORDER -- Setting A-1 through A-7 for Hearing, Chicago, Ill.
i July 23, 1976
7 6 | 3 | RESPONSE -- MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY OF NEW YORK w/cert. of service |
R 634| RESPONSE -- FERDINAND J. GUTTING, et al. w/cert. of service |
7/2/76} | RESPONSE =-- NEWYORK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY w/cert. of service :
6 6! RESPONSE —-- HASKIN & SELLS w/cert. of service |
1/6/76 | RESPONSE -- MUTUAL LIFE INS. CO. OF NEW YORK (Brief	in Support of
1 1 Response No. 3) w/cert of service |
2/6/76 i 8 | RESPONSE —- INDUSTRIAL NATIONAL BANK OF RHODE ISLAND, FIRST PA. BANK N.A.
! 3 § FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF COMMERCE w/cert. of serviée
7/6/76___} 9 § RESPONSE -- WILLIAM J. HEALY AND JOHN C. CALHOUN w/cert. of service
7/16/76 110 J} REPLY -~ PAUL KALMANOVITZ and Supplemental Motion to XHFXEXY
1 1} REX XKE XB AREE EEE XE XN EXE XX XE EEX ER EX XE EX KXEE XE EX XX NXBX
I RAXXEXXXEXXXXNBXXEIBXXTERHEX Add 4 cases
2 0 : REP =- a 3 Brewing OYD & Pa Kalmanovi — - a
7/23/76 12§ REPLY -- HASKIN& SELLS -- FILED IN OPEN COURT ]
6/3/77 oo ONSENT Q RAN REE._COURT For JUDGE H. KENNETH WANGELIN .
| to handle litigation in the EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI _
5 UNDER 28 U.S.C. §1407
6/3/77 3} | OPINION AND ORDER -- Transferring A-l, A-2, A-4, A-5
i j and A-7 to the E.D, Missouri to be assigned to Judge a
1 H. Kenneth Wangelin der 28 §140 (A-6 pending in E.D. Mo.)
NI A-6 Fa a N ife Ins. Co., et al., N.D. Cal., ]
§B—1 Paul Kalmanovitz v. First National EE 3 Commerce, E.D. La.,
ee C.A No 76-2386	| Iso bp: Kalmanovi [Industrial National Bank of Rhode Island,
YT	1 pp. r.I., C.A. # CAT6-276
I IB-3 Paul Kalmanovitz v. The First Pennsylvania Banking & Trust Corp.
ED. Pa., C.A. # 76-2218 --CTO FILED TODAY NOTIFIED INVOLVED JBHRERLS

JPML FORM 1A - Continuation DOCKET ENTRIES -- Dp. _2
DOCKET NO. 263 ~-- IN RE FALSTAFF BREWING CORPORATION ANTITRUST LITIGATION
No.
Date Code]
7/6/77 | | B-1 Paul Kalmanovitz v. First National Bank of Commerce D a
CC C.A. No. 76-2386 :
] B-2 Paul Kalmanovitz v. Industrial National Bank of Rhode and
CC] D. R.I., C.A. No. CA76-276
| | B-3 Paul Kalmanovitz v. The First Pennsylvania Banking & Trust Corp.,
LC E.D. Pa., C.A. No. 76-2218
| CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY —- NOTIFIED INVOLVED CLERK
| AND INVOLVED JUDGES.
8/7/78 | | LETTER -- Dated July 19, 1978 FROM JUDGE H. KENNETH WANGELIN -- ]
CC SUGGESTING REMAND OF A-7 Paul Kalmanovitz v. New York Life Ins.
Co., et al., 77-611C(2) to the Northern District of Calif. (cs
8/7/78 LC A-7 Paul Kalmanovitz v. New York Life Insurance Co., et al., C.A. No.
CC 77-611C	(2)
| CONDITIONAL REMAND ORDER FILED TODAY -- Notified involved judge and
counsel (cds
8/23/78 | | A-7 Paul Kalmanovitz v. New York Life Ins. Co., et al., C.A. No.
CC 77611C (2)
| | CONDITIONAL REMAND ORDER FINAL TODAY -- NOTIFIED INVDLVED CLERKS
AND TRANSFEREE JUDGE (cds)
Ll
|
|
|
|
|
|
|]
IE]
] a
|
|
|
|]
| |
|
|
|
|
]
|]
|

OPINION AND ORDER, Junexdy \A7{olBEF pRVBRNt Z2#8i 05/04/15 Page 3 of 8
DOCKET NO. 263 -— JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
: Description of Litigation J
- J a
IN RE FALSTAFF BREWING CORPORATION ANTITRUST LITIGATION C ~~ ( a -.TL TT TT ITITTEUTmAry of PanaRKREETOnSS SE =
PT SE Tom tT ae mr PR Bh feb em nr i er oe in Lm i eyTREem
1/23/7176. J— Be JON— J —— = — FSDate(s) of Opinion(s) or Order(s) 6/3/77_ ____ == (2
"Consolidation Ordered XX Name of Transferee Judge JH, KENNETH WANGELIN lt TD
Consol:dation Denied Transferee District EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI No
Intra-,7	Ipistrict| civilCT mater
Office; and Action Transfer transferee Dismissal
Namber| Caption | Judge Number Jpmie_|purker to, Qr Remand] Misc.	SA-l Falstaff Brewing Corp., et al. v. |R.I. 6/3/77 177-606C
Industrial National Bank of Rhode | pettin ! 7 4 2,
Island C-76-0074
| | |
A-2 Falstaff Brewing Corp., et al. v. 5.0.0. 6/3/71. 722-607¢€ 71/8| The First Pennsylvania Banking McGlynn { | 7
and Trust Co. C-76-438 : |
| |
A-3 Falstaff Brewing Corp., et al. v. E.D.Mo. | |
Boatmen's National Bank of St. Wangelin > N - 7 2/75]Louis 76-120C(\)
A-4 Falstaff Brewing Corp., et al. v. |E.D.La. | 6 (08 ~ A / id :First National Bank of Commerce Cassibry F—v6-452 | | a ad Z	i : | !
. | | | Ni [eo
A-5 Falstaff Brewing Corp., et al. v. | N.-D-Caly 1 6/3/77 77- (oq Id /0 {<
| New York Life Insurance Co., et 21. Witliam Cc 75-2342-5W- i j i
| lL -
| SST,	A-6 | Falstaff Brewing Corp., et al. v. | N.D.Cal, DERIED/ [ v |
| New York Life Insurance Co., et al. | Poole C 75-1560-RHS ™ |
A-7 Paul Kalmanovitz v. New York Life N.D.Call 6/3/71 12-6// (1 ’ 23/Y5 oyInsurance Co., et-al. if [Poole CTTE=106=RHS— rm TT Ten Nin
Cer Sf7€ :

JBML FORM 1 -€a€omidbwatiz®® Document1 Filed 05/04/15 Page	4 of 8
DOCKET NO. 263 -= IN RE FALSTAFF BREWING CORPORATION ANTITRUST LITIGATION -- P, 2
Intra- Distric Civil Date of
Office and Action TransferflransfereePismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Remand Misc.
XYZ-1 | Paul Kalmanovitz v. Boatmen's E.D.Mo.| 76-639	(C) 4 IN 7K &
National Bank of St. Louis @¥ — Tee. B-1 Paul Kalmanovitz v. First National E.D.La.| 76-2386 14 : >/6 +4
Bank of Commerce é/a0/27 assSibry ’ (2)uz [717-715 7B-2 Paul Kalmanovitz v. Industrial National	D. R.IL CA76-276 i fd—3 J, y
Bank of Rhode Island &/20/27 a BOLE: of 17) _ ALA EF 2)B-3 Paul Kalmanovitz v. The First E.D.Pa. [16-2218 7 [17 77 2 d
Pennsylvania Banking and Trust p Yoram - / 7 yz
an yd ’ . [Sy y vd ” co / : ) gy
les S57So /2 NY.»/ > ss 7CL	g fed ( rr we o ny i. a

Pp. _1_
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
| Je. NO. 263 =~ _IN RE FALSTAFF BREWING CORPORATION ANTITRUST LITIGATION
Plaintiff Defendant
FALSTAFF BREWING CORP. INDUSTRIAL BANK OF RHODE ISLAND
PAUL KALMANOVITZ John H. Blish, Esquire
John H. Boone, Esquire Edwards’& Angell
Boone, Schatzel, Hamrick & Knudsen 2700 Hospital Trust Tower
o Russ Building, Suite 420 Providence, Rhode Island 02903235 Montgomery Street
San Francisco, California 94104 FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF COMMERCE,
NEW ORLEANS, LOUISIANA
PAUL KALMANOVITZ John F. Weeks, II, Esquire
(B-1) (B-2) &(B-3) Usry, Leefe, Hartley & Stahl
James F. Boccardo, Esq. Suite 1710
Boccardo, Blum, Lull, / 144 Elk Place
Niland & Bell ‘New Orleans, Lousiana 70112
111 West St. John St. EE
San Jose, CA 95113 FIRST PENNSYLVANIA BANK, N.A.
Edward W. Mullinix, Esquire
: : : Schnader, Harrison, Segal
& Lewis
1719 Packard Building
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19102
| NEW YORK LIFE IYSURLANCE SOMPAN
| Giryan Pegk, Equipe
Mofrison/a Fofrstfr
dhe Post Strfel, #2600
San Francisco, falyforyia [94104
C THE MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY	OF NEW YORK
Thomas A. H. Hartwell, Esquire
Cooley, Godward, Castro,
Huddleson & Tatum v
— One Maritime Plaza
The Alcoa Building
San Francisco, California 94111
BOATMEN'S NATIONAL BANK OF
ST. LOUIS
Ce Robert S. Allen, Esquire .
Lewis, Rice, Tucker, Allen
o and ChubbSuite 1400 Railway Exchange Bldg.
611 Olive Street
St. Louis, Missouri 63101

pe _____©
RXXXRRXRRX ASECOSE	OL
HASKIN & SELLS "NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE CO.
Graham B. Moody, Jr., Esquire Robert D. Raven, Esquire CMcCutchen, Doyle, Brown & Enersen William Alsup, Esquire
601 California Street t Morrison & Foerster I's
San Francisco, Calif. 94108 One Marlet Flaza
Spear Street Tower
FERDINAND J. GUTTING San Francisco, CA 94103
a/k/a FERD GUTTING
JAMES S. MCCLELLAN, ESQ.
+ ALVIN GRIESEDIECK, JR.
JOSEPH GRIESEDIECK
+ EDWARD J. GRIESEDIECK, JR.
HARVEY A. BEFFA, JR.
WILLIAM S. LOWE CMONTE E. SHOMAKER
J. HOWARD WEMHOENER
Robert E. Gooding,Jr., Esquire
Howard, Prim, Rice, v
Nemerovski, Canady & Pollak
650 California Street, Suite 2900
San Francisco, Calif. 94108
WILLIAM J. HEALY
+ JOHN D. CALHOUN
Harry	B. Wilson, Esq.
Husch, Eppenberger, Donohue,
Elson & Cornfeld
| 18th Floor, The Boatmen's Tower
100 North Broadway
St. Louis, Missouri 63102

JP Form 3 : )
SE P.
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 263 -- IN RE FALSTAFF BREWING CO. ANTITRUST LITIGATION
do
COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST
NAME OF PARTY NAMED AS PARTY IN FOLLOWING ACTIONS
INDUSTRIAL NATIONAL LA-1 &-5 »X% ApB-/	7]
BANK OF RHODE ISLAND Lb _ ~~~ — #7 merino fio A
ee
ee
FIRST PENNA. BANKING EeAND TRUST CO. ee]
a
BOATMEN'S NATIONAL lA-3 A-5 NAY ODF	000000
BANK OF ST. LOUIS
re
| ——————————
EN.
FIRST NATIONAL BANK | ~~ —
OF COMMERCE ee
ee
| re
| NEW YORK LIFE INS. ee	-
Co. ————
ee
le	]
THE MUTUAL LIFE INS. | — — — — ———— ——	ooo]
CO. OF N. Y. -
EE.
re
a
ee]
| A-7 | LF
FERDINAND J. GUTTING [————ee@r————
Fred Gutting —————
Ce] :
A -...»,S 000
- A. A. BEFFA, S/W	——————————i
a]
|A-7-.-.. @@0Z0z0 Zo Zz	oo]
JAMES C. MCCLELLAN ene
————————
1
OOo]

| Pp.
A IVIN GRIESEDIECK JR. A-7 £8 ) |
CSEPH GRIESEDICK -—
TLLiAM ©. LOWE = 2-7
| ————————————————————————
ONTE E. SHOMAKER FEY £& SE
A
7. HOWARD WEMHOENER al 8 =f .
FA CY	A
CLLIAM J. HEALY 1]
=
JOHN C. CALHOUN ear