IN RE: Beef Industry Antitrust Litigation

Zire 4
co Ek
52 |
® . ER -_
FR . | —— —
Date \Q ee
4/76 MOTION-- BRIEF -- EXHIBITS -- CERT OF SERVICE.
1 DEFENDANTS -- SAFEWAY STORES, INC., THE KROGER CO., THE
REAT ATLANTIC AND PACIFIC TEA CO., IN
1 _ AMERICAN STORES CQ,, FOOD FAIR STORES, INC
| THE GRANDUNION COMPANY,LUCKY STORE
[ NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FOOD CHA 'HE NATIONA
——] PROVISIONER, INC., THE SUPERMARKE NERAL CORP	WINN-DIXIE STORES, IN
|] —	SUGGESTED. TRANSFER] ORUM == N.D XA
I ee SUGGESTED TRAN R D ~~ CH D AYLOR6 IREQUEST FOR EXTENSION	TQ FILE —- PLAINTIFF LOWE, ET 2 RANTED TO
>, 0 |-—Jpes ARAN S: BURK P RSEN, ET AL, owe mmerha Q	- 4 PON R RK CATT] 0 N --_Ben Krage guire
M ELMAN RANCH CO, -- Rober J. Allen, Esq. = = = =
: 1 R HARD OW A == Alan Raywid quire
A MEAT	PRICE INVESTIGATORS ABBN =-- Cochrane & Bresnahan
] A Black == Jame A Nithe POON Sq.
—_ — AEEWA OR \ -=_John B. Bate guire	i : KROGER CO. -~- Alexande Benne quire
—— : H REA A AN & PA A 0 ~-=_Deni M neroe	: ACME MARK N AMERTCAN OR == Benjamin. Quigg
- OOD_FATR OR \ David Rosen NEE	he RAND NITON QO —_— enhen M AxXinn S14 re
| _ K OR A = ArnoldM arman quire
1) NATTONA A N O QOD HAIN — ame R 1
—_— THE NATIONAL PROVISIONER, INC, =-= Fred H. Bartlit, Jr.
— PERMARK NERA QRD — Geo a M Kalmus
— 1 NINN=D LX OR I —-— he = Bede. l Sa
_ ] FIRST NATIONAL STORES, INC. -- Charles Il Thomson
—] ALBERTSON'S INC. =-- Jess B., Hawle Jr. SLL
| SUPER VLAU STORES, INC. -- Michael E. Bress :
| BORMAN'S INC. -- Sylvan Rapapport, Esq. i	i SKAGGS COMPANIES, INC. -- Donald B. Holbrook =. ~~
THRIFTMART, INC. -- Timothy J. Sargent CEC
NATIONAL TEA CO. -=- William T. Clabault _ __..
ARDEN-MAYFAIR, INC. -- Alf R, Brandin TRE
——] CIRCLE K Corp. ==- William D. Baker	ALLIED SUPERMARKETS, INC. -- Gerald S., Cook “~¥mm:
I COLONIAL STORES, INC. =-- Kilpatrick, Cody, ROG AYi
3/1 — McClatchey & Regenstein ng gt	3/15/76 | APPEARANCES: JEWELL COMPANIES, INC. ~~ Gheofore A. Grognke; Esquire
3/16/76 2] RESPQN - A QOMPAN \ 1/ce . ervice wp	4/76 I REQ OR _EXTENSION__ aga 0. ——- GRANTED to March 31,%197%
/ : | OPPO ON 0 REQ OR X N ON —-= Plainti owe e O erwice
4 0 rs R PON -=_ PLAIN TIFF LOWE, ET AL. w/cert. of service EE	: 6 § 4 J RESPON ~~ MEAT PR INVESTIGATORS	ASSN w/cert. of service =
3/25/76 _ 1 5 § RESPONSE -- PONY CREEK CATTLE CO. w/cert. of service
6 * REQUEST FOR EXTENSION -- ALBERTSON'S -- GRANTED TO ALBERTSON ONLY -
= to and including March 31, 1976	3/26/76 RESPONSE -- PETERSEN, ET AL., AGEE., AND BLACK ET AL.
3/26/76 | 7 IBRIEF -- MPIA., w/Affidavit Cd
3/26/76	| IREQUEST FOR EXTENSION -- CIRCLE K CORP. -- GRANTED TO MARCH 31, 1976
|3/26/76	| REQUEST FOR EXTENSION -- TQ FILE REPLY -- MOVANTS —- GRANTED TO APRIL 7.
|3/30/76	| 8 | RESPONSE -- MOTION, BRIEF -- SKA OMPAN r INC to add Bl ———
w/cexrt. of service —

3» &
rin B
hp] [1 2 To —
Date EE —
3/30/76 _§ 9 §RESPONSE -- ALBERTSON'S INS -- w/cert of service
6___& - ORDER -= Setting A-1 through B-1 for hearing, April 2 916
| ee ..¥Washington, D. C. ee,
: 8.10 == CIRCLE K. CORPORATION w/cert. of servicd . .._
A RR EN AREA == BS Sf 2 hose, etal. Black et 3
4/5/76 ._ 4 APPEARAN =~ Samuel Hoar, Esq. -- Stop & Shop. Co., Inc.
4 76 _§ 13 § RESPONSE -- SUPER VALUE STORES w.cert. of service = =
4/6/76 814 § RESPONSE FIRST NATIONAL STORES, INC, w.cert of service
4/7/76 316 3 RESPONSE -- SKAGGS COMPANIES w/cert.	of service
4/7/76 §16 | SUPPLEMENT	TO MOTION -- MOVANTS to add B-l and B-2 ===	==
4/7/76 __417 J REPLY BREIF -- MOVANTS ~~ ~~~ ~~ ~~~ ~~ ~~
4/7/76 $18 §SUPPLEMENTAL	REPLY =-- MOVANTS oo.
4/20/76 _§ EWAIVERS OF ORAL ARGUMENT -- 4/23/76 HEARING -- MUSSELMAN RANCH
EE 8 _3CO., RICHARD LOWE, THE CIRCLE K. CORP.,	[23/76 tio 1 EXHIBITS == -= PRICE INVESTIGATOR
ESTES EXHIBITS == RRR RH Gy FOR ORAL ARGuMmNg ZS HRAR BRICK LIVESTIGMO
8/18/76 a0 NOTIFICATION	OF PENDING ACTION -- Ronald Becker,	et al,	, etc.	v.
YY T— — __Safeway Stores, Inc., et al,, S.D. Iowa, 76=251-1 (B=3) |	2/2/76. SR. OF TRANSFEREE COURT -- FOR JUDGE WILLIAM TAYLOR, JR. to handle
he litigation in the N,D, Texas under =
— ky.	280U.S.C. S1407 _ _
9/2/76	4 § OPINION AND ORDER —- transferring A-1l, A-2, A-3, A-4, A-5, A-6, B-l and
— ee	_B=2 to the N.D. Texas for assignment
PE ee Be TO age Ww 1H a Q
under	28 U.S.C. S1407
9/20/76 4 _§B=3 RONALD BECKER, ET AL. V. SAFEWAY STORES, INC., ET AL.,
-_ kf S.D.TOWA,=76=25]1=1 == CTO filed today. Notified counsel,
—_—— A involved judges ee———————————————
9/20/76§ § B-4 MEAT PR 0 ATORS ASSN OWA BR PRO QR N A
-_goof _S.D.TOWA, 76-252-2 == SHOW CAUSE ORDER FILED. Notified counsel
—_ bk8 involved judges. _
~9/29/76	_§ _§j APPEARANCES -- FLAVORLAND INDUSTRIES, INC. -- Jeffrey J. Scott, Esq.
__% _ MBPXL CORP, -- John C. Dods, Esguire
—_ 4 IOWA BEEF PROCESSORS, INC., -- Edward W. Roth,	Esq. = |
yg SPENCER FOODS, INC, -- Gordon S. G. Busdicker,Esq.
_10/4/76_}21 | RESPONSE -- A, L. BLACK, ET AL. w/cert/ of service = ==
10/5/76 _ | HEARING ORDER -- Setting B-4 MPIA v. Iowa Beef Processors, S.D.Iowa
XRXEXIEX } RKSX 76-252-2 for hearing 10/29/76 Wash., D.C.
10/5/76_ {22 § RESPONSE —= DEFENDANLS I THE TRANGHERRED LIYICATEON cers ~oF Servic	service10/5/76	__ {23§ RESPONSE -- SPENCER FOODS, INC. , TOWA BEEF PROCESSORS, INC.AND"
g i ~ TT TMBPXI, CORP.w/cert.	of service ~~ TT TTT
57mm ter “{ RESPONSE	-- FLAVORLANDINDUSTRIES, INC. w/Cért. of“serviceTT
1078776	7 76 [25{| RESPONSE —- MPIA w/cért. of service ~~~ ~~ ~~-3 RONALD BECKER, ET AL, V. SAFEWAY STQRES, INC., ET AL., S.D.ITOWA
——— 3. involved judge SUSU
orem a6 {rns oh om movies, Te we	/cert of service =0/22/76 27 & Joint reply - Albertson's, Inc., et al. w/cert. of service
0 6"28 {itv request to postpone hearing by plaintiffs’ spokesman w/servics_10/. 68. .& ORDER —-_ CONTINUING HEARING SCHEDULE FOR B-4 MEAT PRICE INVEST. ASSN |
By, IOWA BEEF, S.D, Iowa, 76-252-2 Notified counsel, involved |
; Ey =
6 | JLETTER -- COUNSEL FOR RICHARD LOWE -- REqusgt for Continuation of Hearing |
etl b - yal - : —
Cr TC oA
i §

JPML FORM 1A - Continuation . . DOCKET ENTRIES -- pe. #
DOCKET NO. 248 —-- IN RE BEEF INDUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION
No.
Date Code
10/19/76 | | B-5 varian v. Safeway, et al., C. D. Calif., CV76-3073-
CC] Conditional transfer order filed today notify counsel-involved judges.
11/4/76 | |B-5 varian v. Safeway, et al., C.D. Calif. CV76-3073-LTL
| conditional transfer order final today. notified transferee clerk,
Fo] Judge, involved clerk and judge.
11/4/76 | | HEARING ORDER -= Setting B-4 MPIA wa Bee D. Towa, 16-252-2
Co] For Hearing, Dec. 3, 1976 San Diego alifornia
11/30/76 | | WAIVER OF ORAL ARGUMENT FOR D 976 HEARING == Plaintiffs Lowe
| et al Po ek Ca e Co et 3 de }
IR Skaggs Co. and Albertsons
2/24/77 | |B-6 Meat Price Investigators Assn.,et al. v. Safeway Stores, Inc.,et al.
Co D.D.C., C.A. No. 77-0211
| |B-7 Becker, et al. v. Safeway Stores, Inc., et al.,D.D.C., CA No.77-0210
| |B-8 Little Ranch Co., Inc., et al. v. Nat'l Assn., of Food Chain§, et al.
CC N.D. Cal., C.A. No. C77-0124=WHO
] CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY. NOTIFIED INVOLVED COUNSEL
CC] AND INVOLVED JUDGES,
3/14/77 B-6 Meat Price Invesiigators Assn., et al. v. Safeway Stores, Inc., etal
- |] D.D.C., Civil Action No. 77-0211
B-7 Becker, et al. v. Safeway Stores, Inc., et al., D.D.C., Civil
IE Action No. 77-0210
] B-8 Little Ranch Co., Inc., et al. v. Nat'l Assn., of Food Chains, et al
FC] Civil Action No. C77-0124-WHO, N.D. Cal.
LC] CONDITIONAI, TRANSFER ORDERS FINAL TODAY. NOTIFIEP INVOLVED
Co CLERKS AND JUDGES.
6/7/77 LC B-4 MPIA v., Iowa Beef Producers, et al., S.D. Iowa, 76-252-2
lL] OPINION AND ORDER transferring action to the N.D. Texas under
] 28 U.S.C. §1407
6/30/77 |B-9 Cameron, et al Iowa Beef Processq D. Iowa A. No =192-2
|	|B-10 Wagon Rod Ranch, et al. v. Safeway, D. Utah, C.A. No. C77-0188
CTOs filed today. Notified counsel, involved judges & transferee
CC judges
APPEARAN -- H. Kenneth Kudon, Esg. for Gian Food
Co] Kenneth L. Starr, Esq. for Dillon Co., Inc.
7/15/77 | | APPEARANCE -- H. Robert Halper, Esquire -- RED OWL STORES, INC.
7/18/77 CC APPEARANCE Michael T. Sullivan, Esquire =-- for Waldbaum Supermarkets,
1/18/77 | B-10 Wagon Rod Ranch, et al. v. Safeway Stored Tnc., D. Utah
Civil Action No. C-77-0188 —— NOTICE OF OPPOSITION -- Defendant
CC Red Owl.
7/18/77 ~~ I|B-9 Darrell Cameron, et al. v. Iowa Beef Processors, S.D. Iowa,
IE C.A. No. 77-192-2 —- CTO Final Today -- NOTIFIED INVOLVED JUDGES
CL & CLERKS.
7/20 lL B-11 Don Ludvigson, et al. v. Iowa Beef Processors, Inc., et al.,
CC S.D. Towa, C.A. No. 77-200-2 -- CTO FILED TODAY ~-- Notified
| | involved counsel & judges.
7/22/77 | | APPEARANCE -- JAMES HAMILTON, ESQ. for Publix Supermarkets, Inc
8/1/77 |	|INOTICE OF OPPOSITION (B-10) Wagon Ro& Ranch, et al. v. Safeway Stores
lL] Inc., et al., D. Utah, -0I88 Defendant --Giant
] Food
| —-¥

JPML. FORM 1A ~ Continuation . DOCKET EHTRIES -- p.
DOCKET NO. 248 __ IN RE BEEF INDUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION :
No. ee ee
Date Code
8/2/77 | ~~ |WITHDRAWAL OF NOTI OF OPPO ON == RED OWL __"w/copy of Dismissa
| | B-10 Wagon Rod Ranch, et al. v. Safeway stores, Inc., et al.,
CC] Ob. Utah, C.A. NO. -JI88 ” TT TT
8/3/77 B-10 Wagon Rod Ranch, et al. v. Safeway Store, Inc., etal .,
| | D. utah, C77-c188 -
LC MOTION-BRIEF TO VACATE CTO —- W/ Cert: Of SeIVICTE == GIANT FOODS
° OU| BU Wagon RodrRanch; eta TTy "Safeway, D. Utah, ~TB
CC] MOTION, BR 0 VACA U Ch ge SLVICS == pUBLIX SUPERMKTS.
3 | B=1l rupvicsoN, ET AL. V. IOWA BEEF PROCESSORS, 5.D.IOWA, 77-200-
] CTO final today. Notified ZBHREEXY involved judges, Clerks
5/16 | | REQUEST FOR EXTENSION -- Fisher Foods, Inc. --— GRANTED 10.
8/22/17 | 311 RESPONSE, MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT, MOTION OF DEFENDANT, & MEMORANDUM OF
| | DEFENDANT TO VACATE CTO -- Fisher Foods, Inc. w/cert. of service
RX AER T IX HX X XX KX HERRING XRRRR RX KX REE EXHER 1 rs — —————————e
8/26/77 Ll HEARING ORDER -=- Setting B-10 Wagon Rod Ranch, et al. v. Safewa
CC] Stores, et al., D. Utah, C.A.No.C77-0188 for hearing,
BN September 30, 1977 Boston, Massachusetts.
9/20/77 | | LETTER —- dated Sept. 14, 1977 -- Wagon Rod Ranch, et al.
9 7 B-12 McAdoo, et al. v. Safeway Stores, Inc., et al.,W.TEX.
| c.a.# EP-77-CAl53
| CTO_FILED TODAY. NOTIFIED INVOLVED COUNSEL AND JUDGES.
, ? : = a J URS x Cr 3 2 o a — = - promenade Emm apap —— y 5
10/5/77 RESPONSE -- Defendant Publix Super Markets, Inc. w/cert. of svc.
10/5/77 | |NOTICE OF OPPOSITION (B-17) Mrs. J.V. McAdoo v. Safeway Stores, Inc.,
| w.D. Texas, C.A. #EP-77-CAI53 Defendant —- Publix Super Markets
10/6/77 | |NOTICE OF OPPOSITION (B-12) Mrs. J.V. McAdoo Vv. Safeway Stores, Inc.,
| W.D. Texas, C.A. #EP-7/-CAl53 Defendant Fisher Foods, Inc.
10/20/77 | |REQUEST FOR EXTENSION TO FILE MOTION AND BRIEF TO VACZ 0
] Fisher Foods and Publix-— GRANTED TO OCT. 26, %-
10/28/77 | 33 |MOTION TO STAY CTO (B-12 McAdoo, et al. v. Safeway Storeg,Inc., et al.
| | C.A.# EP-77-CAl133), MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION ——
| | Fisher Foods, Inc. and Publix Super Markets, Inc. w/cer Q
4 HEARING ORDER == Setting -- B-12 McAdoo, et al. v. Safeway Stores, Inc.
CC] et al. ERxI¥IxRAxX53x W.D. Tessas, EP-77-CA-153 for
lL] hearing Dec. 7, 1977, San Diego, Calif.
12/2/77 JOINT MOTION TGC TRANSFER John T. Bean, et al. v. Safeway #### Stores,
] Inc., et al. BRIEF -- on behalf of 22 defendants wit e
] of service. (ea) and opposition to vacate McAdoo & Wagon Rod.
12/19/77 (35 | RESPONSE -—- Defendants Fisher and Publix, w/Cert. of Service cds)
S | HEARING ORDER -- Setting C-1 John T. Bean et al. v. Safeway Stores,
lL Inc., et al., W.D. Texas, C.A. No. EP-77-CA r
LC hearing Jan. 27, 197% Miami, Florida
13th ~0,2,0,0 OO	X RR Ee RAR ERR IGCERN OR REX REE XE SRC CRO OTRISOOR “
NT NX	REETPOSSXP TEECEEREDELTON TAO CERKCR XXOXoeGESSREEER %
EE Ne, ‘-., : . ~ ~~,

i"
JPML, FORM 1A - Continuation DOCKET EHTRIES -- pe. -
DOCKET NO. 248 —- IN RE BEEF INDUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION «
No.
Date Code
1/2775 |	[ORDER -- transferring B-12 and §-JVto the N.D. TEXAS under 28 U.S.C.
C 1407 and remanded claims against Fisher Foods, Publix
] and Super Glan
1/18/78 | | WAIVER OF ORAL ARGUMENT FOR 1/27/78 HEARING -- 22 Moving Defendants
CC by Richard W. Odgers, Esq.
] PUBLIX SUPERMARKETS by James Hamilton, Esq.
CC and FISHER FOODS, INC. by John F. McClatchey, Esq.
3/1/78 | |TRANSFER ORDER -- transferring C-1 Bean, et al. v. Safeway Stores,
Inc., et al., W.D. Texas, C.A.No. EP-//-CA- o e N.D. Texas
TT 5 oordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings pursuan
Ie to Section 1407. ea
3/1/78 ||ORDER DENYING TRANSFER OF CERTAIN CLAIMS AS MOOT -- B-12 McAdoo,
CC] et al. v. Safeway Stores, Inc., et al., W.D.Texas, C.A.No.
LL] P=7/"CA~123, le
5/22/78 | | Order Granting the Motions to Dismiss -- Signed by Judge Aldon J.
] Anderson (cds
5/22/78 | | ORDER DENYING TRANSFER OF CERTAIN CLAIMS AS MOOT -- Notified involved
judges, clerks and counsel (cds)
8/21/78 | |MPPEARANCE —-— John D. Leech, Esq. forFirst National Stores
~~	7
SN
rr	NN
HZ
7 —
LL

JEML FORM A .
SOCKET DNTRIES
SUISLOTAL PAN ON MULLS porn LITIGATION
Loa oo. 248 0 In re Beef Industry Antitrust Litigation So
TT end peseraption TT
82/02/25 ~~ ORDER REASSIGNING LITIGATION -- reassigning litigation from
Hon. William M. Taylor, Jr. to Hon. Patrick E.
Higginbotham, N.D. Texas for the remainder of the
coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings pursuant
to 28 U.S.C. §1407. (eaf)
84/09/13 ORDER (N.D. Texas) for assignment of litigation to Judge
~ George P. Kazen signed by Judge Higginbotham (emh)
84/09/13 ORDER REASSIGNING LITIGATION -- reassigning litigation from
- Honorable Patrick E. Higginbotham to Honorable George P.
Kazen (in S.D. Texas) -- NOTIFIED clerk, judges and all
~ counsel (emh)

© September 2, 1976 050 1/9 FISHER. Np, p48 Document1 Filed 05/01/15 Page	7 of 18 /] ~ A DO KET NO.p48 ==— JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION *	June 7, 1977, 0&0 F. upp, Al) 9
‘ : Description of Litigation [£7
— "ZY
MDL DOCKET NO. 248 -- IN RE BEEF INDUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION v7 & 2
TT Summary Of Panel Action — — —
Date(s) of Hearing(s) 4/23/76 10/29/7176 oo
Date(s) of Opinion(s) or Order(s) 9/2/76 6/7/77 __HONORABLE_George P. Kazen (S.D.Tex.)
Consolidation Ordered XX Name of Transferee Judge FXRDOTRMKNKCOCROUORKXIIRR-Patrioks Iotigginbothan
Consolidation Denied Transferee District NORTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
Intra- District Civil Date of
Office and Action Transfer| Transferee [Dismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date Docket No. jor and Misc. y
A-1 Burke Petersen, et al. v.-oslilEg N.D.Cal{C75-0984-RFP9/2/76 eH- 3-76 7 7s, EIEN Ty
Ste oo: |Safeway~Staeres, Inc., et al. Peckham , 55-1) :| 9h Fad). fie
A-2 Pony Creek Cattle Co., Inc., et al. |N.D.Tex|CA3-75-07 { ; = Lotte selv. The Great Atlantic & Pacific / i
. Tea Co., et al. Taylor | # 7 Ev iJ J
| | aig |e	A-3 Richard S. Lowe, et al. v. Safeway N.D.IowaC75-4043 9/2/76 14-374 Pi TEL YS
Stores, Inc., et al. MoManus
|
A-4 Heat Price:dnvestigators Association] S.D.Iowa 75-333-2 | 9/2/76 3-267, &// 5/5 =
et al. v. Safeway Stores, Inc., Hanson -
et al. fai J y	Vs v7 % / PA) 5 Foes S|
Thre Thede yr 4] ‘ TE !A-5 oe Lite 11 v. Safeway Stores D. Nev-R-75-224- xT9/2/76 CA 3-767) Lf | Rd xInc., et al. Thompso | Jali 0)
A-b . L. Black, et al. v. Acme Markets,|N.D.Tex|CA2-75-186| CA.326/ ys pyar
Inc., et al. Woodwar | |
B-1 Chaparral Cattle Corp., etc. Vv. D. Utah 76-79 ~~ [79/2/76 CA=-376~4 pI vr yy
Safeway Stores, Inc., et al. i .
B-2 James F. Boccado, et al. v. N.D.Cal ¢76-0800-0JC 9/2/76	07 2"7® A
Safeway Stores, Inc., et al. Fares | ”

N - Case MDL No. 248 Docum iled 05/01/15 Page 8 of 18
DOCKET NO. NRE 9 PAGE 3
—— TT	TT rr
ntra- District Civil Date of
Offige’} ~~~ and Action Transfer| Transferee| Dismissal
Number Caption . Judge Number Date Docket No.| or Remand Misc.
© B-3 Ronald Becker, et al, etc. v. S.D. 76-251-1 pub 7 7 gSafeway Stores, Ipc., et al. Iowa 7) 77 ’ — 37 YZdaofre {Stuart a, Pe-/3C/ Cl
B-4 Meap Price Investigators Assn. S.D. 76-25252 19/77 CAZ-17-0: hind Hea 77 O ’et al. v. Iowa Beef Progessors [Iowa ey Rp — e gho/
Fac d , CAE. antl 9z1/ 2 cal
B-5 John O. Varian, et al. v. 8afeway C.D.Cal| CV76-3073=FK 1/17 76 ~/4 7D CEs	0
Stores, Inc., et al. 10/19/7% - Gg a |
nse 774000 GrB-6 Meat Price Investigators Assn., |D. D.C. [77-0211 3/1 A323 , We & Jo 5 eoet al. v. Safeway Stores, Inc. Parker
et al. A /24/77) , 3 = |
3/y/rieA3 77" er-eq| 7TTIEseB-7 Ronald Becker, et al. v. Safeway PonC 77-0210 v JStores, Inc., et al. ry Parker ” Con ard
| , Inc. A877] 3-77 ¢2-CF | tte. . Fs uf77 7 iran aB-8 Little Ranch Co., Inc., et al. vJ N.D.Cal |[C77-0124-WHO: =p fxdNational Association of, Food orrick oT
oo Chaina, et al. . #217IE nN dL { / . N Lo es .
aa EN A SS LI Par. ia se
B-9 Darrell Cameron, et al. v. Iowa §|.D. Iowa |/7-192-2 78) CA-3-77- PY. RE |
Beef Processors, Inc., et al. Hanson Cy ) = : 9/99
“30/77 1/4/77) AA-3 78150 /	B-10 Wagon Rod Ranch, et al. v. Safeway D. Utah |C~77-0188 IA ~ RIES wT
h Stores, Incy, net, al. >/7 7 Anderson
a 5 7, bi 4A 2 " fi ~ = e——" —
B-11 | Don Ludvigson, ef al. Vv. Iowa S.D, 'Iowg77-200-2 3/777 af3-7740 O- 4 9/	Beef Processors, Inc.,et al. Ce Ae fy 57
7h0/77 |! ~~.
. i ~. A
B-12 | Mrs. J.V . McAdoo, et al. v. W.D.Tex EP-77-CA153 Jf | Lh-3- 78-42	Safeway Stores, Inc,, et al. Sessions / 78] 2 s,/5 20>
per ATpeed 775)7 —7 3/77

LL JEML. FORM 1 -CaokibinNetid4®h Document1 Filed 05/01/15 Page	9 of 18
DOCKET NO. 248 -- IN RE BEEF INDUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION -— P.
Intra-| = © Distric Civil Date of
Office and Action Transferllransfereepismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.fhr Remand Misc.
Cc-1 John T. Bean, et al. v. Safeway D.TX EP-77-C2A213 .9¢. 9 Ae 2
Stores, Inc., et al. Sessions 3 / 75 AZ 78-2 q 93s 9
wr
XYZ-1 Trigg Cattle Co., Inc., et al. v. N.D.TEX CA-3-78-0124G { Yr9l590Safeway Stores, Inc., et al. J ,
“Sa
XY7Z-2 Sagebrush Cattlefeeders, Inc., et al. |N¢D.TEX CA-3-78-012%¢ | : TT BAER
v. Safeway Stores, Inc., et al. y,	1 94 Ae
XYZ-3 Seven..Rivers Cattle Co., et al. v. .D.TEX CA-3-78-0126-§ 1 Cl 94Safeway Stores, Inc., et al.
XYZ-4 A.D. Lee, et al. v. Safeway Stores, .D.TEX |CA-3-78-0123~-
- Inc., et al. 7 , rl , T A197 AJ O— : Lc / y 5) - / J {7 X yr | A 2D , yaaa p Zz of ,- |
| Co yy | v4 B / /0Se nm
iki SIT T oo | SF tz
2 7 Vid Lore . YN
50/7 Lo olg — : . REAL Cur 7 \sT : ro
7 RIC 2) Ie y= 4 Cer	ce RD -
XYz-5 Durward W. Lewter, et al. v. N.D.TX. {CA3-81-1918 — fo :
Safeway Stores, Inc., et al. | A “S30 2
FT am wa lo /
Ce bg TED STA ANY J — =
. 3,py ) ~~ yo So PI ET { / Ed I 7	p RY ra 7 Pa Ea . pa i 7
Onl p57 - 17 See — 4 2. :	74
().,,./ / FGFS 7 2 KR
Lolly 1950 = F278 zz.
i 2 yy > GS NCR.	ae 2 )28 . : 72> > 7 ; 3 = PY a a
Aone ws 17% Zz Nr4 ) D5 or Si a

Co Co MAR 9 1376
Pp. __	1
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
QO... NO, 248 =-- IN RE BEEF INDUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION eee
Plaintiff Defendant
BURKE PETERSEN, ET AL. (A-1) SAFEWAY STORES, INC.
~ CHAPARRAL CATTLE CORP. (B-1) Richard W. Odgers, Esq. ’	JN, Lowell Vv. summerhays,	Esd. i i
1010 University Club’ Building w Pillsbury, Hadison & Sutro
C Balt Lake City, Utah 84111 San Francisco, Ca. 924120
“"PONY CREEK CATTLE CO., INC. (A-2) a I	—
Ben Krage, Esquire - THE KROGER CO,
: \/Rosenbe Kasmir& Willingham | Afaxander E. t, Esquire	© 2300 Mair Tower © A. \_~\] Atomold, x Po :
1300 Hain stress. Coss. Lavaies 12 inetee ., N.W.Dallas, Texas 75202 \Waghingtoén, D.C. Y20036
MUSSELMAN RANCH COMPANY KC ( THE GREAT ATLANTIC & PACIFIC
er J. Allen, Esquire A \ \/ TEA COMPANY, INC.X Strdsher, Davis& Levy (Lo\uened Denis McInerney, Esquire© 2001 Bryan Tower, Suite 3838 ~ Cahill, Gordon & Reindel
Dallas, TExas_ 75201 80 Pine Street
~~ New York, New York 10005
RICHARD S. LOWE, ET AL. (A-3)
Alan Raywid, Esquire . AMERICAN STORES CO.
“ Cole, Zylstra & Raywid ACME MARKETS, INC.
2011 Eye Street, N.W. Benjamin M. Quigg, Jr., Esquire
Washington, D. C. 20006 Morgan, Lewis & Bockius
2100 The Fidelity Building ~
© MEAT PRICE INVESTIGATORS ASSN. (A-4) 123 South Broad Street
Cochrane & Bresnahan | Philadelphia, Pa. 19109
X suite 500, Cochrane & Bresnahan Bldg.
C 360 Wabasha ¥OOD FAIR STORES, INC.	St. Paul, Minn. 55102 David A. Rosen, Esquire -
Stein, Rosen & Ohrenstein
R. DIRK AGEE (A-5) 1370 Avenue of Americas
Jerrold N. Offsk€in, Esquire ] New York, New York 10019
“ Law Offices Jerrold N. wia Offstei THE GRAND UNION CO.
111 ter Street, Suite 1432 Stephen M. Axinn, Esquire
n Francisco, CA. 94104 Skadden, Arps, Slate, a
, Meagher & Flom
A. L. BLACK, {4-{) 919 Third Avenue
James W. Witherspoon, Esquire New York, New York 10022
[ YFitherspoon, Aikin, Langley, Woods	& Gulley LUCKY STORES, INC. i
P.O. Box 1818 Arnold M. Lerman, Esquire “
Hereford, TExas 79045 Wilmer, Cutler & Pickering
1666 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D. C. 20006

' . p. 2 ’ *
Plaintiff Defendant
RONALD BECKER, ET AL. (B-3) NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FOOD CHAIN
MEAT PRICE INVESTIGATOR ASSN, ET AL. — . A 3
(B-4) Coliter, Shanhon; Rill,Edward
Cochrane & Bresnahan + - © & Scott annem, Fr-ty ar °
1055 Thomas Jefferson Street
Fex Hawkins, FAA Cavs esyekence faite 298, D.C J
SD or s, Esq. RR THE NATIONAL PROVISIONER, INC.	~Fifth-ave. h) NAT ung Fred H. Bartlit, Jr., Esquire
Des Moines, Iewa 50309 Kirkland & Ellis —
~~ 200 E. Randolph Dr.
JOHN O. VARIAN, ET AL. B-5 Chicago, Illinois 60601
X Lowell V. Summerhays, Esq :
Gary Smith, Esquire Geoffrey M. Kalmus, Esquire C37 Wilshire B 5 Nickerson, Kramer, Lowenstein, Nessen,
Los A les . 90010 Kamin & Soll .
Co 919 Third Ave.
Willi " D. wning, Esq. New York, New York 10022177 J¥. ‘Church
son, Arizona 82701 et al WINN-DIXIE STORES, INC.	a Seo	Soo So	. Chester Bedell, Esquire
MEAT PRICE INVESTIGATORS ASSN. (B-6)| pedell. Bedell. Dota o
RONALD BECKER, ET AL. (B-7) Zehmer ’
/ Burt Braverman, Esq. (A-3) ; ;
Nox Hawking Baan by 3 1500 Barnett Bank Building	’ . = 1 i
Blenn L. Norris, Esq. (B-3) Jacksonville, Florida 32202
John A. Cochrane (A-4) FIRST NATIONAL STORES, INC. oo
John D. T.eech, Esquire
LITTLE RANCH CO., INC., ET AL. (B-8)} chalfee, Halter & Griswold
Joseph L. Alioto, Esq. 1800 Central National Bnk. Bldg. t
Alioto & Alioto Cleveland, Ohio 44114
111 Sutter St. a
San Francisco, California 94104 ALBERTSON'S INC
Jess B. Hawley, Jr., Esquire —
DARRELL CAMERON, ET AL. (B-9) Hawley, Troxell, Ennis & Hawley
Glenn L. Norris, Esq. P.O. Box 1617
and Boise, Idaho 83701 CLex Hawkins, Esq. (See B-3 & B-4) ’
James W. Witherspoon, Esq. Michael E. Bress, Esquire el
See (A-6) Dorsey, Windhorst, Hannaford,
Whitney & Halladay
WAGON ROD RANCH (B-10) 2300 First National Bank Bldg.
kXmymIxx Minneapolis, Minn. 55402
\ lowell V. Summerhays, Esquire i
| BORMAN'S INC. Cas
zr Robert Anderson, Esq. Sylvan Rapaport, Esq. ; Sd-0. Box 275 . ¢/o Borman's ‘Inc. AE a
Monticello, Utah 84535 P.O. Box 446 a. a
i ichi 7, ae
Floyd R. Brown Es . : Detroit, Michigan 18232 LER
12a) 3% ° — |SBulife '60i0\ | JON
Newport Beach CN1 CA 92660 N

JPML FORM 2A -- Continuation . .
Attorney List -- p. J )
DOCKET NO. --
J
eT Donald B. Holbrook, Esquire
Ss - . ’	ame as Counsel for (B-4) Jones, Waldo, Holhrook & McDonogh
800 Walker Bank Building
Cochrane & Brmenahan Salt Lake City, Utah 84111
Lex Hawkins, Esq. THRIFTIMART, INC.
Tifothy J. Sargept, E ire
Bogkin, M rthy/, /Saxgpht & Smith
Additional Individual 20 i ifre B eva '
Defendants in B-11 o geYes) Californi 90005
Lucille S. Holman NATIONAL TEA CO.
Marcella R. Scott William T. Clabault, Esquire
Marvin S. Berenstein Mayer, Brown & Platt
c/o Iowa Beef Processors 231 South LaSalle Street
Dakota City, Nebraska Chicago, Illinois 60604
[1]
FISHER FOODS, INC. | ARDEN-MAYFAIR,	INC.
= McClatchey, E i Alf R. Brandin, Esquire
Charles ce 4 en SN 1 Lillick, McHose& Charles
Thompson, : Flory OES Two Embarcadero Center
1100 NaséBhal City Bldg 26th Floor
c and, OH 44114 CA 2 San Francisco, Calif. 94111
| 6, ha CIRCLE K CORP.
| Willyam D, Baker, Esquire
alist & Kiewit 7)300 Valley 53 Be fee //.	Phoenix, AriZzon 5073
ALLIED SUPERMARKETS, INC.
Gerald S. Cook, Esquire
Honigan, Miller, Schwartz & Cohn °°
2290 First National Building
Detroit, Michigan 48226
COLONIAL STORES, INC. oo
Kenneth	A, Plevan, Esq.
Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher
& Flom
919 Third Ave.
New York, New York 10022
oo . William H, Tinsley, Esq.: Johnson & Cravens
yo 1900 Mercantile Dallas Bldg.
EE Dallas, Texas 75201

JPML FORM 2A -- Continuation ; :
P.4 revised 9/29/76 Attorney List --p. __ 4
DOCKET NO. 248 .__ IN RE BEEF INDUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION
SPENCER FOODS, INC. PUEBLO INTERNATIONAL, INC.
Gordon S. G. Busdicker, Esquire Weil, Gotshal & Manges
Faegre & Benson - 767 Fifth Avenue
1300 Northwestern Bank Building New York, New York 10022
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402 :
JEWEL COMPANIES, INC.
FLAVORLAND INDUSTRIES, INC. Theodore A. Groenke, Esquire
Jeffrey J. Scott, Esquire bo McDermott, Will & Emery 4
Kutak, Rock, Cohen, Campbell 111 West Monroe Street )
Garfinkle & Woodward Chicago, Illinois
600 Woodmen Tower
Omaha, Nebraska 68101 STOP & SHOP CO., INC.
- Samuel Hoar, Esquire _
IOWA BEEF PROCESSORS, INC. Goodwin, Procter & Hoar
Edward W. Rothe, Esquire 28 State Street
Freeman, Rothe, Freeman & Salzman Boston, Massachusétts 02109
Suite 3200 - One IMB Plaza
Chicago, Illinois 60611 " DALLION COMPANIES, INC.
MBPXL CORP. [Fenyeth J Stake/ Rsqg.
. rellknd, (Qtapl n, Pryor Holmes
John C. Dods, Esquire 700] proadway 93 14	Shook, Hardy & Bacon i LT ’
20th Fl, Mercantile enver. Colorada 80290
Bank Tower - 1101 Walnut co
Kansas City, MO 64106 PUBLIX SUPERMARKETS, INC.
James Hamilton, Esq.
i ~ Ginsburg, Feldman & Bress
— © Suite 300
Big Bear Stores, Inc. 1700 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W. B
770 Goodale oo Washington, D.C. 20006
Columbus, Ohio . ee
. “rn Ca GIANT FOOD INC, ESQ.
Ce er H. Kenneth Kudon, Esquire
0 Danzansky, Dickey, Tydings,
—— ee —— Quint & Gordon
Suite 1010
LE 1120 Connecticute Ave., N.W.
Shea, Gould, Climenko & Casey Washington, D.C. 20036330 Madison Avenue
New York, New York 10017 RED OWLSTORES,	INC.! H. Robert Halper, Esquire
rtd Ce O'Connoré& Hannan
LL 1747 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
Ds a Tih aie . Washington, D.C. 20006 .

: ©" JPML FORM 2A -- Continuation ’ : ZzAttorney List -- p. _ ~~
DOCKET NO. 248 -- — IN RE BEEF INBUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION
—_—— eee
MRS. J. V. MCADOO, ET AL, (B-14) SHOP RITE FOODS, INC.
Lowell V. Summerhays, Esq. Talbot Rain, Esq.
(See A-1) Rain, Harrell, Emery, Young, & Doke
4200 Republic Nat'l Bank Tower
C. R. Kit Bramblett, Esq. Dallas, Texas 75201
1551 Montana Ave. Bldg.
Suite 200
El Paso, Texas 79902
JOHN T. BEAN, ET AL. (c-1)
Lowell V. Summerhays, Esq.
(See A-1)

w .—= JP Form 3 J
ph v p . 1 ’
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
\
DOCKET NO. 40 -—- IN RE BEEF INDUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION
do
COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST | \\J
NAME OF PARTY NAMED AS PARTY IN FOLLOWING ACTIONS (YS R
(A722 fA-2 AY H-% HB-4 LO-2 dF]
SAFEWAY STORES, INC. W8-% [MA-f, A~T7 O/H 4 (-] ~~ \ 7 |
=]
FE	.
le	]
| b-5 fA A727" D-)" ~~ 0 Oo OOOO 7]
THE KROGER CO. -
ee
THE GREAT ATLANTIC & | MZ-9D Hb LZ B/» bH-1 |]
| PACIFIC TEA CO., INC. eeI
ee
AMERICAN STORES CO. | B-3 M-lo AF § B= bH-]}L -] |
| =
| Aes Medals I	| {
i ee
| FOOD FAIR STORES, INC.| f—~/O® 0-4 (,g¢ ~~ = — = ~~
a	-
V/V EAT) LAE
~ THE GRAND UNION CO. | M=2 B=l A] LCE" B/d O-/ Cf |
dA
ee
LUCKY STORES, INC. | Ae HS Aw Ref fo, Bad 000 |]
’ SP Pol ATF LH -Y [A 0 D-IKN C-/ :
:
(PPT & —% Ar Hl HL (o>	|
NATIONAL ASSN. OF ly B-) KK p10 B-]h (CNS 000 |
FOOD CHAINS ZA
| ¥ 00d ‘ beg gp	|
| NATIONAL PROVISIONER, | Dr -le BJ] [A=/0 =) H-)A Cf |
ES prev	EA
SUPERMARKETS GENERAL | H.-F #~% J-l fA [hd &S fo-le H-7 |
CORP. | BEX L-y0 H-j3 CJ) ~ = © 00O0O0© | |
- |

p. _2 +
WINN-DIXIE STORES, INC. AAe B-7 ZA—F L720 HD-NA (=) |
A
r -~
Az RAJ AS YN B-72_C-] 00000 'FIRST NATIONAL STORES, INC. ~~ ¥ +=" "Xx ~~ = "~~ |
ee
ee]
ee]
SUPER VALU STORES, INC. I
I |
~~]
ae nyesezZr OOOO] ;
|P. BORMAN, INC. (Weyal"BE
INS LAIPW VARA 1 2.
14 YEENP, AY oY (yy 2COLONIAL STORES, INC. vr (ey vr; <7
—— ————	I : Py
TARA=]	BF Bd RS fA 8B
JEWELL COMPANIES, INC. CA]APO	DJ C-) = ]
ccs cots Zs Bo] Bo F B70 BA C7]oy a 14 . pe =]
| Skaggs-Albertsons, a — ——————————— |Pertnership = 7 |
%— _ AX HA A-TPfJ B70 BI C7 1THRIFTMART, INC. a	]
aR
nz A &< J OOOO
VW ERS NIE AI SEA A.
PUEBLO INTERNATIONAL, INC. [7), ®&/¥¢ ‘A weX lX=2>/	|
grr ~—	7!
te = 0-0 3 hz. CC] |
NATIONAL TEA CO. ee |
ee]
ee]
oo]

~ =~ JP Form 3
t - Pp. ] 3
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 248 — IN RE BEEF INDUSTRY ANTITRUST LITIGATION
do -_—	—— ————
SQMMON PARTY CHECKLIST :
\/ _ A a
NAME OF PARTY £5 X00rf RS) PARTY IN FOLLOWING ACTIONSEN NEB [sf . ~— 0O00
STOP & SHOP COMPANIES, KN, JAA YP 0 ~~~	1 °°
INC. ~\>\y ~~
A LP Bg) 8-3 7/0 DH-/2 (C—) 0000000]
IARDEN-MAYFAIR, INC. |
: a
Fs	]
Ala Ih] BS 5K MSL PZ C.-] |
ALLIED SUPERMARKETS ey	- -
| INC. |]
PENN FRUIT CO. HEA	A
ee
a
i aa]
ICIRCLE K. CORP. 1]
| re
EE J :SPENCER FOODS, INC. tg I=" le. 4 7
EY, ~~
a
oo]
a,
IOWA BEEF PROCESSORS, |B-4 «2-94 5-4
|e 1
MBPXL CORP. 5-4 2 O50	0000000000000
TT _	___]
l/ ’ é Aons rocery ee	2 =~ EE	= -
[ |

. pe - a
7 tS. Yrtnmay z= 0 OOOO
7]
-—	7]
Te BE-—
-—
-—
-— X
([A~ JA RENO 21]LY EE CN
Fisher Foods, Inc. -—
-— 0]
n —
o IS ol ARS A 3ey ———— ee]
LSM) i————17 = 1 —~—~——
VAN A [SUN A
Waldbaum Supermarkets, me JFL — {JZEa 3
B20447 ASY-__ ]
| Publix Supermarkets, Inc. | (Yr DIZ
-_—
Shop Rite Foods, Inc. ————-_—
-_— |
7 — -	1
sd pet) Heart FR§
| -_
-—