William Turner v. City of Philadelphia

Filed October 11, 2001
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT
No. 00-1519
WILLIAM TURNER; YVONNE RUFFIN; JAMES OECHSLE;
GLADYS WOODARD; GEORGE AALBREGTSE; CALVIN
AKERS; ROBERT ALBRIGHT; BARRY AMOS; KEVIN
ANDERSON; ELLIOTT BAILEY; TYRONE BANKS; WILLIAM
BAUER; WILSON BECKWITH, JR. ; VITO BENDZIUS;
DEBORAH BLACKMAN; GLENDA BLAKE; LORETTA
BLAKE; BERTRAND BLIER, SR.; JOSEPH BLOCKER;
MARY BONETT; JAMES BOSTON; CHARLES BOTTOMS;
CAROLYN BOYCE; FABIAN BRINSON; VICTOR BROWN;
WILLIAM BRYANT; RALPH BURTON; CARL BURWELL;
VALERIA CARR-PULLEN; JULIE I. CARTER; SHEILA
CATLETT; BARBARA CHAVIS; RODNEY CHRISTIAN;
RONALD CIAVARDONE; EDWARD CLARK; DONNA
COLLIER; RICHARD CONGELOSI; EILEEN COOK; JAMES
COOPER; GENEVIEVE CORBI; JOSEPH COUSER;
EDWARD CRUMP; CLEMON DAVIS; CORNELIA DAVIS;
GLEN DAVIS; NATHANIEL DAVIS; HERMINIO DELGADO;
TERESA DIXON; ELIZABETH DONNELLY; JOHN
DONNELLY; SHAWN DONNELLY; GLORIA DOUGHTY;
FREDERICK DRAKE; KEITH T. DRAKE; RICARDO
DRUMMOND; TIMOTHY DUFFY; DIANA DUKES; FAY
EARLY; CARLOS FELICIANO; ANTHONY FISHER;
CHRISTINE FOWLER; RALPH FOXWORTH; SYBIL
FREEMAN; RICHARD FRENCH; MICHAEL FULLER;
JOSEPH FURNESS; JOHN GALLAGHER; RICHARD
GALLOWAY; LUCINDA GIBBONS; VICTOR GILL; JOAN
GOLDBERG; MICHAEL GOODMAN; LISA GOODS;
DEMETRIA GORDAN; JOHN GREEN; RUTH GREEN;
RONNIE HAAS; NADA HALL; TRACI HALL; ROBIN
HAMES-SMITH; JULIA HAMILTON; CHARLES HAMMOND;
CHARLES HARLEY; JACQUELINE HARRISON; EILEEN
HARVEY; SHARON HATCHER; PATRICK HENDERSON;

-- 1 of 4 --

SEAN HENDERSON; ELIZABETH HENRY; TRACI
HERDER; BURNIE HILL; WILLETTE HILL; GAIL
HOLLAND; JACQUELINE HOLLOWAY; STANLEY HOLMES;
TRUEMANNA HOWLAND; WILLIAM HUBER; MARY HULL;
GERALDINE HUNTER; RONALD HUNTER; MICHAEL
INNAMORATO; GLORIA JACKSON; GLORIA JEFFCOAT
EDWARDS; ESTELLE JENKINS; GENEVA JOHNSON;
HELENE JOHNSON; MELVIN JOHNSON; SAMUEL
JOHNSON; ARLETHA JONES; BERTHA JONES; ERNEST
JONES; MARGARET JONES; LORNA KAPLAN; THOMAS
KEYS; THEODORE KRAUS; JOYCE LAUGHINGHOUSE;
TYRA LAWS; WILLIAM E. LAWTON; KEVIN LEE; JOHN
LEWIS, SR.; PATRICIA LEWIS; WILLIAM LOGAN;
MICHAEL LONG; JOSE LOPEZ; EUGENE LOVE;
CHARLES LUBICKY, JR.; ANTHONY LUCAS; ARTHUR
LUPTON; MARY HELEN MADDEN; WILFREDO MALAVE;
MICHAEL MARATEA; RICHARD MARCHEWKA; RICHARD
MARIOTT; GREGORY MARSHALL; GERALD MAY; DARYL
McCALL; PAUL McCANN; ARNEIDA McNEIL; DORLEEN
McQUEEN; ERMA MERRITT; MARK MICHALOWSKI;
DAWN MIDDLETON-BRYANT; MARY MILLER; JONATHAN
MOODY, JR.; JACQUELIN MOORE; JOSEPH MOORE;
KENNETH MOORE; MICHAEL MORAN; ALVIN MORRIS,
JR.; EUGENIA MUHAMMAD; EDWARD MULHOLLAND;
LINDA MULLIN; JOHN MUNIZZA; JANICE MURPHY;
CLAUDE MYERS; NANETTE NORMAN; JAMES NUSKY,
JR.; BERNARDO OLIVER; SUSAN ORTIZ; WILLIAM ORTIZ;
DENEAN OSBORNE; BRYAN OUTTERBRIDGE; PAUL
PALMER; CLAYTON O. PICKENS; WANDA PICKETT;
AARON PIERCE; RENEE POLES; ANTHONY PORTA;
CHRISTOPHER PORTA; ANN PORTER; ANNAMARIA
POWELL; EARL PRYOR; NINA QUARLES; WILLIAM
QUIGLEY; MARIAN REESE; MARSHALL ROBINSON;
MARTY ROBINSON; MARTA RODRIGUEZ; JULIA
ROGERS; NANCY ROLLINS; WILLIAM ROSS; KEITH
RUSSELL; ROBERT RUSSELL; JOHN SAHOU; JOHN
SCHMIDT; GEORGE SCOTT; KENNETH SHAW; PETER
SHAW; LISA SHELTON; ROBERT SHELTON; CATHERINE
SHIRLEY; KATIE SINGLETON; EUGENE SMITH; KEVIN
SMITH; PHYLLIS SMITH; ROOSEVELT SMITH; SHARON
SMITH; SIDNEY SMITH; FRANCINE SMITH-SHELTON;
2

-- 2 of 4 --

VERONICA SMOKES; CHARLENE SNEAD; RICHARD
SPINELLI; CHARLES SPORT; DENISE ST. JOHN; MARY
STATON; LATANYA M. STEPHENSON; PAMELA L.
STEVENS; WILLIAM E. STEWART, JR.; CHERYL
STOVALL; NATHANIEL SULLIVAN; ALBERT SWINDLE,
JR.; JOHN TARCZEWSKI; ANIKA TAYLOR; BARBARA
THOMAS; PATRICIA THOMAS; BRADFORD THOMPSON;
FLOYD TILLMAN; DONALD TOMES; GEORGE TRAPP;
KIMTHIA TRUESDALE; JANICE TURNER; CHARLES
TURPIN; CORNELL TYLER; UFA UTLEY; LILLIAN
WALKER; WAYNE WALLACE; MICHAEL WEAVER;
FREDERICK WEBB; THERESA WEBER; BERNADETTE
WEST; ROCHELLE WHITTINGTON; RONALD WILCH;
FRED WILEY; IRIS N. WILEY; WILLIAM WILEY; RONALD
WILKINS; ERIC WILLIAMS; JIMMY WILLIAMS; IRVIN
WYATT; PATRICIA YOUNG; TIMOTHY YOUNG, Appellants
v.
CITY OF PHILADELPHIA; THOMAS COSTELLO,
PRISONS COMMISSIONER
On Appeal From the United States District Court
For the Eastern District of Pennsylvania
(D. C. Civ. No. 98-cv-02990)
District Judge: Honorable Jay C. Waldman
Argued: July 31, 2001
Before: BECKER, Chief Judge, McKEE, and
WEIS, Circuit Judges.
(Opinion Filed: August 21, 2001)
3

-- 3 of 4 --

ORDER AMENDING OPINION
The slip opinion in the above case filed August 21, 2001
is amended as follows:
1. On page 4 of the slip opinion, the correct counsel
who argued for Appellees is George A. Voegele, Jr., Esquire.
BY THE COURT:
/s/ Edward R. Becker
Chief Judge
Dated: October 11, 2001
A True Copy:
Teste:
Clerk of the United States Court of Appeals
for the Third Circuit
4

-- 4 of 4 --