CourtListener 9988713•Williams v. Los Angeles County Sheriff's Dept. CA2/8
Williams v. Los Angeles County Sheriff's Dept. CA2/8
CourtListener 9988713CalctappJul 2, 2024
Full text
Filed 7/2/24 Williams v. Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Dept. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
BRIAND WILLIAMS, B323866
Plaintiff and Appellant, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 21STCV16669
v.
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
SHERIFF’S DEPARTMENT,
Defendants and Respondents.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Yolanda Orozco, Judge. Affirmed.
Briand Williams, in pro per., for Plaintiff and Appellant.
No appearance for Defendants and Respondents.
____________________
Briand Williams filed suit on April 30, 2021. By all
indications, he did not serve any defendant. The trial court held
a case management conference on August 31, 2021. No one
appeared.
On September 23, 2021, the court heard an order to show
cause why the case should not be dismissed for failure to appear
and for failure to prosecute. No one appeared. The court
dismissed the case the same day.
On August 5, 2022, Williams filed a motion to set aside and
to vacate the dismissal pursuant to section 473 of the Code of
Civil Procedure. Unspecified code citations are to this code.
On September 1, 2022, the court denied Williams’s section
473 motion.
The court ruled Williams’s untimely motion violated section
473’s jurisdictional time limit of six months.
Williams moved for reconsideration on September 14, 2022.
The court denied this motion on October 6, 2022. Motions for
reconsideration require a showing of new facts relating to the
motion at hand. The court ruled Williams had not offered facts or
law that Williams could not have presented at the first hearing.
Williams cited Lewis v. Superior Court (1985) 175
Cal.App.3d 366 (Lewis), which the trial court stated did not give
it discretion to waive or toll section 473’s six-month requirement.
Williams filed a notice of appeal on October 6, 2022.
The trial court correctly applied the six-month time
requirement of section 473. “This six-month time limitation is
jurisdictional; the court has no power to grant relief under section
473 once the time has lapsed.” (Austin v. Los Angeles Unified
School Dist. (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 918, 928.)
Williams cites Loeb v. County of San Diego (2019) 43
Cal.App.5th 421, 430, which is not on point because it did not
involve section 473. In the context of a ruling on a summary
judgment motion and a discussion of competing proposed verdict
forms, the Loeb court held that a trial court can correct its own
2
error if it, on reflection, has concluded an earlier interim order
was erroneous. (Ibid.)
The same goes for Lewis, supra, 175 Cal.App.3d 366, which
Williams also cites. The Lewis case tolled a statute of limitation
when compliance with the statute was impossible. (Id. at p. 380.)
The decision did not involve section 473.
Lewis is inapplicable for another reason as well. Lewis
involved a plaintiff’s situation that made it literally impossible to
meet a deadline. Williams has not made a showing of
impossibility. For this same reason, his citation of section 3531 of
the Civil Code is inapt. This five-word statute states “The law
never requires impossibilities.”
First we review Lewis.
Plaintiff Lewis retained attorney Bartlett, who engaged in
pre-complaint settlement discussions with a defense insurance
company. Bartlett calendared March 16, 1984, for the filing of a
complaint for Lewis if parties had not finalized the settlement.
(Lewis, supra, 175 Cal.App.3d at p. 370.) On March 12, 1984, a
car hit Bartlett, who “suffered severe, life-threatening injuries to
his head and body that totally disabled him mentally and
physically beyond the March 17, 1984, deadline for filing
plaintiff’s personal injury complaint. Bones in Bartlett’s forehead
were crushed; his temple bones, facial bones and nose were
fractured; his ribs and legs suffered multiple fractures, and he
developed a cerebral hematoma. [⁋] Emergency surgery was
performed and Bartlett remained in the . . . intensive care unit
until recovering consciousness on March 22.” (Ibid., italics
added.)
3
Williams offered argument and evidence about the extent of
hardships he has faced, which are lamentable. They do not,
however, match the impossibility of the Lewis situation.
Williams attached his declaration and exhibits to his
section 473 motion. We review these pages in some detail.
Williams’s August 2022 declaration stated the following.
Williams has mobility and vision impairment issues and
has been homeless for years. It is a very difficult task to travel
from San Diego by bus to attend court hearings. Williams once
traveled from San Diego for a Los Angeles court hearing, but the
court made him wait. He missed his ride back and was stranded
in Los Angeles. “The streets are very cold everywhere and now
since [Williams] is in far worst health, and homeless as well this
court is not going to care at all.”
On August 18, 2021, the wind blew a heavy overhead car
hatch down on Williams’s head. Weeks later, a hospital
diagnosed his condition as post concussion syndrome. Williams
asserted he was in the emergency room on or about September 8
to 9, 2021 and since August 2021 has had a difficult time trying
to function and take care of himself.
Williams “did not come to remember” about the scheduled
case management conference because “he had been placed on bed
rest and pills.”
Williams declared that two doctors saw him, as described in
Exhibits A and B.
Exhibit A is one page of a hospital’s nine-page “After Visit
Summary” stating a doctor saw Williams due to “headache” and
that the diagnosis was “post concussion syndrome.” This visit
apparently was September 8 or 9, 2021, or both, at a Cedars-
Sinai facility listing a phone number in the (310) area code.
4
Apparently Williams selected this Los Angeles hospital for
medical care. The hospital’s recommendation was to schedule a
visit with a Cedars-Sinai neurologist in Los Angeles.
Exhibit B is one page of a three-page “after visit summary”
of a doctor visit on November 11, 2021. The locale again was a
Cedars-Sinai facility listing a (310) area code phone number.
“Today you were seen for fatigue. We think this is due to the
head trauma that you had several months ago.” The instructions
were to schedule an appointment with a neurologist and to return
for a follow-up appointment in five weeks. There was also a
referral to a “dietitian/nutrition” facility, again in Los Angeles.
Williams declared a doctor, on December 2, 2021, concluded
he needed physical, speech, and occupational therapy, as detailed
in Exhibit C. Exhibit C is a packet of selected pages: pages one,
four, five, and six of a six-page “after visit summary” of a Los
Angeles Cedars-Sinai doctor visit on December 2, 2021. Page one
stated Williams saw a doctor “for: Consult. The following issues
were addressed: Post concussion syndrome and Chronic post-
traumatic headache, not intractable.” This page also stated
Williams could pick up a prescribed medication at a pharmacy in
Inglewood, California. The page listed three referrals: one to
speech therapy at a Los Angeles address and one each to
occupational and physical therapy with no listed addresses. The
remainder of these pages is a generic description of post-
concussion syndrome that includes the statement that
“[s]ymptoms usually go away on their own over time.” There are
other instructions, including to “[g]radually return to your
normal activity level. If a certain activity brings on your
symptoms, stop or slow down until you can do the activity
without it triggering your symptoms.”
5
Williams declared he saw more doctors on December 16,
2021 and on February 24, March 17 and May 5, 2022, as detailed
in Exhibits D, E, and F. Williams declared he also suffered a
stroke during this time.
Exhibit D is one page of a three-page “after visit summary”
dated December 16, 2021. This Cedars-Sinai form summarized
Williams’s Los Angeles visit as a follow-up concerning “Fatigue,
unspecified type, Class 2 obesity . . . and Hyperlipidemia . . . .”
The “Instructions” were that Williams had been seen for fatigue,
that Williams should continue with his prescribed medication,
that Williams was referred for a sleep study to rule out another
possible cause of his fatigue, that Williams was started on a
cholesterol medication, and that he should start changing his diet
to eat fruits and vegetables and to stop eating candy and fast
food. The form advised Williams to pick up his prescriptions at a
pharmacy in Inglewood, California.
Exhibit E is one page of a two-page “after visit summary”
dated February 24, 2022. This Cedars-Sinai form summarized
Williams’s Los Angeles visit as a follow-up concerning
hyperlipidemia, asymptomatic microscopic hematuria, and
chronic low back pain. The form recommended Williams return
in about three months and noted his March 2022 appointment
with a Los Angeles neurologist.
Also included in this exhibit are 12 pages of generic
information about strokes. These pages appear to be some type
of general brochure or handout. They do not mention Williams.
No medical record in Williams’s motion suggests he suffered a
stroke.
Exhibit F is a one page reminder that Williams was
scheduled for a May 5, 2022 appointment with a Los Angeles
6
neurologist. There also is one page of a two-page “after visit
summary” dated May 5, 2022. This Cedars-Sinai form
summarized Williams’s Los Angeles visit as a follow-up
appointment. Multiple redactions and an omitted page make it
difficult to draw further conclusions concerning this visit. The
form recommended Williams return in about three months.
Exhibit G is one page of a two-page “after visit summary”
dated August 4, 2022. This Cedars-Sinai form summarized
Williams’s Los Angeles visit as a follow-up appointment. The
doctor instructed Williams to get a sleep study to rule out sleep
apnea as a cause of Williams’s hypersomnia. The form noted
Williams’s upcoming appointment with a Los Angeles doctor in
September 2022. There is also a one-page form entitled “sleep
study referral” with a telephone number for appointments.
Williams concluded his declaration with the statement that
“Plaintiff is unable to adequately represent myself as need be in a
clearly and consciously manner so that Plaintiff, can express his
thoughts and speak clearly without the possibility of stuttering
over his vocabulary when trying to address the court in a
respectful manner as required so I am asking for this time to
heal.”
Williams supplied the trial court with documents
suggesting his medical situation is at best a partial explanation
of his delay in pursuing his litigation. Williams included only
portions of his records. He redacted parts of the pages he did
supply. No page supports Williams’s claim that he suffered a
stroke.
Williams evidently has suffered ongoing problems with
headaches and other medical issues. The documents he
submitted suggest Williams was able to make and keep medical
7
appointments in Los Angeles. They do not describe a situation
like the Lewis case.
DISPOSITION
We affirm the dismissal. We award no costs. The
respondents did not appear or file briefing.
WILEY, J.
We concur:
GRIMES, Acting P. J.
VIRAMONTES, J.
8
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.