CourtListener 9716530•In re E.L. CA2/3
Full text
Filed 6/21/24 In re E.L. CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re E.L. et al., Persons Coming B331243
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
Los Angeles County
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Super. Ct. Nos.
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN 18CCJP05419F,
AND FAMILY SERVICES, 18CCJP05419G,
18CCJP05419H,
Plaintiff and Respondent, 18CCJP05419I,
18CCJP05419J
v.
H.L., Sr.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Tiana J. Murillo, Judge. Dismissed.
Robert McLaughlin, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Sally Son, Deputy County Counsel,
for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________
Father appeals from the juvenile court’s jurisdictional
and dispositional findings and orders relating to his five children.
The court declared the children dependents of the juvenile court
under section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code1 based
on father’s and mother’s conduct and removed them from parents’
custody. Father contends substantial evidence did not support
the court’s jurisdictional findings based on his history of
substance abuse, and there was insufficient evidence to justify
removing the children from his custody. Mother is not a party
to this appeal.
While this appeal was pending, the juvenile court returned
the children to father’s custody. Father’s appeal is moot. The
children would remain dependents of the juvenile court even if
we were to reverse the jurisdictional findings against father, and
there is no effective relief we can provide him now that the court
has placed the children in his custody. Father nevertheless asks
us to exercise our discretion to consider the merits of his appeal.
We decline to do so and dismiss his appeal as moot.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND2
Father has five children with mother: E.L. (born October
2010), Jay.L. (born April 2012), H.L. (born September 2013), Z.L.
(born May 2015), and Jas.L. (born August 2018).
1. Past dependency petition
In December 2018, the juvenile court sustained a section
300 petition on behalf of the children based on parents’ domestic
1 Statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.
2 We include facts relating to mother only as necessary
for background and to our analysis.
2
violence in the children’s presence; father’s creation of a
detrimental home environment in having had ammunition,
methamphetamine, marijuana, and knives in areas accessible
to the children; and father’s “unresolved history of substance
abuse,” including with methamphetamine.
In November 2020, the juvenile court terminated
jurisdiction and issued a juvenile custody order granting
mother sole legal and physical custody of the children and
father monitored visitation three times a week for three hours
each visit. Father’s visitation was monitored due to his failure
to complete court-ordered programs: a drug abuse treatment
program with random drug testing, a domestic violence program
for offenders, a parenting course, and individual counseling.
2. Current dependency petition
The Los Angeles County Department of Children and
Family Services (DCFS) again became involved with the family
in early April 2023 when it received a report about mother’s
neglect of the children. According to the reporting party, mother
was homeless—staying at different motels with the children—
and had a history of using “crystal meth” daily. She was
leaving the children unattended; they sometimes would go
a day without eating. The children had said mother had
hit E.L. and Jay.L. with a wire and asked E.L. to hold her
drug paraphernalia.
About three weeks earlier, paternal great-aunt had picked
the children up from a motel and brought them to her house
to care for them.3 E.L. had called her because the children were
3 Jay.L., however, had been staying with maternal aunt
for the past two months, not paternal great-aunt.
3
hungry. At the time, father was living with paternal great-aunt
and was enrolled in domestic violence classes. He had been
released from jail in October 2022.
After receiving the report, DCFS contacted paternal
great-aunt. She told the social worker the children weren’t
attending school and hadn’t seen a doctor in months. They
felt unsafe with mother and did not want to return to her care.
Paternal great-aunt said father had been living with her before
the children had arrived. She was willing to ask father to leave
so the children could remain in her home.4
DCFS interviewed the children about mother and father.
They had seen mother use drugs. They described mother
smoking in the bathroom all day, sometimes with friends. She
left pipes and “bongs” out in the bathroom. Mother also left the
children alone in the motel room all day, leaving E.L. in charge.
Mother hit the children, sometimes leaving marks and bruises.
Jay.L. said the children sometimes called father when they
had not eaten. He would bring them food.
Jay.L. said father “used to use drugs too but not anymore.”
He was “doing a lot better now” and worked at UPS. E.L. also
said father was working for UPS and had given paternal great-
aunt money to buy the children school clothes and food. She and
H.L. said father lived in the home, spent time with them there,
and “was nice to them.” E.L. and H.L. denied having seen father
use drugs while in paternal great-aunt’s home. E.L. said he
was “doing a lot better now” and stated, “ ‘I love my dad.’ ”
4 Paternal great-aunt’s husband, paternal grandmother,
paternal uncles, and paternal aunt—as well as father—also lived
in the home.
4
Father told the social worker he was aware of mother’s
and the children’s living situation. He said the children had
called paternal great-aunt several times when mother had not
paid the motel, leaving them with nowhere to stay. On those
occasions, he gave money to paternal great-aunt to pay the motel
for a few more days. When asked why he personally hadn’t done
anything to protect the children, father said he didn’t want to
have any direct contact with mother given their history. He
denied ever witnessing mother use drugs but thought she was
using methamphetamine.
Father admitted he used to use methamphetamine but
said he had been sober since his release from jail on October 5,
2022, for possessing a firearm. He was on probation. He said he
regularly checked in with his probation officer and drug tested.
Father submitted to a drug test for DCFS, and the results were
negative for all substances. After his release from jail, father
was advised to enroll in individual counseling, domestic violence
classes, and substance abuse services. He had enrolled in
domestic violence classes but said he didn’t have the resources
to enroll in the other services. Father was willing to move out
of paternal great-aunt’s home so the children could remain there.
On April 13, 2023, DCFS obtained a removal order
authorizing the children’s detention from parents. All five
children were placed in paternal great-aunt’s home. Father
immediately moved out.
On April 17, 2023, DCFS filed a section 300 petition
on behalf of the children based on (1) mother’s substance abuse,
her physical abuse and neglect of the children, and her emotional
abuse and medical neglect of Z.L., whose ADHD diagnosis mother
had failed to treat; and (2) father’s substance abuse. The petition
5
alleged father “has a history and is a current abuser of
methamphetamine which renders [him] incapable of providing
regular care and supervision of the children”; due to her
young age, Jas.L. required “constant care and supervision and
. . . father’s substance abuse interferes with providing regular
care and supervision of the child”; and the children were former
dependents of the juvenile court due to father’s substance abuse.5
At the initial hearing the next day, the juvenile court
ordered the children detained from parents and that parents’
visitation be monitored.
3. Pre-adjudication reports
DCFS filed its jurisdiction/disposition report on May 19,
2023 and an interim review report on June 1, 2023. Father’s
criminal history included arrests and/or citations from October
2015 to July 2022 for spousal battery, infliction of corporal injury
on a spouse, possession of a controlled substance and possession
of a controlled substance for sale, violation of court orders, and
robbery.6 An April 25, 2023 letter from father’s probation officer
stated father had been convicted on October 5, 2022 for vehicle
theft and possession of a firearm.7 Father’s probation did
not include drug testing terms, but father had tested once
5 DCFS filed an amended petition alleging additional counts
against mother. It asked the court to dismiss the counts relating
to Z.L.’s diagnosis.
6 Father’s most recent arrest or citation for possession of
a controlled substance was in April 2021.
7 Father was released with time served.
6
on November 15, 2022, with negative results. Father was
in compliance with his probation terms.
The jurisdiction report stated father “reported having
abused methamphetamine as early as October 2022.” In his
DCFS interview after that report was filed, however, father
stated it had been more than a year and a half since he last
had used methamphetamine. Father clarified October 2022
was when he was released from jail—in other words, he
had not resumed using methamphetamine after his release.
Father stated he began using methamphetamine when he was
about 20 years old and marijuana when he was 11 years old.
He also had become active in a gang at a young age. Father
acknowledged the earlier domestic violence with mother.
Father was not participating in a substance abuse
treatment program. He said he had stayed sober “with the
support of his girlfriend and the motivation of reunifying with
the children.” Father submitted to one drug test in April 2023
and four in May 2023. Each test was negative for all substances.
Father knew mother had smoked marijuana in the past
but said he had had no reason to believe mother was using drugs.
He had had little contact with her after his release in October
2022. Father said he would have been able to tell if mother were
abusing drugs based on his past abuse of methamphetamine and
marijuana. He also told DCFS he did not know mother had been
physically abusing the children. The children never told him
about the abuse or that they feared mother. When the children
called him for food or money, he dropped it off with E.L. outside
the motel. He also had paternal grandmother bring the children
what they needed. In the past, mother had been appropriate
with the children. He said that, because he believed mother
7
“was a good mother[,] he never ‘stepped up’ to be more active in
the children’s lives.” He would visit the children when they were
at paternal grandmother’s home or during family gatherings.
As for the allegations against mother, the children
consistently stated mother used drugs in their presence, hit
and yelled at them, and neglected them. They feared mother
and did not feel safe with her. Mother denied the allegations.
The older children discussed father’s substance abuse
with DCFS. E.L. knew father had used marijuana and
methamphetamine in the past, as she had seen the drugs and
drug paraphernalia in their home. E.L. also was aware father
had served jail time due to drug charges during the earlier
dependency case. Jay.L. and H.L. similarly were aware of
father’s past drug use.
All three children stated father currently was not abusing
drugs. E.L. said she knew father was sober because he visited
them consistently, was emotionally present during visits, and
had tested for DCFS. Jay.L. said father did not have any drugs
or paraphernalia with him on visits. She didn’t believe father
would visit them on Saturdays and Sundays if he were abusing
drugs. H.L. also mentioned father’s visits—that he was “awake”
and played with the children and brought food so they could
have a meal together.
Father reported regularly visiting the children at paternal
great-aunt’s home. He hoped to have longer visits, or to move
into the home, to help paternal great-aunt with the children.
Paternal great-aunt monitored father’s visits and said they were
appropriate. Paternal great-aunt said she had asked father to
make himself available for longer visits or to visit on more days.
8
DCFS concluded it currently was unsafe to release
the children to mother or father. DCFS did not believe the
children’s safety and well-being could be ensured without
court intervention. It again noted father had reported using
methamphetamine as early as October 2022. It also noted
father’s failure to reunify with the children in the previous
matter and that he had failed to protect the children from mother
“even after having suspicion of . . . mother’s substance abuse.”
DCFS recommended the children be declared dependents
and parents receive family reunification services.
The originally-scheduled June 6, 2023 adjudication hearing
was continued to July 18, 2023. In its interim report filed
before the continued hearing, DCFS explained Jay.L. had been
hospitalized in May 2023 after attempting to hang herself with
an electrical cord and other self-harm. She identified “family
dynamics and unresolved anger and resentment with dad”
as “[t]riggers.”
DCFS also noted father had tested negative for all
substances on June 1, 6, and 14, 2023. He tested positive
for marijuana, however, on June 21 and 26, and July 6, 2023.
Father admitted he had resumed smoking marijuana to address
a toothache. He did not see it as an issue because he did not
smoke in the presence of the children and did not visit them
while under the influence of marijuana.
By July 2023, father had attended 14 of 52 sessions of
his domestic violence program and had missed two sessions. He
also had enrolled in a parenting course and had attended four
of 10 sessions.
9
4. Combined adjudication and disposition hearing
Father submitted written stipulated testimony for the
combined adjudication and disposition hearing signed by all
counsel. If called, he would testify that, when he told the social
worker he had been sober from methamphetamine since his
release from jail on October 5, 2022, he meant that he had not
“used at all” since his release. He did not mean that he had
used on that date and never said he had used methamphetamine
on that date. He did not use methamphetamine while he was
incarcerated or after his October 2022 release. As of July 2023,
he had not used methamphetamine “for about two years” and
had not been cited or charged with any drug-related offenses
“in over two years.” The juvenile court accepted father’s
stipulated testimony, took judicial notice of the case file, and
admitted into evidence DCFS’s, father’s, and mother’s exhibits.
Counsel for father asked the court to dismiss the
allegations against father, arguing there was insufficient
evidence of a current risk of harm to the children based on
his past methamphetamine use. Counsel argued father had
not used methamphetamine since his release from jail and
voluntarily had drug tested for DCFS with all negative results
for methamphetamine. Father admitted to using marijuana,
but counsel argued he had not cared for the children while under
the influence or used it in their presence. Counsel also noted
paternal great-aunt had declared she smelled marijuana on
father only once during the six months that he lived in the home.
Counsel argued DCFS had presented no evidence aside from
father’s “historical use of methamphetamine,” and had not
demonstrated a nexus between that past use and a current
risk of harm to the children.
10
The children’s counsel noted father had not completed
a drug treatment program and currently was testing positive
for marijuana use, which would be considered a “mind-altering
substance” in a drug treatment program. She argued father
therefore still was not sober and noted Jas.L. was very young,
at only four years old. Counsel argued those facts, coupled with
father’s history of methamphetamine use and “lack of programs,
creates a nexus.” DCFS’s counsel joined the children’s counsel,
arguing the risk of harm was not “just” based on father’s past
drug use, but the fact he had never completed a substance
abuse program and now was testing positive for marijuana.
The juvenile court sustained the counts against mother
except for those alleging she medically neglected and emotionally
abused Z.L. The court sustained the two identical counts
alleged against father under section 300, subdivisions (b)
and (j), amending them to state he was a “ ‘recent abuser
of methamphetamine,’ ” rather than a “current abuser.” The
court noted there was no evidence father had ameliorated
his methamphetamine abuse issues—he had not completed
a program or complied with the prior court orders. The court
commended father for his negative drug tests, but noted his
positive tests for marijuana. The court found that, given the
court’s prior sustained petition as to father, the lack of evidence
that father had addressed those issues, and the ages of the
children, a current risk of harm to the children existed, “until
[the court could] see some addressing of the issues with [father].”
The juvenile court found the children were described under
section 300 and declared them dependents of the court.
As to disposition, father’s counsel asked that father’s
visitation be unmonitored and that he have two, unmonitored,
11
overnight visits with the children in paternal great-aunt’s home
per week. The children’s counsel joined in father’s request
for unmonitored overnight visits, stating the children and
paternal great-aunt said father’s visits had been consistent
and appropriate. Counsel noted the children would like to return
to father’s care, but that was not the current request, and she
“wouldn’t have been in agreement with that.” Counsel for DCFS
objected to overnight visitation at that time, stating it would
be premature.
The court found by clear and convincing evidence that
the children could not safely be released to either parent’s
custody until the court saw “remediation of some of these issues.”
The court removed the children from parents’ custody and
ordered them suitably placed. The court ordered that father
have unmonitored visits with the children, as well as two
overnight visits a week in paternal great-aunt’s home, and
gave DCFS discretion to liberalize. The court ordered father
to participate in random and on-demand drug testing, a 12-step
program, and substance abuse counseling alongside individual
counseling to address child safety and other case-related issues.
5. Post-appeal developments
On January 16, 2024, before father filed his opening brief,
the juvenile court terminated its suitable placement order for
the children and ordered the children placed in father’s custody.
With its respondent’s brief, DCFS filed a motion asking us to
take judicial notice, or accept as additional evidence, the court’s
January 16, 2024 minute orders. We granted the unopposed
motion on March 12, 2024.
12
DISCUSSION
1. Father’s appeal is moot
“[T]he critical factor in considering whether a dependency
appeal is moot is whether the appellate court can provide any
effective relief if it finds reversible error.” (In re N.S. (2016) 245
Cal.App.4th 53, 60, quoted by In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266,
276 (D.P.).) “[R]elief is effective when it ‘can have a practical,
tangible impact on the parties’ conduct or legal status.’ ” (D.P.,
at p. 277.)
An appeal may be rendered moot where “jurisdictional
findings have been made as to both parents but only one parent
brings a challenge.” (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 283.) Father’s
appeal does not challenge the jurisdictional findings against
mother and she has not appealed the court’s order. Thus, even
if we were to reverse the jurisdictional findings against father,
the juvenile court would continue to have jurisdiction over the
children. (Ibid. [“[T]he principle that ‘[d]ependency jurisdiction
attaches to a child, not to his or her parent’ [citation], means that
‘ “[a]s long as there is one unassailable jurisdictional finding, it is
immaterial that another might be inappropriate.” ’ ”].) An appeal
is not moot, however, where the jurisdictional finding against
the appealing parent “ ‘serves as the basis for dispositional orders
that are also challenged on appeal.’ ” (Ibid.)
Here, father also challenges the court’s disposition order
removing his children from his custody. He contends substantial
evidence did not support the removal order and, as the court’s
jurisdictional findings against him formed the basis of the order,
his challenge of those findings is justiciable. Nevertheless, as the
children have been placed in father’s custody, the removal order
no longer adversely affects his custody rights. Accordingly, there
13
is no effective relief we could grant father, even if we were to
agree the court’s findings on which the order was based lacked
sufficient evidence. (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 276 [for
relief to be “ ‘effective’ ” parent must complain of ongoing harm
“capable of being rectified by the outcome” the parent seeks].)
Similarly, father’s complaint of the jurisdictional findings’ stigma
is “insufficient to sustain” his appeal, as any stigma from those
findings no longer affects father’s legal status in a way that
we can redress due to the court’s termination of its suitable
placement order and entry of its home of father order. (Id.
at p. 277.) Father’s appeal therefore is moot.
2. We decline to exercise our discretion to review
the merits of father’s appeal
“Even when a case is moot, courts may exercise their
‘inherent discretion’ to reach the merits of the dispute.” (D.P.,
supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 282.) Generally, that discretion is
exercised “when ‘the case presents an issue of broad public
interest that is likely to recur,’ ‘when there may be a recurrence
of the controversy between the parties,’ or ‘when a material
question remains for the court’s determination.’ ” (Ibid.)
Father’s appeal presents none of these circumstances.
Recently, our high court identified a non-exhaustive
list of factors for assessing whether a court should exercise
discretionary review of a moot appeal in a dependency
proceeding. (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 286.) Courts may
consider (1) “whether the challenged jurisdictional finding ‘could
be prejudicial to the appellant or could potentially impact the
current or future dependency proceedings,’ or ‘ “could have
other consequences for [the appellant], beyond jurisdiction” ’ ”;
(2) “whether the jurisdictional finding is based on particularly
14
pernicious or stigmatizing conduct”; and (3) “why the appeal
became moot.” (Id. at pp. 285–286.) Although, “no single factor
is necessarily dispositive of whether a court should exercise
discretionary review of a moot appeal,” a court ultimately “should
be guided by the overarching goals of the dependency system”
in deciding whether to exercise that discretion on a case-by-case
basis. (Id. at pp. 286–287.)
Father asks us to exercise our discretionary review
to reach the merits of his appeal. He contends discretionary
review is appropriate because (1) the court’s jurisdiction findings
based on his history of substance abuse, and disposition findings
that his conduct endangered the children, stigmatize father
as an “ ‘offending parent’ ” and “chronic substance abuser” and
will prejudice him in any future dependency and family court
proceedings; (2) his “ ‘laudable behavior’—substantial progress
‘toward alleviating or mitigating the causes necessitating
placement’—arguably rendered” his appeal moot; and
(3) dismissal essentially would insulate the “ ‘erroneous’ ”
jurisdictional and dispositional findings from review. (Quoting
D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 285–286.)
Father argues DCFS’s reliance on the 2018 sustained
petition to support the court’s findings in this proceeding
demonstrates how the current findings similarly could
prejudice him in future proceedings. His claim of future
prejudice is nevertheless speculative. Even if we were to reverse
the jurisdictional and dispositional findings, a court in a future
dependency or family court proceeding still could consider the
historical facts and circumstances on which the current petition
and removal order were based, along with father’s earlier case
with DCFS and the juvenile court. (See, e.g., In re Madison S.
15
(2017) 15 Cal.App.5th 308, 330 [allegation comprising challenged
jurisdictional finding “would almost certainly be available in
any future dependency or family court proceeding, regardless
of any determination on our part as to whether it formed an
independent basis for juvenile court jurisdiction”].) Moreover,
based on the 2020 juvenile court custody order, father was
noncustodial when the current proceedings began. Mother had
both physical and legal custody of the children, and father was
limited to monitored visitation due to his failure to complete his
court-ordered programs. That custody order would be available
in any future proceeding involving the children. (Evid. Code,
§ 452, subds. (c) & (d).) Of course, in any such future proceeding,
father would have an equal opportunity to present the court’s
orders in this matter to show the court awarded him unmonitored
and overnight visitation and—after finding he had made
substantial progress—ultimately placed the children in his
custody.
Nor do we find the jurisdictional and dispositional
findings against father were based “on particularly pernicious or
stigmatizing conduct” so as to raise a concern over not insulating
erroneous and stigmatizing jurisdiction findings from review
to warrant exercise of our discretion to reach the merits. (D.P.,
supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 285–286 [“The more egregious the
findings against the parent, the greater the parent’s interest in
challenging such findings.”].) And, although we commend father
for making substantial progress to ameliorate or mitigate the
case issues that led the court to terminate its suitable placement
order and place the children with him, “no single factor is
16
necessarily dispositive of whether a court should exercise
discretionary review of a moot appeal.” (Id. at p. 286.)8
On balance, after considering all the pertinent factors
and the totality of the evidence in the record, we conclude
discretionary review of father’s moot appeal is not warranted.
DISPOSITION
The appeal is dismissed as moot.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
EGERTON, J.
We concur:
LAVIN, Acting P. J.
ADAMS, J.
8 Father may have forfeited his challenge of the removal
order in any event. Although he asked for the children to be
placed with him at the initial hearing, father did not ask for
custody at disposition. His counsel asked for overnight and
unmonitored visits, which is what the court ordered.
17
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.