Light Wireless Communications v. Jaffe CA4/1

CourtListener 9608060CalctappJun 20, 2024

Full text

Filed 6/20/24 Light Wireless Communications v. Jaffe CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or
ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

LIGHT WIRELESS D081842
COMMUNICATIONS, LLC, et al.,

Plaintiffs and Respondents,
(Super. Ct. No. 37-2020-
v. 00006157-CU-BC-CTL)

DOUGLAS JAFFE,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Carolyn M. Caietti, Judge. Affirmed.
Law Office of Douglas Jaffe and Douglas Jaffe, in pro per., for
Defendant and Appellant.
MBK Chapman, Jason K. Boss and William D. Chapman for Plaintiffs
and Respondents.
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Douglas Jaffe appeals from an order awarding $10,000 in discovery
sanctions to Light Wireless Communications, LLC. By memorandum
opinion, we conclude the trial court did not abuse its discretion in issuing the
sanctions. (Cal. Stds. Jud. Admin., § 8.1; People v. Garcia (2002)
97 Cal.App.4th 847, 851-854.) We therefore affirm.
A court may impose a monetary sanction for misuse of the discovery
process, which includes failing to respond to discovery, providing evasive
responses, disobeying a court order to provide discovery, or unsuccessfully
opposing a discovery motion. (Clement v. Alegre (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 1277,
1285 (Clement).) If a monetary sanction is authorized, the court shall impose
that sanction unless the party subject to the sanction acted with substantial
justification. (Code Civ. Proc., § 2023.030(a).)
We review orders imposing sanctions for abuse of discretion. (People v.
Edwards (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1259, 1266.) “[T]his standard of review is
highly deferential to the trial court’s wide discretion in determining the facts,
choosing from the array of available sanctions, and deciding the severity of
any sanction chosen.” (People v. Landers (2019) 31 Cal.App.5th 288, 304.)
Due process considerations require that the sanction is suitable and
necessary to enable the party seeking discovery to obtain the objects of the
discovery sought, but the court may not impose sanctions designed to punish.
(Petersen v. City of Vallejo (1968) 259 Cal.App.2d 757, 782.) We will reverse a
sanctions order only if the trial court’s action was arbitrary, capricious, or
whimsical. (Clement, supra, 177 Cal.App.4th at p. 1286.)
Jaffe contends Light Wireless failed to properly meet and confer before
filing its motion and the trial court ignored his opposing separate statement
regarding each special interrogatory at issue. Jaffe asserts the true reason
for the sanction was to punish him but provides no argument or record
support for such contention. Based on our review of the record, Jaffe’s claims
have no merit.

2
The trial court ordered the instant sanction after Jaffe’s seventh
supplemental response to Light Wireless’ special interrogatories in this legal
malpractice lawsuit brought by Jaffe’s former clients. This was the third
time the trial court ordered monetary sanctions against Jaffe. The court
previously ordered him to pay Light Wireless $4,365 for failure to adequately
respond to document requests.
Regarding the special interrogatories at issue, Jaffe initially responded
with boilerplate objections. After Jaffe ignored counsel’s meet and confer
letter, Light Wireless filed a motion to compel seeking over $9,000 in
sanctions. Jaffe supplemented his responses just before the hearing. For
almost all responses, he cited section 2030.230 and directed Light Wireless to
his “document production, the Court file, and the file that was received by
Plaintiffs at the time Jaffe substituted out” of the underlying cases.
Among other insufficiencies, the trial court found Jaffe’s reliance on
section 2030.230 was “incomplete” as that provision requires the responding
party to specify the responsive documents “in ‘sufficient detail to permit the
propounding party to locate and to identify’” the documents, which Jaffe’s
responses failed to do. The court also found that Jaffe’s late supplemental
responses showed “indicia of inappropriate gamesmanship.” The court
compelled code-complaint responses without objections to 145 out of 148
special interrogatories and sanctioned Jaffe $5,000. What followed was a
series of supplemental responses and meet and confer letters, culminating in
Jaffe’s seventh supplement that is the subject of Light Wireless’ motion.
Jaffe’s contention that Light Wireless failed to properly meet and
confer prior to filing their motion is disingenuous, as Light Wireless sent
three comprehensive meet and confer letters in the process. After Jaffe’s
sixth supplemental response, which he served just two days after his fifth,

3
Light Wireless made clear in its final meet and confer letter that its next
move would be for monetary, evidentiary, and terminating sanctions absent
code-complaint responses. Jaffe’s seventh supplement was still insufficient
and largely the same as his sixth, contrary to his claim that they are
“substantially different.” Light Wireless’ effort to meet and confer prior to
moving for sanctions was reasonable, as well as the court’s finding that any
additional effort would not have been fruitful. (Clement, supra,
177 Cal.App.4th at p. 1294.)
Contrary to Jaffe’s claim that the trial court did not consider his
responsive separate statement, Jaffe and the court referenced his separate
statement at the hearing, Jaffe conceded that he could supplement some
responses, the court reconsidered the requests that Jaffe urged he could not
further respond to, and the court ultimately identified over 70 responses that
Jaffe could and was required to supplement.
Without addressing each deficiency, Jaffe’s seventh supplemental
response still referenced his entire document production and the underlying
case dockets. The court had warned Jaffe this was insufficient, Light
Wireless raised the issue again in its final meet and confer letter, and as
stated in the court’s order on appeal, “[t]his continues to remain the case with
the seventh supplemental responses for many of the interrogatory responses.”
Jaffe argues, as he did below, that he did not reference just “Jaffe Document
Production” but rather specified the pages of the document production.
However, he “specified” pages 1-127 each time, which is his entire production.
Similarly, while Jaffe contends he specified the court register of action
numbers, it appears he identified the entire range of entries for each docket.
The sanctions were not “arbitrary, capricious, or whimsical” in light of
Jaffe’s conduct, which included providing evasive responses and refusing to

4
comply with a discovery order. There is no indication the court issued the
sanctions as a means of punishment; rather, the court made clear “the
monetary sanctions are intended not to penalize anyone.” The court selected
an amount that would motivate Jaffe to comply with his discovery
obligations. While Jaffe contends the amount Light Wireless requested—
$28,000—was unreasonable, the court reduced the award to $12,000 in its
tentative and further reduced it to $10,000 in its final order after hearing
argument. Besides a passing reference to block billing in his briefs, Jaffe
makes no argument that the $10,000 was an unreasonable amount to award.
Finally, Jaffe contends Light Wireless “had a pattern of needlessly
moving to compel and seeking excessive sanctions” based on one motion to
compel responses to document requests that Light Wireless subsequently
withdrew. Without expressing any opinion on the legitimacy of this
contention, it has no bearing on Light Wireless’ justification for seeking
sanctions for Jaffe’s failure to provide previously-ordered code-complaint
responses to special interrogatories.
DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed. Light Wireless is to recover its costs on appeal.

CASTILLO, J.

WE CONCUR:

DATO, Acting P. J.

KELETY, J.

5

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.