CourtListener 9541516•People v. Roberts CA4/1
Full text
Filed 6/12/24 P. v. Roberts CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D081739
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
(Super. Ct. No. SCD287551)
ANTHONY B. ROBERTS,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Aaron H. Katz, Judge. Reversed in part, affirmed in part as modified, and
remanded with directions.
Heather E. Shallenberger, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Arlene A.
Sevidal and Christopher P. Beesley, Deputy Attorneys General, Plaintiff and
Respondent.
A jury found Anthony B. Roberts guilty of committing two counts of
sodomy with a child under age 14 (Pen. Code,1 § 286, subd. (c)(1)) (counts 1–
2); four counts of oral copulation with a child under age 14 (§ 287, subd. (c)(1))
(counts 3–6); and four counts of lewd acts upon a child under age 14 (§ 288,
subd. (a)) (counts 7–10). After making true findings on various aggravating
factors, the trial court sentenced Roberts to a prison term of 18 years.
The sole contested factual issue at trial was whether the victim was
under the age of 14 at the time Roberts committed the relevant acts. Roberts
contends that insufficient evidence supports such a finding. He further
contends that the trial court erred in refusing to give a clarifying jury
instruction regarding the victim’s age.
We conclude that due to the fact that the victim was adopted from an
Ethiopian orphanage at the stated age of three and a half, and his Ethiopian
birth certificate does not provide reasonable, credible and solid evidence of
his actual age, insufficient evidence supports a finding that the victim was
under the age of 14 during the relevant time period. Accordingly, we reduce
the convictions in counts 1 through 6 to the lesser included offenses of
sodomy and oral copulation with a person under the age of 18, and we reverse
the convictions in counts 7 through 10 for committing a lewd act on a child
under the age of 14.
1 Unless otherwise indicated, all further statutory references are to the
Penal Code.
2
I.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
At trial, Roberts did not contest that between approximately September
2019 and the beginning of 2020, he engaged in a series of sexual acts
involving Boy.2
Boy was adopted from an Ethiopian orphanage as a young child.
According to the evidence at trial, when Boy’s adoptive parents went to
Ethiopia to adopt him in 2010, they were provided with a birth certificate
that stated a birthdate in June 2006, meaning that Boy was identified as
being three and a half years old when he was adopted. After Boy arrived in
the United States, the Ethiopian birth certificate was used to generate an
American birth certificate, which also stated a June 2006 birthdate.
After the sexual conduct came to light, Roberts was charged in an
indictment alleging 10 sexual acts that took place between August 1, 2019
and March 1, 2020. Based on Boy’s birthdate in June 2006, he was 13 years
old during each of those alleged acts. Specifically, based on his stated age,
Boy would have ranged from the age of 13 years and three months old in late
September 2019 to the age of 13 years and eight months in late February
2020. Accordingly, each of the 10 counts alleged crimes that required a
victim under the age of 14 years: two counts of sodomy with a child under
age 14 (§ 286, subd. (c)(1)) (counts 1–2); four counts of oral copulation of a
2 At trial, Boy testified that the sexual conduct started in September
2019 and lasted until sometime in January or February 2020. Based on the
testimony of Boy’s mother, Roberts moved out of town in March 2020,
meaning that the physical contact between Boy and Roberts necessarily
ended by that date.
3
child under age 14 (§ 287, subd. (c)(1)) (counts 3–6); and four counts of lewd
acts upon a child under age 14 (§ 288, subd. (a)) (counts 7–10).
At trial, Roberts did not attempt to dispute that the sexual conduct
occurred. Defense counsel’s sole argument was that the People failed to
prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Boy was under 14 years of age at the
time of the offenses. Based on that argument, defense counsel stated that the
jury should (1) find Roberts guilty of lesser included offenses for the sodomy
and oral copulation counts, which required the People to prove only that Boy
was under 18 years of age at the time of the offenses (§§ 286, subd. (b)(l));
287, subd. (b)(l)); and (2) acquit Roberts on the lewd act counts (§288,
subd. (a)), as no age-based lesser included offense was applicable.
To support his contention that the People failed to meet their burden to
prove Boy was under 14 years of age between September 2019 and early
2020, Roberts presented extensive evidence about the unreliability of the
birthdate that appears on a birth certificate of a child adopted from an
Ethiopian orphanage.
An expert on Ethiopian adoptions testified that Ethiopia does not have
a birth registration system to keep track of the date on which a person is
born. Most people in Ethiopia do not know what their birthdate is because a
birthdate is not relevant information in Ethiopian culture. Birthdays are not
celebrated, and many people are illiterate and therefore are unable to
informally record family member birthdates. If an Ethiopian person needs a
birth certificate for something, such as obtaining a passport or facilitating an
adoption, a birth certificate is issued based on a “guesstimate” of the person’s
birthdate. Further, the location indicated on Boy’s birth certificate as his
birthplace is a rural, uneducated and impoverished part of Ethiopia, making
4
it “very very unlikely” that someone would know their birthdate in the place
where Boy was born.3
The expert testified that because a birth certificate is required for
adoption from Ethiopia, but orphanages “never know” a child’s actual
birthdate, “it’s a pure guess in trying to figure out a child’s age.” Further, the
expert explained, “I’ve discussed it with orphanage people in Ethiopia. They
know that families want to adopt young children. So they will make the child
younger to get the child placed because they keep getting more children
brought in, and they’re running out of the space. They’re running out of food.
So the younger that they can make the child, the more quicker the child is
going to be placed for adoption and moved from the government orphanage to
the adoption agencies private orphanage.” Thus, according to the expert, she
was aware of cases where the child’s actual age was understated “[b]y several
years,” and she had “seen three and four year olds who really after they
started having medical care and nutrition were really five and six years old.”
When asked, “generally speaking, would you expect a date of birth on an
Ethiopian birth certificate to be accurate?” The expert answered, “No, never.
No, it’s a guess.”
Roberts also presented testimony from Boy’s pediatrician. According to
the pediatrician, Boy was extremely tall for his age at 11, 12, 13, and 14
3 Complicating matters further, Ethiopia uses a different calendar than
the Gregorian calendar used in the United States and many other countries.
Thus, the birth certificate issued for Boy in Ethiopia shows a birthdate of
“17/10/1998” in the Ethiopian calendar as well as a birthdate in June 2006
using the Gregorian calendar. The expert testified that “not everybody”
correctly converts between an Ethiopian calendar date and a Gregorian
calendar date.
5
years of age.4 The pediatrician testified that, based on the milestones he
observed in caring for Boy, it was plausible that Boy is the age stated on his
birth certificate, but Boy could also be a year older.
Other than presenting evidence of Boy’s birth certificates, and allowing
the jury to view Boy’s physical appearance and demeanor when he testified at
trial (at the stated age of 16), and participated in a forensic interview (at the
stated age of 13) the People presented no evidence relevant to the actual date
on which Boy was born. The People also did not attempt to discredit the
testimony of the defense’s expert on Ethiopian adoptions. Instead, during
closing argument, the People argued that the jury should simply accept as
fact the date of birth stated on Boy’s birth certificate. “He was three and a
half when he was brought over here. He was brought to doctor’s
appointments where it was a fact that he was three and a half[,] that he was
this stated age. He went to school where it was a fact that he was a stated
age. He grew up in the house . . . where it was a fact that he was a stated
age. . . . It was a fact that [Roberts] was there [to celebrate birthdays], and
that [Boy] was the age that he was. That everyone knew him to be. That
was his age. That didn’t change.” The People argued that Boy “has a birth
certificate, and you heard testimony from the person himself.” The People
explained to jurors that they should not even consider the lesser included
offenses that were based on Boy’s age being over 13, representing that “the
[lesser included offenses] are only given to you because they’re legally
4 At age 11, Boy’s height was in the 97th percentile; at age 12, it was in
the 98th percentile; at age 13 it was in the 99th percentile and “off the
charts”; at age 14 it was in the 98th percentile. If Boy was actually a year
older than his stated age, he would have been in the 90th percentile when his
stated age was 11 rather than in the 97th percentile.
6
required by state law. They don’t apply here. Because the fact is [Boy] was
13. That’s not in question.”
In contrast, defense counsel argued that “[i]t’s his actual birthday
which matters. It’s his actual birthday which must be proven beyond a
reasonable doubt before you can think about convicting Mr. Roberts of the
primary charges relating to [Boy] being under 14 at the time of these acts.
According to defense counsel, because of the uncertainty created by Boy’s
adoption from an Ethiopian orphanage, the People had not met that burden.
The jury returned guilty verdicts on all of the counts as charged. After
making true findings on certain aggravating circumstances, the trial court
imposed a prison sentence of 18 years.
II.
DISCUSSION
A. Roberts’s Challenge to the Sufficiency of the Evidence
Roberts contends that insufficient evidence supports a finding that Boy
was under the age of 14 during the relevant time frame of September 2019 to
early 2020.5
1. Standard of Review
In determining whether sufficient evidence supports a finding that Boy
was under 14 years of age during the relevant time frame, “we must ‘ “review
the entire record in the light most favorable to the judgment,” ’ and then
determine whether it contains ‘ “evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of
solid value” ’ such that a reasonable jury could have found the defendant
5 The evidence at trial did not indicate any particular date between
September 2019 and early 2020 for any of the specific acts of sexual conduct
charged against Roberts. Instead of proving that specific acts took place on
particular dates, the People relied on the argument that, based on Boy’s
stated birthdate in June 2006, he was under the age of 14 during the entire
time frame.
7
guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. . . . ‘[S]ufficiency determinations
necessarily take account of the “standard of proof that applied before the trial
court.” ’ . . . ‘[T]hat is why in criminal cases we must ensure the record
demonstrates substantial evidence to establish guilt beyond a reasonable
doubt.’ [¶] . . . We must ‘ “presume in support of the judgment the existence
of every fact the jury could reasonably have deduced from the evidence . . .
‘for it is the exclusive province of the trial judge or jury to determine the
credibility of a witness and the truth or falsity of the facts upon which a
determination depends.’ ” ’ . . . But we cannot, however, venture beyond the
evidence presented at trial, and may consider only those inferences that are
reasonably supported by the record. ‘ “[A] reasonable inference . . . ‘may not
be based on suspicion alone, or on imagination, speculation, supposition,
surmise, conjecture, or guess work.’ ” ’ . . . It ‘must logically flow from other
facts established in the action,’ and it cannot be ‘based entirely on the
suspicions of the officers involved in the case and the conjecture of the
prosecution.’ ” (People v. Ware (2022) 14 Cal.5th 151, 167–168, citations
omitted, italics added].)
2. Insufficient Evidence Supports the Convictions
“[U]nder the due process guarantees of both the California and United
States Constitutions, the prosecution has the burden of proving beyond a
reasonable doubt each essential element of the crime.” (People v. Flood
(1998) 18 Cal.4th 470, 481.)
Each of the offenses that Roberts was found guilty of committing
required the People to prove, as an element, that the victim was under the
age of 14. Specifically, section 286, subdivision (c)(1) makes it a crime to
“participate[ ] in an act of sodomy with another person who is under 14 years
of age and more than 10 years younger than [the defendant].” Section 287,
8
subdivision (c)(1) makes it a crime to “participate[ ] in an act of oral
copulation with another person who is under 14 years of age and more than
10 years younger than [the defendant].” Section 288, subdivision (a), makes
it a crime to commit a lewd act “upon or with the body, or any part or
member thereof, of a child who is under the age of 14 years, with the intent of
arousing, appealing to, or gratifying the lust, passions, or sexual desires of
that person or the child.”
“In common parlance, a person reaches a particular age on the
anniversary of his or her birth and remains that age until reaching the next
anniversary of his or her birth.” (People v. Cornett (2012) 53 Cal.4th 1261,
1265.) Relying on the language in former Civil Code section 26 (now
contained in Family Code section 6500), our Supreme Court has explained
that a person becomes one year older on the first minute of the anniversary of
the person’s birth, which is known as the “birthday rule.” (In re Harris (1993)
5 Cal.4th 813, 844, 849 (Harris); see also Fam. Code, § 6500 [“The period of
minority is calculated from the first minute of the day on which the
individual is born to the same minute of the corresponding day completing
the period of minority.”].)6 Thus, to obtain a conviction against Roberts, the
People were required to prove to the jury, beyond a reasonable doubt, that
Roberts engaged in sexual conduct with Boy before the 14th anniversary of
Boy’s birth.
6 Harris explained that the Legislature chose the “birthday rule” for
calculating a person’s age instead of the common law rule, under which a
person was treated as turning a year older on “the earliest moment of the day
before their anniversary of birth.” (Harris, supra, 5 Cal.4th at pp. 844–845.)
Based on Harris, the trial court instructed with the standard CALCRIM jury
instructions for each of the offenses charged against Roberts that “[u]nder the
law, a person becomes one year older as soon as the first minute of his or her
birthday has begun.” (CALCRIM Nos. 1080, 1082, 1090, 1092, 1110.)
9
In the vast majority of criminal prosecutions, a person’s age will not be
disputed because that person will have been born in a country that keeps
records of births. However, in those cases where age is in dispute, “[p]roof of
age, like proof of any other material fact, can be accomplished by the use of
either direct or circumstantial evidence, or both.” (People v. Kurey (2001)
88 Cal.App.4th 840, 847 (Kurey).) “Physical appearance may be sufficient to
determine whether a person is a minor or an adult. [Citations.] However,
physical appearance is more accurate to approximate the extremes of old age
and youth.” (People v. Vital (2019) 40 Cal.App.5th 925, 936, italics added.)
Common experience teaches that appearance is only an approximate
indicator of age, especially in the case of teenagers. Indeed, the pediatrician
agreed in his testimony that children grow at a different rates. Where, as
here, the jury must make a precise determination of a close call about the age
of a teenager, appearance alone provides only a speculative basis to
determine beyond a reasonable doubt that the victim is a specific age.
(See Vital, at p. 936 [concluding that physical appearance did not provide
evidence to establish that a female was over the age of 18 because “[q]uite
often, there is no appreciable difference in physical appearances between an
18-year-old woman and 13- to 17-year-old girls,” and noting that “[w]e are not
dealing with extremes” of age].)
A jury may not base an inference merely on “ ‘ “ ‘suspicion[,] . . .
imagination, speculation, supposition, surmise, conjecture, or guess
work.’ ” ’ ” (Ware, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 167.) It would have been purely
speculative for the jury to rely on Boy’s physical appearance to infer that Boy
was, in fact, his stated age of 13 years and three months to 13 years and eight
months during the relevant time frame rather than having turned 14 years
old either before or during that period.
10
The only other relevant evidence of Boy’s age was the Ethiopian birth
certificate, which was then used to generate the American birth certificate.
Substantial evidence must be of “ ‘ “reasonable, credible, and of solid
value.” ’ ” (Ware, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 167.) The uncontradicted expert
testimony presented by the defense established that the Ethiopian birth
certificate did not provide reasonable, credible and solid evidence of Boy’s
actual birth date. Instead, as the expert explained, the birthdate on the birth
certificate was almost certainly a guess, and the people who came up with the
date may have had an incentive to say that Boy was younger than they
believed him to be.
The People were not without options to attempt to prove Boy’s actual
age if they believed that Boy was, in fact, under 14 years old during the
relevant time period. They could have presented their own medical expert,
who may have attempted to rely on certain developmental factors or other
approaches to determining a child’s age. (Cf. Kurey, supra, 88 Cal.App.4th at
pp. 844–845, 847 [in a case where the People had the burden of proving that
persons depicted in pornographic images were minors, both parties called
medical experts to opine on age].) They could have asked Boy’s mother
during her testimony to authenticate family photographs showing Boy at a
number of different stages of his childhood to help the jury assess whether
Boy’s stated birthdate was accurate.7 They could have asked Boy’s mother,
with experience raising two other sons who were slightly older than Boy,
whether Boy’s stated birthdate seemed to be accurate based on
developmental milestones she witnessed during his childhood. Further, if the
facts supported such an approach, the People could have presented their own
7 The only photographs shown to the jury were one photo from shortly
after Boy’s adoption and recent photos from 2019 and 2020.
11
expert on Ethiopian adoptions to call into question some of the things said by
the defense’s expert. However, the People did none of those things.8 Instead,
they simplistically urged the jury to follow the birthdate that appeared on
Boy’s Ethiopian birth certificate because that birthdate was always
understood as “a fact.” The People’s approach, although apparently
persuasive to the jury, was not based on the law, which requires a finding as
to a victim’s actual age.
We conclude that the People did not meet their burden to present
evidence sufficient for a reasonable juror to find beyond a reasonable doubt
that Boy was under the age of 14 from September 2019 to early 2020.9
B. Reduction to the Lesser Included Offenses for the Sodomy and Oral
Copulation Counts
As a remedy for the lack of sufficient evidence to support his
convictions, Roberts does not seek an outright reversal on all of the counts.
Instead, he seeks a disposition (1) reducing his convictions on the sodomy and
oral copulation counts to lesser included offenses applicable to cases in which
the victim was under 18 years of age (§§ 286, subd. (b)(1), 287, subd. (b)(1));
and (2) reversing the convictions for committing lewd acts on a child under
the age of 14 (§ 288, subd. (a)). The disposition that Roberts seeks here is the
same result that he sought from the jury, when he asked it to return a guilty
8 Boy’s trial strategy focusing on the lack of evidence regarding his
actual date of birth should not have been a surprise to the People, as defense
counsel filed a motion almost two months before the start of trial, which
argued that Boy’s birth certificates and all mention of Boy’s age should be
excluded at trial due to uncertainty as to Boy’s true age.
9 Because we are reversing based on insufficiency of the evidence, we
need not, and do not, consider whether, as Boy contends, the trial court
prejudicially erred in declining to instruct the jury that it must determine
whether Boy was under 14 years of age based on his actual birthday.
12
verdict on the lesser included offenses to the sodomy and oral copulation
counts, and to acquit him on the lewd act counts.
“[A]n appellate court that finds that insufficient evidence supports the
conviction for a greater offense may, in lieu of granting a new trial, modify
the judgment of conviction to reflect a conviction for a lesser included
offense.” (People v. Navarro (2007) 40 Cal.4th 668, 671 [citing § 1181,
subd. (6) and § 1260].)
Section 286, subdivision (b)(1) makes it a crime to “participate[ ] in an
act of sodomy with another person who is under 18 years of age.”
Section 287, subdivision (b)(1) makes it a crime to “participate[ ] in an act of
oral copulation with another person who is under 18 years of age.” Both
crimes are lesser included offenses to sodomy and oral copulation with a child
under the age of 14, as the statutory elements of the greater offense involving
a victim under the age of 14 include all of the statutory elements of the lesser
offense involving a victim under the age of 18. (People v. Culbertson (1985)
171 Cal.App.3d 508, 516; People v. Jerome (1984) 160 Cal.App.3d 1087, 1098
[“By logical imperative, it necessarily follows if one commits oral copulation
with a minor under 14, one also commits that act with a person under 18];
see also People v. Reed (2006) 38 Cal.4th 1224, 1227 [describing the
“ ‘elements’ ” test for determining a lesser included offense].) When the jury
found, in counts 1 through 6, that Roberts committed the crimes of sodomy
against a child under the age of 14 and oral copulation against a child under
the age of 14, it also necessarily found all of the elements needed for the
lesser included offenses set forth in section 286, subdivision (b)(1) and
section 287, subdivision (b)(1). However, there is no age-based lesser
13
included offense to the crime of committing a lewd act against a child under
the age of 14 (§ 288, subd. (a).)10
Accordingly, we reduce the convictions in counts 1 and 2 to the crime of
sodomy with a person under 18 years of age (§ 286, subd. (b)(1)), and we
reduce the convictions in counts 3 through 6 to the crime of oral copulation
with a person under 18 years of age (§ 287, subd. (b)(1)). As there is no age-
based lesser included offense to the crime of committing lewd acts against a
child under the age of 14, the convictions in counts 7 through 10 are reversed
because they are not supported by sufficient evidence.
10 Although section 288, subdivision (c)(1) makes it a crime to commit a
lewd act against “a child of 14 or 15 years,” that offense is not a lesser
included offense of section 288, subdivision (a), which makes it a crime to
commit a lewd act against “a child who is under the age of 14 years.” The age
requirements for the two offenses are not overlapping, and therefore the two
offenses involve distinct statutory elements.
14
DISPOSITION
We modify the judgment to reduce the convictions in counts 1 and 2 to
the crime of sodomy with a person under 18 years of age (§ 286, subd. (b)(1)),
and to reduce the convictions in counts 3 through 6 to the crime of oral
copulation with a person under 18 years of age (§ 287, subd. (b)(1)). The
convictions for committing lewd acts against a child under the age of 14 in
counts 7 through 10 (§ 288, subd. (a)) are reversed. This matter is remanded
to the trial court for resentencing.
IRION, Acting P. J.
WE CONCUR:
DATO, J.
KELETY, J.
15
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.