People v. Payne CA2/3

CourtListener 9512152CalctappJun 6, 2024

Full text

Filed 6/6/24 P. v. Payne CA2/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(a). This
opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115(a).

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

THE PEOPLE, B329503

Plaintiff and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. YA015989
v.

CARLTON LAVERT PAYNE,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Nicole C. Bershon, Judge. Affirmed.
William L. Heyman, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Noah P. Hill and Steven E. Mercer, Deputy
Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
INTRODUCTION

A court sentenced Carlton Lavert Payne to two terms of life
without the possibility of parole (LWOP) after a jury found him
guilty of two counts of first degree murder and found true the
special circumstance allegation of multiple murders under Penal
Code1 section 190.2, subdivision (a)(3). More than 27 years later,
Payne filed a request to initiate a proceeding under People v.
Franklin (2016) 63 Cal.4th 261 (Franklin), seeking to make a
record of information relevant to a future youth offender parole
hearing. The trial court denied the request on the basis Payne’s
sentence renders him ineligible for relief. On appeal, Payne
argues section 3051, subdivision (h) — the statute that makes
him ineligible — violates the equal protection guarantees found
in the federal and California Constitutions. He also contends that
section 3051 causes his LWOP sentences to be cruel or unusual
punishment under the California Constitution. We affirm.

FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND2

On June 5, 1993, Payne attended a combined birthday and
housewarming party at an apartment with Eara Pollard and
their infant son. Payne was a member of the 190th Street East
Coast Crips gang. While they were at the party, Pollard noticed
Payne had a gun in his waistband and told him not to have the
weapon while playing with children. He put it in a diaper bag.
Five men arrived and invited Payne to smoke marijuana with

1 All undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.

2 We paraphrase the factual background set forth in the unpublished

opinion in People v. Payne (May 13, 1997, B099459), which Payne
includes in full in his opening brief.

2
them in a bedroom. Payne later came out and told Pollard that
the men were Bloods but he was “not tripping.” (An attendee
testified that, to his knowledge, none were active members of the
Crenshaw Mafia Gangster Blood gang.) Payne went back to the
bedroom and remained there for some time. No one in the
bedroom did anything to make Payne believe they were Bloods,
though one of the men present, Darryl Benford, was wearing a
red shirt. Benford tried to be friendly with Payne and told him
his brother used to associate with the 118th Street East Coast
Crips. The men did not threaten Payne and Payne also did not
behave in a threatening manner.
However, Benford got into a verbal argument with Payne
and asked another attendee whether he had a gun, though
Benford then said “just forget it.” Payne left the bedroom and
grabbed the diaper bag and returned it without the gun. Pollard
checked because she knew something was wrong based on how
Payne was acting. The hostess’s sister told the men it was time to
sing happy birthday and everyone went to the kitchen. Pollard
observed Payne put on some brown gloves and one of the men
said something to him. Payne pulled the gun from his pants.
Pollard attempted to stop him, but Payne grabbed one of the
men, Marwinn Cook, and shot him in the head. He then shot
another man, Richard Bolin. One of the attendees heard as many
as six additional shots. Benford was shot in both arms. Marcus
Mackey, a child, was shot in the left leg. Cook and Bolin died as a
result of gunshot wounds to the head.
A jury convicted Payne of two counts of first degree murder
(§ 187, subd. (a); counts 1 and 2), two counts of attempted willful,
deliberate, and premeditated murder (§§ 664/187, subd. (a);
counts 3 and 5), and one count of assault with a firearm (§ 245,

3
subd. (a)(2); count 4). In connection with counts 1, 2, 3 and 5, the
jury found that Payne personally used a firearm within the
meaning of section 12022.5, subdivision (a). In connection with
counts 3 and 4, it found true the allegation that Payne personally
inflicted great bodily injury within the meaning of
section 12022.7. In November 1995, a court sentenced Payne to
two LWOP terms for counts 1 and 2, plus 16 months for each
count for the firearm enhancements; two life terms for counts 3
and 5, plus 16 months for each count for the firearm
enhancements and three years for the great bodily injury
enhancement for count 3; and four years for count 4 plus five
years for the firearm enhancement and three years for great
bodily injury enhancement. The court ordered that the sentence
on count 4 be served first and the sentences on counts 1, 2, 3, and
5 each be served consecutively thereafter. Payne appealed and a
panel of this division affirmed the judgment. (See People v.
Payne, supra, B099459.)
In January 2023, Payne filed a motion to initiate a
proceeding under Franklin, seeking to make a record of
information relevant to a future youth offender parole hearing. In
it, he asserted that he was 23 years old at the time of the crimes
of conviction.3 Payne acknowledged his LWOP sentences render

3 It is unclear from the record whether Payne was 23 or 24 years old at

the time of the crimes of conviction. The probation report indicates that
his birth date was May 6, 1969, whereas the motion to initiate a
proceeding under Franklin stated that he was 23, and his notice of
appeal states that his birth date is October 27, 1969. Ultimately, we
agree with the Attorney General that whether Payne was 23 or 24
years old at the time of the crimes of conviction is a distinction without
difference, as both are over 18 and less than 26.

4
him statutorily ineligible for a youth offender parole hearing.
Nevertheless, he argued that section 3051, subdivision (h)
violates the equal protection guarantees found in the United
States and California Constitutions. He also argued that the
exclusion of 18- to 25-year-old LWOP offenders from youth
offender parole violates the state constitutional ban on cruel or
unusual punishment.
The trial court denied Payne’s motion, noting the weight of
authority holds section 3051, subdivision (h) does not violate
equal protection. The court did not address his cruel and unusual
punishment contentions in its written order. Payne timely
appealed.

DISCUSSION

1. The denial of youth offender parole hearings under
section 3051 to young adult offenders sentenced to
LWOP does not violate equal protection.
Our Legislature enacted section 3051 in light of United
States Supreme Court decisions that recognized the lessened
culpability and greater prospects for reform that distinguish
juvenile from adult offenders. (See Stats. 2013, ch. 312, § 1;
Graham v. Florida (2010) 560 U.S. 48 (Graham); Miller v.
Alabama (2012) 567 U.S. 460 (Miller).) Section 3051 requires the
Board of Parole Hearings (the Board) to conduct a “youth offender
parole hearing” at specified times during the incarceration of
certain youthful offenders. (See § 3051, subds. (a)(1), (b);
Franklin, supra, 63 Cal.4th at p. 277.) Generally, offenders who
were younger than 26 years old when they committed the
controlling offense are eligible for a youth offender parole hearing
if they were sentenced to a determinate term or a life term with

5
the possibility of parole. (§ 3051, subd. (b).) Offenders sentenced
to LWOP are entitled to a hearing only if they were younger than
18 years old when they committed the controlling offense. (Id.,
subd. (b)(4).) The statute explicitly states it does not apply to
“cases in which an individual is sentenced to life in prison
without the possibility of parole for a controlling offense that was
committed after the person had attained 18 years of age.” (Id.,
subd. (h).) Section 4801 provides that, when a prisoner committed
the controlling offense, as defined in section 3051, when he or she
was 25 years of age or younger, the Board “shall give great
weight to the diminished culpability of youth as compared to
adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent
growth and increased maturity in the prisoner in accordance with
the relevant case law.” (§ 4801, subd. (c).)
In Franklin, the California Supreme Court interpreted
section 3051 to require a youth offender have a “sufficient
opportunity to make a record of information relevant to his
eventual youth offender parole hearing.” (Franklin, supra, 63
Cal.4th at p. 284.) These hearings are commonly referred to as
Franklin hearings. At a Franklin hearing, the offender and the
People have the opportunity to “put on the record any evidence
that demonstrates the juvenile offender’s culpability or cognitive
maturity, or otherwise bears on the influence of youth-related
factors” at the time of the offense. (Ibid.) “[A]n offender entitled
to a hearing under section[ ] 3051 . . . may seek the remedy of a
Franklin proceeding even though the offender’s sentence is
otherwise final.” (In re Cook (2019) 7 Cal.5th 439, 450–451.)
Here, Payne was 23 or 24 years old when he committed the
murders that resulted in the LWOP sentences. As Payne
acknowledges, because he was not a juvenile when he committed

6
the controlling offenses, he is ineligible for a youth offender
parole hearing under section 3051, subdivision (h). Nevertheless,
Payne argues he is entitled to a Franklin hearing because section
3051, subdivision (h) violates the equal protection guarantees
found in the United States and California Constitutions.
“At core, the requirement of equal protection ensures that
the government does not treat a group of people unequally
without some justification.” (People v. Chatman (2018) 4 Cal.5th
277, 288 (Chatman).) Where the challenged law is not based on a
suspect classification and does not burden fundamental rights,
the law denies equal protection “only if there is no rational
relationship between a disparity in treatment and some
legitimate government purpose. [Citation.] This core feature of
equal protection sets a high bar before a law is deemed to lack
even the minimal rationality necessary for it to survive
constitutional scrutiny. Coupled with a rebuttable presumption
that legislation is constitutional, this high bar helps ensure that
democratically enacted laws are not invalidated merely based on
a court’s cursory conclusion that a statute’s tradeoffs seem
unwise or unfair.” (Id. at pp. 288–289; see In re Murray (2021) 68
Cal.App.5th 456, 463–464 (Murray) [applying rational basis
review to claim section 3051 violates equal protection].)
Payne argues that he is similarly situated to persons with
LWOP sentences who committed their controlling offenses before
they were 18 years old and persons with non-LWOP sentences
who committed their offenses before they were 26 years of age,
both of which are entitled to a youth offender parole hearing
under section 3051. However, our high court recently clarified:
“[W]hen plaintiffs challenge laws drawing distinctions between
identifiable groups or classes of persons, on the basis that the

7
distinctions drawn are inconsistent with equal protection, courts
no longer need to ask at the threshold whether the two groups
are similarly situated for purposes of the law in question. The
only pertinent inquiry is whether the challenged difference in
treatment is adequately justified under the applicable standard
of review.” (People v. Hardin (2024) 15 Cal.5th 834, 850–851
(Hardin).)
“A classification in a statute is presumed rational until the
challenger shows that no rational basis for the unequal treatment
is reasonably conceivable. [Citation.] The underlying rationale for
a statutory classification need not have been ‘ “ever actually
articulated” ’ by lawmakers, and it does not need to ‘ “be
empirically substantiated.” ’ ” (Chatman, supra, 4 Cal.5th at
p. 289.) Payne argues that the Legislature lacked any rational
basis to grant youth offender parole hearings to young adult
offenders sentenced to non-LWOP terms and offenders under the
age of 18 sentenced to LWOP terms while denying hearings to
young adult offenders sentenced to LWOP terms. As Payne
concedes, courts have repeatedly rejected this exact argument. Of
the published opinions on the issue, all but one held section 3051
does not violate equal protection. (See, e.g., People v. Ngo (2023)
89 Cal.App.5th 116, 129; People v. Bolanos (2023) 87 Cal.App.5th
1069, 1080–1081; People v. Morales (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 326,
347–349; People v. Jackson (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th 189, 199–200;
People v. Acosta (2021) 60 Cal.App.5th 769, 780–781; Murray,
supra, 68 Cal.App.5th at pp. 463–465; In re Williams (2020) 57
Cal.App.5th 427, 433–436 (Williams); but see People v. Hardin
(2022) 84 Cal.App.5th 273, 278–279, review granted Jan. 11,
2023, S277487.)

8
Payne contends that these cases were wrongly decided.
However, while this appeal was pending, the California Supreme
Court decided Hardin, supra, 15 Cal.5th 834, which confirmed
section 3051’s exclusion of young adult offenders sentenced to
LWOP does not violate equal protection.4 We are bound by this
authority. (Auto Equity Sales, Inc. v. Superior Court (1962) 57
Cal.2d 450, 455–456.) Accordingly, we reject Payne’s argument.
2. The denial of youth parole hearings to young adult
LWOP offenders under section 3051 does not render
Payne’s LWOP sentences cruel or unusual punishment.
Article I, section 17 of the California Constitution provides:
“Cruel or unusual punishment may not be inflicted or excessive
fines imposed.” A court assessing a claim of cruel or unusual
punishment must “decide whether the penalty given ‘is so
disproportionate to the crime for which it is inflicted that it
shocks the conscience and offends fundamental notions of human
dignity,’ thereby violating the prohibition . . . against cruel or
unusual punishment of article I, section 17 of the California
Constitution.” (People v. Cunningham (2001) 25 Cal.4th 926,
1042; In re Lynch (1972) 8 Cal.3d 410, 424, fn. omitted [prison
sentence violates article I, section 17, if “it is so disproportionate
to the crime for which it is inflicted that it shocks the
conscience and offends fundamental notions of human dignity”],
superseded by statute on other grounds as stated in People v.

4 Although the court left open the possibility of “other challenges to the

distinctions drawn by the special circumstances statute based on a
more robust record or a more focused as-applied inquiry” (Hardin,
supra, 15 Cal.5th at p. 862), Payne has not made an as-applied
challenge to section 3051.

9
West (1999) 70 Cal.App.4th 248, 256.) In Lynch, our Supreme
Court identified a three-pronged test for courts to use when
reviewing disproportionality claims. (Lynch, at pp. 425–429.)
“First, [it] examined the nature of the offense and the offender.
[Citation.] Second, [it] compared the punishment with the
penalty for more serious crimes in the same jurisdiction.
[Citation.] Third, [it] compared the punishment to the penalty for
the same offense in different jurisdictions. [Citation.]” (People v.
Cartwright (1995) 39 Cal.App.4th 1123, 1136.)
“ ‘ “Whether a punishment is cruel or unusual is a question
of law for the appellate court, but the underlying disputed facts
must be viewed in the light most favorable to the judgment.
[Citations.]” [Citation.]’ ” (People v. Abundio (2013) 221
Cal.App.4th 1211, 1217.) A defendant must overcome a
“considerable burden . . . in challenging a penalty as cruel or
unusual.” (People v. Wingo (1975) 14 Cal.3d 169, 174.) “The
doctrine of separation of powers is firmly entrenched in the law of
California, and a court should not lightly encroach on matters
which are uniquely in the domain of the Legislature. Perhaps
foremost among these are the definition of crime and the
determination of punishment. [Citations.] While these
intrinsically legislative functions are circumscribed by the
constitutional limits of article I, section 17, the validity of
enactments will not be questioned ‘unless their
unconstitutionality clearly, positively and unmistakably
appears.’ [Citation.]” (Ibid.) “[T]he length of a sentence of
imprisonment is largely a matter of legislative prerogative, and
cannot violate the [prohibition against cruel and unusual
punishment] in any but the rarest cases.” (People v. Weddle
(1991) 1 Cal.App.4th 1190, 1193.)

10
“While the federal proscription concerns ‘cruel and unusual’
punishments, article I, section 17 of the California Constitution
states in pertinent part that ‘[c]ruel or unusual punishment may
not be inflicted.’ No distinction need be attached this difference
from an analytic perspective, however.” (People v. Mantanez
(2002) 98 Cal.App.4th 354, 358, fn. 7.) Thus, even though “[w]e
construe this provision separately from its counterpart in the
federal Constitution” (People v. Cartwright, supra, 39
Cal.App.4th at pp. 1135–1136), “[t]here is considerable overlap in
the state and federal approaches.” (People v. Baker (2018) 20
Cal.App.5th 711, 733.) “ ‘[B]oth standards prohibit punishment
that is “grossly disproportionate” to the crime or the individual
culpability of the defendant.’ [Citation.] ‘The touchstone in each is
gross disproportionality.’ [Citation.]” (Ibid.)
Payne concedes that his “LWOP sentences . . . may not
meet the three-part test set forth in [Lynch].” We accept this
concession.5 However, Payne contends that sections 3051 and
4801 demonstrate that the Legislature has determined that
offenders under the age of 26 years are less culpable than

5 Murder is among the most serious crimes conceivable, to say nothing

of the fact that this was a double homicide case. (Williams, supra, 57
Cal.App.5th at p. 438 [“The United States and California Supreme
Courts have recognized there is no crime more depraved or more
injurious than intentional first degree murder. [Citation.] This is
doubly true in the case of a double murder, even when committed by a
21 year old.”]).) Following Lynch, our high court has indicated that all
that is required is “intracase” review; i.e., an evaluation of whether the
sentence is “grossly disproportionate” to the offense. (See, e.g., People
v. Bradford (1997) 15 Cal.4th 1229, 1384.) In any event, Payne does
not argue that LWOP is not a sentence imposed for murder in other
jurisdictions.

11
individuals above 26 years who commit the same offenses. He
argues that these sections “cause[] LWOP sentences, without any
hope for a parole hearing and possible parole at some point, for
such offenders, to be grossly disproportionate to the offenses for
which they were imposed.” We are not persuaded.
Following the enactment of section 3051, California courts
have held that the imposition of LWOP sentences on young adult
offenders does not violate the federal Constitution’s ban on cruel
and unusual punishment. In Williams, supra, 57 Cal.App.5th
427, the defendant, who was 21 years old when he shot and killed
two people during the commission of a robbery, was sentenced to
two consecutive terms of LWOP. (Id. at p. 430.) The defendant
filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus in which he argued that
the denial of a youth offender parole hearing under section 3051
violated his right to equal protection of the laws and constituted
cruel and unusual punishment. (Ibid.) With respect to cruel and
unusual punishment, the defendant argued that the LWOP
sentence for the crime he committed was grossly disproportionate
to his diminished culpability as a 21-year-old offender. (Id. at
p. 437.) He asserted that his age rendered him less culpable than
a mature adult who commits the same crimes, yet both he and a
mature adult will serve the same LWOP sentence if he is not
granted a youth offender parole hearing — indeed, he may be
imprisoned for longer due to the fact that he was younger when
incarcerated. (Id. at pp. 437–438.) The Court of Appeal
recognized that, “[w]ith the exception of death, LWOP is the most
severe penalty available under our Penal Code” and that “[s]ome
LWOP inmates may be more culpable than other LWOP
inmates.” (Id. at p. 438.) It explained that “[c]ourts need not rank
every convicted defendant on a continuum of culpability and

12
ensure each of their sentences are precisely matched to their
particular culpability as compared to another defendant’s
culpability.” (Ibid.) The court also noted that our Supreme Court
has observed that a sentence will rarely be constitutionally
disproportionate where the crime committed is “ ‘subject by
statute to life-maximum imprisonment.’ ” (Ibid., citing In re
Dannenberg (2005) 34 Cal.4th 1061, 1071.)
“In light of the severity of this crime and the magnitude of
the harm inflicted,” the Williams court concluded that the LWOP
sentence was not “ ‘grossly disproportionate’ ” to the defendant’s
culpability. (Williams, supra, 57 Cal.App.5th at p. 439.) It
observed that, “[t]o the extent petitioner contends an LWOP
sentence is an unconstitutional cruel and unusual punishment
when imposed on any 21-year-old defendant, . . . our Supreme
Court has essentially rejected that very argument in the context
of the death penalty.” (Ibid., citing People v. Flores (2020) 9
Cal.5th 371, 429.) “If the Eighth Amendment does not prohibit a
sentence of death for 21 year olds, then most assuredly, it does
not prohibit the lesser LWOP sentence.” (Williams, at p. 439;
accord, People v. Acosta, supra, 60 Cal.App.5th at pp. 781–782
[declining to extend Miller to 21-year-old offender on the autism
spectrum and holding that triple LWOP sentence for the murder
of three people was not barred by the Eighth Amendment].)
Like the defendant in Williams, Payne was over the age of
18 but under the age of 26 when he shot and killed two people.
Payne does not seek to distinguish the facts of Williams but
asserts that its reasoning does not apply because it was decided
under the Eighth Amendment of the federal Constitution, not
article I, section 17 of the California Constitution. Payne
contends that the choice of the disjunctive “or” in the California

13
Constitution was purposeful (People v. Anderson (1972) 6 Cal.3d
628, 634–367, superseded on other grounds by Cal. Const., art. I,
§ 27), a point we do not dispute. However, he fails to explain why
the difference between the federal constitution’s use of “and” and
the California constitution’s use of “or” has significance in this
case and renders the analysis in cases like Williams inapplicable.
As discussed, a punishment violates both the California
and federal Constitutions if it is grossly disproportionate. (See
People v. Baker, supra, 20 Cal.App.5th at p. 733.) Williams
concluded that the LWOP sentence was not grossly
disproportionate to the offense committed and is therefore
instructive. Further, as the court in Williams observed, the
California Supreme Court has reaffirmed the age of 18 as the
bright line that our society uses to separate childhood from
adulthood for many purposes, including the propriety of criminal
punishments like the death penalty. In People v. Tran (2022) 13
Cal.5th 1169, 1234, our high court rejected the argument “that
imposing the death penalty on persons for crimes committed
while they were 18 to 20 years old violates the state and federal
Constitutions because it is cruel and unusual punishment and
because a death sentence cannot be reliably imposed on such
youthful offenders.” The court explained that section 3051 did
“ ‘not establish the “national consensus” necessary to justify a
categorical bar on the death penalty for individuals between the
ages of 18 and 21 at the time of their offenses.’ ” (Tran, at p. 1235,
quoting People v. Flores, supra, 9 Cal.5th at p. 429.) This
reasoning applies with greater force to a defendant who was older
at the time of the crimes of conviction and subject to the lesser
sentence of LWOP. (See Williams, supra, 57 Cal.App.5th at
p. 439.)

14
Payne concedes that the decision in People v. Argeta (2012)
210 Cal.App.4th 1478 undermines his position on appeal. In
Argeta, the defendants were 15 and 18 years old when they
committed the offenses and were convicted of one count of murder
and five counts of attempted murder. (Id. at p. 1482.) The trial
court imposed a minimum aggregate sentence of 100 years on the
minor defendant. (Ibid.) It is unclear from the published portion
of the opinion what sentence the trial court imposed on the adult
defendant. Division Four of this court analyzed the defendants’
federal and state constitutional claims of cruel and/or unusual
punishment together. (Id. at pp. 1480–1482.) The court observed
that the sentence for the defendant who was 15 years old at the
time of the crime was the functional equivalent of LWOP. (Id. at
p. 1482.) Although it declined to hold that the sentence was
categorically barred as cruel and unusual, it concluded that the
trial court’s sentencing determinations “must be reversed and
remanded for resentencing on all counts in a manner consistent
with the decision of the United States Supreme Court in Miller
and our Supreme Court in [People v. Caballero (2012) 55 Cal.4th
262 (Caballero)[6]].” (Id. at p. 1482.)

6 Caballero, supra, 55 Cal.4th 262 involved a juvenile who was

sentenced to 110 years to life for multiple nonhomicide offenses. (Id. at
pp. 268–269.) The court found that when a juvenile is sentenced to
minimum terms that exceed his or her life expectancy, the punishment
is the functional equivalent of LWOP and constitutes cruel and
unusual punishment. (Ibid.) It also concluded “the state may not
deprive [juveniles] at sentencing of a meaningful opportunity to
demonstrate their rehabilitation and fitness to reenter society in the
future.” (Id. at p. 268.) Caballero also laid out mitigating
circumstances that must be considered by a sentencing court before
determining at what point juveniles can seek parole, including their

15
With respect to the defendant who was an adult at the time
of the crimes, the court rejected the contention that his sentence
was categorically cruel and/or unusual, even though he was only
five months over the age of 18. (People v. Argeta, supra, 210
Cal.App.4th at p. 1482.) The court noted that, while “ ‘[d]rawing
the line at 18 years of age is subject . . . to the objections always
raised against categorical rules . . . [, it] is the point where society
draws the line for many purposes between childhood and
adulthood.’ [Citation.]” (Ibid.) “Making an exception for a
defendant who committed a crime just five months past his 18th
birthday opens the door for the next defendant who is only six
months into adulthood. Such arguments would have no logical
end, and so a line must be drawn at some point.” (Ibid.) The court
thus opted to respect the line drawn by society and the decisions
of the United States Supreme Court and our own high court for
sentencing purposes. (Ibid.; see also People v. Abundio, supra,
221 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1219–1221 [rejecting defendant’s attempts
to rely on Graham and Miller to support argument that LWOP
sentence for special circumstance murder committed when he
was 18 was cruel or unusual punishment].)
Payne argues that Argeta is not instructive because it was
decided before the enactment of section 3051. However, Argeta
was decided after and cites Miller, Graham, and Caballero, the
same decisions the Legislature identified as the impetus for
section 3051. (See Stats. 2013, ch. 312, § 1.) Moreover,
considering the Supreme Court’s ruling in Tran, we are not
persuaded that the enactment of section 3051 undermines the

age, whether they were a direct perpetrator or an aider and abettor,
and their physical and mental development. (Ibid.)

16
reasoning in Argeta as applied to LWOP sentences imposed on
young adults.
Accordingly, we conclude that section 3051 does not render
the imposition of LWOP sentences on individuals over 18 and
under 26 years old cruel or unusual punishment in violation of
the California Constitution.

17
DISPOSITION

The order is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

LAVIN, J.
WE CONCUR:

EDMON, P. J.

ADAMS, J.

18

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.