CourtListener 9507720•In re Abigail M. CA2/2
Full text
Filed 5/28/24 In re Abigail M. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has
not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re ABIGAIL M., a Person B329969
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No. 22CCJP03179)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
JOSE M.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Stephen C. Marpet, Judge. Affirmed.
Janette Freeman Cochran, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, William D. Thetford, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Jose M. (father) appeals from an order terminating
jurisdiction over his daughter Abigail M. (born October 2015)
pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 3641 with a
custody order granting sole legal and physical custody to mother
Rosa A. (mother) with monitored visits for father. Father
contends the juvenile court erred in terminating jurisdiction
because continued jurisdiction is necessary to enforce his conjoint
counseling and visitation with Abigail. We affirm the order of the
court.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The family
When these proceedings commenced, Abigail lived with
mother, her half siblings Darlene P. (born July 2008) and
Matthew S. (born November 2020), and Matthew’s father,
Christopher S.2 Father had no contact with Abigail for five years
prior to the commencement of these proceedings.
Prior referral involving father
On November 5, 2017, the Los Angeles County Department
of Children and Family Services (DCFS) received a referral
alleging a violent altercation among father, mother and
Christopher S. Father was returning Abigail to mother’s home at
7:00 a.m. after the weekend visit. Mother arrived at 7:30 a.m.
with her boyfriend Christopher S. Father left Abigail in the car,
shoved Christopher S. in the chest, began an argument, and
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2 Darlene P. and Matthew S. are not subjects of this appeal.
Christopher S. and Darlene’s father, Luis P., are not parties to
this appeal.
2
threatened to kill Christopher S. Father also argued with
mother, who he grabbed by the neck and began to choke. A
neighbor witnessed the incident and called police. Father took
Christopher S.’s cell phone and left in his car. He was stopped by
police and arrested for domestic violence, making a criminal
threat, theft of Christopher S.’s phone and driving with a
suspended license. Mother obtained a temporary restraining
order.
Current referral and investigation
On June 24, 2022, DCFS received a referral alleging
Christopher S. pulled a knife and threatened to kill himself on
the preceding day, with mother’s encouragement. An aunt was
present and intervened. The same day, mother and
Christopher S. were heard arguing, and Christopher S. was
heard telling mother to stop hitting him. The aunt observed
Christopher S. holding mother down next to Matthew’s crib.
Matthew had a fever of 102 degrees. It was believed the parents
were caught up in their argument and neglecting the needs of the
child.
Mother confirmed the allegations were true. Mother and
Christopher S. also admitted disciplining Abigail by hitting her
with a belt on one occasion. Christopher S. indicated, though he
had only used the belt on Abigail once, he would refrain from
such behavior in the future.
Abigail, six years old and entering first grade, reported her
basic needs were met at home and denied anyone was mean to
her. Abigail did confirm Christopher S. hits her with a belt on
her bottom when she misbehaves and reported having been left
with a bruise on her leg. Abigail considered Christopher S. her
father and calls him “Daddy.” Abigail confirmed mother and
3
Christopher S. fight and hit each other. Mother and Abigail had
not had contact with father for five years as, he was not part of
Abigail’s life.
The family agreed to a voluntary safety plan. The children
remained with mother at the home of maternal grandmother.
On August 10, 2022, DCFS was unable to contact father at
his last known number, but the social worker left a detailed
message.
Petition and initial hearing
On August 15, 2022, DCFS filed a section 300 petition on
behalf of Abigail and her half siblings alleging mother and
Christopher S. engaged in domestic violence, that Christopher S.
had mental and emotional problems, including suicidal ideation
and self-harming behavior, and that Christopher S. physically
abused Abigail by striking her with a belt, causing bruising.
Father was not named in the petition.3
Father was present at the August 29, 2022 initial hearing.
The juvenile court found he was Abigail’s presumed father. The
court released Abigail and her half siblings to the home of mother
under the supervision of DCFS. The court noted father was not
named in the section 300 petition and ordered DCFS to assist in
setting up conjoint counseling for father with Abigail. Father
was granted monitored visitation, with DCFS given discretion to
liberalize.
Jurisdiction and disposition
The jurisdiction hearing took place on October 12, 2022.
Father appeared by phone with counsel, who informed the court
3 On September 29, 2022, a first amended petition was filed
adding a count regarding Luis P., but not father.
4
father was having trouble reaching the social worker. Counsel
requested the social worker contact father by the end of the week
to arrange visitation. Father had not yet had a visit with Abigail.
On November 1, 2022, father again appeared with counsel,
who raised the issue of visitation, explaining father had not had a
visit with Abigail despite his efforts to contact the social worker.
In addition, DCFS was supposed to evaluate father’s home and
had not yet done so.
The court declared Abigail a dependent of the court and
released her to the home of mother. Father was ordered to
participate in conjoint counseling with Abigail when deemed
appropriate by the child’s therapist. Father was granted
monitored visits, with discretion to liberalize, twice a week for
two hours. The court set a hearing date of November 30, 2022, to
address father’s visitation with Abigail, a progress hearing for
January 31, 2023, and a review hearing for May 2, 2023.
Progress reports and hearings
On October 12, 2022, November 4, 2022, and November 16,
2022, the social worker telephoned father and left detailed
messages, including her contact information. Father had still not
been in contact with DCFS.
On November 15, 2022, the social worker spoke with
Abigail, who had no memory of father and did not want to visit
with him. The social worker informed Abigail she would not be
forced to visit, but they would address the issue again.
At the November 30, 2022 hearing, father denied anyone
from DCFS had telephoned him, yet acknowledged the telephone
number in the report was his. Father had no visits, and conjoint
counseling had not begun. The court noted Abigail did not want
visits, and suggested starting with monitored virtual visits. The
5
court ordered Abigail’s therapist to assist with her resistance to
visits and incorporate father into the therapy. County counsel
reiterated father had not been in touch with DCFS.
At the progress hearing on January 31, 2023, father
appeared by telephone with counsel, who indicated father had
been unsuccessfully trying to have visits with Abigail and
requested that DCFS contact him. The children’s attorney noted
Abigail’s therapist was supposed to be dealing with the issue, and
it was not as simple as merely setting up visits.
In a status review report filed on April 28, 2023, DCFS
noted mother and Christopher S. had fully complied with their
court-ordered treatment programs. The three children were
living with mother and Christopher S. Mother and
Christopher S. had regular contact with DCFS and continued to
protect the children from further exposure to family violence.
Christopher S. took full responsibility for his actions and
expressed gratitude to DCFS for helping him get his life together.
In an interview on April 21, 2023, Abigail stated, “I love my
family and I am happy. Daddy Christopher is good to me.”
DCFS assessed the family’s risk level as low and
recommended termination of juvenile court jurisdiction.
On May 30, 2023, DCFS filed a last minute information for
the court indicating the social worker had met with father at the
DCFS office. Father reported he lived with his sister and niece in
Pasadena and worked Monday through Friday from 5:00 p.m. to
1:30 a.m. Father had no contact with Abigail for five years
because mother relocated, stopped all communication with him,
and hid Abigail from him. Mother’s family refused to tell him
anything. Father admitted engaging in the physical altercation
in 2017 when he saw mother with Christopher S. Mother had
6
then obtained a three-year restraining order that prevented
contact between father and mother and Abigail. Father did not
want to wait any longer to have contact with Abigail. He
indicated he would ask his sister to monitor visits. The social
worker informed father that Abigail did not want visits. Father
understood and would continue to be available for visits. On
May 11, 2023, the social worker submitted a mental health
referral for conjoint counseling.
On May 19, 2023, DCFS interviewed mother, who stated
father’s last contact with Abigail had been in 2017, and he had
never been in the child’s life. Mother denied keeping Abigail
from father and said he had opportunities to get in touch with
Abigail and be part of her life.
Abigail told the social worker she did not remember
anything about father. Abigail did not want to visit with father
because she did not know him.
DCFS informed the court father “has not been available to
[DCFS] to work toward having visitations with the child Abigail
and participate in conjoint counseling.” DCFS recommended
termination of jurisdiction over Abigail with sole legal and
physical custody to mother and monitored visits for father.
Termination of jurisdiction
On May 31, 2023, the juvenile court held a review hearing
that father attended by Webex with counsel. The court ordered
sole legal and physical custody to mother, with father to have
visits once a month at a minimum. Father’s counsel did not
object to the court’s order. The court did not need a custody order
for Matthew and terminated jurisdiction on that date. As to
Abigail and Darlene, the court continued the matter for
submission of a custody order.
7
On June 7, 2023, the juvenile court filed the custody order
regarding Abigail that specified, “Father has monitored visits a
minimum of 2 hrs per visit once per month. Visits to be
monitored by a mutually agreed upon monitor or professional
monitor paid for by Father.” The order indicated father had not
completed, nor made substantial progress in, conjoint counseling
with Abigail.
Notice of appeal
On June 13, 2023, father filed a notice of appeal from the
orders made on May 31, 2023, at the section 364 hearing.
DISCUSSION
I. Mootness
DCFS argues father’s appeal of the May 31, 2023 orders
was rendered moot by the subsequent issuance of the custody
order on June 7, 2023. DCFS points out that father’s notice of
appeal identified only the findings made on May 31, 2023, and
father failed to appeal from the issuance of the custody order on
June 7, 2023, which superseded the court’s previous order. Thus,
reversal of the orders made on May 31, 2023, would not provide
father any effective relief. DCFS argues father’s appeal is
therefore moot. (Citing In re E.T. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 426,
436 [“An appeal may become moot where subsequent events,
including orders by the juvenile court, render it impossible for the
reviewing court to grant effective relief.”]; In re Dani R. (2001) 89
Cal.App.4th 402, 404 [granting of mother’s § 388 petition and
stipulation of parents to findings of the juvenile court rendered
appeal moot].)
“A judgment in a proceeding under Section 300 may be
appealed in the same manner as any final judgment, and any
8
subsequent order may be appealed as an order after judgment.”
(§ 395, subd. (a)(1); accord, In re S.B. (2009) 46 Cal.4th 529, 531-
532.) “The dispositional order is the ‘judgment’ referred to in
section 395, and all subsequent orders are appealable.” (In re
S.B., at p. 532.) “‘“A consequence of section 395 is that an
unappealed disposition or postdisposition order is final and
binding and may not be attacked on an appeal from a later
appealable order.”’” (Ibid.)
However, “[g]enerally, we must liberally construe a notice
of appeal in favor of its sufficiency. (Cal. Rules of Court, rules
8.100(a)(2), 8.405(a)(3).) A notice of appeal shall be ‘“liberally
construed so as to protect the right of appeal if it is reasonably
clear what [the] appellant was trying to appeal from, and where
the respondent could not possibly have been misled or
prejudiced.”’” (In re J.F. (2019) 39 Cal.App.5th 70, 75.)
There are limits to a court’s ability to liberally construe a
notice of appeal. (In re J.F., supra, 39 Cal.App.5th at p. 76.)
“‘The policy of liberally construing a notice of appeal in favor of
its sufficiency [citation] does not apply if the notice is so specific it
cannot be read as reaching a judgment or order not mentioned at
all.’” (Ibid.) “‘[I]t is well “beyond liberal construction” to view an
appeal from one order as an appeal from a “further and different
order.”’” (Ibid.)
Here, we find we may liberally construe father’s notice of
appeal to include the later-issued order of June 7, 2023. On
May 31, 2023, the juvenile court made the findings and orders on
the record and stayed termination of jurisdiction until June 7,
2023, to allow mother’s counsel to prepare and submit the
juvenile custody order. Father’s notice of appeal, which was filed
just six days after the filing of the juvenile custody order, may
9
reasonably be construed to encompass the June 7, 2023 order.
The June 7, 2023 order was not a different order, but the same
order, reduced to writing. Further, DCFS could not have been
misled or prejudiced by father’s failure to specify the later order.
The June 7, 2023 order did not differ substantively from the
order made verbally on May 31, 2023.
Under the circumstances, we elect to liberally construe
father’s notice of appeal to include the June 7, 2023 order and
address father’s arguments on the merits.
II. Applicable law and standard of review
Section 364 applies when “a child under the supervision of
the juvenile court . . . is not removed from the physical custody of
his or her parent or guardian.” (§ 364, subd. (a).) Because
Abigail remained with mother throughout these proceedings,
section 364 is applicable here.
Section 364, subdivision (c) provides: “After hearing any
evidence presented by the social worker, the parent, the
guardian, or the child, the court shall determine whether
continued supervision is necessary. The court shall terminate its
jurisdiction unless the social worker or his or her department
establishes by a preponderance of evidence that the conditions
still exist which would justify initial assumption of jurisdiction
under Section 300, or that those conditions are likely to exist if
supervision is withdrawn. Failure of the parent or guardian to
participate regularly in any court ordered treatment program
shall constitute prima facie evidence that the conditions which
justified initial assumption of jurisdiction still exist and that
continued supervision is necessary.”
Section 364 thus provides a statutory presumption in favor
of termination of jurisdiction unless a party proves, by a
10
preponderance of evidence, the conditions still exist that justified
the initial assumption of jurisdiction. (In re Aurora P. (2015) 241
Cal.App.4th 1142, 1155 (Aurora P.).) Under the statute, “the
juvenile court must terminate dependency jurisdiction unless
either the parent, the guardian, the child, or the social services
agency establishes by a preponderance of the evidence that the
conditions justifying assumption of jurisdiction exist or will exist
if supervision is withdrawn.” (Id. at pp. 1155-1156.) In short,
under section 364, “termination of dependency jurisdiction will be
the ‘default result.’” (Aurora P., at p. 1156.) The juvenile court
makes its determination as to whether or not to continue
jurisdiction “‘based on the totality of the evidence before it.’” (Id.
at p. 1155.)
Orders terminating jurisdiction pursuant to section 364 are
reviewed for substantial evidence. (Aurora P., supra, 241
Cal.App.4th at p. 1156.) The party challenging the juvenile
court’s decision to terminate jurisdiction has the burden of
proving that conditions justifying assumption of jurisdiction
continued to exist or would exist if supervision were withdrawn.
(Id. at pp. 1155-1156.)
III. Father has failed to meet his burden of proof
Father has the burden of proving that the evidence before
the juvenile court compelled a finding that continued supervision
was necessary because conditions justifying assumption of
jurisdiction continued to exist or would exist if supervision were
withdrawn. (Aurora P., supra, 241 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1157,
1163.) Father has failed to meet this burden.
Abigail came under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court
due to domestic violence between mother and Christopher S.,
Christopher S.’s mental and emotional problems, and
11
Christopher S.’s physical abuse of Abigail. Father had no
relationship of any kind with Abigail at the time these
proceedings commenced.
At the section 364 hearing, the juvenile court had evidence
showing mother and Christopher S. substantially complied with
their court-ordered case plans and there were no longer any
safety issues requiring juvenile court supervision. Abigail had
remained with mother throughout the proceedings and expressed
to the social worker that she felt happy and safe in the home.
Father provided no evidence at the section 364 hearing
suggesting the conditions justifying court supervision remained
or that such conditions would exist if supervision were
withdrawn. Under the circumstances, termination of jurisdiction
was mandatory. (§ 364).
Father argues that termination of jurisdiction was error
because the juvenile court did not require DCFS to carry out the
initial orders regarding conjoint counseling between father and
Abigail. However, Abigail’s relationship with father was not one
of the conditions that brought Abigail within the jurisdiction of
the juvenile court. At the time the juvenile court exercised
jurisdiction, father had not seen Abigail in five years. Nothing in
section 364 permits the juvenile court to retain jurisdiction to
assist in counseling with a nonoffending parent. Because the
conditions no longer existed that justified the initial assumption
of jurisdiction, the court was required to terminate its jurisdiction
over Abigail.
Father has the benefit of the custody order to enforce his
rights to visitation with Abigail in family court. Father contends
it will be difficult for him to make substantial progress in conjoint
counseling without the cooperation of DCFS or mother in this
12
case. Again, father points to no legal authority suggesting a
juvenile court may retain jurisdiction over a child in order to
assist a parent in furthering his relationship with a child he
admittedly has not seen in over five years.
Father points out pursuant to section 202, subdivision (a),
the purpose of the juvenile court law is to “preserve and
strengthen the minor’s family ties whenever possible.” Father
argues completion of conjoint counseling with Abigail could have
constituted a significant change of circumstances for the purpose
of modifying the juvenile court’s final custody order. However,
due to father’s absence from so much of Abigail’s young life, the
family unit the juvenile court was concerned with consisted of the
children, mother, and Christopher S. The evidence showed
Abigail did not remember father and thought of Christopher S. as
her father. The juvenile court was not required to become
involved with reuniting absent parents who were not part of the
child’s life at the time the proceedings commenced.
Father objects that the juvenile court removed Abigail from
father during the proceedings, although he was nonoffending.
Father did not appeal the November 1, 2022 order removing
Abigail from his custody. “‘“[A]n unappealed disposition or
postdisposition order is final and binding and may not be
attacked on an appeal from a later appealable order.”’” (In re
S.B., supra, 46 Cal.4th at p. 532.) Father did not list the removal
order in his notice of appeal, and it is not before us in this appeal.
Father may raise custody issues in the family law court.
Father failed to satisfy his burden of showing conditions
existed that would justify initial assumption of jurisdiction under
section 300 or that those conditions were likely to exist if
supervision were withdrawn. (§ 364, subd. (c); Aurora P., supra,
13
241 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1155-1156.) The juvenile court properly
terminated jurisdiction over Abigail.
DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.
________________________
CHAVEZ, J.
We concur:
________________________
LUI, P. J.
________________________
HOFFSTADT, J.
14
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.