In re Ro.H. CA4/3

CourtListener 10871969CalctappJun 8, 2026

Full text

Filed 6/8/26 In re Ro.H. CA4/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

In re Ro.H., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.

ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL
SERVICES AGENCY,
G066295
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. 25DP0042)
v.
OPINION
Re.H.,

Defendant and Appellant.

Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Orange County,
June Jee An, Judge. Affirmed.
Michelle D. Peña, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Leon J. Page, County Counsel, Debbie Torrez and Aurelio Torre,
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
No appearance for the Minor.
* * *

Re.H. (mother) appeals from a custody order concerning her nine-
year-old daughter Ro.H. (minor)1 issued at the close of dependency
proceedings pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 362.4.2 The
juvenile court granted N.H. (father) sole physical custody and tiebreaking
authority within the parents’ joint legal custody, and ordered mother to have
supervised visitation. Mother claims this was error. We find no abuse of the
court’s discretion and affirm the order.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND3
I.
DETENTION
Orange County Social Services Agency (SSA) removed minor and
her siblings from their parents in January 2025 after receiving substantiated
allegations of general neglect, emotional abuse, and risk to the siblings. The
parents were allegedly aware minor’s siblings had been experiencing mental

1 While this appeal concerns only minor, we reference her two

siblings, L.H. and J.H., throughout the opinion.
2 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and

Institutions Code.
3 Our factual summary is limited to those facts relevant to the

issues presented in this appeal.

2
health issues, including suicidal ideation, past suicide attempts, and self-
harming, but had neglected to follow up with medications and therapist
appointments.
At the time of detention, the parents shared custody of the
children. Per the custody order, mother had 40 percent custody, and father
had the children every other weekend and every other Wednesday. The
parents, however, would alternate custody with the children weekly. Overall,
the custody situation was contentious.
In its detention report, SSA noted father seemingly had issues
with alcohol use. Additionally, mother had mental health issues and had
attempted suicide. According to father, mother repeatedly spoke negatively
about him to the children, even though the courts and mental health
professionals had warned the parents about the negative effect this could
have on children. Mother also told the children they could legally refuse to go
with father without getting into trouble.
SSA interviewed both of minor’s sibling’s therapists about the
family. Both siblings had expressed concerns about father’s drinking,
although one sibling did not bring up any concerning behavior father
exhibited while drinking. Both therapists explained father was available to
his children, concerned for them, and empathetic towards them. One
therapist described him as organized and involved with the children. Overall,
there were no concerns about father’s parenting behaviors. On the other
hand, mother had obsessive or enmeshed relationships with the children. She
was disorganized and unstable, would lose focus during sessions, and would
become aggressive towards the therapist. Mother had threatened to
terminate all J.H.’s medical providers and find new ones. She also punched a
wall during an argument with father in front of L.H. Mother would bring up

3
the past, become adamant that the children were sick or had medical issues,
and make her own diagnosis even when the therapist saw no signs or
symptoms of the diagnosis. Additionally, mother would express “‘concerns out
of the blue.’” For example, mother was concerned L.H. had been sexually
abused because she changed her clothing style from “girly to tomboy.” Thus,
the therapists believed the children would be safer with father rather than
with mother.
SSA also interviewed minor’s therapist. Minor began to see her
because she was experiencing anxiety after the parents separated and began
having custody issues. Minor had a difficult time when she could not see
mother after mother’s suicide attempt. The therapist reported father would
provide a more stable environment for minor than mother because mother
would “stir things up.”
II.
JURISDICTION AND DISPOSITION
SSA filed a jurisdiction and disposition report in February 2025.
At the time, minor denied seeing father act out of character, belligerent, or
aggressive. Father would consume alcohol but would act normal. While she
was worried about the constant verbal arguing between the parents, minor
wanted to continue visiting with them.
When SSA interviewed the parents, mother admitted she had
diagnosed L.H. with a mental health disorder. However, mother claimed the
therapist was not credentialed to identify some of the disorders. Additionally,
mother alleged J.H. had attempted suicide because of daily verbal and
physical abuse. According to father, mother would doctor shop to ensure J.H.
was diagnosed as mother wanted. Moreover, mother was coaching the
children and alienating them from father. Father also alleged mother was

4
upset the juvenile court had granted him full medical consent over the
children and allowed him to “overwrite” mother when it came to medical
needs or medical disagreements.
The juvenile court sustained an amended petition in February
2025. The sustained petition detailed that minor was at risk of harm based
on the parents’ contentious relationship, minor’s mental health issues, and
mother’s perceptions of the children’s well-being.4
In its first March 2025 addendum report, SSA recommended
mother’s visitation be restricted to monitored. The maternal grandmother
reported she had found a handwritten note from mother in J.H.’s belongings.
The note listed “things outside your control” including numerous genetic
disorders, “family history of mental health,” and a list of specific mental
health disorders. The maternal grandmother believed the note triggered
J.H.’s emotional distress. Mother also continued to tell the children about
their alleged diagnoses. Additionally, mother had reported to SSA that J.H.
had been assaulted during a recent hospitalization, and this assault caused
J.H. to faint. The contact at the hospital denied this assault took place.
Mother also told SSA that J.H. should not be placed with paternal
grandmother because she “was in a Satanic Cult” and “‘had given birth to
hundreds of babies before the age of 16.’” She also alleged paternal
grandmother’s parents had “‘sacrificed to Satan in ritual murder.’”
In the same March 2025 report, SSA reported father had found
an email from mother to J.H’s doctor asking if J.H. could have a specific
medical condition. Father believed mother was seeking out doctors to

4 The juvenile court also sustained allegations regarding minor’s

siblings.

5
diagnose J.H. with a medical condition. During this time, minor’s visits with
father were going well. Maternal grandmother reported minor was happy to
see father and happy after the visits. Based on this report, the juvenile court
followed SSA’s recommendation and ordered minor be released to father’s
care and monitored visitation for mother. The court also ordered mother not
to make medical appointments, make recommendations, or seek direct
treatment with the children’s medical providers. Additionally, the court
ordered mother not to discuss medical conditions, diagnosis, or symptoms
with the children.
In its second March 2025 addendum report, SSA noted father had
reached out to express concern over an interaction between mother and
minor. Mother had been telling minor she had allergy issues like mother and
needed to take an allergy pill before playing sports. After the game, mother
stopped minor and pointed to, then touched minor’s face. When father spoke
to minor a minute later, minor said “‘Oh, my face is so red, my face is so red!’”
Father also discovered mother had told maternal grandmother to give minor
an allergy pill before the game. Maternal grandmother refused and explained
to mother that face flushing is normal. Father reported mother had been
saying minor had allergies and needed medication. Father was concerned
about this interaction because he believed mother would continue to diagnose
the children and tell them they are sick even when supervised.
In the same second addendum report, SSA reported on an
interview with minor. Minor felt safe living with father but would like to live
part time with both parents. She described her visits with mother as “good”
and claimed mother did not talk about father.

6
At the April 2025 hearing, the juvenile court determined custody
with mother would be detrimental. The court granted enhancement services
to mother and ordered she undergo an Evidence Code section 730 evaluation.
III.
FAMILY MAINTENANCE
SSA filed a status review report in September 2025. At the time,
minor continued to live with father. Minor reported she felt happy and calm
all the time. Minor’s therapist reported minor had no major symptoms and
was able to adjust well to her living situation. Mother reported to SSA that
she had learned how to be understanding and patient with minor. Moreover,
she shared she did not force or pressure her relationship with minor and gave
her space when she needed it. Mother also stated she learned not to talk
badly about father to minor. Mother’s therapist reported mother was open,
honest, and willing to comply with juvenile court orders. As for visitation,
mother continued to have monitored visitation with minor, and the visits
were going well. During the visits, mother would not bring up medical topics.
Father had complied with his case plan and learned not to speak negatively
about the mother to the children. Father also continued to seek therapy and
make time for self-care. Father’s therapist reported father was making
positive progress. Minor was doing well in father’s care.
SSA filed an addendum report in October 2025, recommending
the dependency proceedings be terminated with exit orders. Minor continued
to have positive visitation with mother and felt safe in her care. Later that
month, SSA filed a second addendum report. Minor reported her visits with
mother were still going well. SSA reported mother had sent father’s therapist
a long text message where she seemingly tried to manipulate and sway the
therapist into thinking critically of father. In the message, mother stated she

7
had never spoken negatively about father to the children. She accused father
of never taking responsibility, apologizing, or admitting he was wrong. She
also claimed he “would twist the narrative” during marriage therapy and
leave out information so he would not look bad. Mother also accused father of
defaming her, lying under oath, making false accusations, and falsely
accusing mother of having Munchausen’s by proxy. She further claimed
father refused to take the children to doctors or therapists to address their
mental health issues.
IV.
TERMINATION
The juvenile court terminated jurisdiction over minor in
November 2025. In the exit order, the court granted father sole physical
custody, and the parents joint legal custody with tie-breaking authority to
father should the parents disagree about any medical, dental, or spiritual
decision. The court also ordered mother to have supervised visitation with
minor up to 10 hours a week on Fridays from 4:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m. and
Saturday from 2:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m. If minor’s siblings had their visits
liberalized to unsupervised, minor was allowed to participate in those visits
up to four hours per week. Her siblings were to be present at those visits.
While mother was allowed to attend minor’s extracurricular activities, she
was to do so as an observer only. Mother could not contact minor during the
activities and, if minor initiated contact, mother was to redirect her. Mother
was prohibited from discussing medical issues, conditions, or treatments with
minor during visitation, even if minor asked about them.
Mother timely appealed.

8
DISCUSSION
I.
APPLICABLE LAW
When terminating its jurisdiction over a child who has been
declared a dependent child of the court, the juvenile court may issue “an
order determining the custody of, or visitation with, the child.” (§ 362.4, subd.
(a).) The orders remain in effect until modified or terminated by a subsequent
order in the family court. (In re T.S. (2020) 52 Cal.App.5th 503, 513 (T.S.).)
When making an order under section 362.4, “‘the court’s focus
and primary consideration must always be the best interests of the child.’”
(T.S., supra, 52 Cal.App.5th at p. 513.) Thus, certain statutory presumptions
in the Family Code do not apply. (In re Jennifer R. (1993) 14 Cal.App.4th 704,
711.)
II.
STANDARD OF REVIEW
We review a juvenile court’s custody and visitation order for an
abuse of discretion. (In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295, 318.) A
reviewing court should not disturb a custody determination in a dependency
proceeding “‘“unless the trial court has exceeded the limits of legal discretion
by making an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd determination.”’”
(Ibid.) “‘“When two or more inferences can reasonably be deduced from the
facts, the reviewing court has no authority to substitute its decision for that
of the trial court.”’” (Id. at p. 319.)
An abuse of discretion may arise if the juvenile court bases its
decision on impermissible factors or an incorrect legal standard. (People v.
Knoller (2007) 41 Cal.4th 139, 156.)

9
III.
ANALYSIS
A. Custody
First, mother argues the juvenile court abused its discretion by
ordering father to have sole physical custody of minor. SSA contends mother
forfeited this challenge by failing to request physical custody or object to the
exit order. We agree with SSA.
Reviewing courts “ordinarily will not consider a challenge to a
ruling if an objection could have been but was not made in the trial court.” (In
re S.B. (2004) 32 Cal.4th 1287, 1293 (S.B.).) This forfeiture rule is meant to
“encourage parties to bring errors to the attention of the trial court, so that
they may be corrected.” (Ibid.) The rule applies in dependency cases, and “the
failure to object to a disposition order on a specific ground generally forfeits a
parent’s right to pursue that issue on appeal.” (In re Anthony Q. (2016) 5
Cal.App.5th 336, 345; see In re Malick T. (2022) 73 Cal.App.5th 1109, 1127
[“[F]orfeiture generally applies when a party did not alert the juvenile court
that he or she objected to an order being made or when a party failed to ask
in the juvenile court for relief being sought on appeal.”].) Although
application of the forfeiture rule is not automatic, a reviewing court should
exercise its discretion to excuse forfeiture “rarely and only in cases presenting
an important legal issue.” (S.B., at p. 1293; see Anthony Q., at p. 345
[“Although the forfeiture doctrine applies in dependency cases . . . [citations],
when the appeal involves an important and purely legal issue subject to our
independent review . . . , we have discretion to entertain the challenge to the
juvenile court’s order notwithstanding the parent’s failure to object on that
basis in the juvenile court”].)

10
Mother concedes she did not request joint physical custody or
object to the exit order. She argues she did not do so because, based on off-
record discussions, such a request would have been futile. The record does not
support this contention. The reference to the “off the record” discussion
mother cites indicates the discussions pertained to visitation. Thus, we
determine mother forfeited her challenge to the portion of the exit order
granting father sole physical custody.
B. Visitation
Second, mother argues the juvenile court abused its discretion
when it ordered supervised visitation because the court improperly delegated
its authority over visitation orders. The record does not support this
argument.
“‘The power to determine the right and extent of visitation by a
noncustodial parent in a dependency case resides with the court and may not
be delegated to nonjudicial officials or private parties. [Citation.] This rule of
nondelegation applies to exit orders issued when dependency jurisdiction is
terminated.’” (In re A.C. (2011) 197 Cal.App.4th 796, 799.) Although a
juvenile court may delegate to a third party the responsibility to manage the
details of visitation, such as the time, place and manner of visits (In re
Moriah T. (1994) 23 Cal.App.4th 1367, 1374–1376), a visitation order that
actually or effectively allows a third party (including a parent) to decide
whether visitation occurs at all is impermissible because it erroneously
delegates the judicial power to set visitation. (In re Armando L. (2016) 1
Cal.App.5th 606, 616; In re Rebecca S. (2010) 181 Cal.App.4th 1310, 1314; In
re S.H. (2003) 111 Cal.App.4th 310, 317–319.)
Mother relies on In re T.H. (2010) 190 Cal.App.4th 1119 for the
proposition that the juvenile court delegated its authority over visitation

11
orders to a third party. In T.H., the court’s exit order provided visitation for
the noncustodial parent “only upon the ‘agreement of the parents[,]’”
“effectively delegat[ing] to [the custodial parent] the power to determine
whether visitation w[ould] occur at all.” (Id. at p. 1123.) The court’s abuse of
discretion in that case was “framing its order in a way that gave [the
custodial parent] an effective veto power over” the noncustodial parent’s
visitation rights. (Id. at p. 1124.) Here, mother contends SSA and the court
weighed heavily on father’s opinion of her visitation. By doing so, mother
contends the court gave father authority to determine whether visitation
occurs. The record, however, clearly identifies mother’s visitation schedule.
The schedule does not provide any veto authority to father. Similarly, mother
contends the court effectively delegated visitation to a third party when it
made mother’s visits with minor contingent on her success with her visits
with minor’s siblings. The contingent visitation schedule is a step-up plan
intended to provide mother with additional visits with minor. The limitations
of those visits are also clearly defined by the order. Because mother has not
shown the exit order allows father or a third-party to curtail her visitation
rights, the court did not abuse its discretion.
C. Tie-Breaking Authority
Third, mother contends the juvenile court erroneously ordered
father to have tie-breaking authority. In making this decision, mother
contends the court overlooked father’s disparaging remarks about mother
and “inattention to the older siblings’ mental health issues.” Additionally,
mother contends the court overlooked her “inability” to help the older
siblings’ mental health issues due to the family court order limiting her
medical decision-making.

12
We conclude the juvenile court could reasonably have found the
order to be in minor’s best interest. Contrary to mother’s argument, the fact
the parents had difficulty coparenting tends to support an order granting one
parent tie-breaking authority. When parents who share joint legal custody
cannot coparent, decisions cannot be made. Decisions ranging from medical
care, what school to go to, and even what sports to play, get delayed or end in
a stand-off. Moreover, it is often reasonable to award tie-breaking authority
to the parent who is the primary custodial parent; here, that parent is father.
It would make little sense to award mother tie-breaking authority when
minor lived with father full-time and spent 10 hours a week with mother. We
find no abuse of discretion.
As stated previously, these orders remain subject to modification.
If circumstances change, either parent can file a request in family court to
modify this order.

DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order is affirmed.

DELANEY, ACTING P. J.

WE CONCUR:

SCOTT, J.

GOODING, J.

13

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.