In re M.P. CA1/4

CourtListener 10855922CalctappMay 7, 2026

Full text

Filed 5/7/26 In re M.P. CA1/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not
been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FOUR

In re M.P. et al., Persons
Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law.

L.C.,
Defendant and
Appellant,
A175076
v.
SOLANO COUNTY HEALTH (Solano County Super. Ct.
AND HUMAN SERVICES Nos. JD25-00056,
DEPARTMENT, J43474-001)
Plaintiff and Respondent.

L.C. (mother) appeals an order issued following a combined
jurisdiction and disposition hearing on a Welfare and Institutions
Code1 section 300 petition regarding her now twelve-year-old son,
M.P., and her now three-year-old daughter, P.P. Mother does not
challenge the court’s jurisdictional findings but argues that the
court erred in removing the children from her care. We find no
error and affirm the order.

1 All undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare

and Institutions Code.
BACKGROUND
On July 30, 2025, the department received a referral
regarding concerns for excessive physical discipline of M.P. as
well as emotional abuse relating to domestic violence in the
home. Specifically, it was reported that father had choked M.P.
and attempted to harm mother when she intervened, and that
P.P. was present during the incident. Interviews with mother
and M.P. the following day confirmed the report.
On August 7, the department filed a petition under section
300, subdivision (b)(1). As to mother, the petition alleged that
she and father had a significant history of engaging in domestic
violence in the minors’ presence and, based in part on the events
of July 30, that she is unable to protect M.P. from father’s
excessive discipline. With respect to father, the petition alleges
that his “engagement in domestic disputes and inability to
control his anger in the presence of the minor[s] places the
minors at significant risk of physical harm, abuse and/or neglect.”
Before the detention hearing, the social worker reported
that in an interview on July 31, mother said that she and father
have been in a relationship since 2013. Mother indicated that
she called the police on July 30 due to safety concerns. The
report states: “When law enforcement arrived, the mother denied
a restraining order and reported she is ‘not ready’ to take that
step.” Mother told the social worker that she “would like father
to take anger management classes” and that she “would work
with the property manager to have her locks changed, as she did
not want the father back in the home.” Mother and the social

2
worker completed a safety plan that indicated she would contact
law enforcement if father returned to the home and she would
contact her support people if she felt unsafe due to father
attempting to come to the home.
The social worker reported further that mother and father
had a prior dependency case from 2016 in which the court
sustained allegations that mother and father were unable to
protect M.P. as a result of domestic violence in their relationship.
At that time, M.P. was removed from father’s care but continued
in mother’s care with family maintenance services. Jurisdiction
was terminated with the parents having joint legal custody and
mother having sole physical custody. The report also lists an
additional child welfare referral in 2023 for emotional and
physical abuse of M.P. that was determined to be inconclusive
after investigation.
The social worker also interviewed other family members
who confirmed the parents’ lengthy history of domestic violence.
Mother’s aunt reported that mother and father have had ongoing
domestic violence throughout their relationship, with both
parents being the aggressors. Another maternal aunt indicated
that she was aware of the domestic violence history of the
parents and reported concern that mother feels father is the only
person she can depend on for support and does not believe her
children can be removed from her for father’s actions. Mother’s
in-home support staff worker was also interviewed and indicated

3
that mother and father have frequent arguments and have been
together for a long time.2
At a meeting on August 4, the social worker reiterated her
safety concerns and mother acknowledged that she had changed
the locks to her home before but thereafter gave the father “a
key, as the father is able to speak to her in a way that makes her
continue to have a relationship with him.” The social worker
reported that mother was “unreceptive” to her safety suggestions,
which included a restraining order, supervised visits, and
changing current custody and visitation orders.
Finally, the social worker reported that during a follow-up
conversation with mother on August 6, mother reported that, at
her request, father came to the home on Sunday, August 3 to help
with diapers and milk.
At the detention hearing on August 8, mother objected to
detention of the minors and asserted that she would not permit
father to have unauthorized or unsupervised contact with the
minors and would work with service providers. The department
indicated that it would like the discretion to release the children
to mother with notice if it is able to work with her providers and
counsel and ensure safety prior to disposition. The court ordered
the children detained and granted the department’s request for
discretion to return the minors to mother with ten-day notice to
all counsel. The department was ordered to provide services to

2 Mother receives support services for a global

developmental delay that can affect learning and memory.

4
parents pending the jurisdiction hearing, including parenting
education, mental health services, and domestic violence services.
On September 11, the department filed a combined
Jurisdiction/Disposition Report recommending that the court
sustain the allegations contained in the petition, continue the
children’s detention, and offer reunification services to both
mother and father. The social worker reported that on
September 3 she had an interview with mother during which
mother said that she “overreacted” when she called the police on
the father, and that the children were taken from her because
she called the police. She specified that she and father argue a
lot, that father yells a lot when disciplining the children, and that
he “has a bad temper.” She said that his anger is “scary” and
reported feeling unsafe at an 8 or 9 on a scale of 1 to 10. When
asked about her plans to keep the children safe, mother
responded that she would not allow father to chastise the kids
and she would have his visits outside the home, with her mom
present. While mother initially stated that she would not call her
interactions with father “domestic violence,” after the social
worker described the cycle of violence and discussed behaviors of
abusers, mother agreed that the conduct sounded familiar to her.
The Jurisdiction/Disposition report stated that mother had
signed up for anger management classes and completed two
classes by that time. The social worker spoke with the service
provider and arranged for mother to enroll in domestic violence
classes immediately. The social worker verified that mother was
enrolled in parenting classes and had in-home support services

5
that were providing her with a full-time caregiver who transports
her to and from appointments and helps her with daily living
activities. Finally, the social worker provided mother with
referrals for individual counseling.
The Jurisdiction/Disposition report contained the
department’s assessment the minors would not be safe in
mother’s care due to her history of domestic violence with father,
lack of insight into the actions of father being violent, prior
violation of the safety plan, and her previous inability to protect
M.P. from corporal punishment from father. The social worker
explained to mother at the September 3 meeting that “the
Department is concerned that [mother] is saying calling the
police was a mistake and doesn’t feel that there is ongoing
domestic violence . . . . [C]alling the police was being protective of
herself and her son but violating the safety plan and allowing
father in the home[] shows that there are still some things she
needs to be worked on.”
A contested combined Jurisdiction/Disposition hearing was
held on October 24. In an addendum submitted before the
hearing, the social worker reported that on September 15, she
received a text message from mother in which mother accused
her of “being a jerk” and wanting mother not to have her kids for
the holidays because the social worker was in her “feelings about
everything” because mother still gets along with her kid’s father.
When the social worker responded that her job was to ensure the
safety of the children and that mother was “missing the point in
regards to the severity of the situation,” mother responded with

6
several profanity-laced messages and then blocked the social
worker’s phone number. The addendum adds that on September
17, the social worker spoke with mother’s case manager, who
reported that the social worker could communicate with mother
through her for the time being. The addendum also indicates
that mother had enrolled in domestic violence classes and had
completed one class.
Finally, the addendum reports that after a supervised visit
on September 12, at which the visitation supervisor had to
remind mother not to talk to her son about when he might be
going home, mother sent an angry, profanity-laced text message
to the visitation supervisor. The social worker reported that, at a
supervised visit on September 26, security was brought into the
visit and the visit was terminated after mother was repeatedly
confrontational with the visitation supervisor. At the
October 3 visit, mother responded, “I’m about to get irritated”
when the visitation supervisor asked her to pay attention to her
daughter who was engaging in dangerous behaviors. Following
the September 12 visit, mother was referred to therapeutic visits
and she completed her first visit on October 16.
At the hearing, mother explained that she understands
that the department is concerned that she cannot keep her
children safe, but she disagrees because she called the police for
their protection.
With respect to her text messages to her social worker,
mother apologized and acknowledged that she “overreacted and
kind of, said some things [she] shouldn’t have said.” She

7
testified, however, that she still does not talk to the social worker
directly and “will not talk to her at all.” Regarding the issues at
her visits, she claimed that the visitation supervisor
“intentionally bullied me to the point where I had to have my in-
home support worker sitting in those visits with me.” On cross-
examination, she confirmed that she had blocked both her social
worker and the visitation supervisor on her phone. She was
unwilling to unblock her social worker, but agreed that if a new
social worker were assigned, she would not block the new social
worker.
Mother acknowledged that she called father for help with
diapers on August 3. She claimed that she did not understand
that she was not supposed to reach out to him and that the
department “made it seem like I was not trying to protect my
kids because I called for help.” She continued to justify calling
him, explaining that her sisters and godmother were unavailable,
she had just gotten out of the hospital, and her daughter was out
of diapers. She needed help so she called “the only other person
[she knew] would help.” She agreed to her attorney’s suggestion,
however, that in the future if her family members were not
available, she would call her in-home support worker. She
confirmed that if father showed up at her home, she “wouldn’t
answer the door and [she] would call law enforcement.” On cross-
examination, she explained that she did not request a restraining
order against father initially because “he had visitation where he
was supposed to pick up my son every other weekend and he pays

8
child support” and that, as of the hearing, she had no need for a
restraining order because they no longer talk.
Mother testified that since the incident, she is no longer in
a romantic relationship with father and had not seen him since
August 3 when he dropped off the diapers. On cross examination,
she testified, “I don’t even talk to him as far as like any of that.
He doesn’t come see me. He only asks about the kids and that’s
it. . . . I don’t be anywhere near him. He don’t be nowhere near
me.”
When asked whether she regretted calling the police on
July 30, she responded, “[a] little bit.” She explained that she did
not know “that it was going to lead to them taking my kids” or
that the police were “going to make another report to [child
protective services].”
Mother testified that she had started the domestic violence
treatment program and was learning how to tell the difference
between a good and a bad relationship. She also testified,
however, that prior to the July 30 incident, nothing had
happened that would have led her to suspect that the children
were not safe around father “because they have a good
relationship.” When asked about the previous dependency case,
mother indicated she did not feel the prior domestic violence
between her and father was harmful to her children because the
violence was directed towards her and not the kids. She did not
see the domestic violence between her and father as a “problem”
because they “always go through something and make up.” She
did not believe the prior domestic violence impacted M.P. because

9
he was either not in the room when it occurred or because he was
a baby and not “old enough to do anything.”
The social worker, after confirming mother’s participation
in services, opined, “Based on the information that I received and
my investigation, my interviews with the mother, her reactions
to—myself as well as visitation social worker and interviews with
the children, it was my assessment that . . . removal was the best
option at this time so that [mother] could focus on herself and
learn coping skills to manage her anger and to be able to refrain
from domestic violence in order to keep the children safe.” She
did not believe there was an alternative to removal.
On November 12, 2025, the court sustained the allegations
in the petition and found by clear and convincing evidence that
there was a substantial danger to the physical health and
emotional well-being of the minors and there were no reasonable
means by which their physical and emotional health could be
protected without removing them from their parents’ custody.
The court explained: “I believe that from listening to [mother]
that she regrets calling the police because she did not expect that
her children would be removed from her care and that their
removal was surprising to her as in the previous case, [M.P.] was
placed back in her care throughout the dependency proceeding.”
The court also noted that despite having a support system,
including a support worker in her home from 10:00 a.m. to
6:30 p.m., and despite having signed a safety plan under which
she agreed to call the police if father came to her home, mother
“reached out to the father to assist her in getting diapers and

10
things for the baby on August 3, some four days after the incident
in question.” The court observed that, while it is clear that
mother loves her children, she is not clear on how domestic
violence can impact her children. The court cited the testimony
set forth above in support of its belief that mother “is minimizing
domestic violence and its effect on her children.” Finally, the
court noted that by refusing direct communication with her social
worker, mother has made it nearly impossible for the social
worker to assess her services and determine what additional
services are needed so that the children can return home.
DISCUSSION
Under section 361, subdivision (c)(1), a minor may be
removed from the home only if the child protective agency
establishes by clear and convincing evidence that (1) “[t]here is or
would be a substantial danger to the physical health, safety,
protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor if the
minor were returned home” and (2) “there are no reasonable
means by which the minor’s physical health can be protected
without removing the minor from the minor’s parent’s . . .
physical custody.” Under section 361, subdivision (e), the court
must “make a determination as to whether reasonable efforts
were made to prevent or to eliminate the need for removal of the
minor from their home” and “state the facts on which the decision
to remove the minor is based” on the record.
Jurisdictional findings other than severe physical abuse of
a child under the age of five do not result in a presumption in
favor of removal. (In re Zoe H. (2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 58, 72.)

11
Instead, a juvenile court considers the current risk to the child
given the parent’s past conduct and present circumstances.
(In re Cole C. (2009) 174 Cal.App.4th 900, 917.) It is not
necessary to show prior harm to the child; rather, the statute
focuses on averting harm. (Ibid.) We review the juvenile court’s
findings for substantial evidence keeping in mind the clear and
convincing evidence standard. (In re Zoe H., supra,
104 Cal.App.5th at p. 71.)
Mother contends that, in making its dispositional findings
and orders, the court minimized the services in which she was
participating, such as parenting education, therapy, and domestic
violence services, and instead focused on the original allegations
in the petition regarding the physical violence in the home. She
notes that, by the time of the hearing, she had terminated her
relationship with father and agreed to follow the safety plan and
call the police if father came to her home. She was enrolled and
participating in anger management classes and individual
therapy and was participating in a 12-week batterer’s
intervention program. In addition, she had a support worker in
her home every weekday and had support from her two sisters
and her godmother, whom she indicated she could call if she
needed assistance. She argues that her voluntary acceptance of
services, strong support network, and progress were evidence
that the children would not be at risk if placed in her care under
the department’s supervision.
The standard of review, however, requires us to view the
evidence “in the light most favorable to the prevailing party

12
below” (i.e., the department), and to give “due deference” to the
juvenile court’s resolution of conflicts in the evidence.
(Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 996; see also
In re Cole C., supra, 174 Cal.App.4th at p. 918.) Here, the record
contains ample evidence on which the court reasonably found
that, despite mother’s participation in services, the children
would be at risk if placed in mother’s care because she would
likely permit father to have access to the children and that
removal was necessary to protect the children.
Given mother’s prior history with father, the trial court was
not required to accept her testimony that she would abide by her
safety plan going forward. And despite mother’s participation in
services, the court reasonably relied on evidence that showed that
mother’s understanding of domestic violence generally, and the
impacts on children specifically, was limited at that time.
Finally, although mother argues in her reply that she “physically
and emotionally separated herself from Father, with whom she
had been in a relationship for more than a decade,” mother
acknowledged at the hearing that she still communicated with
father regarding the children.
The evidence also establishes, contrary to mother’s
argument, that the department made reasonable efforts to
prevent the need for the children’s removal, but that there were
no reasonable means to protect the children without removing
them from mother’s care. The department’s detention report
indicates that it made reasonable efforts to prevent the need for
the children’s removal by meeting with mother and creating a

13
safety plan, but that the plan was ineffective because mother
immediately violated it. The record shows that at the detention
hearing, the department requested discretion to return the
children to mother’s care. Mother does not dispute that
thereafter the department worked with her existing service
providers to ensure her access to services and that she
participated in those services. The record reflects, however, that
mother demonstrated an inability to manage her anger and a
refusal to communicate with the department. Mother suggests in
her reply that “she remedied the situation by agreeing not to
block the social workers from her phone and agreed to follow the
Department’s directions,” but the record does not support her
claim. As set forth above, she agreed only not to block a new
social worker and continued to refuse direct communication with
her existing social worker. Moreover, the court was not required
to believe her testimony at the hearing when presented with
evidence of her past conduct.
Finally, mother faults the court for failing to articulate
what reasonable alternatives to removal were taken. We find no
error. The court’s citation of the evidence in its ruling is
sufficient to comply with the requirement in section 361,
subdivision (e), that the court state the facts on which the
decision to remove the minor is based.
Accordingly, we find no error in the court’s dispositional
order removing the children from mother’s care.

14
DISPOSITION
The jurisdiction and disposition orders are affirmed.
GOLDMAN, J.

WE CONCUR:

STREETER, Acting P. J.
SWEET, J. *

*Judge of the Marin Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice

pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

15

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.