CourtListener 10850501•K.H. v. Superior Court CA1/4
Full text
Filed 4/29/26 K.H. v. Superior Court CA1/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR
K.H. et al.,
Petitioners,
v.
THE SUPERIOR COURT OF A175348
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY,
(Contra Costa County
Respondent; Super. Ct. No. J2400403)
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES BUREAU,
Real Party in Interest.
In this dependency proceeding involving L.H., a boy born in 2022, the
juvenile court terminated reunification services to L.H.’s parents—K.H.
(Mother) and B.C. (Father)—and set a Welfare and Institutions Code1
section 366.26 selection and implementation hearing. Mother and Father,
through counsel, have filed petitions seeking extraordinary writ relief and
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
1
requesting a stay of the section 366.26 hearing.2 We will deny the petitions
and the stay requests.3
I. BACKGROUND
A. Detention, Jurisdiction, and Disposition
On July 17, 2024, the Contra Costa County Children and Family
Services Bureau (Bureau) filed a section 300 dependency petition on behalf
of 19-month-old L.H. In the petition and an accompanying detention report,
the Bureau alleged that, on July 14, 2024, L.H. and his two-year-old sibling
were playing outside on the hot sidewalk for two hours, naked except for
very soiled diapers, while Mother slept inside the house. A similar incident
reportedly had occurred on July 2, 2024.
In the July 14 incident, police officers, responding to a call from a
neighbor, found the children outside and also noticed numerous items
strewn about the front yard and porch, including a kitchen knife with a six-
inch blade on the outside porch. The officers arrested Mother and detained
L.H. and his siblings. Mother told police the children had not been fed or
changed since the night before, although she later stated they had been fed
and changed that morning.
The petition also alleged Mother had not scheduled necessary medical
appointments for L.H. L.H. was exposed to syphilis at birth and was
supposed to have follow-up exams that Mother did not schedule.
2 The dependency proceedings also involved two of L.H.’s siblings.
Mother states in her writ petition that she is only challenging the juvenile
court’s order as to L.H. Father’s petition similarly focuses on L.H. and
makes no argument about the other children.
3 In addition to the petition filed by her counsel, Mother has submitted
several documents to this court (purportedly as an in propria persona
litigant), including a “petition” and some exhibits. Since Mother is
represented by counsel, we will disregard these unauthorized filings.
2
At a detention hearing on July 17, 2024, the court ordered the
children detained from Mother. L.H. was initially placed with Father.
The Bureau filed an amended petition on September 17, 2024, adding
an allegation that Father had substance abuse problems and had tested
positive for amphetamine, methamphetamine, and cocaine/benzoylecgonine.
On September 18, 2024, the court ordered L.H. detained from Father.
At a contested jurisdiction/disposition hearing in October 2024, the
court sustained the amended petition and directed that Mother and Father
be provided reunification services. The Bureau’s report for the hearing
stated Mother had neglected the children and failed to supervise and protect
them; Father had failed to protect the children from Mother’s conduct; both
parents had engaged in substance abuse; and the Bureau was concerned the
parents would “continue to neglect the needs of the children due to their
inability to provide a safe home environment, provide proper care and
supervision, and medical treatment.”
The parents’ case plan required them to complete parenting classes;
attend the children’s school, therapy and medical appointments, if asked;
stay free from illegal drugs; attend Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) 12-step
meetings; drug test negative for at least six months; and complete
outpatient substance abuse treatment programs. Visitation was to be
provided for both parents.
B. The Six-Month Review
The six-month review hearing commenced on April 2, 2025, continued
on May 7, 2025, and was completed on June 25, 2025. L.H. had been placed
with his paternal grandparents and was stable in their care.
The Bureau recommended continuing services until the 12-month
hearing. According to reports by the Bureau, the family visits were chaotic,
with the parents appearing unprepared to handle the children. Both
3
parents had positive drug tests and missed tests, although some of these
were reclassified as excused. The Bureau received allegations that Mother
used her brother’s urine for tests.
In March 2025, it was reported the parents were participating in some
services, including therapy, drug treatment, and parenting classes. In May
2025, Mother stated she had completed a drug treatment program and was
in an aftercare recovery program. She was taking medication for anxiety.
Father participated in outpatient drug treatment but turned down the
option to reside in an inpatient sober living program.
At the conclusion of the six-month hearing, the court followed the
Bureau’s recommendation, extended reunification services, and scheduled a
12-month review hearing for September 10, 2025. The parents’ case plans
were revised to require participation in individual counseling. The court
also increased visitation from once to twice per week.
C. The Bureau’s Report for the 12-Month Review
In its September 2025 report for the 12-month review hearing, the
Bureau recommended that the court terminate reunification services for the
parents and set a section 366.26 selection and implementation hearing. The
parents had participated in therapy. Mother had seen four different
therapists for short periods of time. The parents reported maintaining a
period of sobriety. Both parents submitted AA/NA sign-in sheets that
included future dates. Both parents had some missed and positive drug
tests between August 2024 and August 2025.
During visits with the children, Mother was described as bringing
unhealthy food and relying on Father to supervise the children. Mother
only minimally engaged with the children and rarely showed affection
toward them. Father provided supervision and engaged with the children.
He provided snacks, sugary foods, soda and juice at the visits. Some visits
4
were chaotic, with the children fighting and inadequately supervised. At
one visit, Mother commented that one of her older children (not one of the
three involved in the current dependency proceeding) is her favorite.
In recommending termination of services, the Bureau stated Father
had relapsed with a positive drug test in May 2025; the parents had not
engaged in sufficient therapeutic services to address the factors that led to
the children’s removal; Mother was not stabilized on psychotropic
medication to address her anxiety; and Mother had not shown the capacity
to meet the children’s needs. The parents appeared to lack an
understanding of the level of care and supervision necessary to meet the
children’s needs. The parents had made minimal progress despite receiving
12 months of services.
D. The 12-Month Review Hearing
The contested 12-month review hearing was held over several court
days, beginning on October 15, 2025, and concluding on January 14, 2026.
The court heard testimony from the social worker, the social casework
assistant (who supervised visits), Mother, and Father. The court also
received documentary evidence.
The social worker stated Mother was not in compliance with the
therapy requirement in her case plan because Mother kept starting with
new providers and was not making progress. One of the therapists provided
a letter to the Bureau stating Mother was not on time, canceled
appointments, and was not in a private area where they could conduct
virtual or phone sessions. The therapist stated Mother had not made
progress toward taking accountability for how her children ended up
unsupervised outside. On one occasion, the therapist challenged Mother
about her relationship, and Father responded directly to the therapist,
which alarmed the therapist because Father should not have been present.
5
The social worker opined that Mother did not gain any insight from the
therapists because each time she changed therapists she had to restart the
rapport-building stage.
The social worker testified that a rock found in L.H.’s younger
sibling’s diaper after a park visit showed negligence by the parents in
supervising the children. The social worker observed a visit at a bowling
alley (the location chosen by the parents), which was not a child-centered
visit.
The social worker stated that, although the parents had been drug
testing negatively for the past few months, the Bureau recommended
termination of reunification services because the risk to the children
remained high, and the parents had not demonstrated they could maintain
sobriety. The social worker also did not believe Father had strong
boundaries with Mother such that he could keep the children safe and not
allow Mother to intervene in their care.
The visitation supervisor testified the visits were “[a] little loud, a
little chaotic, fun.” The visits had recently transitioned to being loosely
supervised. The boys were lively and liked to run, so “you have to be on top
of them . . . .” The supervisor felt the parents did a good job of making sure
the children’s needs were met, such as by bringing snacks and toys. Mother
usually focused on her daughter (the youngest child), while Father would
run and play with L.H. and his older brother.
There were some visits at the bowling alley and others at parks. In
the beginning, the supervisor frequently had to step in to assist. At a recent
visit at a park in October 2025, L.H.’s brother walked off without the
parents noticing, and Mother initially would not rush after him. On another
occasion at the same park, Father had to run after L.H.’s brother and grab
6
him before he got to the street, which the supervisor described as “a close
call.” In general, Mother was resistant to suggestions from the visitation
supervisor.
Mother testified she had completed parenting classes and was drug
testing negative. When describing the steps of the AA/NA recovery program
in which she was participating, Mother stated she had gone through all 12
steps and had started going through them again. She expressed confusion
about which step was which. Mother had changed therapists multiple
times. She had stopped taking the medication that had been prescribed to
help with her anxiety. When shown photos of L.H. and his sibling on the
day they were detained by police in July 2024 (i.e., when they were
wandering outside Mother’s home unattended), Mother asserted the police
or neighbors had put dirt on the children to make it look like they were
neglected.
Father testified he sometimes stays with Mother and sometimes with
a friend. Father denied that a positive drug test in April 2025 was accurate.
Father had certificates from parenting and other classes he had completed.
Father acknowledged he used drugs after L.H. was removed from his care,
but he denied regular usage after that time. He was currently testing
negative. He was participating in therapy. Father testified that he believes
the reason his children were detained from his care is that he failed a drug
test.
E. The Court’s Ruling
At the conclusion of the hearing on January 14, 2026, and after
hearing argument, the court found the return of L.H. to parental custody
would create a substantial risk of detriment to his safety, protection, or
well-being; the Bureau had offered reasonable services; and there was not a
substantial probability L.H. would be returned by the end of the 18-month
7
period (which was just two months away, in March 2026). The court
terminated reunification services to the parents and set a section 366.26
hearing for May 13, 2026.
In explaining its ruling as to L.H. and his siblings, the court noted the
history of the dependency proceeding revealed a longstanding dysfunctional
relationship between Mother and Father. Mother had a long history with
child welfare issues, and she had four older children who were not in her
care. Mother had performed well in a residential drug treatment program
years earlier, but in contrast displayed a “complete and utter lack of insight”
when testifying in the current proceeding. Mother did not have any
understanding or knowledge of the 12 recovery steps. In the present case,
when Mother was assessed to be appropriate for a higher level of substance
abuse intervention, she opted for the lowest level. Even at that level,
Mother was inconsistent in her engagement.
The court noted that Mother’s therapist had reported that Mother was
inconsistent with scheduling. Mother told the therapist that she could not
meet on video because she could not get the app on her phone, so they did
phone calls, but Mother would put the therapist on speaker with Father
present, which the court noted “completely invades and destroys the patient-
therapist relationship and the confidential nature of those discussions.” The
therapist noted Mother had not made progress toward taking accountability
for how her children ended up unsupervised outside.
The court noted this report by the therapist was in accord with
Mother’s testimony at the hearing, in which “after all this time and all this
engagement in services, including a parenting class, to say that it was the,
quote-unquote, cops and neighbors who made the children look dirty and
messy. The translation of that is, I did absolutely nothing wrong, and this
8
was a complete setup. [¶] It’s shocking that at this contested review that
Mother pretty much ends her testimony on that. That shows, in my view,
no insight and really no accountability and very little, if any, progress.”
The court found Mother was inconsistent with mental health
treatment, transitioning between four different providers over the course of
the dependency proceeding. Mother was also “inconsistent and sporadic” in
her engagement with drug treatment providers and had “not attended a
one-on-one [session] for months.” Mother’s lack of insight was also reflected
in her decision to stop taking her medication, a decision the court found
“deeply concerning.” Mother did not follow up on annual checkups for L.H.,
although he had been diagnosed with what “could have been [a] life-altering
disease, infection when he was born.”
The parents had been provided with extensive visitation, but the
quality of the observed portions of the visits was problematic, with “chaos
and disorganization” as “the themes that run with that.” During visits,
Mother frequently focused solely on her daughter (the youngest child), and
even this child was seated in a stroller most of the time. Mother was
“combative and uncooperative and defensive” throughout the proceedings.
As to Father, the court stated, “I don’t know that he is really a
noncustodial nonoffending parent given his involvement with Mother in
these matters.” The court noted Father “had a front-row view to all of this
and left these kids in Mom’s care and did nothing to intervene. And, in fact,
was with Mom the night before and apparently the early morning of the
time these children were found wandering outside.”
Neither parent had acknowledged or accounted for their many missed
drug tests (although some turned out to be excused), and both had positive
tests. More recently, the parents had been showing up for drug tests and
9
testing negative. The court found, however, that the parents had not shown
insight. The court added that, at least as to Father, his approach seemed to
be “check off the boxes. And I checked those boxes, and now I want my
children back.”
The court found that, based on the record and the concerns it had
outlined, returning the children to parental custody would not be
appropriate. The court found by a preponderance of the evidence that a
return to parental custody would create a substantial risk of detriment to
L.H.’s safety, protection or physical or emotional well-being. The court
found by clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services were offered
to the parents. Finally, the court found there was not a substantial
probability L.H. would be returned to parental custody by the time of the
18-month review hearing, which would need to be held in just two months,
in March 2026. The court therefore terminated reunification services and
set a section 366.26 hearing.
II. DISCUSSION
A. Legal Standards
At the 12-month review hearing, the juvenile court “shall order the
return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian
unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of
the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of
detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the
child.” (§ 366.21, subd. (f)(1).) The Bureau has the burden to show
detriment. (Ibid.)
If the child cannot be returned to parental custody, the court generally
has three options: (1) continue the case for up to six months for an 18-month
permanency review hearing under section 366.22 (see § 366.21, subd. (g)(1));
(2) schedule a selection and implementation hearing to be held within 120
10
days under section 366.26 (§ 366.21, subd. (g)(4)); or (3) order the child to
remain in foster care (§ 366.21, subd. (g)(5)).
The case will be continued to an 18-month hearing only if the court
“finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned
to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely
maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that
reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian
. . . .” (§ 366.21, subd. (g)(1).) To find a substantial probability of return, the
court must “find all of the following: [¶] (A) That the parent or legal
guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the
child. [¶] (B) That the parent or legal guardian has made significant
progress in resolving problems that led to the child’s removal from the
home. [¶] (C) The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity
and ability both to complete the objectives of their treatment plan and to
provide for the child’s safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being,
and special needs.” (Ibid.)
We review the juvenile court’s findings on these points for substantial
evidence. (J.H. v. Superior Court (2018) 20 Cal.App.5th 530, 535; In re B.S.
(2012) 209 Cal.App.4th 246, 252.)
B. Analysis
As noted, the juvenile court, applying the legal framework outlined
above, found that (1) returning L.H. to parental custody would create a
substantial risk of detriment to L.H.’s safety, protection, or well-being
(§ 366.21, subd. (f)(1)), and (2) there was not a substantial probability that
L.H. would be returned to parental custody by the time of an 18-month
hearing (§ 366.21, subd. (g)(1)), a hearing that would be held in March 2026,
just two months after the completion of the 12-month hearing in
11
January 2026.4 We conclude, contrary to Mother’s and Father’s contentions,
that these findings are supported by substantial evidence.
Mother contends there was a substantial probability L.H. would be
returned to her care by the 18-month date. Mother argues she made
significant progress in resolving the problems that led to L.H.’s removal
from her care. Mother notes she participated in parenting classes, alcohol
and drug counseling, and therapy. She was prescribed medication for her
anxiety. Some providers gave positive feedback on Mother’s engagement.
Mother argues she “substantially complied” with services and, while
acknowledging her progress has been “rocky,” she states she should not be
expected to achieve perfection. Finally, she states she is willing to
participate in any services the Bureau recommends.
These arguments do not persuade us the court erred. Based on the
record before it, the court reasonably could conclude (as it did in its
thoroughly explained oral ruling) that Mother had not made significant
progress towards resolving the problems that led to L.H.’s removal and had
not gained insight into those problems. Mother continued to blame the
police and neighbors for the initial incident. She lacked an understanding of
the substance abuse recovery steps. She had started and stopped with
multiple therapists, and there was evidence that, as a result, she had not
made meaningful progress in therapy. Mother stopped taking the
medication that was intended to address her anxiety. Her drug testing
record, while it had improved recently, included many missed tests and
some positive tests. The court reasonably could conclude Mother had not
4 The court also found by clear and convincing evidence that
reasonable services had been provided to Mother and Father. (§ 366.21,
subd. (g)(4).) Mother and Father do not challenge this finding in their writ
petitions.
12
made significant progress and there was not a substantial likelihood that
the safe return of L.H. to her care would occur in the next two months.5
For his part, Father presents a conclusory argument that the court
erred—both in finding that an immediate return to parental custody would
create a substantial risk of detriment, and in finding there was not a
substantial probability of return by the 18-month date—because Father had
completed all his services, had a positive relationship with his children, and
maintained sobriety. But the court reasonably could take a different view of
the record. Father showed a lack of insight about his role in failing to
protect the children. In an opinion that the court reasonably could credit,
the Bureau expressed concern Father did not maintain adequate boundaries
with Mother to properly care for and protect the children. Father had
numerous missed drug tests and some positive tests, although he was
currently testing negative. It appeared to the court that Father believed he
just needed to check the necessary boxes to regain custody. Neither parent
has shown the court erred in terminating services and setting a
section 366.26 hearing.
5 The cases cited by Mother are distinguishable and do not persuade
us the court erred in declining to extend services beyond the 12-month
hearing. (See F.K. v. Superior Court (2024) 100 Cal.App.5th 928, 931, 935–
936 [juvenile court erred in failing to exercise discretion under the different
standards applicable at a six-month review hearing, which allow a court to
continue services even if no substantial probability of return has been
shown]; Jennifer A. v. Superior Court (2004) 117 Cal.App.4th 1322, 1344–
1345 [parent’s missed drug tests did not support termination of
reunification services where drug use was not a basis for initial detention
and where parent was generally in compliance with reunification plan].)
13
III. DISPOSITION
The petitions for extraordinary writ relief and the requests for a stay
of the section 366.26 hearing are denied. Our decision is final as to this
court immediately. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.490(b)(2)(A).)
STREETER, Acting P. J.
WE CONCUR:
GOLDMAN, J.
SWEET, J.*
* Judge of the Marin Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
14
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.