In re E.P. CA2/1

CourtListener 10848640CalctappApr 27, 2026

Full text

Filed 4/27/26 In re E.P. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

In re E.P., a Person Coming B349669
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 21CCJP02776)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

JENNIFER G.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Juan M. Valles, Judge Pro Tempore.
Affirmed.
Emery El Habiby, under appointment by the
Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Navid Nakhjavani, Principal
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________

In 2022, the juvenile court assumed jurisdiction over E.P.
(born in 2015), because of mother’s substance abuse and serious
mental health concerns. In a prior appeal, we affirmed the order
assuming jurisdiction over E.P. and rejected mother’s challenge
to the juvenile court’s dispositional order requiring her to attend
a substance abuse treatment program.
The current appeal is from the denial of mother’s Welfare
and Institutions Code1 section 388 petition requesting placement
of E.P. in her care, or in the alternative, additional reunification
services. We conclude the juvenile court did not abuse its
discretion in denying mother’s petition. Mother had a nine-year
substance abuse problem and had relapsed just two months
before the section 388 hearing. Mother also did not identify any
changes in her mental health, even though mother’s serious
mental health issues were the other basis for taking jurisdiction
over E.P. We thus affirm.

1 Undesignated statutory citations are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.

2
BACKGROUND

1. Prior Dependency History2
“E.P.’s sibling, M.P. (born in 2021), was declared a
dependent of the juvenile court in 2021. She was born with a
positive toxicology for marijuana. Mother too tested positive for
marijuana and also tested positive for amphetamines at M.P.’s
birth. Mother admitted to a history of crystal methamphetamine
use as well as use while pregnant with M.P. In the prior
dependency proceedings [involving M.P.], the juvenile court
sustained allegations that mother’s substance abuse rendered her
incapable of providing regular care and supervision of M.P.”
(In re E.P. (Oct. 24, 2023, B324815) [nonpub. opn.].)
“During M.P.’s case, mother enrolled in an inpatient drug
program. On July 16, 2022, two days after she completed the
program, mother tested positive for methamphetamine. Mother
did not complete her court ordered services, including mental
health services, and parenting and domestic violence programs.”
(In re E.P., supra, B324815.)

2. In 2022, the Juvenile Court Assumes Jurisdiction
Over E.P.
E.P. lived with his paternal grandmother for three years
and then lived with mother for a few weeks before the
Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services
(DCFS) commenced dependency proceedings. (In re E.P., supra,
B324815.) On October 12, 2022, the juvenile court assumed

2 Mother quotes extensively from our prior opinion
following mother’s challenge to jurisdiction and disposition. We
also rely on portions of our prior opinion.

3
jurisdiction over E.P., sustaining the allegation that mother’s
abuse of methamphetamine and marijuana prevented her from
caring for E.P. The court also sustained allegations that mother
had mental and emotional problems, including schizophrenia and
suicidal ideation, which resulted in a suicide attempt and
prevented mother from providing regular care for E.P.
Additionally, the court sustained the allegation that mother
failed to take her psychotropic medication as prescribed and was
involuntarily hospitalized.
The court ordered mother to participate in a six-month
drug and alcohol program and a 12-step program. The court
ordered mother to attend parenting classes and mental health
counseling, undergo a psychological assessment, take all
psychotropic medications, and participate in individual
counseling. (In re E.P., supra, B324815.)
In affirming the court’s jurisdictional order we concluded:
“Substantial evidence supports that mother abused
methamphetamine at the time of the jurisdictional hearing and
that the abuse placed E.P. at substantial risk of harm. Mother
suffered from cravings and urges to use methamphetamine,
causing her to use it while pregnant with M.P. and still after
completing her inpatient substance abuse program. The abuse
affected mother’s life as demonstrated by her losing custody over
M.P. and hospitalization when she overdosed. Additionally,
rather than visiting M.P., mother would sleep. Mother admitted
she continued using controlled substances while pregnant
because she ‘ “couldn’t stop it.” ’ The substance abuse continued
at the time of the jurisdictional hearing when mother tested
positive for methamphetamine in July 2022 and missed her

4
scheduled tests in August and September 2022.” (In re E.P.,
supra, B324815.)
We also concluded substantial evidence supported the
“conclusion that mother’s mental health issues posed a
substantial risk to E.P., notwithstanding the fact that mother
cared for E.P. for one month without incident. Mother did not
treat her mental health issues, which were serious enough to
require hospitalization, caused her to ‘ “los[e] her mind for a little
bit,’ ” and involved suicidal ideations and attempted suicide.
There was no evidence mother could control those episodes, or
understood what triggered them. Although it appears that E.P.
was shielded from mother’s suicide attempts and hospitalizations
while he lived with paternal grandmother, there was no evidence
that mother was able or willing to treat her mental illness to
avoid a future episode.” (In re E.P., supra, B324815.)
We rejected mother’s challenge to the juvenile court’s order
that she participate in substance abuse program: “The juvenile
court acted well within its discretion in ordering mother to
participate in the services she now eschews. A substance abuse
program is designed to assist mother in ameliorating the
conditions that led to the dependency proceedings, specifically
mother’s methamphetamine abuse.” (In re E.P., supra, B324815.)

3. After a Reunification Period, Mother’s Reunification
Services Are Terminated
In April 2023, (approximately six months after the juvenile
court assumed jurisdiction over E.P.), DCFS reported that
mother had attended a six-month program on drug and alcohol
education, mother had not enrolled in a 12-step program, and
mother had not enrolled in therapy. Mother stated that she
stopped taking her psychotropic medication because “she felt like

5
she did not need them anymore.” Mother reported she had
stopped using methamphetamine a month earlier. “Mother
admitted that these past couple of months she has not been doing
what the court has asked of her . . . .” Mother missed five drug
tests in 2022, two tests in January 2023, two tests in February
2023, and she tested positive for marijuana in March 2023.
In May 2023, E.P. moved into his current placement with
prospective adoptive parents.
In August 2023, mother enrolled in an inpatient substance
abuse program. Mother’s counselor told a social worker that in
September 2023, mother was placed on an involuntary hold
because she was acting aggressively and crying a lot. The
program discharged mother.
In October 2023, DCFS reported, “Mother stated that she
has been sober for one month.” Mother admitted she was not
testing for controlled substances. Mother acknowledged she was
addicted to controlled substances and stated she would avoid the
people and places that trigger her to use those substances.
Mother was attending an outpatient substance abuse program.
After her positive test for marijuana, mother missed her next
14 scheduled tests. In July 2023, mother tested positive for
marijuana and for oxycodone and then missed her next five
scheduled tests.
On October 26, 2023, the court found mother’s progress was
unsubstantial and terminated her reunification services.

4. After Mother’s Reunification Services Are
Terminated, Mother Enrolls in Substance Abuse
Treatment and Starts Mental Health Services
In April 2024, mother told a social worker she planned to
attend a rehabilitation program. In May 2024, however, mother

6
tested positive for benzodiazepines and cannabis. She also was
placed on a 14-day hold due to a “grave disability.”3 Around the
same time, mother was arrested; she did not recall the reason for
the arrest.
In September 2024, mother reported she was participating
in Pacifica Housing Rehabilitation Center and previously
participated at another rehabilitation center. Beginning in
October 2024, mother started visiting E.P. “fairly” consistently.
In December 2024, a doctor prescribed Zoloft for mother,
which she took for six days and then stopped taking it. She then
started again the following month when her doctor suggested
mother take the medicine at night.
In February 2025, DCFS reported mother was receiving
mental health services, including psychotherapy and medication
management, and was participating in drug rehabilitation
programs. Mother was living in a sober housing facility that
did not allow children. Mother enrolled in a program to assist
homeless individuals and attended a support group where she
learned about anger management, parenting, social skills, and
relapse prevention. Additionally mother completed an eight-
week parenting course.

5. Section 388 Petition and Hearing
On July 2, 2025, mother petitioned to change a court order.
Mother requested the court place E.P. in her custody, or in the
alternative, reinstate reunification services. Mother asserted she
“has completed her case plan by attending AA classes, testing

3 The record does not identify the nature of that disability.

7
negative for the department [sic] and completed parenting
classes, and attending individual counseling.”
Mother filed a declaration stating she completed an
inpatient substance abuse program in November 2024 and
completed an outpatient program in May 2025. Mother stated
she had been sober since July 31, 2024. Mother claimed she had
attended Alcoholics/Narcotics Anonymous classes “multiple times
a week” and had a sponsor. Mother represented she attended
weekly individual counseling sessions.
A counselor at mother’s substance abuse program told a
social worker that mother made positive changes and wants to be
a good parent. Mother tested negative for controlled substances
seven times from November 2024 through March 2025.
The social worker evaluating mother’s section 388 petition
concluded mother was addressing her substance abuse, but not
her mental health issues. The social worker noted mother was
placed on an involuntary hold in May 2024, was inconsistent with
her individual therapy, failed to show up for psychiatry
appointments, and stopped taking her psychotropic medications.
DCFS recommended denying mother’s section 388 petition.
On August 12, 2025, mother contacted a social worker and
reported that she had relapsed and entered a residential
substance abuse program. Mother said she reconnected with old
friends and drank alcohol “and then kept drinking . . . .” Mother
then used methamphetamine. After her positive test on
August 12, 2025, mother tested negative for controlled
substances five times between August 19, 2025 and
September 16, 2025.

8
6. Hearing on Mother’s Section 388 Petition
On October 7, 2025, Mother testified at a hearing on her
section 388 petition. Mother said she was 26 years old, and
started using drugs when she was 17 years old. Initially, she
used methamphetamine once a month but subsequently, her use
became more frequent. Mother admitted she abused drugs.
Mother admitted she could not properly care for E.P. when she
was using drugs. Mother said she participated in Alcoholics
Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous meetings. Mother spoke
to her sponsor every day.
Mother testified the last time she used drugs was
August 11, 2025. Mother added that she sought treatment and
was participating in an inpatient program at the time of the
section 388 hearing. Mother represented that her longest period
of sobriety was 11 months. Between the ages of 17 and 26,
mother participated in eight substance abuse programs. Mother
testified she still did not “know[ ] how to live sober,” but she was
“working towards it.” Mother further testified she was “building
[her] way to start [her] 12-steps” and was “not just . . . going to
jump into [her] first step.”
Mother stated she took nine parenting classes and
participated in individual counseling for more than a year.
Mother was learning “[h]ow to live in the moment as a parent
and not look back at the past parent [she] used to be.”
Mother said she was diagnosed with anxiety and
depression. Mother admitted she stopped taking her prescribed
medications. Mother explained she restarted her medication
after the doctor prescribed a lower dose.
Mother testified E.P. could not live with her because there
was no bed available at the facility where she was staying.

9
Mother still asked for E.P. to return to her care. Mother
acknowledged she had not cared for E.P. full time since
August 2022.
Mother’s counsel argued mother showed that she “can
maintain sobriety.” Counsel contended mother’s efforts to
maintain her sobriety and her honesty concerning relapse shows
that she “is a changed person.” Counsel asked for an additional
six months of reunification services or allow E.P. to reside with
mother when a bed became available. E.P.’s attorney argued E.P.
was 10 years old and would be happy to live with mother at her
program.
DCFS’s attorney argued mother’s circumstances may be
changing but were not changed. “[W]hile mother does appear to
be extremely well intentioned, mother still has a long way to go
to change the circumstances that brought this case to the court’s
attention.” DCFS’s counsel argued that mother also struggled to
treat her mental health issues and stopped taking psychotropic
medication when she relapsed.

7. The Juvenile Court Denies Mother’s Section 388
Petition
On October 7, 2025, the juvenile court heard mother’s
section 388 petition. The juvenile court first “touch[ed] on best
interest” and stated based on the evidence before it at the
hearing, that “mother and [E.P.] share a close, close bond.” The
court noted that “adoption versus guardianship” was not before
it, but the issue of changed circumstances was the subject of the
hearing. The court then weighed mother’s almost nine years of
substance abuse against her efforts to mitigate “that substance
abuse problem.” The court noted mother had an 11-month “span
of sobriety” but did “relapse” about two months before the

10
hearing. The court found there was insufficient evidence of
changed circumstances. “At this time, the mother’s
circumstances are changing as she works her way through
recovery.” Although the court denied the section 388 petition
because “not enough time has passed,” it urged her “to keep
working on [her] sobriety, keep attending [her] programs, . . . and
keep testing.” The court reiterated that mother should “[k]eep
doing all . . . that you have been doing” and “[i]f we were at
disposition six months from now, it could be really, really
different . . . .”
Mother timely appealed.

DISCUSSION
“Section 388 allows a parent to petition to change, modify,
or set aside any previous juvenile court order. [Citation.] ‘The
petitioner has the burden of showing by a preponderance of the
evidence (1) that there is new evidence or a change of
circumstances and (2) that the proposed modification would be in
the best interests of the child.’ [Citation.]” (In re J.M. (2020)
50 Cal.App.5th 833, 845; § 388, subd. (a).) We review the grant
or denial of a section 388 petition for an abuse of discretion.
(In re Alayah J. (2017) 9 Cal.App.5th 469, 478.)
Mother argues that the court abused its discretion in
finding no changed circumstances since mother had 11 months of
sobriety prior to her most recent relapse, confessed her relapse,
entered an inpatient substance abuse program, and had been
sober from August 2025 through October 7, 2025.
Mother admitted to using controlled substances for nine
years. At the time of the hearing on mother’s section 388
petition, mother had been sober for only two months. Despite
participating in eight drug programs, mother continued to

11
struggle with methamphetamine abuse and acknowledged she
was unable to care for E.P. while under the influence. Mother’s
relapse two months before the hearing on her section 388 petition
supported the juvenile court’s conclusion that despite her efforts,
mother had not changed her circumstances of addiction that led
to the dependency jurisdiction over E.P. (In re Ernesto R. (2014)
230 Cal.App.4th 219, 223 [no changed circumstances where the
parent had “a history of drug relapses, is in the early stages of
recovery, and [was] still addressing a chronic substance abuse
problem”]; In re Cliffton B. (2000) 81 Cal.App.4th 415, 424
[200 days of sobriety insufficient to show changed circumstances];
see also In re Jayden M. (2023) 93 Cal.App.5th 1261, 1277 [recent
period sobriety “often not enough to counter a long-standing
pattern of use and relapse”].)
Additionally, mother ignores the second basis for
jurisdiction and identifies no changed circumstance with respect
to her mental health. Most significantly, mother was placed on
an involuntary hold in April or May 2024 due to a “grave
disability.” Mother also admitted she stopped taking her
prescribed medication. On appeal, mother does not address her
mental health issues and does not dispute respondent’s argument
that mother failed to show a meaningful change in her mental
health status.
In sum, mother shows no abuse of discretion in the juvenile
court’s finding that mother had not changed her circumstances.
Because mother has not shown changed circumstances, we
need not consider mother’s argument that a change in the court
order would promote E.P.’s best interest.

12
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order denying mother’s Welfare and
Institutions Code section 388 petition is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

BENDIX, J.

We concur:

ROTHSCHILD, P. J.

WEINGART, J.

13

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.