CourtListener 10847337•People v. Cardarelli CA2/7
Full text
Filed 4/23/26 P. v. Cardarelli CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SEVEN
THE PEOPLE, B337513
(Los Angeles County Super.
Plaintiff and Respondent, Ct. No. KA121884)
v.
SHAUN CARDARELLI,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Mike Camacho, Jr., Judge. Affirmed.
Boyce & Schaefer and Laura Schaefer, under appointment
by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Amanda V. Lopez and Nicholas J. Webster,
Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
______________________
Shaun Cardarelli appeals from a judgment after a jury
found him guilty of murder and conspiracy to commit arson and
found true the special circumstance that Cardarelli committed
the murder while engaged in a robbery. Cardarelli contends his
counsel was ineffective for failing to object to and stipulating to
the admission of three sets of hearsay evidence. We affirm the
judgment.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Prosecution’s Case
1. The participants
When they were 15 years old, friends A.S. and S.B. ran
away from their foster home and lived with 18-year-old Elijah
Rouse in his apartment. While living there, A.S. would have sex
with men for money. Rouse would set up appointments for A.S.
and take pictures of her for the men. A.S. would give money she
made to Rouse. Sometimes after A.S. had sex, Rouse would rob
the man using a knife that had a red handle and no tip.
A.S. also had frequent contact with 37-year-old Cardarelli,
whom she referred to as “uncle” because he used to date her aunt.
S.B. overheard Cardarelli and Rouse talking about using A.S. to
lure men to the apartment so they could rob them.
2. The murder of John Aguila
On August 20, 2019, Cardarelli texted A.S., “You said to let
you kno the plan. What plan?” A.S. responded, “what U wanted
to do,” adding, “my roommate/BF” “that’s who I’m staying with.”
Cardarelli stated he would contact A.S. when he found his stolen
car.
In the early morning of August 21, A.S. texted Cardarelli
that she had “clients” coming over. Cardarelli asked if he was
2
supposed to be present, told her to be safe, and then again asked
if she needed him there.
An hour later, A.S. texted Cardarelli that she had a client
on his way. A.S. texted, “[Rouse] said it would be easier nn more
quiet if your here.” She added, “So yea. Go ahead n come.”
Cardarelli responded, “I think he is right I should be there,”
adding, “I so wish you would have told this to me sooner.”
Several hours later, Cardarelli asked A.S., “How did everything
go?” A couple hours later, she sent him multiple photos of
herself, including some in which she was only partially clothed.
That evening, Cardarelli texted A.S. that he could “help
out” by coming to the apartment and asked, “What time is this
going to happen?” A.S. responded, “We waitin on reply [but] we
have a couple others as well.” Cardarelli later texted that he was
on his way. That same evening, A.S. had a man over to the
apartment who was going to pay for sex. The man was smoking
with A.S. and S.B. S.B. texted A.S. to tell Rouse that they should
not do “it,” referring to robbing the client. S.B. also texted Rouse
that “we not gone do that to this one.” Rouse responded, “Do
what??” He texted that the next customer was coming and also
that “uncles on his way.” S.B. replied that she knew that because
she and A.S. were just on the phone with “uncle.” They talked
about “uncle” needing a ride or taking the train.
In the early morning of August 22, Cardarelli texted A.S.
asking her if she was happy he was at the apartment. Later that
day, Rouse texted an acquaintance, Davone Smith, and stated he
needed to talk with him but not over the phone. Rouse told
Smith to come over later that evening “cuz someone gonna get”
and then sent a water gun emoji, which Smith interpreted as
someone was going to get hurt. Rouse had repeatedly asked
3
Smith for a gun in the days before the murder in order to “rob
somebody.”
In the evening of August 22, John Aguila messaged an app
account associated with A.S. and scheduled “an appointment”
with A.S. and another girl after a price was agreed upon. Rouse,
who was operating the account and pretending to be A.S., sent a
photo of A.S. topless. Aguila asked the girls’ ages, and Rouse
replied they were 19 and 22. Rouse sent the address of his
apartment, and Aguila said he would be there around 6:00 p.m.
When Aguila set up the appointment, Cardarelli, Rouse,
A.S., and S.B. were at the apartment. Rouse and A.S. told S.B.
that Aguila was coming to the apartment. Rouse stated he and
Cardarelli were going to rob Aguila. He and Cardarelli practiced
how they were going to do it, including how they were going to
put Aguila in a chokehold and choke him out. Rouse
demonstrated doing a chokehold. Cardarelli participated in the
conversation.
At 5:28 p.m., S.B. texted A.S. that she wanted to die. She
texted half an hour later that she was scared. A.S. responded
that she was scared, and S.B. replied, “Me too.” Minutes later,
A.S. texted S.B. that Cardarelli looked like he was about to cry.
S.B. replied, “FR,” meaning “for real,” and A.S. responded, “Yea.”
Minutes later, S.B. texted A.S., “When it happens, please don’t
just sit there” and “I don’t want you to have to go through dat.”
A.S. responded, “I would rather it be me then you.” Minutes
later, A.S. texted S.B., “What if the dude has a gun?” S.B.
responded, “Uughhhh.” S.B. texted Rouse asking him to get her
some water. Rouse texted, “Not right now. Wait till we are
done.” S.B. then asked Rouse if the client was even coming.
Rouse replied that he was there.
4
At 6:18 p.m., Aguila indicated he had arrived outside the
apartment. A.S. texted S.B. that Aguila was coming up right
now. S.B. went into a bedroom before Aguila arrived while Rouse
and Cardarelli remained in the living room. S.B. repeatedly
texted A.S. to come in the bedroom with her.
Within a minute of Aguila entering the apartment, S.B.
heard an argument and A.S. ran into the bedroom with her. S.B.
heard struggling and what sounded like a fight. Aguila yelled for
help. Rouse or Cardarelli shouted, “Shut the fuck up.” S.B.
heard struggling for approximately 10 to 30 minutes out in the
hallway. She could hear someone being hit.
After it got quiet, A.S. exited the room and S.B. followed.
Cardarelli and Rouse looked exhausted and had blood on them.
Rouse had blood “everywhere,” include on his face, hands, and
clothes. Cardarelli had blood on his shirt. Aguila was dead and
laying with his legs in the hallway and his upper body in the
other bedroom. He had a blanket placed over him. S.B. saw the
knife that Rouse used in the prior robberies. Two bookends and
the knife had blood on them. There were bloodstains on the
carpet and throughout the bedroom.
The autopsy showed Aguila suffered blunt force injuries all
over his head, including a fractured skull, nose, and jaw, chipped
teeth, and injuries to his lips, chin, and scalp. He had sharp force
injuries to his face, including multiple stab wounds to the eye and
a slice on his neck. The forensic examiner opined that the cause
of death was blunt and sharp force injuries causing brain damage
and blood loss. He opined that the injuries “shook the brain itself
and that would have caused the bleeding found in the brain.”
The blood loss from the stab wounds also contributed to the
death.
5
3. The aftermath
After the murder, Cardarelli, Rouse, A.S., and S.B. got in
Aguila’s car and went to the store so Cardarelli could get
cigarettes. At some point, Rouse threw the knife and bookends in
a dumpster. When they were back at the apartment, Rouse
stated they needed to get rid of the body, and Cardarelli agreed.
Rouse stated their best option was to burn it, and Cardarelli
suggested a camping area. Rouse had A.S. contact Smith for
assistance, thinking he would know what to do, in part because
Smith was a gang member.
When Smith arrived, he sold drugs to Cardarelli, Rouse,
and A.S., and they all smoked methamphetamine. They also
showed Smith the body, which had been wrapped in plastic wrap
and blankets. Rouse told Smith that Aguila tried to rape A.S.,
and he “had to do what he had to do.” Rouse told Smith he
stabbed Aguila in the eye and hit him with a “little statue.” He
stated Aguila was about to “get away,” and Cardarelli “helped
out.” Cardarelli, who was present, did not dispute this version of
events, nor did he act surprised, angry, or upset about what
happened. At some point, Cardarelli, Rouse, and Smith left the
apartment and purchased more methamphetamine.
Around midnight, Cardarelli, Rouse, and Smith brought
Aguila’s body to the trunk of Aguila’s car. Smith drove Rouse in
one car, and Cardarelli drove Aguila’s car alone. Both cars
stopped at a gas station where Rouse filled a water bottle with
gasoline, and Cardarelli went inside to pay. They drove to San
Antonio Heights, where they stopped and put Aguila’s body in a
ditch on the side of the road. Rouse poured gasoline on it, and
Smith set it on fire. They fled the scene.
6
Cardarelli, Rouse, and Smith returned to the apartment,
where they drank alcohol and the atmosphere was one of
“celebration.” Rouse told S.B. that he stabbed Aguila in the neck
and eye. Rouse stated he was trying to choke Aguila, but he gave
up and stabbed him. Cardarelli stated he “was hitting” Aguila.
At some point, S.B. learned that A.S. was texting people about
the murder. A.S. told S.B. she had posted about the murder on
social media and was going to take the blame if anything
happened.
In the early morning of August 23, Smith took Cardarelli
home. During the drive, Cardarelli stated something along the
lines of “[Rouse] started beating the guy up and [I] had to help
out and finish him.”
4. The arrests and law enforcement investigation
Aguila’s body was discovered burning in the early morning
of August 23, but it was not immediately identifiable. Law
enforcement later received a missing person report regarding
Aguila. They also obtained a search warrant for Rouse’s
apartment after retrieving messages from Aguila’s cell phone
that showed the communications with A.S. regarding sex.
On August 27, law enforcement arrived at the apartment
and instructed the occupants to exit. Cardarelli came out the
front door after eight minutes. Rouse and A.S. tried to escape by
climbing out a window and onto the roof. While on the roof,
Rouse tried to cover himself with his shirt and conceal himself
behind the eaves. A.S. fell off the roof and broke her arm.
Aguila’s financial cards and driver’s license were found on the
roof. His car key fob was found in a garbage can outside the
apartment. Rouse had small cuts on his hands. He had photos
on his phone of Aguila’s body wrapped in blankets and Aguila’s
7
possessions. A.S. also had photos of the crime scene and Aguila’s
body on her phone.
Cardarelli and Rouse were placed in jail cells next to each
other. In a recorded conversation, Rouse stated he had an idea
that Cardarelli may not like. He proposed letting A.S. “take the
fall” because she was a juvenile, and Cardarelli replied, “Yeah,
that’s fine with me.” Rouse proposed the story that they were not
present during the murder and when they returned A.S. had
killed the person she was hooking up with because he was
aggressive. Cardarelli replied, “Okay.” Rouse told Cardarelli to
call people and see if he could get an alibi.
In a recorded conversation with a jailhouse informant,
Cardarelli was mostly quiet but stated he did not know why he
had been arrested and blamed Rouse for why he was in jail.
Law enforcement also recorded a conversation between
Rouse and a jailhouse informant. Rouse stated he had no idea
why he had been arrested. He then stated he and Cardarelli left
the apartment and when they returned A.S. had stabbed some
man. Finally, he stated A.S. had someone over for sex who
became aggressive, so Rouse fought the man and A.S. stabbed
him to death.
The next three recorded conversations that were played for
the jury, two involving Rouse and one involving A.S., are at the
heart of Cardarelli’s argument on appeal.
In a recorded jail phone call with his aunt, Rouse stated a
few days ago he was “with the homegirl and the homies and the
homie he just got robbed.” When his aunt asked if he had talked
to an attorney, Rouse stated, “I’m already guilty, Auntie.” He
stated he did what “they” told him to do; he held Aguila while
others went through his pockets, expecting they would then let
8
Aguila go. But “then they just stabbed and then I just left” and
“[w]hen I came back, there was a dead body in my house.” Rouse
stated he had “some leverage,” noting “the person I was with,
they posted it on social media that they killed him. Admitting
that they did it.” Rouse stated he would “admit to holding
someone down” and “being an accessory” but would “not admit to
murder. Something I did not do.” He repeatedly stated he was
not a murderer and did not “kill him.”
The next recorded conversation was part of a Perkins
operation1 involving A.S. A.S. had previously told law
enforcement she and Rouse had stabbed Aguila during a drug
sale that S.B. had set up. A detective came to her jail cell and
played the recording of Rouse and Cardarelli planning to pin the
murder on her. After the detective left, A.S. told her cellmate (an
informant) she “didn’t touch anything or anybody” and she had
“made up lies.” A.S. stated that instead Rouse and Cardarelli
were going to “jack” Aguila and ended up “beating the shit out of”
and killing him while she and S.B. hid in the bedroom. She
stated that, after the murder, Rouse told her to clean the mess or
else she would “end up looking like” Aguila.
Finally, in a recorded interview with law enforcement while
in jail, Rouse acknowledged he communicated with men for A.S.
to have sex with and that A.S. paid him money she received from
having sex with the men. He stated Cardarelli did not “pimp”
A.S., emphasizing “[t]hat’s her uncle.” As for the murder, Rouse
stated he attacked Aguila because Aguila became rough with A.S.
1 A “Perkins operation” is when an undercover operative is
placed in a cell with the suspect to obtain information from the
suspect. The term derives its name from Illinois v. Perkins
(1990) 496 U.S. 292.
9
during sex. Rouse stated it was A.S. who then stabbed Aguila.
Rouse did not mention Cardarelli being present. He stated A.S.
told others she had stabbed Aguila in the eye and killed him. He
denied planning a robbery.
After being pressed, Rouse stated Cardarelli was in the
apartment and hit Aguila with a wooden figurine during the
struggle. Again, he denied it was a robbery, explaining he was
there to “protect” A.S. and Cardarelli was “just there ’cause that’s
her uncle.” Rouse stated Cardarelli was high on
methamphetamine and asleep on a couch, did not react until
Rouse responded to A.S.’s cries, and only helped once A.S. had
stabbed the victim.
Finally, Rouse changed his story again and stated
Cardarelli and A.S. proposed a robbery because Cardarelli
needed money, and Rouse just helped. Rouse stated he and
Cardarelli entered the room where Aguila and A.S. were and
Cardarelli “roughed [Aguila] up” and Rouse “choke[d] him out.”
Rouse stated Cardarelli was the one who stabbed Aguila. Rouse
stated he gave Aguila’s money to Cardarelli because he “needed
all of it.” Rouse later stated he split the money up between
himself, Cardarelli, and A.S.
During the interview, Rouse acknowledged he had a cut on
his hand that he admitted was from a knife and occurred during
the struggle, but he denied being the stabber. He stated he was
“[c]lueless” as to how he got the cut but suggested it might have
happened while he was “fucking around” with knives, something
he often did.
10
B. The Defense’s Case
Cardarelli testified at trial. Cardarelli met A.S. through
her aunt, whom he had previously dated for almost two years.
On the day before the murder, A.S. told Cardarelli that she was
prostituting. He asked who would pay for sex with a 15 year old.
Shortly after that, A.S. sent him the semi-nude photos, which he
deleted, and he called to tell her she should not be doing that and
to never send him photos like that again. On cross-examination,
the prosecution asked Cardarelli about evidence showing he
subsequently messaged A.S. telling her to send him photos.
Cardarelli stated he did not remember the messages.
Cardarelli went to Rouse’s apartment the night before the
murder. That was when he first met Rouse. On cross-
examination, the prosecution presented evidence showing a text
from Cardarelli’s phone number to Rouse’s phone number that
was sent 10 days before the murder. Cardarelli stated he did not
remember this message.
On the night before the murder, A.S. told Cardarelli that
clients would sometimes get into arguments with Rouse because
they wanted her to leave with them. She and Rouse wanted
another person there. When A.S. texted that “[Rouse] said it
would be easier nn more quiet if your here,” Cardarelli thought
she was talking about his being there to minimize the noise of
Rouse’s arguments with clients seeking to get A.S. to leave with
them. Even though he responded that he thought Rouse was
right and that he should be there, Cardarelli “never had the
intent to go there or to be a part of it.”
On the day of the murder, Cardarelli made excuses why he
could not go to the apartment. He called A.S. and told her he did
not want to be part of the prostitution. Over the phone, A.S.
11
stated she did not want to prostitute, but Rouse would not let her
leave. She stated she needed Cardarelli to come to the apartment
and pick her up. Cardarelli arrived at the apartment in the early
afternoon. A.S. and S.B. kept making excuses about why A.S.
could not leave. At some point, Rouse confronted Cardarelli, and
Cardarelli told Rouse he “came here not to do what he’s
expecting” but rather “just to pick [A.S.] up and to leave.” At that
point, Cardarelli wrestled Rouse, and Rouse overpowered him.
Rouse threatened Cardarelli and told him to sit on the couch and
do what he was told. The look in Rouse’s eyes scared Cardarelli
and made him fear for his life.
Aguila arrived several hours later. When Aguila entered
the apartment, Rouse acted like he knew him. A.S. and S.B.
were in a bedroom with the door shut. Rouse escorted Aguila to
the bedroom, but when Aguila looked in, no one was there. As
Aguila turned around, Rouse struck him in the face with an
object, and Aguila fell. Rouse started violently striking and
kicking Aguila in the face and head. When Aguila tried to get up,
Rouse jumped on his back and started choking him. At that
point, Rouse screamed for A.S. and told her to get his “tool.”
Aguila was back on the ground and trying to get up. Rouse
kicked him in the face and then used the knife that A.S. brought
from the kitchen to slice Aguila’s neck. Rouse then repeatedly
stabbed Aguila in the face.
Cardarelli approached and stated Aguila was not going to
get up, and “it’s enough.” Rouse pushed Cardarelli, and
Cardarelli hit his elbow on the door as he fell to the ground.
Rouse came toward Cardarelli with the knife and asked if he
wanted to be next. Rouse told him to sit on the couch and shut
up, and stated he would kill A.S., S.B., and Cardarelli’s family
12
and roommate if he did not cooperate. Rouse returned to Aguila
and kicked him in the head.
A.S. came out of the bedroom and talked in a low voice with
Rouse in the hallway. She came into the living room and took
Cardarelli’s two phones and stated he needed to cooperate with
Rouse to get out of this. Cardarelli helped wrap up the body
because Rouse told him to. Rouse made Cardarelli strip down
because there was blood on his shirt from where Rouse pushed
him. Rouse gave him new clothes to wear.
Rouse made Cardarelli drive them to Compton in Aguila’s
car to try to find someone to help with the situation. They never
found the person they were looking for. They then went to a gas
station, and Cardarelli bought cigarettes. They drove back to the
apartment, and Rouse told Cardarelli to sit and wait as he and
A.S. tried to contact people.
Smith arrived and Cardarelli and A.S. smoked
methamphetamine with him. After that, Rouse showed Smith
the body. Rouse, Smith, and A.S. discussed what to do with the
body. Cardarelli was present but did not speak because he had
been told to shut up. A decision was made to burn the body later
that night. Cardarelli helped move the body into a closet in the
meantime. He then smoked marijuana with S.B.
Later, after Rouse and Smith failed to lift the body,
Cardarelli followed Rouse’s order and carried the body
downstairs by himself to Aguila’s car. Cardarelli drove Aguila’s
car and was told to follow Rouse and Smith, who were in the
other car. They all went to a gas station where Cardarelli went
inside and paid for the gasoline using money Rouse gave him.
Cardarelli did not flee in the car because he feared Rouse’s
threats and still did not have one of his phones. The phone was
13
very important because it had addresses and contacts in it and
Rouse had threatened to kill his family.
When they arrived in the mountains, Rouse and Smith
pulled Aguila’s body into the ditch and covered it in gasoline.
After Rouse and Smith lit the fire, Cardarelli got in Aguila’s car
and took off while Smith drove with Rouse in the opposite
direction. Cardarelli could have fled, but he was scared of
Rouse’s threats, hoped he could get A.S. and S.B. out of the
apartment, and wanted his phone back.
When they returned to the apartment, they smoked more
methamphetamine. Rouse told Cardarelli to clean the
apartment, which was still a mess. At some point, Smith stated
he was leaving, and Cardarelli asked for a ride. Cardarelli
denied telling Smith that Rouse started the fight with Aguila and
that he (Cardarelli) had to help finish it.
On August 24, two days after the murder, Cardarelli texted
Rouse, A.S., and S.B., “Good afternoon. Are we having a good
day?” Cardarelli testified that he did not know why he sent that
message.
On August 27, the day of the arrests, Cardarelli went back
to Rouse’s apartment to retrieve his phone. Before Cardarelli
went over, Rouse texted him from A.S.’s number, “Hey, it’s
[Rouse]. How far out are you[?]” Even though he saw Rouse kill
Aguila and was afraid of Rouse’s threats, Cardarelli still went
over to the apartment. He was there for a couple hours before
the police arrived. He was there that long because A.S. would not
give him his phone back and she was “playing games” with him.
In the days after the murder, Cardarelli never sent a message to
A.S. about not having one of his phones or demanding it back and
instead raised the subject “only on phone calls.”
14
At the time of the murder, Cardarelli was six feet, one inch
tall and weighed 190 pounds. Rouse was smaller and lighter
than him. During their recorded jail conversation, Cardarelli
was still scared of Rouse.
C. Charges, Verdicts, and Sentence
The People charged Rouse and Cardarelli with first degree
murder (Pen. Code, § 187, subd. (a)),2 conspiracy to commit arson
(§§ 182, subd. (a)(1), 451, subd. (d)), recklessly causing a fire of a
structure or forest land (§ 452, subd. (c)), and human trafficking
of a minor for a commercial sex act (§ 236.1, subd. (c)(1)). The
People also alleged the special circumstance that Rouse and
Cardarelli committed the murder while engaged in a robbery
(§ 190.2, subd. (a)(17)). They further alleged Rouse and
Cardarelli personally used a deadly or dangerous weapon in the
commission of the murder. (§ 12022, subd. (b)(1)).3
Before Cardarelli’s trial, the People dismissed the
recklessly causing a fire charge and struck the personal use of a
weapon allegation against Cardarelli.
The jury found Cardarelli guilty of first degree murder and
conspiracy to commit arson and found true the robbery special
circumstance. The jury acquitted Cardarelli of the human
trafficking charge. The court sentenced him to life in prison
without the possibility of parole for the murder and a
2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
3 The People alleged additional charges against Rouse, who
pleaded no contest before trial (the record does not disclose the
details of his plea and conviction).
15
determinate term of two years (the middle term) for conspiracy to
commit arson.
Cardarelli timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
Cardarelli argues his defense counsel provided ineffective
assistance of counsel by failing to object to the admission of three
sets of hearsay evidence: Rouse’s jail phone call with his aunt,
A.S.’s statements during the Perkins operation in her jail cell,
and Rouse’s police interview.
A. Relevant Proceedings
Defense counsel did not object when the prosecution played
for the jury a recording of Rouse’s jail phone call with his aunt.
During the next break, the court stated it was concerned the call
was inadmissible hearsay, explaining Rouse’s statements were
against his penal interest but expressing uncertainty as to
whether Rouse was legally unavailable such that the hearsay
exception for statements against penal interest could apply. The
court further explained it had not raised the issue when the
prosecution presented the call because it recognized that “these
trial attorneys are extremely experienced” and it did not want to
interfere with possible strategy. The court added it knew defense
counsel had “a strategy and that’s abundantly clear. And
whether or not you feel this evidence even if it comes in would
benefit your client in some way, which maybe it does, but I can
only assume it’s a strategy call for you to allow this evidence to
come in . . . .”
Defense counsel responded that not objecting was a
“complete strategy call,” explaining, “I want as much evidence in
16
from Mr. Rouse as I could possibly get in because my position is
that he is lying about my client’s involvement in the murder.
And calls like [the jail phone call] show that he’ll lie even to his
aunt about what happened, and there is a pattern of him lying.
We’re going to find out that that happens in his interviews with
the police, that changing of stories and so forth. And that’s the
reason I didn’t object to it and wouldn’t ever object to it.” The
court stated it would not interfere with the strategy and would
allow the admission of the call as statements against penal
interest if the parties stipulated that Rouse was legally
unavailable. After defense counsel and the prosecutor explained
that Rouse’s time to appeal following his own no-contest plea had
not yet elapsed such that he still had a privilege against self-
incrimination, both parties stipulated that he was unavailable.
The court then raised a related hearsay concern regarding
the prosecution’s prospective presentation of a recording of A.S.’s
conversation with the jailhouse informant. The prosecutor
argued A.S.’s statements were nontestimonial and against penal
interest and that A.S. was believed to be in New York and thus
unavailable. The prosecutor explained he had discussed the
admission of the conversation with defense counsel before trial.
Although the prosecutor was not going to play the part of the
conversation in which A.S. stated she stabbed the victim, defense
counsel planned to elicit those facts from the investigating
detective who would lay foundation. Defense counsel explained,
“I’ll deal with that and change of stories which, again, falls into
the only defense I have, which is everybody is changing stories
and that, you know, you can’t trust anything they say.” Counsel
reiterated, “I don’t have a problem with this. Again, it allows me
to get in things that maybe I would not otherwise be able to get
17
in.” Counsel stated he had communicated with A.S.’s family, who
confirmed she was in New York and indicated “there is no way in
heck she’s coming out to California to testify in this case.” The
court stated that if both parties stipulated that A.S. was legally
unavailable, it would permit admission of her statements as
against penal interest. Both parties so stipulated, and the
prosecution presented the evidence without objection.
Finally, after these stipulations, the prosecutor indicated
he also intended to present Rouse’s jail interview with law
enforcement. Defense counsel stated he would not object. The
parties indicated they would further discuss the issue amongst
themselves. The next trial day, the prosecutor again raised the
issue, expressing desire to play a recording of the interview for
the jury with the understanding that defense counsel would ask
to play it if he did not. Defense counsel concurred, stating the
interview goes “to my strategy in terms of defending [Cardarelli],
and . . . there is stuff in it that helps him. There is stuff in it that
helps me. So it’s going both ways on here. So where it would
normally be testimonial and I would be technically arguing I
don’t have a chance to cross-examine, but in this case I don’t need
to cross-examine. It’s done within the statements that he makes
that will get the points out that I would have gotten out had I
been able to cross-examine him.”
The court stated it appeared the parties wanted to stipulate
to the admission of the interview and waive any legal objection.
The parties agreed. The prosecutor reiterated that defense
counsel “is making a strategic decision because he feels it’s in the
best interest of his client to play this” and agreed the evidence
did “cut both ways.” The prosecutor raised the possibility of this
becoming an issue on appeal but stated that “[defense counsel’s]
18
many years of doing this and his great success on cases” was
“sufficient for my concern for an appellate issue.” Defense
counsel reiterated he was purposely not objecting, describing it as
“a situation of me affirmatively wanting this [evidence] in.”
Counsel stated “an appellate court is not going to have an issue
as to whether there is a failure to object because of strategic
reasons,” emphasizing “[i]t is completely a strategic decision on
my part.” The court permitted admission of the interview, which
the prosecution later played for the jury without objection.
B. Defense Counsel Did Not Provide Ineffective Assistance
1. Applicable legal standards
To demonstrate ineffective assistance of counsel, Cardarelli
must show (1) his counsel’s performance fell below an objective
standard of reasonableness, and (2) but for counsel’s error, a
different result would have been reasonably probable.
(Strickland v. Washington (1984) 466 U.S. 668, 687 (Strickland).)
“A reasonable probability is a probability sufficient to undermine
confidence in the outcome.” (Id. at p. 694.) “Whether counsel’s
performance was deficient, and whether any deficiency
prejudiced defendant, are mixed questions of law and fact subject
to our independent review.” (In re Gay (2020) 8 Cal.5th 1059,
1073.)
“Because of the difficulties inherent in making the
evaluation [of counsel’s performance], a court must indulge a
strong presumption that counsel’s conduct falls within the wide
range of reasonable professional assistance; that is, the
defendant must overcome the presumption that, under the
circumstances, the challenged action ‘might be considered sound
trial strategy.’ ” (Strickland, supra, 466 U.S. at p. 689; accord,
19
People v. Stanley (2006) 39 Cal.4th 913, 954 [“ ‘ “[W]e accord
great deference to counsel’s tactical decisions” [citation], and we
have explained that “courts should not second-guess reasonable,
if difficult, tactical decisions in the harsh light of hindsight”
[citation]. “Tactical errors are generally not deemed reversible,
and counsel’s decisionmaking must be evaluated in the context of
the available facts.” ’ ”].) “[S]trategic choices made after thorough
investigation of law and facts relevant to plausible options are
virtually unchallengeable.” (Strickland, at p. 690.) “On direct
appeal, a conviction will be reversed for ineffective assistance
only if (1) the record affirmatively discloses counsel had no
rational tactical purpose for the challenged act or omission,
(2) counsel was asked for a reason and failed to provide one, or
(3) there simply could be no satisfactory explanation. All other
claims of ineffective assistance are more appropriately resolved in
a habeas corpus proceeding.” (People v. Mai (2013) 57 Cal.4th
986, 1009; accord, People v. Johnsen (2021) 10 Cal.5th 1116,
1165; People v. Sepulveda (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 291, 301.)
2. Cardarelli has not shown defense counsel’s
performance was deficient
Cardarelli contends his defense counsel was ineffective for
failing to object to the hearsay evidence and stipulating to its
admission. We examine whether Cardarelli has overcome the
presumption that his counsel’s strategy articulated during the
trial was reasonable, based on the circumstances and facts known
to counsel at the time. (See People v. Stanley, supra, 39 Cal.4th
at p. 954.)
Hearsay evidence is “evidence of a statement that was
made other than by a witness while testifying at the hearing and
that is offered to prove the truth of the matter stated.” (Evid.
20
Code, § 1200, subd. (a).) “Hearsay is generally inadmissible
unless it falls under an exception.” (People v. Sanchez (2016)
63 Cal.4th 665, 674; see Evid. Code, § 1200, subd. (b) [“Except as
provided by law, hearsay evidence is inadmissible.”].) Further, if
an accuser makes a formal out-of-court statement to a
government officer (i.e., testimonial hearsay), then a criminal
defendant’s Sixth Amendment right to confront the accuser is
triggered: admission of testimonial hearsay against a defendant
violates the confrontation clause “unless (1) the declarant is
unavailable to testify and (2) the defendant had a previous
opportunity to cross-examine the witness or forfeited the right by
his own wrongdoing.” (Sanchez, at p. 680; accord, People v.
Martinez (2018) 19 Cal.App.5th 853, 860.) While statements
made during a formal police interrogation are testimonial,
statements made unwittingly to a government informant are not.
(People v. Gallardo (2017) 18 Cal.App.5th 51, 67-68; People v.
Washington (2017) 15 Cal.App.5th 19, 28.)
“The improper admission of hearsay is an error of state
law. The improper admission of testimonial hearsay is an error
of federal law, in that it violates the [federal] Constitution’s
confrontation clause.” (People v. Martinez, supra, 19 Cal.App.5th
at p. 860.)
Cardarelli correctly contends Rouse’s statements during his
interview with the police were testimonial hearsay. Cardarelli
asserts the admission of these statements violated his
confrontation clause rights because Rouse was not subject to
cross-examination. With respect to Rouse’s statements in his jail
phone call and A.S.’s statements during the Perkins operation,
although they were not testimonial, Cardarelli contends at least
portions of the statements were not admissible under the hearsay
21
exception for statements against penal interest. That exception
permits the admission of statements by a declarant that, “when
made, . . . so far subjected him to the risk of civil or criminal
liability . . . that a reasonable man in his position would not have
made the statement unless he believed it to be true.” (Evid.
Code, § 1230; see People v. Grimes (2016) 1 Cal.5th 698, 710-711
[“[T]he rationale underlying the exception is that ‘a person’s
interest against being criminally implicated gives reasonable
assurance of the veracity of his statement made against that
interest,’ thereby mitigating the dangers usually associated with
the admission of out-of-court statements.”].) For the exception to
apply, the proponent of the evidence must show (1) the declarant
is unavailable, (2) the declaration was against the declarant’s
penal interest when made, and (3) the declaration was
sufficiently reliable to warrant admission. (Grimes, at p. 711.)
Cardarelli argues the exception does not apply because Rouse’s
and A.S.’s statements shifted blame and were self-serving and
thus were not sufficiently against penal interest.
Even assuming Cardarelli had meritorious objections to
keep the three sets of hearsay evidence from being admitted into
evidence, however, Cardarelli has not met his burden to show his
counsel’s performance was deficient in stipulating to the
admission of the statements. As his counsel explained to the trial
court, he believed Cardarelli’s best defense was to rely on the
many inconsistencies in other actors’ statements to cast doubt on
Cardarelli’s participation in the crimes. Cardarelli asserts this
strategy was “not sound” because neither Rouse nor A.S.
testified, and thus there was no need to impeach their credibility.
But it was not irrational for defense counsel to acquiesce to
evidence coming in to show Rouse and A.S. repeatedly changed
22
their stories and pointed fingers in numerous different directions,
in an effort to sow doubt as to Cardarelli’s role because it was
impossible to trust what any of the other participants said.
Cardarelli argues the hearsay evidence contradicted his
defense and thus it was unreasonable for his counsel to allow it to
come in. Indeed, defense counsel acknowledged the hearsay
evidence cut both ways. In their statements, the declarants gave
versions of the night of the murder that implicated Cardarelli as
a participant in the robbery and murder. But they also told
versions of their stories that did not implicate him at all.
Moreover, some of the declarants’ statements supported
Cardarelli’s own version of the night and provided favorable
evidence for his defense. For instance, just as Cardarelli testified
he spent the evening of the murder in fear of Rouse, A.S. told the
jailhouse informant that she cleaned up the crime scene because
Rouse told her she would “end up looking like” the victim if she
did not. And Rouse unequivocally maintained in his police
interview that Cardarelli did not participate in A.S.’s
prostitution, providing strong evidence for Cardarelli’s defense to
the human trafficking charge, on which the jury ultimately found
him not guilty.
Counsel’s reliance on this strategy was not objectively
unreasonable given the other ample and strong evidence
depicting Cardarelli as an active participant in the crimes and
given the inconsistencies in and inherent unbelievability of
Cardarelli’s own version of the events. (See Harrington v. Richter
(2011) 562 U.S. 86, 109 [“To support a defense argument that the
prosecution has not proved its case it sometimes is better to try to
cast pervasive suspicion of doubt than to strive to prove a
certainty that exonerates.”].) It was not as if the hearsay
23
evidence provided the only evidence tying Cardarelli to the
robbery, the murder, or the conspiracy to dispose of the body by
burning it. Unrebutted evidence at trial showed Rouse and A.S.
engaged in a pattern of robberies of men who paid to have sex
with A.S. Cardarelli went to the apartment on the night one of
those robberies was planned, and S.B. testified that, immediately
before the murder, Rouse and Cardarelli discussed robbing
Aguila and practiced how they were going to do it. Texts between
Cardarelli and A.S. about Rouse and her wanting Cardarelli to be
at the apartment so that “it would be easier nn more quiet” and
Cardarelli agreeing and wanting to be there to “help out” also
supported the conclusion that Cardarelli knowingly went to the
apartment to participate in a robbery on the day of the murder.
Just before Aguila arrived at the apartment, A.S. and S.B. texted
about how scared they were and expressed fear that Aguila might
have a gun, confirming the planned nature of the robbery. A.S.
texted that Cardarelli looked like he was about to cry, strongly
suggesting that he too was nervous about the robbery.
Afterwards, however, Cardarelli did not seem upset or surprised
about what had happened, suggesting he knew a robbery was
planned and was not surprised something went wrong.
In the conversations with Smith after the killing,
Cardarelli did not dispute that he had helped Rouse kill Aguila,
and Cardarelli told Smith that Rouse started beating Aguila up,
but Cardarelli had to step in to finish it. The evidence also
showed Cardarelli helped Rouse in planning to burn Aguila’s
body and then in executing that plan. Thus, defense counsel was
aware that even without the hearsay evidence, there was strong
evidence that Cardarelli knowingly participated in the robbery of
24
Aguila and his murder, as well as the conspiracy to commit arson
afterwards.
While Cardarelli asserts defense counsel never even raised
the issue of Rouse’s and A.S.’s credibility during closing
arguments, counsel did emphasize the uncertainty in the
collective evidence at trial and the doubt it created as to the
actual truth of who did what. He stated: “[N]obody . . . knows
who delivered a blow to Mr. Aguila that actually killed him. If
we assume there [are] two people involved, we don’t know that.
Nobody could tell us that. The coroner can’t tell us that. Nobody
can. But that assumes two people are involved, and Mr.
Cardarelli has told you he wasn’t involved in the actual killing of
Mr. Aguila. I don’t know. You know, nobody knows what went
wrong that day . . . .” Counsel may have determined the
contradictions in Rouse’s and A.S.’s statements were so obvious
that they did not need special emphasis.
“Under these circumstances, we cannot say counsel was
constitutionally ineffective in his attempt to make the best of a
bad situation.” (People v. McPeters (1992) 2 Cal.4th 1148, 1187,
superseded by statute on another ground as stated in Verdin v.
Superior Court (2008) 43 Cal.4th 1096, 1106.) Counsel’s choice to
not object to the hearsay evidence and instead use it as part of
the defense strategy can be considered a rational tactical
decision. Even if opinions can differ on the advisability of such a
tactic, hindsight is not the proper perspective for assessing the
competence of counsel’s trial decisions. (In re Valdez (2010)
49 Cal.4th 715, 729-730; accord, Strickland, supra, 466 U.S. at
p. 689; see People v. Weaver (2001) 26 Cal.4th 876, 928 [“ ‘even
“debatable trial tactics” do not “constitute a deprivation of the
effective assistance of counsel” ’ ”].) “As [Cardarelli] has failed to
25
show affirmative evidence that counsel could have had ‘no
rational tactical purpose’ for these decisions, [he] has not
demonstrated constitutionally deficient performance on this
record.” (People v. Mickel (2016) 2 Cal.5th 181, 200.)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
STONE, J.
We concur:
MARTINEZ, P. J.
FEUER, J.
26
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.