People v. Leonard CA3

CourtListener 10845623CalctappApr 16, 2026

Full text

Filed 4/16/26 P. v. Leonard CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Placer)

THE PEOPLE, C103245
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. SCV-0018150)
v.

HARVEY MACK LEONARD,
Defendant and Appellant.

Defendant Harvey Mack Leonard was committed for an indefinite term of
treatment as a sexually violent predator under the Sexually Violent Predator Act (Welf. &
Inst. Code,1 § 6600 et seq.) (Act). He appeals from an order denying his petition for
conditional release as frivolous. (See § 6608, subd. (a).) Defendant contends the trial
court abused its discretion by denying his petition, which he argues “made a prima facie
showing that he would not be a danger to others while under supervision and treatment in
the community.” We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In 2008, defendant was adjudged a sexually violent predator under the Act and
committed to the State Department of State Hospitals (Department) for an indefinite
term. Prior to his indefinite commitment, defendant had been continually incarcerated or

1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.

1
institutionalized since 1996. Defendant’s sexual offense history spanned an nine-year
period from 1976 to 1985, during which he was convicted of two counts of forcible rape
involving female victims under the age of 18 years old. Several adult female victims also
alleged that during this period defendant committed sexual assault, assault with intent to
commit rape, attempted rape, digital penetration, forcible oral copulation, and forcible
rape.
I
Petition For Conditional Release
On July 5, 2024, defendant filed a petition for conditional release pursuant to
section 6608, subdivision (a). In support of this petition, defendant attached a declaration
and eight exhibits. Most exhibits were documents the Department created between 2019
and 2024—including treatment plans, annual evaluations, psychological assessments, and
a progress note. The last was a community reentry plan prepared by defendant on a
Department form.
In defendant’s declaration, he stated “professional staff” assessed his
dangerousness as low. He also challenged the Department’s annual evaluator’s
determinations and raised his medical conditions and advanced age as protective factors
against reoffense.
The January 2024 treatment plan exhibit identified the following dynamic risk
factors as barriers to defendant’s discharge: intimacy deficits (i.e., hostility towards
women and lack of concern for others); general self-regulation (i.e., impulsive acts, poor
cognitive problem-solving, and negative emotionality or hostility); sexual self-regulation
(i.e., sex as coping and deviant sexual interests); and lack of cooperation with
supervision. Defendant enrolled in a sex offender treatment program to address his
sexual self-regulation.
According to the community reentry plan exhibit, defendant intended to relocate to
a mobile home in Tennessee and support himself by renting mobile homes in partnership

2
with his family. Defendant wrote the plan on a Department form and supplied
information in response to the fields of inquiry. He stated, “[S]ex means nothing to me,”
and “[l]ife in general is the best group you will be able to complete” to summarize his
intended sex offender treatment program and prevention plan for release.
Defendant also attached a psychological assessment from 2021 and a cognitive
assessment from 2024 as exhibits. The 2021 psychological assessment, which measured
defendant’s responses to sexual stimuli and included his self-reported sexual interests,
suggested he had a high sexual interest in adolescent and adult females, with no
indication of interest in sexual violence. The 2021 psychological assessment also
reflected a discrepancy between defendant’s admitted sexual behaviors and offense
history. The 2024 cognitive assessment reported and interpreted the results of
defendant’s cognitive screening, which suggested he functions in the borderline range for
overall neurocognitive abilities, with spelling and memory deficits.
II
The Department’s Annual Evaluation
In 2024, the Department prepared and submitted an annual evaluation (2024
annual evaluation) stating defendant should not be considered for conditional release.
The 2024 annual evaluation sourced information from prior annual evaluations, including
those attached by defendant as exhibits to his petition.
The 2024 annual evaluation noted defendant enrolled in module two of the
Department’s four-module sex offender treatment program in 2021. A facilitator
reported defendant “participated actively and independently,” making “[a]cceptable to
[v]ery [g]ood progress.” The Department’s staff also described defendant as having a
“positive attitude” and being “highly motivated to participate in treatment.” In 2023, the
facilitator reported “not being comfortable supporting” defendant’s transition to the next
module in the sex offender treatment program without polygraph assessments, and noted
concerns about the dynamic risk factors.

3
The 2024 annual evaluation acknowledged defendant “has several medical
conditions but no untreated medical conditions that would negatively impact motivation
or ability to reoffend.” It further acknowledged: “[Defendant] suffer[s] from Peyronie’s
Disease erectile dysfunction … however, … much of his sexualized violence against his
young female victims was not limited to penile penetration; it also included forced oral
copulation. Accordingly, this factor does not provide protective influence.” The 2024
annual evaluation found defendant’s advanced age provided “protective influence for the
risk of future re-offense,” but was “likely diluted by the presence of severe psychopathy
and relatively recent (November 2022) active presence” in the sex offender treatment
program.
The 2024 annual evaluation concluded, “[C]onditional release is not currently in
[defendant’s] best interest and conditions cannot be imposed that adequately protect the
community.” The 2024 annual evaluation reasoned defendant’s “arousal to sexually
deviant stimuli cannot [currently] be ascertained because he has not undergone the
relevant objective assessments” and cited concerns about the dynamic risk factors. The
Department’s conditional release program also did not endorse defendant’s release. The
Department recommended defendant continue to participate in the sex offender treatment
program, enroll in treatment for substance abuse and the unaddressed dynamic risk
factors, complete polygraph and neurological assessments, and develop a thorough
release plan in preparation for community outpatient treatment.
III
Trial Court’s Ruling
The trial court found defendant’s petition frivolous. The court found the 2024
annual evaluation gave appropriate consideration to defendant’s medical conditions and
advanced age as protective factors against reoffense when concluding release was not in
defendant’s best interest. The court considered the 2024 annual evaluation’s assessment
of defendant’s progress in the sex offender treatment program and readiness for

4
conditional release. The court also considered defendant’s release plan, noting it lacked
specificity and coordination with defendant’s treatment team and the conditional release
program. Accordingly, the trial court denied the petition as frivolous.
Defendant appeals.
DISCUSSION
Defendant contends the trial court abused its discretion by denying his petition for
conditional release as frivolous and “should have appointed an independent expert to
evaluate [defendant], obtained a recommendation from [the Department’s director], and
conducted further proceedings as set forth in section 6608, subdivision (b).” We
disagree.
Section 6608, subdivision (a) allows “[a] person who has been committed as a
sexually violent predator … to petition the court for conditional release with or without
the recommendation or concurrence of the [Department’s director].” The trial court must
“review the petition and determine if it is based upon frivolous grounds.” (Ibid.) A
frivolous petition is denied without a hearing. (Ibid.)
“A frivolous petition is one that ‘indisputably has no merit.’ ” (People v. McKee
(2010) 47 Cal.4th 1172, 1192.) Specifically, a petition is frivolous if “any reasonable
attorney would agree that the petition on its face and any supporting attachments [are]
totally and completely without merit.” (People v. Olsen (2014) 229 Cal.App.4th 981,
999.) A petition is not frivolous “if the defendant has made a showing that he or she [or
they] ‘would not be a danger to others due to his or her [or their] diagnosed mental
disorder while under supervision and treatment in the community.’ ” (Id. at p. 996.)
“To make this threshold determination, the trial court reviews the petition and any
supporting attachments to determine ‘ “if the defendant’s position has some merit on the
issue of whether he or she [or they] may qualify for conditional release.” ’ ” (People v.
Olsen, supra, 229 Cal.App.4th at p. 996.) The trial court may also consider the
Department’s annual report in determining whether a petition is frivolous. (Ibid.) It is

5
not necessary for a petition to append admissible evidence. (People v. Collins (2003)
110 Cal.App.4th 340, 350.)
On appeal, we review the trial court’s denial of defendant’s petition for abuse of
discretion. (People v. Reynolds (2010) 181 Cal.App.4th 1402, 1408.) “Where there is a
basis for the trial court’s ruling and it is supported by the evidence, we will not substitute
our opinion for that of the trial court.” (Ibid.)
Here, the trial court considered defendant’s petition, the attached exhibits, and the
Department’s 2024 annual evaluation to determine frivolousness. Contrary to
defendant’s argument, section 6608 does not require the court to appoint an independent
expert before finding a petition frivolous. (See § 6608, subd. (g).) While section 6608,
subdivision (e) requires the court to obtain the written recommendation of the director of
the treatment facility, the court complied with that requirement by obtaining the 2024
annual evaluation, which contained a statement of agreement by the director of the
treatment facility with the evaluation’s findings and recommendation. In light of the
compliance with section 6608, defendant, as the petitioner, bore the burden of proof that
his petition was not frivolous. (People v. Smith (2022) 75 Cal.App.5th 332, 343.) The
trial court did not abuse its discretion by finding defendant failed to carry this burden.
The 2024 annual evaluation noted defendant’s participation in module two of the
Department’s sex offender treatment program, which addressed his sexual
self‑regulation. Despite this participation, the facilitator was not comfortable supporting
defendant’s transition to the next module, noting concerns about the dynamic risk factors.
Further, defendant did not allege any efforts he took to address the other dynamic risk
factors identified by the Department, leaving unanswered the question of how he sought
to address risks of his reoffending.
The 2024 annual evaluation also noted the Department’s conditional release
program did not endorse defendant’s release. The Department recommended defendant
receive additional treatment and develop a thorough release plan. The community

6
reentry plan prepared by defendant lacked specificity and failed to identify a sex offender
treatment program or prevention plan for release. It was not unreasonable for the trial
court to find defendant’s self‑serving assurances that sex meant nothing to him or “[l]ife
in general” was his treatment plan as insufficient options of preventing reoffense upon his
release.
The 2024 annual evaluation considered that defendant “ha[d] several medical
conditions but no untreated medical conditions that would negatively impact motivation
or ability to reoffend” due to the nature of his sexualized violence. The 2024 annual
evaluation also acknowledged defendant’s advanced age as a “protective influence for
[defendant] against the risk of re-offense.” Considering defendant’s medical conditions
and advanced age, the 2024 annual evaluation still concluded conditional release was not
appropriate. Though defendant raised his medical conditions and advanced age as
protective factors against reoffense, his petition does not explain how these factors would
prevent him from reoffending or otherwise negate the Department’s concern that his
medical conditions do not sufficiently protect against reoffense given the circumstances
of his crimes. This is especially true given defendant’s lack of a postrelease treatment
plan.
Defendant argues his case warrants reversal because his petition raised legitimate
concerns with the annual evaluations. Specifically, defendant argues the annual
evaluations ignored positive reviews of his participation in sex offender treatment and
objective assessments. Not so. The 2024 annual evaluation noted defendant’s
participation in sex offender treatment. Further, the attached assessments did not provide
probative information defendant would refrain from sexually violent behavior if released.
The 2021 psychological assessment evaluated defendant’s sexual interests by observing
his reaction to sexual stimuli. While defendant demonstrated an interest in adolescent
and adult women without indication of an interest in sexual violence, the assessment was
several years old and defendant did not appear to engage in the Department’s

7
recommended tests for it to meaningfully assess his suitability for release. The 2021
psychological assessment further reflected inconsistencies between defendant’s admitted
sexual behaviors and offense history. The 2024 cognitive assessment reported
defendant’s cognitive functioning and did not address his mental health condition or
likelihood of reoffense. At bottom, defendant misrepresents the relevance of the attached
assessments, which do not undermine the trial court’s decision.
Further, this case is unlike those in which summary denials were reversed because
the petitions were not frivolous. (People v. LaBlanc (2015) 238 Cal.App.4th 1059, 1078,
1081; People v. Collins, supra, 110 Cal.App.4th at pp. 351-352.) For instance, in
LaBlanc, the defendant’s petition was supported by a clinical psychologist’s report that
challenged the validity of his mental diagnosis. (LaBlanc, at pp. 1063-1064.) The report
also detailed the defendant’s severe medical conditions and how those conditions
significantly reduced the defendant’s ability to reoffend. (Id. at p. 1077.) Similarly, in
Collins, the defendant’s petition was supported by a report from his treating psychiatrist,
who stated he could be managed in the community if released. (Collins, at p. 345.) The
defendant’s counsel in Collins also submitted a declaration stating hospital staff would
testify the defendant “was not likely to reoffend if released to proper supervision.” (Ibid.)
Here, defendant failed to support his claim he would not be a danger to others
while under supervision and treatment in the community. He did not offer any opinion of
a mental health professional or assurances his medical conditions would prevent him
from reoffending. Nor did he explain how he planned to refrain from sexually violent
criminal behavior or participate in treatment if released.
Accordingly, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying defendant’s
petition for conditional release as frivolous.

8
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

/s/
ROBIE, Acting P. J.

We concur:

/s/
MAURO, J.

/s/
WISEMAN, J.*

* Retired Associate Justice of the Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, assigned
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

9

Filed 4/16/26 P. v. Leonard CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Placer)

THE PEOPLE, C103245
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. SCV-0018150)
v.

HARVEY MACK LEONARD,
Defendant and Appellant.

Defendant Harvey Mack Leonard was committed for an indefinite term of
treatment as a sexually violent predator under the Sexually Violent Predator Act (Welf. &
Inst. Code,1 § 6600 et seq.) (Act). He appeals from an order denying his petition for
conditional release as frivolous. (See § 6608, subd. (a).) Defendant contends the trial
court abused its discretion by denying his petition, which he argues “made a prima facie
showing that he would not be a danger to others while under supervision and treatment in
the community.” We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In 2008, defendant was adjudged a sexually violent predator under the Act and
committed to the State Department of State Hospitals (Department) for an indefinite
term. Prior to his indefinite commitment, defendant had been continually incarcerated or

1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.

1
institutionalized since 1996. Defendant’s sexual offense history spanned an nine-year
period from 1976 to 1985, during which he was convicted of two counts of forcible rape
involving female victims under the age of 18 years old. Several adult female victims also
alleged that during this period defendant committed sexual assault, assault with intent to
commit rape, attempted rape, digital penetration, forcible oral copulation, and forcible
rape.
I
Petition For Conditional Release
On July 5, 2024, defendant filed a petition for conditional release pursuant to
section 6608, subdivision (a). In support of this petition, defendant attached a declaration
and eight exhibits. Most exhibits were documents the Department created between 2019
and 2024—including treatment plans, annual evaluations, psychological assessments, and
a progress note. The last was a community reentry plan prepared by defendant on a
Department form.
In defendant’s declaration, he stated “professional staff” assessed his
dangerousness as low. He also challenged the Department’s annual evaluator’s
determinations and raised his medical conditions and advanced age as protective factors
against reoffense.
The January 2024 treatment plan exhibit identified the following dynamic risk
factors as barriers to defendant’s discharge: intimacy deficits (i.e., hostility towards
women and lack of concern for others); general self-regulation (i.e., impulsive acts, poor
cognitive problem-solving, and negative emotionality or hostility); sexual self-regulation
(i.e., sex as coping and deviant sexual interests); and lack of cooperation with
supervision. Defendant enrolled in a sex offender treatment program to address his
sexual self-regulation.
According to the community reentry plan exhibit, defendant intended to relocate to
a mobile home in Tennessee and support himself by renting mobile homes in partnership

2
with his family. Defendant wrote the plan on a Department form and supplied
information in response to the fields of inquiry. He stated, “[S]ex means nothing to me,”
and “[l]ife in general is the best group you will be able to complete” to summarize his
intended sex offender treatment program and prevention plan for release.
Defendant also attached a psychological assessment from 2021 and a cognitive
assessment from 2024 as exhibits. The 2021 psychological assessment, which measured
defendant’s responses to sexual stimuli and included his self-reported sexual interests,
suggested he had a high sexual interest in adolescent and adult females, with no
indication of interest in sexual violence. The 2021 psychological assessment also
reflected a discrepancy between defendant’s admitted sexual behaviors and offense
history. The 2024 cognitive assessment reported and interpreted the results of
defendant’s cognitive screening, which suggested he functions in the borderline range for
overall neurocognitive abilities, with spelling and memory deficits.
II
The Department’s Annual Evaluation
In 2024, the Department prepared and submitted an annual evaluation (2024
annual evaluation) stating defendant should not be considered for conditional release.
The 2024 annual evaluation sourced information from prior annual evaluations, including
those attached by defendant as exhibits to his petition.
The 2024 annual evaluation noted defendant enrolled in module two of the
Department’s four-module sex offender treatment program in 2021. A facilitator
reported defendant “participated actively and independently,” making “[a]cceptable to
[v]ery [g]ood progress.” The Department’s staff also described defendant as having a
“positive attitude” and being “highly motivated to participate in treatment.” In 2023, the
facilitator reported “not being comfortable supporting” defendant’s transition to the next
module in the sex offender treatment program without polygraph assessments, and noted
concerns about the dynamic risk factors.

3
The 2024 annual evaluation acknowledged defendant “has several medical
conditions but no untreated medical conditions that would negatively impact motivation
or ability to reoffend.” It further acknowledged: “[Defendant] suffer[s] from Peyronie’s
Disease erectile dysfunction … however, … much of his sexualized violence against his
young female victims was not limited to penile penetration; it also included forced oral
copulation. Accordingly, this factor does not provide protective influence.” The 2024
annual evaluation found defendant’s advanced age provided “protective influence for the
risk of future re-offense,” but was “likely diluted by the presence of severe psychopathy
and relatively recent (November 2022) active presence” in the sex offender treatment
program.
The 2024 annual evaluation concluded, “[C]onditional release is not currently in
[defendant’s] best interest and conditions cannot be imposed that adequately protect the
community.” The 2024 annual evaluation reasoned defendant’s “arousal to sexually
deviant stimuli cannot [currently] be ascertained because he has not undergone the
relevant objective assessments” and cited concerns about the dynamic risk factors. The
Department’s conditional release program also did not endorse defendant’s release. The
Department recommended defendant continue to participate in the sex offender treatment
program, enroll in treatment for substance abuse and the unaddressed dynamic risk
factors, complete polygraph and neurological assessments, and develop a thorough
release plan in preparation for community outpatient treatment.
III
Trial Court’s Ruling
The trial court found defendant’s petition frivolous. The court found the 2024
annual evaluation gave appropriate consideration to defendant’s medical conditions and
advanced age as protective factors against reoffense when concluding release was not in
defendant’s best interest. The court considered the 2024 annual evaluation’s assessment
of defendant’s progress in the sex offender treatment program and readiness for

4
conditional release. The court also considered defendant’s release plan, noting it lacked
specificity and coordination with defendant’s treatment team and the conditional release
program. Accordingly, the trial court denied the petition as frivolous.
Defendant appeals.
DISCUSSION
Defendant contends the trial court abused its discretion by denying his petition for
conditional release as frivolous and “should have appointed an independent expert to
evaluate [defendant], obtained a recommendation from [the Department’s director], and
conducted further proceedings as set forth in section 6608, subdivision (b).” We
disagree.
Section 6608, subdivision (a) allows “[a] person who has been committed as a
sexually violent predator … to petition the court for conditional release with or without
the recommendation or concurrence of the [Department’s director].” The trial court must
“review the petition and determine if it is based upon frivolous grounds.” (Ibid.) A
frivolous petition is denied without a hearing. (Ibid.)
“A frivolous petition is one that ‘indisputably has no merit.’ ” (People v. McKee
(2010) 47 Cal.4th 1172, 1192.) Specifically, a petition is frivolous if “any reasonable
attorney would agree that the petition on its face and any supporting attachments [are]
totally and completely without merit.” (People v. Olsen (2014) 229 Cal.App.4th 981,
999.) A petition is not frivolous “if the defendant has made a showing that he or she [or
they] ‘would not be a danger to others due to his or her [or their] diagnosed mental
disorder while under supervision and treatment in the community.’ ” (Id. at p. 996.)
“To make this threshold determination, the trial court reviews the petition and any
supporting attachments to determine ‘ “if the defendant’s position has some merit on the
issue of whether he or she [or they] may qualify for conditional release.” ’ ” (People v.
Olsen, supra, 229 Cal.App.4th at p. 996.) The trial court may also consider the
Department’s annual report in determining whether a petition is frivolous. (Ibid.) It is

5
not necessary for a petition to append admissible evidence. (People v. Collins (2003)
110 Cal.App.4th 340, 350.)
On appeal, we review the trial court’s denial of defendant’s petition for abuse of
discretion. (People v. Reynolds (2010) 181 Cal.App.4th 1402, 1408.) “Where there is a
basis for the trial court’s ruling and it is supported by the evidence, we will not substitute
our opinion for that of the trial court.” (Ibid.)
Here, the trial court considered defendant’s petition, the attached exhibits, and the
Department’s 2024 annual evaluation to determine frivolousness. Contrary to
defendant’s argument, section 6608 does not require the court to appoint an independent
expert before finding a petition frivolous. (See § 6608, subd. (g).) While section 6608,
subdivision (e) requires the court to obtain the written recommendation of the director of
the treatment facility, the court complied with that requirement by obtaining the 2024
annual evaluation, which contained a statement of agreement by the director of the
treatment facility with the evaluation’s findings and recommendation. In light of the
compliance with section 6608, defendant, as the petitioner, bore the burden of proof that
his petition was not frivolous. (People v. Smith (2022) 75 Cal.App.5th 332, 343.) The
trial court did not abuse its discretion by finding defendant failed to carry this burden.
The 2024 annual evaluation noted defendant’s participation in module two of the
Department’s sex offender treatment program, which addressed his sexual
self‑regulation. Despite this participation, the facilitator was not comfortable supporting
defendant’s transition to the next module, noting concerns about the dynamic risk factors.
Further, defendant did not allege any efforts he took to address the other dynamic risk
factors identified by the Department, leaving unanswered the question of how he sought
to address risks of his reoffending.
The 2024 annual evaluation also noted the Department’s conditional release
program did not endorse defendant’s release. The Department recommended defendant
receive additional treatment and develop a thorough release plan. The community

6
reentry plan prepared by defendant lacked specificity and failed to identify a sex offender
treatment program or prevention plan for release. It was not unreasonable for the trial
court to find defendant’s self‑serving assurances that sex meant nothing to him or “[l]ife
in general” was his treatment plan as insufficient options of preventing reoffense upon his
release.
The 2024 annual evaluation considered that defendant “ha[d] several medical
conditions but no untreated medical conditions that would negatively impact motivation
or ability to reoffend” due to the nature of his sexualized violence. The 2024 annual
evaluation also acknowledged defendant’s advanced age as a “protective influence for
[defendant] against the risk of re-offense.” Considering defendant’s medical conditions
and advanced age, the 2024 annual evaluation still concluded conditional release was not
appropriate. Though defendant raised his medical conditions and advanced age as
protective factors against reoffense, his petition does not explain how these factors would
prevent him from reoffending or otherwise negate the Department’s concern that his
medical conditions do not sufficiently protect against reoffense given the circumstances
of his crimes. This is especially true given defendant’s lack of a postrelease treatment
plan.
Defendant argues his case warrants reversal because his petition raised legitimate
concerns with the annual evaluations. Specifically, defendant argues the annual
evaluations ignored positive reviews of his participation in sex offender treatment and
objective assessments. Not so. The 2024 annual evaluation noted defendant’s
participation in sex offender treatment. Further, the attached assessments did not provide
probative information defendant would refrain from sexually violent behavior if released.
The 2021 psychological assessment evaluated defendant’s sexual interests by observing
his reaction to sexual stimuli. While defendant demonstrated an interest in adolescent
and adult women without indication of an interest in sexual violence, the assessment was
several years old and defendant did not appear to engage in the Department’s

7
recommended tests for it to meaningfully assess his suitability for release. The 2021
psychological assessment further reflected inconsistencies between defendant’s admitted
sexual behaviors and offense history. The 2024 cognitive assessment reported
defendant’s cognitive functioning and did not address his mental health condition or
likelihood of reoffense. At bottom, defendant misrepresents the relevance of the attached
assessments, which do not undermine the trial court’s decision.
Further, this case is unlike those in which summary denials were reversed because
the petitions were not frivolous. (People v. LaBlanc (2015) 238 Cal.App.4th 1059, 1078,
1081; People v. Collins, supra, 110 Cal.App.4th at pp. 351-352.) For instance, in
LaBlanc, the defendant’s petition was supported by a clinical psychologist’s report that
challenged the validity of his mental diagnosis. (LaBlanc, at pp. 1063-1064.) The report
also detailed the defendant’s severe medical conditions and how those conditions
significantly reduced the defendant’s ability to reoffend. (Id. at p. 1077.) Similarly, in
Collins, the defendant’s petition was supported by a report from his treating psychiatrist,
who stated he could be managed in the community if released. (Collins, at p. 345.) The
defendant’s counsel in Collins also submitted a declaration stating hospital staff would
testify the defendant “was not likely to reoffend if released to proper supervision.” (Ibid.)
Here, defendant failed to support his claim he would not be a danger to others
while under supervision and treatment in the community. He did not offer any opinion of
a mental health professional or assurances his medical conditions would prevent him
from reoffending. Nor did he explain how he planned to refrain from sexually violent
criminal behavior or participate in treatment if released.
Accordingly, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying defendant’s
petition for conditional release as frivolous.

8
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

/s/
ROBIE, Acting P. J.

We concur:

/s/
MAURO, J.

/s/
WISEMAN, J.*

* Retired Associate Justice of the Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, assigned
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

9

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.