CourtListener 10827491•People v. Shahen CA2/1
Full text
Filed 3/27/26 P. v. Shahen CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
THE PEOPLE, B339337
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. SA098412)
v.
VACHO SHAHEN,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Henry J. Hall, Judge. Affirmed.
Paul Stubb, Jr., under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, David E. Madeo and Sophia A. Lecky, Deputy
Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________
Vacho Shahen appeals from a judgment entered after a
jury found him guilty of three counts of first degree residential
robbery with a person present, four counts of first degree
residential burglary with a person present, five counts of false
imprisonment by violence or menace, and three counts of assault
with a firearm. As to all counts, the jury found the allegation
that he used a firearm during commission of the offenses to be
true. With respect to one of the counts of assault with a firearm,
the jury found the allegation that he inflicted great bodily injury
on the victim to be true. He committed these offenses over a two-
week period during which he burglarized four homes. The court
sentenced him to an aggregate prison term of 46 years and eight
months in prison.
On appeal, he raises one claim of sentencing error. He
contends the trial court violated Penal Code1 section 654 when it
declined to stay punishment on four of the five false
imprisonment counts. He asserts the evidence was insufficient to
show that when he falsely imprisoned each of these victims, he
harbored a separate criminal objective that was not incidental to
the robbery or burglary. We reject his contention and affirm.
BACKGROUND
A. Evidence Presented at Trial2
1. Crimes against Victoria Papazian
Victoria Papazian lived with her family in a three-bedroom
house in Downey. At around 9:00 a.m., on August 15, 2016, she
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2 We include here evidence pertinent to the issue before
us—whether the trial court complied with section 654 when it
imposed and declined to stay punishment on four of the five false
2
was asleep in a bedroom and a noise woke her. She had been
alone in the house. When she opened her eyes, she saw a man,
later identified as Shahen, wearing all black clothing and a “very
scary mask” like that worn in the movie “Scream,” and pointing a
gun at her face. He said, “ ‘I’m not going to hurt you. Don’t make
a sound.’ ” Then, he placed handcuffs on her wrists.
He told her he needed money, and she took him to her
purse in the living room which contained $10,000 in cash. All the
while he pointed the gun at her. He took the money and said he
needed $30,000. She responded that she did not have that much
money and offered to give him a $30,000 Cartier watch. She took
him back to the bedroom where she had been sleeping, and he
grabbed the watch. Next, he demanded the box that went with
the watch, and she took him to a closet in a different bedroom
where she stored the box. He had her sit on the ground and he
pointed the gun at her while he filled a shopping bag with
valuables from the closet, including other watches, necklaces,
rings, bracelets, antique gold coins, a collection of Dupont
lighters, and her fiancé’s gun.
After taking the various items, he led her to the kitchen.
He removed another set of handcuffs from his pocket and
handcuffed her to the stove. Thus, she was then wearing two sets
of handcuffs: one set binding both wrists and another binding one
of her wrists to the stove. She pleaded with him to remove the
handcuffs or place a phone near her, explaining, “ ‘No one is going
to be coming home for a while.’ ” He refused, saying, “ ‘I can’t
risk that,’ ” and “ ‘I’m sorry. I can’t do that.’ ” Eventually, he
imprisonment counts. We do not include a summary of all
evidence supporting the jury’s verdicts, such as evidence
identifying Shahen as the perpetrator of the crimes.
3
agreed to remove the set of handcuffs binding her wrists together,
and he left her with one wrist handcuffed to the stove. Papazian
estimated that Shahen was in her home for approximately one
hour.
After he left, she remained handcuffed for around 10
minutes. At first, she yelled for help, but no one came. Then, she
managed to secure a knife from a drawer and used it to break one
of the handcuffs. Once free, she dialed 9-1-1.
Based on these events, the jury found Shahen guilty of first
degree burglary (§ 459) with a person present (count 1), first
degree robbery (§ 211) with a person present (count 2), and false
imprisonment (§ 236) by violence or menace (count 3). As to
these counts, the jury found the allegation that Shahen
personally used a firearm during commission of the offenses to be
true. (§ 12022.53, subd. (b), as to the robbery; § 12022.5, subd.
(a), as to the other offenses.)
2. Crimes against Edna Perez and Frank
Granadeno
On August 16, 2016, the day after Shahen committed the
crimes against Papazian, he burglarized another single-family
home in Downey where Edna Perez was staying with her friend
and her friend’s adult son, Frank Granadeno.
At around 9:30 a.m., Perez walked out the front door of the
house to take out some trash, and a man later identified as
Shahen confronted her. He was dressed in all black and wore a
mask like the one in the movie “Scream.” He pushed her back
inside the house, hit her on the shoulder with the butt of a gun,
and she fell. He pointed the gun at her while she was on the
floor. She asked him not to kill her and told him she had no
4
money. She stood up and he handcuffed one of her wrists to a
metal pole or railing at the bottom of a staircase.
Shahen climbed the stairs to the second floor, and Perez
heard Granadeno scream. She looked up and saw Shahen
leading Granadeno from room to room, pointing the gun at the
back of Granadeno’s head. On more than one occasion, Shahen
brought Granadeno downstairs and led him to the garage at
gunpoint. Each time, they returned with tools, including a
hammer and a tire iron, and went back upstairs. Perez heard the
sound of tools striking something. The noise lasted more than
two hours. When Shahen finished upstairs, the safe in the
master bedroom closet was open.
Shahen brought Granadeno downstairs and handcuffed
him to the railing of the staircase next to Perez, using a separate
set of handcuffs. He continued to threaten them with the gun, at
one point rubbing the gun against Perez’s body.
Shahen walked through the kitchen, grabbed a set of car
keys, and went to the garage. Perez heard the Maserati that was
parked there start up. Shahen could not drive the Maserati out
of the garage because there was another car in the driveway
blocking the garage. Perez heard the Maserati turn off.
Shahen came back into the house. He gave Perez and
Granadeno a water bottle and some bananas. Then, he left
through the front door. Perez estimated that the whole event
lasted two and a half to three hours. She did not see Shahen take
anything from the house.
After Shahen left, Perez and Granadeno remained
handcuffed for 30 to 60 minutes. Granadeno used his foot to turn
the handle of the front door and open it. He and Perez screamed
for help. A neighbor heard them yelling and came and freed
5
them from the handcuffs, using a key Shahen had left in the
house. Officers were called to the home.
Based on these events, the jury found Shahen guilty of one
count of first degree burglary with a person present against
Granadeno (count 4) and two counts of false imprisonment by
violence or menace (count 6 against Granadeno and count 8
against Perez).3 As to these counts, the jury found the allegation
that Shahen personally used a firearm during commission of the
offenses to be true. (§ 12022.5, subd. (a).)
3. Crimes against Sanford Brotman and Yency
Angulo
On August 26, 2016, at around 5:10 a.m., Yency Angulo
awoke and discovered water entering through a glass door at the
Beverly Hills home of her boyfriend, Sanford Brotman. She and
Brotman went outside to investigate and found a garden hose
jammed with wooden sticks, aimed at the house and spraying
water on the door. As they tried to figure out how this had
occurred, a man later identified as Shahen jumped out from
behind some bushes and pointed a gun at them. He wore all
black clothing and a “Scream” movie mask.
Shahen told them, “ ‘Get in the house. Do as I say,’ ” or
words to that effect. He walked them into the house at gunpoint
and ordered them to be quiet. Once inside, he handcuffed one of
Brotman’s wrists to one of Angulo’s wrists. He said he would not
hurt them if they followed his orders. He ordered Brotman to
walk him around the house, showing him where any safes and
money were located. Brotman complied and they walked through
3 Count 8 is the sole false imprisonment count for which
Shahen does not challenge his sentence.
6
every room. From a safe, Shahen took a watch and cash totaling
less than $1,000. He also took $200 from Angulo’s wallet.
When Shahen finished going through their things, he
brought them to the kitchen. He took their cell phones and
removed the handcuffs. According to Brotman’s trial testimony,
Shahen threatened them as follows: “He told us that he’s not
going to tie us up and to sit in the kitchen and wait while he
leaves. He made a threat that -- I remember specifically that he
knows where we live. Don’t call the police. If he turns around
and sees us get up -- because he wanted us to stay put because
he’s going to wait and see -- he’s going to sho[o]t us through the
window. That’s what he said.” Angulo testified: “He told us to
wait for 15 minutes before we were to call the police. He said he
knows what our faces look like. He knows where we live. He
knows what cars we drive. And that if he were to see us on the
street he could shoot us if we were to call the police before.”
According to Angulo, Shahen also “said that he was going to wait
outside for a while to see if we were to call the police.”
Shahen left, taking the handcuffs with him. The ordeal
lasted between an hour and an hour and a half. Brotman told
Angulo, “ ‘Let’s not move. Let’s just sit here for a few minutes.’ ”
After some period of time, they got up and dialed 9-1-1.
Based on these events, the jury found Shahen guilty of one
count of first degree burglary with a person present against
Brotman (count 9), two counts of first degree robbery with a
person present (count 10 against Brotman and count 11 against
Angulo), and two counts of false imprisonment by violence or
menace (count 14 against Brotman and count 15 against Angulo).
As to these counts, the jury found the allegation that Shahen
personally used a firearm during commission of the offenses to be
7
true. (§ 12022.53, subd. (b), as to the robberies; § 12022.5, subd.
(a), as to the other offenses.)
4. Other crimes
On August 28, 2016, Shahen committed crimes against
three other victims at a home in Santa Monica. He shot one of
the victims in the abdomen. Based on this incident, the jury
found Shahen guilty of one count of first degree burglary with a
person present (count 16) and three counts of assault with a
firearm (counts 20, 22 & 23). As to these counts, the jury found
the allegation that Shahen personally used a firearm during
commission of the offenses to be true. (§ 12022.5, subd. (a).) As
to one count of assault with a firearm (count 22), the jury found
the allegation that Shahen inflicted great bodily injury on the
victim to be true. (§ 12022.7, subd. (a).) We need not elaborate
on the circumstances of these other crimes because they are not
relevant to the issue Shahen raises in this appeal.
B. Sentencing
The prosecution filed a sentencing memorandum
recommending, among other things, that the court impose and
stay punishment under section 654 for the burglary against
Papazian (count 1) and the burglary against Brotman (count 9)
because these offenses were part of the same course of conduct as
the robberies committed against the same victims (counts 2 &
10). The prosecution also recommended that the court impose
and stay punishment for three of the five false imprisonment
counts, count 3 against Papazian, count 14 against Brotman, and
count 15 against Angulo, arguing these offenses were incidental
to and indivisible from the robberies committed against the same
victims. As to the false imprisonment count against Granadeno
8
(count 6), the prosecution asserted it was “unclear” if the offense
“would be subject to [section] 654” but recommended the court
impose and stay punishment “for the sake of avoiding error.”4 As
to all other counts, the prosecution urged the court to impose
consecutive terms.
At the sentencing hearing, the court addressed the
prosecution’s recommendations, agreeing it was appropriate to
impose and stay punishment under section 654 for the burglaries
in counts 1 and 9. The court disagreed with the prosecution’s
section 654 analysis as to the false imprisonment counts, stating:
“[T]his is where the People and I diverge on thoughts on
this -- the various false imprisonment charges in this case reflect
the gratuitous violence and stress of the victims above and
beyond that which is necessary for either the burglaries or the
robberies.
“I’ll note that in the Brotman matter and Angulo matter
[counts 14 & 15], the defendant moved the victims from place to
place at gunpoint. And in the other matters -- two of the other
matters [counts 3 & 6] -- he handcuffed the victims in such a way
that it precluded them from seeking assistance or summoning
help.
“And I think that the violence reflected in those false
imprisonments goes far beyond that which you normally see in a
home invasion robbery or a residential burglary or a burglary
with a person present.
4 A section 654 analysis is not applicable to the remaining
false imprisonment count against Perez (count 8), as Shahen was
not charged with any other crime against her, such as robbery.
9
“And, therefore, because of the violence and the additional
violence, I think that . . . section 654 does not apply to those false
imprisonment cases.”
The court selected count 2, the robbery committed against
Papazian, as the principal term, and imposed the middle term for
the offense plus the statutory term for the firearm enhancement
under section 12022.53, subdivision (b). On all other counts,
except counts 1 and 9 which were stayed, the court imposed
consecutive terms of one-third the middle term for the offense
plus one-third the statutory term or one-third the middle term for
the enhancements applicable to the count. The aggregate prison
sentence, as imposed and executed, is 46 years and eight months.
The term imposed for each false imprisonment count that
Shahen challenges on appeal (counts 3, 6, 14 & 15) is two years:
one-third the middle term for the offense (eight months) plus one-
third the middle term for the firearm enhancement under section
12022.5, subdivision (a) (one year and four months). Shahen asks
us to order that these terms be stayed, thereby reducing his
executed sentence by eight years.
DISCUSSION
Shahen contends the trial court violated section 654 when
it declined to stay punishment on four of the five counts of false
imprisonment. He asserts the evidence was insufficient to show
that when he falsely imprisoned each of these victims he
harbored a separate criminal objective that was not incidental to
the robbery or burglary. We reject Shahen’s contention, as
substantial evidence supports the factual findings underpinning
the court’s decision to impose punishment on each false
imprisonment count.
10
1. Elements of the offenses at issue
In determining whether the court could impose (and decline
to stay) multiple punishments for robbery or burglary on the one
hand, and false imprisonment of the same victim on the other
hand, we begin with the elements of each offense.
As the trial court instructed the jury, the elements of
robbery in violation of section 211 are: “1. The defendant took
property that was not his own; [¶] 2. The property was in the
possession of another person; [¶] 3. The property was taken
from the other person or his or her immediate presence; [¶] 4.
The property was taken against that person’s will; [¶] 5. The
defendant used force or fear to take the property or to prevent the
person from resisting; [¶] AND [¶] 6. When the defendant used
force or fear, he intended to deprive the owner of the property
permanently or to remove the property from the owner’s
possession for so extended a period of time that the owner would
be deprived of a major portion of the value or enjoyment of the
property.” (CALCRIM No. 1600.)
The elements of burglary in violation of section 459, as
applicable to the facts of this case, are: “1. The defendant
entered a building, room within a building, or structure; [¶]
AND [¶] 2. When he entered the building, room, or structure,
he intended to commit theft.” (CALCRIM No. 1700.)
Finally, the elements of false imprisonment by violence or
menace in violation of section 236 are: “1. The defendant
intentionally and unlawfully restrained, or confined, or detained
someone by violence or menace; [¶] AND [¶] 2. The defendant
made the other person stay or go somewhere against that
person’s will. Violence means using physical force that is greater
than the force reasonably necessary to restrain someone. [¶]
11
Menace means a verbal or physical threat of harm, including use
of a deadly weapon.” (CALCRIM No. 1240.)
2. Applicable legal principles regarding section
654
Section 654, subdivision (a), provides in pertinent part, “An
act or omission that is punishable in different ways by different
provisions of law may be punished under either of such
provisions, but in no case shall the act or omission be punished
under more than one provision.” Thus, “If a single action or
course of conduct by a defendant violates multiple laws, ‘the
distinct crimes may be charged in separate counts and may result
in multiple verdicts of guilt, [but] the trial court may impose
sentence for only one offense’ ” and must stay the sentence for the
others. (People v. Sek (2022) 74 Cal.App.5th 657, 673; People v.
Deloza (1998) 18 Cal.4th 585, 591-592.)
Section 654’s purpose is to ensure a defendant is punished
in a manner commensurate with culpability. (People v. Harrison
(1989) 48 Cal.3d 321, 335; People v. Gaynor (2019) 42 Cal.App.5th
794, 800.) To that end, it “precludes multiple punishments for a
single act or indivisible course of conduct.” (People v. Hester
(2000) 22 Cal.4th 290, 294.) Whether a course of criminal
conduct is divisible depends on the intent and objective of the
actor. (People v. Jackson (2016) 1 Cal.5th 269, 354.) If a
“defendant harbored ‘multiple criminal objectives,’ which were
independent of and not merely incidental to each other, he [or
she] may be punished for each statutory violation committed in
pursuit of each objective, ‘even though the violations shared
common acts or were parts of an otherwise indivisible course of
conduct.’ ” (Harrison, at p. 335.) Multiple punishments are also
permissible where a course of criminal conduct is divisible in time
12
and “ ‘the offenses are temporally separated in such a way as to
afford the defendant opportunity to reflect and to renew his or
her intent before committing the next one, thereby aggravating
the violation of public security or policy already undertaken’ ”
and creating a “ ‘new risk of harm.’ ” (Gaynor, at pp. 800, 804;
People v. Peyton (2014) 229 Cal.App.4th 1063, 1080.)
“Section 654 ‘cannot, and should not, be stretched to cover
gratuitous violence or other criminal acts far beyond those
reasonably necessary to accomplish the original offense.’ ”
(People v. Vasquez (2020) 44 Cal.App.5th 732, 737 (Vasquez).)
“[A]t some point the means to achieve an objective may become so
extreme they can no longer be termed ‘incidental’ and must be
considered to express a different and a more sinister goal than
mere successful commission of the original crime.” (People v.
Nguyen (1988) 204 Cal.App.3d 181, 191.) For example,
“gratuitous violence against a helpless and unresisting victim . . .
has traditionally been viewed as not ‘incidental’ to robbery for
purposes of . . . section 654.” (Id. at p. 190.)
3. Standard of review
“The question of whether section 654 is factually applicable
to a given series of offenses is for the trial court, and the law
gives the trial court broad latitude in making this
determination.” (People v. DeVaughn (2014) 227 Cal.App.4th
1092, 1113; Vasquez, supra, 44 Cal.App.5th at p. 737.) Generally,
“a trial court may base its decision under section 654 on any of
the facts that are in evidence at trial,” even those that may not
have been the basis for the jury’s verdicts. (People v. McCoy
(2012) 208 Cal.App.4th 1333, 1340, italics omitted.) We review
the trial court’s express or implied findings regarding the
defendant’s intent and objective under the substantial evidence
13
standard of review. (Vasquez, at p. 737.) To that end, we “review
the trial court’s determination in the light most favorable to the
respondent and presume the existence of every fact the trial court
could reasonably deduce from the evidence.” (People v. Jones
(2002) 103 Cal.App.4th 1139, 1143.)
4. Analysis
With respect to count 3 (Papazian), count 6 (Granadeno),
count 14 (Brotman), and count 15 (Angulo), substantial evidence
supports the factual finding that the false imprisonment was not
incidental to the robbery or burglary. Therefore, section 654 does
not bar separate punishment.
a. Papazian and Granadeno
As to Papazian and Granadeno, substantial evidence
presented at trial shows: Neither had resisted as Shahen trained
a firearm on them and searched their homes for loot. Thereafter,
he immobilized them by handcuffing them to household fixtures.
Papazian begged him not to leave her handcuffed to the stove,
explaining that no one would be home for a while to help her free
herself. Shahen provided Granadeno with water and bananas
before he left him handcuffed to the staircase—an indication
Shahen intended that Granadeno be restrained long after Shahen
left the area. Handcuffing Papazian and Granadeno in this
fashion created a new risk of harm, separate and apart from the
robbery or burglary, and demonstrated a divisible course of
conduct that was separately punishable.
People v. Foster (1988) 201 Cal.App.3d 20 is instructive
here. There, two men robbed a convenience store, one armed
with a knife and the other armed with a tire iron. “After they
obtained the money, they locked two employees and a bystander
in the store’s cooler [citation to record]. After [the perpetrators]
14
left, the victims escaped from the cooler through the soda pop
display case.” (Id. at p. 23.) The Court of Appeal rejected the
appellant’s contention “that the false imprisonment of the three
victims was merely incidental to the robbery, and that therefore
Penal Code section 654 require[d] that the execution of sentence
on each of the false imprisonment counts be stayed.” (Id. at p.
27.) The appellate court reasoned: “The imprisonment of the
victims occurred after the robbers had obtained all of the money,
and therefore was not necessary or incidental to committing the
robbery. Locking the victims in the store cooler was potentially
dangerous to their safety and health. It is analogous to a
needless or vicious assault committed after a robbery, which has
long been held separately punishable and distinguishable from
an assault which is merely incidental to robbery.” (Id. at pp. 27-
28.)
Shahen argues the analysis in Foster is inapplicable,
asserting that there the victims were gratuitously “imprisoned
under dangerous conditions” after the robbers had obtained the
money, while here “the false imprisonment was inexorably tied to
the robbery or burglary by neutralizing any potential resistance
by the victims and to facilitate escape without detection or
infliction of any traumatic physical injury or great bodily injury
or death.” (Italics omitted.) We disagree. Papazian and
Granadeno were not resisting when Shahen made the decision to
handcuff them to household fixtures. He had achieved their
submission by training a firearm on them during the entire
duration of the robbery (Papazian) or burglary (Granadeno).
Handcuffing them in this manner before he left, ensuring they
would remain restrained after he already obtained all he would
steal, created new and different risks of harm, both psychological
15
and physical, just like in Foster. Section 654 does not bar
multiple punishments for this divisible course of conduct.
Imposing and declining to stay punishment for these false
imprisonment counts ensures that Shahen is punished in a
manner commensurate with his culpability, consistent with the
purpose of section 654.
b. Brotman and Angulo
In his section 654 analysis in his appellate briefing, Shahen
describes the false imprisonment of Brotman and Angulo as
follows: They “had the handcuffs removed and were told to wait
before calling for law enforcement.” His analysis omits key facts.
Evidence presented at trial demonstrates that Shahen
threatened to wait outside and shoot Brotman and Angulo
through the window if he saw them stand up or call the police.
He also threatened to return to their home or confront them out
on the street and shoot them if he discovered later that they did
not wait 15 minutes before getting up and calling the police.
Based on these facts, we have no cause to disturb the trial
court’s imposition of multiple punishments for the robberies and
false imprisonments. The additional terror Shahen inflicted on
Brotman and Angulo after he obtained their money, by
threatening to lie in wait and shoot them and by emphasizing he
knew what they looked like and where they lived, was gratuitous
and not incidental to the robberies (or necessary for his escape to
a place of temporary safety). (See In re Jesse F. (1982) 137
Cal.App.3d 164, 171 [although the “crime of robbery is not
actually complete until the robber ‘has won his way to a place of
temporary safety,’ ” this “cannot mean every act a robber commits
before making his getaway is incidental to the robbery”].) The
16
trial court did not violate section 654 in imposing separate
punishment for this divisible course of criminal conduct.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
M. KIM, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
WEINGART, J.
17
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.