In re M.K. CA5

CourtListener 10804505CalctappMar 5, 2026

Full text

Filed 3/5/26 In re M.K. CA5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

In re M.K., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law.

MERCED COUNTY HUMAN SERVICES F090769
AGENCY,
(Super. Ct. No. 24JP-00090-B)
Plaintiff and Respondent,

v. OPINION
J.M.,

Defendant and Appellant.

THE COURT*
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Merced County. Mark V.
Bacciarini, Judge.
Susan M. O’Brien, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, and J.M., in pro
per, for Defendant and Appellant.
No appearance for Plaintiff and Respondent.
-ooOoo-

* Before Detjen, Acting P. J., Meehan, J. and De Santos, J.
J.M. (father) is the biological father of now one-and-a-half-year-old M.K.
(daughter). Father appeals from the juvenile court’s order denying a Welfare and
Institutions Code section 3881 petition filed by maternal grandmother requesting that
daughter be placed with another relative. After reviewing the juvenile court record,
father’s court-appointed counsel informed this court she could find no arguable issues to
raise on father’s behalf. This court granted father leave to personally file a letter brief
setting forth a good cause showing that an arguable issue of reversible error exists. (In re
Phoenix H. (2009) 47 Cal.4th 835, 844 (Phoenix H.).)
Father filed a letter brief asking us to review whether the juvenile court erred in
denying him reunification services and whether he was afforded a meaningful
opportunity to testify and participate in the proceedings. We conclude father failed to
address the ruling made at the November 4, 2025, hearing or set forth good cause
showing any arguable issue of reversible error arose at the hearing. (Phoenix H., supra,
47 Cal.4th at p. 844.) Consequently, we dismiss the appeal.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Daughter came to the attention of Merced County Human Services Agency
(agency) in August 2024, when the agency received a report that she and her mother,
An.K., were transported to the hospital after daughter was born in the living room of
maternal grandmother’s home. Daughter’s urine tested positive for amphetamines, and
she was admitted to the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) as a precaution due to signs
of respiratory distress and fluctuating body temperature. Mother reported she and father
lived with grandmother and mother’s four-year-old daughter A.K. Maternal grandmother
(grandmother) was appointed A.K.’s legal guardian in 2020.
Numerous people, including maternal relatives, told the investigating social
worker that mother and father had mental health and substance abuse issues and regularly

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.

2.
engaged in domestic violence in grandmother’s home. A.K. reported she was afraid
around mother and that mother yelled at her, father, and grandmother, and mother hit and
kicked father.
Grandmother was said to have mental health problems and to have abused
prescription drugs, namely pain medication. While grandmother denied mother’s mental
health behaviors, that mother used drugs, and that father lived in grandmother’s home,
the social worker reviewed 13 police reports generated between 2021 and 2024 in which
grandmother reported daughter’s ongoing substance abuse, mental health problems, and
violence in her home. The reports demonstrated grandmother was aware of mother’s
drug use and violent behaviors, and that grandmother allowed mother and father to live in
the home despite knowing they engaged in domestic violence and used drugs together.
The agency did not know father’s whereabouts and efforts to locate him before the
detention hearing were unsuccessful. Daughter, who was detained by the Merced County
Sheriff’s Department, remained in the NICU.
Based on the foregoing, the agency filed a petition alleging daughter came within
the provisions of section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) (failure to protect) and (g) (no provision
for support).2 Father did not appear at the detention hearing and attempts to reach him by
phone were unsuccessful. The juvenile court found a prima facie case had been made
and ordered daughter removed from parental custody. A jurisdiction and disposition
hearing was set for September 12, 2024.
The Jurisdiction Hearing
In a report for the jurisdiction hearing, father, who was located after the detention
hearing, was described as “unhoused,” but he had a telephone number. A social worker
interviewed him by phone on September 3, 2024, and reviewed the petition’s allegations

2 A.K. was also detained and a subject of the petition, but she is not the subject of
this appeal as appellant is not her father.

3.
with him. Father told the social worker he was daughter’s father, but he was not present
at birth. Father admitted he smoked marijuana and drank alcohol on weekends, but he
denied that he or mother used methamphetamine. Father denied domestic violence or
that mother physically assaulted him, and he denied that he or mother had mental health
issues.
Father was asked twice to complete a random drug screen, but he did not comply.
Although the agency scheduled weekly one-hour visits for father, he missed the first visit
because he was not notified of it, and he missed a visit the following week even though
he had been notified of it and said he would attend.
Neither parent appeared at the jurisdiction hearing. The juvenile court found the
petition’s section 300, subdivision (b)(1) allegations true and dismissed the section 300,
subdivision (g) allegation based on the agency’s representation that it had been in
telephone contact with father. The disposition hearing was set for October 10, 2024.
The Disposition Hearing
Daughter and A.K. were placed together in a maternal relative’s home on
October 4, 2024. In a report for the disposition hearing, the agency recommended that
neither parent receive reunification services – mother because her whereabouts were
unknown and father because, as an alleged father, he was not entitled to them. Father’s
visits were removed from the calendar because he missed two consecutive visits, but they
were placed back on the calendar effective September 24, 2024. While father attended
that visit, he missed subsequent visits as a no call/no show on October 1 and 8, 2024, and
visits were removed from the calendar.
Father appeared at the October 10, 2024, disposition hearing and an attorney was
appointed to represent him. The hearing was continued to October 17, 2024, so the
disposition report could be filed, and father and his attorney appeared at that hearing.
Father’s attorney stated that father wished to elevate his status, and he wanted mother,

4.
who was not present at the hearing, to testify on that issue. The court ordered a DNA test
for father at his attorney’s request.
The disposition hearing was continued multiple times. At a hearing held on
December 16. 2024, father’s attorney stated that father had been determined to be
daughter’s biological father, and the attorney was waiting for the agency to elevate father
to presumed father status.3 County counsel responded that the agency did not intend to
elevate father because he “has not really been showing up for the minor,” as he was not
attending visits or drug testing. Based on that representation, father’s attorney asked for
time to talk to father about the agency’s position and whether to contest his status or file
parentage paperwork. The juvenile court continued the disposition hearing to January 21,
2025, with a readiness conference set for January 16, 2025.4
At the January 16 readiness hearing, father’s attorney again asked whether the
agency would elevate father to presumed father status. County counsel responded that
father had “not been showing up.” He was incarcerated locally, and a request had been
submitted for his presence at the disposition hearing. County counsel stated it was
“almost impossible to assess him for elevation due to his not complying and not reaching
out to the [a]gency.” Father’s attorney stated that as an alleged father, he did not have
standing to contest disposition, but she needed to speak with him and she would file a
“JV-504” on his behalf.
Father and his attorney were present at the January 21 disposition hearing.
Father’s attorney stated she discussed the case with father, and he decided not to exercise
his right to a contested hearing on the agency’s recommendation concerning his status
and instead would submit. The juvenile court adopted the agency’s recommendations

3 The agency subsequently submitted a lab test that stated father could not be
excluded as daughter’s biological father and the probability of paternity was 99.99%.
Father is not listed on daughter’s birth certificate.
4 Subsequent references to dates are to dates in the year 2025.

5.
and declared daughter a dependent, bypassed father for reunification services, and
ordered that mother not receive reunification services as her whereabouts were unknown,
but services would be provided if mother’s whereabouts became known within six
months. The juvenile court denied grandmother’s request to be appointed daughter’s de
facto parent. The court set a six-month review hearing for July 10.
The Status Review Hearings
In a report prepared for the six-month status review hearing, the agency
recommended the setting of a section 366.26 hearing. Mother’s whereabouts remained
unknown; therefore, she had effectively been bypassed for services. According to an
eligibility database for “CalSAWS,” father was homeless and living in a tent. Father had
visited daughter only once since her detention, on September 24, 2024.
Father appeared for the first two settings of the review hearing, but he did not
appear at the continued July 31 or August 19 hearings. At the August 19 hearing, the
court terminated mother’s reunification services and selected December 4 for a section
366.26 hearing. Although the court stated it would “put it on the record that in order to
preserve appellate rights, a notice of intent to file a writ petition must be filed within
seven days of today’s date,” the record does not show that the court directed the clerk to
mail copies of the advisement to the absent parents or contain proofs of service that
advisements were mailed to them. The agency’s report for the section 366.26 hearing,
however, states: “Writ rights were mailed to the mother [name], father [name] on
08/19/25.”
The Section 387 Petition
On September 12, daughter and A.K. were removed from the maternal relative’s
home after the agency received a report the relative’s 10-year-old son sexually assaulted
a minor neighbor. The son denied the allegations and A.K. denied witnessing
inappropriate touching. In addition, the maternal relative was alleged to have engaged in
domestic violence with her partner which the children witnessed. After social workers

6.
advised the maternal relative that the children would be removed from her home,
grandmother arrived at the back door and began recording on her cell phone. The social
workers believed grandmother’s arrival and entry into the home indicated she often came
to the house without agency approval.
The agency filed a section 387 petition seeking a more restrictive placement for
the girls on September 17. Father was present at the detention hearing held the following
day. Although his attorney recognized father did not have standing to object to
placement, she joined in a request for continuance and asked that father be present so he
could have input into the change of circumstances. County counsel did not object to
father’s presence at the hearing.
Father was present at the September 23 hearing on the section 387 petition. Father
did not agree with daughter being removed from the maternal relative. After receiving
testimony from the maternal relative and argument by counsel, the juvenile court found
the maternal relative’s testimony “totally unbelievable” and that the children were in a
dangerous situation where grandmother had “unfettered access to them.” While the court
was announcing its findings, a person announced grandmother was recording the
proceedings on her phone. The court admonished grandmother and adjourned the
hearing.
The JV-180 Petition
On October 31, grandmother filed a petition requesting that daughter be placed
with her step-aunt V.B. pursuant to the section 361.3 relative placement preference.
Grandmother asserted the step-aunt had requested placement, grandmother wanted
daughter placed with her, daughter was bonded with the step-aunt, and it was in
daughter’s best interest to be placed with family.
The reporter’s transcript of a November 4 hearing in A.K.’s case shows the
juvenile court noted at the outset of the hearing that a document was filed the day before
requesting the court to order the agency “to do certain things,” which the court denied.

7.
The court stated that daughter had nothing to do with A.K.’s case and maternal
grandmother did not have standing to raise issues regarding daughter. County counsel
asked if the “two 388’s” were denied, and the court responded, “It’s denied.” The court’s
minutes of that hearing reflect that the juvenile court considered the JV-180 request and
ordered the request denied for the reasons stated on the record. The court denied
maternal grandmother’s counsel’s oral request to argue the court’s ruling as untimely.
The court confirmed the previous orders denying the JV-180 and stated maternal
grandmother previously had been advised that she was not a party to daughter’s matter.
Father was not present at this hearing.
On November 7, father filed a notice of intent to file a writ petition which stated
he was challenging a November 4 juvenile court order setting a hearing pursuant to
section 366.26. On December 3, this court issued an order which explained the notice of
intent was untimely to initiate writ proceedings because the dependency court previously
set a section 366.26 hearing as to daughter on August 19, 2025. On our own motion, we
deemed the notice of intent to be a notice of appeal.
DISCUSSION
This court presumes a trial court judgment or order is correct. (Denham v.
Superior Court (1970) 2 Cal.3d 557, 564.) Father’s burden as the appellant is to raise
claims of reversible error or other defect and present argument and authority on each
point made. If an appellant fails to do so, we may dismiss the appeal. (In re Sade C.
(1996) 13 Cal.4th 952, 994 (Sade C.).)
Father does not raise any issues concerning the order made at the hearing from
which he appealed, namely the November 4 hearing where the juvenile court denied
grandmother’s request to have another relative assessed for placement of daughter. As
such, he has not presented any cognizable appellate issue. Instead, father raises
arguments concerning prior hearings in his letter brief. Specifically, father asks us to
review whether: (1) the juvenile court erred in not ordering reunification services for him

8.
because he was elevated to presumed father status prior to disposition; and (2) he was
afforded meaningful opportunity to testify and participate in the proceedings prior to
rulings affecting his parental rights.
As for the denial of reunification services, that order, which father failed to appeal
from, was made at the January dispositional hearing. The order entered at the
dispositional hearing is the “final judgment” and is immediately appealable, along with
the jurisdictional order. (§ 395, subd. (a)(1); In re Sheila B. (1993) 19 Cal.App.4th 187,
196.) Subsequent orders are appealable as orders after judgment (§ 395, subd. (a)(1)),
except for the order terminating reunification services and setting a section 366.26
hearing which must be reviewed by writ. (§ 366.26, subd. (l)(1); In re Merrick V. (2004)
122 Cal.App.4th 235, 247.)
“An appeal from the most recent order entered in a dependency matter may not
challenge prior orders, for which the statutory time for filing an appeal has passed.” (In
re Elizabeth M. (1991) 232 Cal.App.3d 553, 563, abrogated in part on other grounds in In
re Tabitha W. (2006) 143 Cal.App.4th 811, 817.) “If an order is appealable . . . and no
timely appeal is taken therefrom, the issues determined by the order are res judicata.” (In
re Matthew C. (1993) 6 Cal.4th 386, 393.) Because the disposition order denying father
reunification services was an appealable order and father failed to appeal the order, which
is now final, he cannot challenge the denial of his services in this appeal.
Moreover, contrary to father’s assertion, he was never elevated to presumed father
status. Rather, father elected to remain an alleged father when he decided not to
challenge the agency’s decision not to deem him a presumed father. The juvenile court
does not have a sua sponte duty to establish a factual basis for supporting a finding of
presumed father status and then make such a finding. (In re O.S. (2002) 102 Cal.App.4th
1402, 1410.) Rather, the proponent of the presumption has the burden of establishing the
foundational facts by a preponderance of the evidence and asking the court to make such
a determination. (Ibid.) Here, the record shows that father affirmatively chose to forego

9.
a challenge to his status as an alleged father and did not argue he should receive services
as a biological father because daughter would benefit if he received reunification
services. Therefore, the juvenile court did not err in not offering him reunification
services. (In re B.C. (2012) 205 Cal.App.4th 1306, 1311, fn. 3 [only a presumed father is
entitled to receive reunification services under section 361.5; “a biological father may be
offered reunification services if the juvenile court determines such service will benefit the
child”].)
Father also asks us to determine whether he was afforded a meaningful
opportunity to testify and participate in the proceedings. Father, however, fails to provide
any specific facts or references to the record demonstrating that he was denied the
opportunity to participate in the proceedings. Arguments in a brief that are not supported
by specific facts or citations to the record cannot raise arguable issues on appeal. (See In
re S.C. (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 396, 408; Annod Corp. v. Hamilton & Samuels (2002)
100 Cal.App.4th 1286, 1301.) Without specific reference to the record in this case to
support his assertions, this court cannot evaluate whether the facts are as father represents
or whether they support his claims of error.
In a dependency case, unlike in a criminal case, we have no duty to conduct an
independent review of the record. (Phoenix H., supra, 47 Cal.4th at pp. 844–846.)
Nonetheless, in an abundance of caution, we independently reviewed the record to
confirm there is no good cause that an arguable issue exists. On the record before us, we
find nothing to indicate an arguable issue exists.
DISPOSITION
Because no claim of error or other defect has been raised in this matter, the appeal
is dismissed. (Phoenix H., supra, 47 Cal.4th 835; Sade C., supra, 13 Cal.4th 952.)

10.

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.