CourtListener 10798885•Weigold v. Fine CA4/3
Full text
Filed 2/23/26 Weigold v. Fine CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
MICHAEL WEIGOLD,
Plaintiff and Appellant, G064731
v. (Super. Ct. No. 30-2014-
00762079)
VELMA FINE, et al.,
OPINION
Defendants and Respondents.
Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Aaron W. Heisler, Judge. Affirmed.
Everett L. Skillman, for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Musick, Peeler & Garrett, and Robert A. Bailey for Defendants
and Respondents Velma Fine, Wanda Waltrip, and David Yoshida.
Catanese & Wells, and Bradley W. Gould for Thomas Randolph
Catanese and Catanese & Wells.
The parties are before this court a second time. In the prior
appeal, we reversed a judgment invalidating a trust because of undue
influence. Although the trust beneficiaries who purported to exert undue
influence included William Rosenstein and appellant Michael Weigold, we
reversed the judgment as to Weigold only. We remanded for a merits trial as
to Weigold only.
On remand, the claims against Weigold were dismissed with
prejudice. Weigold, as a purported trust beneficiary, then filed a petition to
recover certain properties he believed were trust assets. Following a bench
trial, the trial court denied the petition on the ground that Weigold lacked
standing because the prior appeal left intact the finding the trust was invalid
because of Rosenstein’s undue influence. Weigold appealed.
On appeal, Weigold contends the prior appeal automatically
reinstated the trust and thus he has standing to assert the claims in his
petition. We disagree. The prior appeal did not address the finding against
Rosenstein. Nor is the finding against Rosenstein inextricably intertwined
with the finding against Weigold, such that the reversal of one finding
necessitated the reversal of the other. Thus, the prior appeal did not
automatically reinstate the trust and Weigold lacks standing. Accordingly,
we affirm.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Loretta J. Nisewander (the decedent) died on March 23, 2014. On
December 17, 2014, Rosenstein filed a petition for order confirming
ownership of property (Rosenstein’s petition). Rosenstein’s petition sought an
order confirming that monies held in five bank accounts were assets of the
Loretta J. Nisewander Trust (the Nisewander Trust), despite being titled in
the decedent’s name at the time of her death. Rosenstein alleged the trust
2
document identified the bank accounts as trust assets, and stated he believed
the decedent’s failure to transfer title of the bank accounts to the Nisewander
Trust was unintentional. The petition alleged that Rosenstein was the
successor trustee and beneficiary of the Nisewander Trust, and that Weigold
was the only other beneficiary.
On April 10, 2015, respondents Velma Fine, Wanda Waltrip, and
Joyce Jozsa (the Fine parties), as lineal blood decedents of Nisewander, filed
their own petition (Fine Petition). The Fine parties were represented by
respondents Thomas Randolph Catanese and David Y. Yoshida of Catanese
& Wells. The Fine Petition sought an order declaring the Nisewander Trust
invalid because, among other reasons, it was the product of undue influence
by Rosenstein and Weigold. It attached a copy of the “purported written
trust.”
Following a bench trial on the Fine Petition, on January 16, 2018,
the trial court issued a judgment which stated, among other things, that (1)
Rosenstein and Weigold were disqualified as beneficiaries of the Nisewander
Trust due to their undue influence, and (2) Rosenstein’s petition was moot
(2018 judgment). The trial court imposed a constructive trust over all of
decedent’s assets, appointed Fine as the trustee of the constructive trust, and
directed Fine to commence probate proceedings within 30 days of entry of
judgment.
The trial court’s basis for invalidating the Nisewander Trust and
a related will was the presumption of undue influence under Probate Code
1
section 21380. Section 21380 provides in relevant part: “(a) A provision of an
1
All further statutory references are to the Probate Code.
3
instrument making a donative transfer to any of the following persons is
presumed to be the product of fraud or undue influence: [¶] (1) The person
who drafted the instrument. [¶] (2) A person who transcribed the instrument
or caused it to be transcribed and who was in a fiduciary relationship with
the transferor when the instrument was transcribed.” The trial court found
that “Rosenstein and Weigold transcribed the Will and the Trust or caused
the Will and the Trust in this case to be transcribed[;] therefore the donative
2
transfers to both of them are presumed to be a result of . . . undue influence.”
On February 9, Rosenstein and Weigold appealed the 2018
judgment invalidating the Nisewander Trust. On April 5, the trial court
awarded attorney fees and costs to the Fine parties against Rosenstein and
Weigold pursuant to section 21380, subdivision (d). That statute provides, “If
a beneficiary is unsuccessful in rebutting the presumption [of fraud or undue
influence], the beneficiary shall bear all costs of the proceedings, including
reasonable attorney fees.” (§ 21380, subd. (d).) On May 3, Rosenstein and
Weigold also appealed the fees and costs order.
While the appeals on the 2018 judgment and fee award were
pending, on January 24, 2019, Rosenstein entered into a global settlement
with the Fine parties, in which he agreed to dismiss his appeals from the
2018 judgment and the fee award, and the Fine parties would dismissed
Rosenstein from the case; which they did on May 6.
On April 10, 2019, Fine, as trustee of the constructive trust, filed
a petition seeking authority to sell a piece of real property, which the trial
court ultimately approved, over Weigold’s objection. The court also awarded
2
Weigold later waived any claims as a beneficiary under the will.
4
fees and costs in connection with that petition against Weigold. Weigold
appealed on May 3.
On December 20, this court issued its opinion on Weigold’s appeal
(2019 opinion). (Fine v. Weigold (Dec. 20, 2019, Nos. G055974, G056279)
[nonpub. opn.]) After noting it had granted Rosenstein’s request to dismiss
his appeal, the panel agreed with Weigold’s contention that there was
“insufficient evidence to show he had drafted or transcribed the trust or
caused either to be transcribed.” (Ibid.) The panel “reverse[d] the [2018]
judgment as to Weigold and remand[ed] for retrial on the merits of the Fine .
. . petition.” The panel also reversed the fee award “as to Weigold.” (Ibid.)
Similarly, the disposition reversed the judgment and postjudgment fee order
as to Weigold and remanded the matter for retrial on the merits of the
amended petition “as to Weigold.” (Ibid.)
Following issuance of the remittitur, on March 22, 2021, the Fine
parties dismissed the remanded claims against Weigold.
On April 2, Weigold filed an amended verified petition (Weigold
petition) for instructions seeking, among other things, to recover assets he
believed belonged to the Nisewander Trust, including the proceeds from the
real property sale and the monies in the five bank accounts. The sole legal
basis for disgorgement was Weigold’s contention that because the 2019
opinion reversed the 2018 judgment, “(a) the Trust and the Will are
reinstated automatically, (b) the constructive trust no longer exists, and (c)
[the Fine parties do not] have standing any longer to prosecute probate
5
proceedings concerning Decedent’s estate.” The Fine parties and their
3
attorneys were named as respondents.
A bench trial on the Weigold’s petition was conducted over
several days, beginning on August 8, 2023. After the close of evidence, the
trial court sought supplemental briefing on the impact of the 2019 opinion on
Weigold’s petition. Following supplemental briefing, on August 16, 2024, the
court entered judgment against Weigold, denying this petition with prejudice.
In its final statement of decision, the trial court concluded
Weigold lacked standing to bring the claims alleged in his petition because
the 2019 opinion left undisturbed the findings and conclusion “that the entire
Nisewander Trust was invalid as the product of Rosenstein’s undue
influence.” Alternatively, even if Weigold had standing, the court concluded
he failed to present persuasive evidence that the bank accounts or real
property were trust assets.
On October 2, Weigold timely noticed an appeal from the August
16, 2024 judgment.
DISCUSSION
The trial court denied Weigold’s petition based on its
interpretation of the 2019 opinion. “Whether the trial court correctly
interpreted our opinion is an issue of law subject to de novo review.” (Ayyad
v. Sprint Spectrum, L.P. (2012) 210 Cal.App.4th 851, 859; see also In re
Groundwater Cases (2007) 154 Cal.App.4th 659, 674 [“The interpretation of
the language of a judicial opinion is a legal determination, and it is therefore
subject to de novo review”].)
3
Weigold later dismissed Joyza without prejudice. In his
appellate briefing, he explained he dismissed Joyza because she had not
received any trust assets.
6
Weigold contends the 2019 opinion automatically reinstated the
Nisewander Trust because, pursuant to Weisenburg v. Cragholm (1971) 5
Cal.3d 892, 896 (Weisenburg), the “legal effect of this Court of Appeal’s
reversal of the 2018 judgment as to Weigold is that it treated the judgment
‘as if it had never been entered.’” (We disagree. Weigold misapprehends the
holding in Weisenburg because he failed to provide the full quote. The full
quote is: “When that judgment was unqualifiedly reversed, however, the
effect was the same as if it had never been entered, except that on a retrial
the opinion of the Court of Appeal must be followed as far as applicable.” (Id.
at p. at 896.) Here, the 2019 opinion did not unqualifiedly reverse the 2018
judgment. Rather, the 2018 judgment was reversed as to Weigold only. Thus,
under Weisenburg, the 2018 judgment against Weigold only is treated as if it
had never been entered.
The legal principle that a reversal of a judgment is limited to the
specific party noticing the appeal or the claims raised on appeal is well-
established. “As a general rule, where only one of several parties appeals
from a judgment, the appeal includes only that portion of the judgment
adverse to the appealing party’s interest, and the judgment is considered
final as to the nonappealing parties.” (Estate of McDill (1975) 14 Cal.3d 831,
840.) Thus, the judgment against Rosenstein and the findings and
conclusions that support that judgment are final and binding in subsequent
litigation. Accordingly, the Nisewander Trust is invalid due to Rosenstein’s
misconduct.
Weigold, however, contends the res judicata effect of the
judgment against Rosenstein cannot be applied against him. “Res judicata”
has frequently been used as an umbrella term encompassing both claim
preclusion and issue preclusion. (DKN Holdings LLC v. Faerber (2015) 61
7
Cal.4th 813, 824.) As relevant here, issue preclusion “prohibits the
relitigation of issues argued and decided in a previous case, even if the second
suit raises different causes of action.” (Ibid.) “[I]ssue preclusion applies (1)
after final adjudication (2) of an identical issue (3) actually litigated and
necessarily decided in the first suit and (4) asserted against one who was a
party in the first suit or one in privity with that party.” (Id. at p. 825.) Here,
the issue that was previously litigated is the validity of the Nisewander
Trust. This issue was actually litigated and necessarily decided in the 2018
judgment, which finally and conclusively adjudicated that the Nisewander
Trust was invalid due to Rosenstein’s undue influence. Weigold was a party
to the prior proceeding resulting in the 2018 judgment. He was on actual
notice of the issue, which was addressed extensively in the written statement
of decision, and he was or should have been aware that a finding that
Rosenstein unduly influenced the decedent into executing the Nisewander
Trust would be fatal to his status as a beneficiary under the trust. In sum,
the preclusive effect of the 2018 judgment was applicable to Weigold’s claims
in the instant proceeding.
Weigold also raises several related arguments which we briefly
address. He contends Rosenstein had no “authority to contract away
Weigold’s rights or unilaterally moot Weigold’s appeal” by obtaining appellate
dismissals. In entering the global settlement, however, Rosenstein only
bound himself, not Weigold, to the terms of the agreement. Although the
legal effect of Rosenstein’s dismissals effectively mooted Weigold’s rights as a
trust beneficiary, Weigold has not explained why Rosenstein would be
prohibited from entering into a global settlement involving only the 2018
judgment and fee award against himself.
8
Weigold suggests the insufficiency of the evidence of undue
influence as to himself also applied to Rosenstein. However, even if factually
inaccurate, an incorrect final judgment still has preclusive effect. (See Busick
v. Workmen’s Comp. Appeals Bd. (1972) 7 Cal.3d 967, 975, fn. omitted [“‘(a)n
erroneous judgment is as conclusive as a correct one’”].)
Weigold argues the Fine parties’ dismissal of Rosenstein’s
petition without prejudice following the 2019 opinion left “no adjudication
setting aside the Trust of Will.” This argument is based on the mistaken
premise that the 2019 opinion reversed the entire 2018 judgment. As
discussed above, that is not the case. The 2019 opinion and the subsequent
dismissal of the Fine Petition resulted in the legal conclusion that Weigold
was not guilty of exerting undue influence. However, Weigold’s factual
innocence does not affect the legal conclusion that the Nisewander Trust is
invalid as a result of Rosensten’s misconduct. As an analogous example, if
Rosenstein had created a document falsely representing that Weigold was a
member of the California bar in good standing without Weigold’s knowledge
or consent, Weigold’s factual innocence in creating the forgery would not
change the fact the identification was false and that Weigold could not
practice law in California. Similarly, even if Weigold did not exercise undue
influence over the decedent, that does not change the fact that Rosenstein did
exercise undue influence over the decedent resulting in the Nisewander
Trust.
Finally, we exercise our discretion to address a related argument
raised below and referenced in the appellate opening brief’s statement of
facts. Weigold contends that if the dismissal of Rosenstein’s appeals resulted
in the invalidity of the Nisewander trust and mooted his claims, why did the
appellate panel address his claims or remand for a new trial? Weigold argues
9
this fact suggests the 2019 opinion impliedly found the Nisewander Trust
was valid or at least not invalid. As an initial matter, the 2019 opinion did
not conclude the Nisewander Trust was valid. Otherwise, there would be no
need for a retrial on the merits of a petition which placed the validity of the
Nisewander Trust at issue. More importantly, Weigold’s appeals are not moot
merely because Rosenstein’s misconduct resulted in the invalidation of the
trust. The fee award against Weigold was based on his inability to overcome
the statutory presumption of undue influence. The 2019 opinion established
that Weigold was able to overcome the presumption, and thus no fee award
could be assessed against him.
In sum, Weigold has not shown he has standing to bring the
claims alleged in his petition. The trial court properly denied his petition
with prejudice. Because we have affirmed the court’s ruling for lack of
standing, we need not address the alternative grounds for the court’s August
16, 2024 judgment.
DISPOSITION
The August 16, 2024 judgment is affirmed. Respondents are
entitled to their costs on appeal.
DELANEY, J.
WE CONCUR:
MOTOIKE, ACTING P. J.
MOORE, J.
10
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.