CourtListener 10796435•In re Lynex
Full text
Filed 1/27/26; Certified for Publication 2/19/26 (order attached)
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re B344569
TOMMIE LAWSON LYNEX, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. PA034126)
on Habeas Corpus.
ORIGINAL PROCEEDING; petition for writ of habeas
corpus, Kevin S. Rosenberg, Judge. Petition construed as a
petition for writ of mandate. Petition granted.
Tommie Lawson Lynex, in pro. per., for Petitioner.
David Lee, Court Counsel, for Respondent Superior Court
of Los Angeles County.
Nathan J. Hochman, District Attorney of Los Angeles
County, Cassandra Thorp and Matthew Brown, Deputy District
Attorneys, for Real Party in Interest the People of the State of
California.
____________________________
In 2000, a jury convicted petitioner Tommie Lawson Lynex
of first degree murder and found true a firearm enhancement
allegation under Penal Code section 12022.53, subdivision (d). 1
The trial court sentenced Lynex to 50 years to life in prison.
Approximately 20 years later, the Legislature enacted the
California Racial Justice Act of 2020 (Racial Justice Act or the
Act; Stats. 2020, ch. 317), which authorizes prisoners to seek
habeas relief on the ground the state sought or obtained their
convictions or sentences based on race, ethnicity, or national
origin. (Standards of Review & Applicable Law, part B, post
[describing the Act].) In 2025, Lynex, who claims to be an
African American man, 2 filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus
under the Racial Justice Act. Lynex attached to his petition a
chart from the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office
(District Attorney) that discloses the racial and ethnic makeup of
individuals who were charged with murder and a firearm
enhancement under section 12022.53, subdivision (d) in 1998,
1999, and 2000. Among other things, the chart shows that the
District Attorney charged far more Black defendants with
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
When Lynex perpetrated the murder in 1999, section 12022.53,
subdivision (d) provided in pertinent part: “[A]ny person who is
convicted of a felony specified in subdivision (a), [e.g.,
murder,] . . . and who in the commission of that felony
intentionally and personally discharged a firearm and
proximately caused . . . death, to any person other than an
accomplice, shall be punished by a term of imprisonment of
25 years to life in the state prison, which shall be imposed in
addition and consecutive to the punishment prescribed for that
felony.” (See Stats. 1998, ch. 936, § 19.5.)
2 (See fn. 5, post.)
2
murder and the firearm allegation than White defendants during
that three-year period. Lynex sought appointment of counsel in
his petition. The trial court denied Lynex’s petition in its
entirety.
We issue a writ of mandate directing the trial court to
vacate its order denying Lynex’s petition. First, we conclude the
trial court erred in ruling that Lynex had to make a prima facie
showing of entitlement to relief to secure appointment of counsel.
Rather, to obtain counsel, the Racial Justice Act requires habeas
petitioners to plead a plausible allegation of a violation of the Act.
Second, the trial court’s denial of Lynex’s request for counsel was
erroneous because regardless of whether he satisfied the minimal
pleading standard governing that request, the court was unaware
of its discretion to grant him leave to amend the petition to plead
a plausible allegation of a Racial Justice Act violation. Lastly,
the trial court erred in invoking the prohibition on successive
habeas petitions because Lynex was not required to address
procedural bars to relief at this initial stage of the proceedings.
Upon issuance of our writ of mandate, the trial court shall assess
whether Lynex’s petition states a plausible claim under the
Racial Justice Act, and, if it finds Lynex failed to satisfy that
standard, then the court shall consider whether to exercise its
discretion to permit him to file an amended pleading.
3
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND 3
We summarize only those facts pertinent to our disposition
of this writ proceeding.
Lynex fatally shot another man in 1999. In 2000, a jury
convicted Lynex of first degree murder and found true a firearm
enhancement allegation under section 12022.53, subdivision (d).
The trial court sentenced Lynex to a prison term of 50 years to
life. This court affirmed the judgment in an unpublished opinion.
(People v. Lynex (July 17, 2001, B145639) [nonpub. opn.] at pp. 1,
5.) 4
In January 2024, Lynex filed a petition in the trial court for
writ of habeas corpus under the Racial Justice Act. Lynex
claimed, inter alia, the police failed to preserve the victim’s
clothing and the firearm enhancement violated the Racial Justice
Act’s prohibition on imposition of a sentence based on a
defendant’s race. The trial court denied the petition in
April 2024.
3 We derive our Procedural Background in part from
admissions in the parties’ briefing, undisputed aspects of the trial
court’s ruling, and assertions made by the District Attorney that
Lynex does not dispute in his reply brief. (See Association for
Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs v. County of Los Angeles (2023)
94 Cal.App.5th 764, 772, fn. 2, 773–774 (Association for
Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs) [employing this approach]; see also
Reygoza v. Superior Court (1991) 230 Cal.App.3d 514, 519 & fn. 4
[criminal case in which the Court of Appeal assumed that an
assertion made by the respondent was correct because the
“defendant did not dispute [the] respondent’s claim in his
reply”].)
4 We, sua sponte, take judicial notice of the prior opinion
affirming the judgment. (Evid. Code, §§ 452, subd. (d), 459.)
4
On January 2, 2025, Lynex filed another petition for writ of
habeas corpus under the Racial Justice Act in the trial court.
Lynex requested appointment of counsel to prepare a discovery
motion under the Act, and raised three claims: (1) the police
improperly disposed of the victim’s property; (2) the police’s
identification procedures were unduly prejudicial and
impermissibly suggestive; and (3) there exist racial disparities in
charging and sentencing criminal defendants. 5
Included with Lynex’s petition is a chart he obtained from
the District Attorney that shows filings and declinations
regarding charges for murder with a firearm allegation under
section 12022.53, subdivision (d) for the years 1998, 1999, and
2000. 6 We reproduce that chart below:
5 In a declaration Lynex filed in support of the petition, he
identified himself as an African American man.
6 Although the chart’s heading indicates it covers
“CALENDAR YEARS 1997 - 2000,” the District Attorney
represents the chart shows “no filings from 1997” because
section 12022.53 did not become effective until January 1, 1998.
5
On February 13, 2025, the trial court denied Lynex’s
habeas petition. 7 The court found Lynex’s Racial Justice Act
claims were successive and thus procedurally barred. The court
also found Lynex failed to allege facts showing that the police’s
destruction of the victim’s property “was tinged by explicit or
implicit racial animus,” or that racial animus or bias played any
role in the police’s identification procedures. Additionally, the
court ruled Lynex failed to “make any specific allegation of racial
disparity in the prosecution’s seeking or obtaining convictions”
“or racial disparity in sentencing.” Lastly, the court stated:
“Prior to the court appointing counsel and giving leave for counsel
to amend the petition, [Lynex] must first allege facts that would
7 The trial judge who denied this habeas petition is not the
judicial officer who sentenced Lynex.
6
establish a violation of section 745, subdivision (a) to make a
prima facie showing that he is entitled to relief. (§ 1473,
subd. (e).) Because [Lynex] has failed to make a prima facie
showing establishing a violation of section 745, subdivision (a),
[Lynex] is not entitled to appointment of counsel under
section 1473, subdivision (e).” 8
On March 10, 2025, Lynex filed in this court a petition for
writ of habeas corpus in pro. per. On June 4, 2025, the court
clerk directed the People to file an opposition to the petition by
July 2, 2025. The People did not respond to the clerk’s
correspondence.
On August 22, 2025, this court construed Lynex’s pending
habeas petition as a petition for writ of mandate and ordered the
trial court either to (1) vacate its February 13, 2025 order
“denying [Lynex’s] request for appointment of counsel in
preparation for filing a Racial Justice Act petition” and issue a
new order appointing counsel for Lynex, or (2) show cause why
this court should not issue a writ of mandate directing the trial
court to do so. The trial court’s counsel thereafter submitted a
minute order from the trial court dated September 5, 2025. In
that minute order, the trial court stated: “The court respectfully
declines to vacate its February 13, 2025 order denying . . .
Lynex’s request for appointment of counsel to assist in the
preparation of filing a Racial Justice Act petition. As noted in the
8 As we explain in our Standards of Review & Applicable
Law, parts B.1–B.2, post, section 745, subdivision (a) sets forth
four categories of conduct that establish a violation of the Racial
Justice Act, and section 1473, subdivision (e) governs, inter alia,
the appointment of counsel for habeas petitioners raising Racial
Justice Act claims.
7
court’s February 13, 2025 order, [Lynex’s] claims are procedurally
barred and he failed to make a prima case [sic] for relief under
the RJA.”
On October 16, 2025, this court ordered the trial court to
show cause why a peremptory writ should not issue directing the
trial court to vacate its February 13, 2025 order and issue a new
order appointing counsel for Lynex. Thereafter, the District
Attorney filed a return in opposition to the petition for writ of
mandate on behalf of the People, and Lynex filed a reply.
STANDARDS OF REVIEW AND APPLICABLE LAW
A. Standards of Review
“[W]hen the issue [on review] . . . is purely legal, such as
the proper interpretation and application of a statute or
constitutional provision, our review is de novo.” (See In re Lugo
(2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 1522, 1535.) “Our fundamental task in
interpreting a statute is to ascertain the Legislature’s intent so
as to effectuate its purpose. [Citation.] We begin with the text of
the statute and give the words their usual meaning while
construing them in light of the statutory framework as a whole.
[Citation.] If the statutory language is unambiguous, then its
plain meaning controls. [Citation.] If the language ‘ “ ‘permits
more than one reasonable interpretation, courts may consider
other aids, such as the statute’s purpose, legislative history, and
public policy.’ [Citation.] . . . . ” ’ [Citation.]” (People v. Carter
(2023) 97 Cal.App.5th 960, 967 (Carter).)
“Discretionary decisions by the trial court are generally
subject to appellate review under the abuse of discretion
standard to determine if they were within the bounds of some
8
applicable legal criteria.” (People v. Hodge (2024)
107 Cal.App.5th 985, 998.)
B. The Racial Justice Act
In 2020, the Legislature enacted the Racial Justice Act.
(McIntosh v. Superior Court (2025) 110 Cal.App.5th 33, 39, 43
(McIntosh).) “The purpose of the [Act] is to ‘purge racial
discrimination from our criminal justice system’ [citation]”
(McIntosh, at p. 43), and to “ ‘ensure that race plays no role at all
in seeking or obtaining convictions or in sentencing’ [citation]”
(People v. Lawson (2025) 108 Cal.App.5th 990, 993 (Lawson),
quoting Stats. 2020, ch. 317, § 2, subd. (i)). “In passing the [A]ct,
the Legislature recognized that racial bias ‘persists’ in our
criminal justice system ‘because courts generally only address
racial bias in its most extreme and blatant forms.’ [Citation.]
The [A]ct acknowledges that ‘all persons possess implicit biases’
that ‘impact the criminal justice system,’ and these biases ‘tend to
disfavor people of color.’ [Citation.]” (Lawson, at p. 993, quoting
Stats. 2020, ch. 317, § 2, subds. (c) & (g).)
The Racial Justice Act added section 745 (see Stats. 2020,
ch. 317, § 3.5), which sets forth legal standards governing a claim
for relief under the Act. (See Standards of Review & Applicable
Law, part B.1, post.) “ ‘[T]he [Act also] amended section 1473,
which identifies bases for prosecuting a petition for writ of
habeas corpus, to add a subdivision governing the litigation of
R[acial Justice Act] claims[,]’ ” to wit, subdivision (e) of the
statute. (See McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at p. 43.) We
next describe in further detail provisions of section 745 and
subdivision (e) of section 1473 that are pertinent to this writ
proceeding.
9
1. Section 745
“The state shall not seek or obtain a criminal conviction or
seek, obtain, or impose a sentence on the basis of race, ethnicity,
or national origin.” (§ 745, subd. (a).) “[S]ection 745,
subdivision (a) . . . sets forth four categories of conduct that, if
proven by a preponderance of the evidence, establish a violation
of the [Racial Justice A]ct.” (Lawson, supra, 108 Cal.App.5th at
p. 998.) “The defendant does not need to prove intentional
discrimination.” (§ 745, subd. (c)(2).)
As relevant here, section 745, subdivision (a)(3) provides a
violation of the Act occurs if: “The defendant was charged or
convicted of a more serious offense than defendants of other
races, ethnicities, or national origins who have engaged in similar
conduct and are similarly situated, and the evidence establishes
that the prosecution more frequently sought or obtained
convictions for more serious offenses against people who share
the defendant’s race, ethnicity, or national origin in the county
where the convictions were sought or obtained.” (§ 745,
subd. (a)(3).)
Similarly, section 745, subdivision (a)(4)(A) applies when:
“A longer or more severe sentence was imposed on the defendant
than was imposed on other similarly situated individuals
convicted of the same offense, and longer or more severe
sentences were more frequently imposed for that offense on
people that share the defendant’s race, ethnicity, or national
origin than on defendants of other races, ethnicities, or national
10
origins in the county where the sentence was imposed.” (§ 745,
subd. (a)(4)(A).) 9
Section 745, subdivision (e) sets forth the remedies
available in the event the trial court finds a violation of
subdivision (a). (See § 745, subd. (e).) For instance, “After a
judgment has been entered, if the court finds that a conviction
was sought or obtained in violation of subdivision (a) [of
section 745], the court shall vacate the conviction and sentence,
find that it is legally invalid, and order new proceedings
consistent with subdivision (a). If the court finds that the only
violation of subdivision (a) that occurred is based on
paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), the court may modify the
judgment to a lesser included or lesser related offense. On
resentencing, the court shall not impose a new sentence greater
than that previously imposed.” (Id., subd. (e)(2)(A).) Another
provision of subdivision (e) states: “After a judgment has been
entered, if the court finds that only the sentence was sought,
obtained, or imposed in violation of subdivision (a), the court
shall vacate the sentence, find that it is legally invalid, and
impose a new sentence. On resentencing, the court shall not
impose a new sentence greater than that previously imposed.”
(Id., subd. (e)(2)(B).)
Subdivision (h) of section 745 defines certain terms used in
the statute, including “ ‘[m]ore frequently sought or obtained’ or
9 Neither party clarifies whether a firearm enhancement
under section 12022.53, subdivision (d) constitutes an “offense”
for purposes of section 745, subdivision (a)(3) or a “sentence”
under subdivision (a)(4)(A). We need not decide that issue
because its resolution would not impact our disposition of the
instant writ petition.
11
‘more frequently imposed’ ” (§ 745, subd. (h)(1)), “ ‘[p]rima facie
showing[,]’ ” (id., subd. (h)(2)), and “ ‘[s]imilarly situated’ ” (id.,
subd. (h)(6)). Of note, “ ‘[m]ore frequently sought or obtained’ or
‘more frequently imposed’ means [in pertinent part] that the
totality of the evidence demonstrates a significant difference in
seeking or obtaining convictions or in imposing sentences
comparing individuals who have engaged in similar conduct and
are similarly situated, and the prosecution cannot establish race-
neutral reasons for the disparity.” (Id., subd. (h)(1).) “The
evidence may include statistical evidence, aggregate data, or
nonstatistical evidence. Statistical significance is a factor the
court may consider, but is not necessary to establish a significant
difference. In evaluating the totality of the evidence, the court
shall consider whether systemic and institutional racial bias,
racial profiling, and historical patterns of racially biased policing
and prosecution may have contributed to, or caused differences
observed in, the data or impacted the availability of data overall.”
(Ibid.)
2. Section 1473, Subdivision (e)
As a preliminary matter, we note that the District Attorney
assumes that the version of section 1473, subdivision (e) that
became effective on January 1, 2026 applies to the instant writ
proceedings because it went into effect “before resolution of this
petition . . . .” Lynex makes that assumption as well.
Accordingly, we proceed on the assumption that version of
subdivision (e) of section 1473 applies. (See Williams v. Superior
Court (1964) 226 Cal.App.2d 666, 674 [“ ‘An express concession or
assertion in a brief is frequently treated as an admission of a
legal or factual point, controlling in the disposition of the case[,]’ ”
second & third italics added]; see also People v. Tran (2022)
12
13 Cal.5th 1169, 1206–1207 [noting that statutory amendments
may apply retroactively to criminal cases under certain
circumstances]; County of Los Angeles v. Niblett (2025)
116 Cal.App.5th 454, 458, fn. 2 [assuming for the sake of an
appeal that the parties identified the version of the relevant
statute that governed review of the trial court’s ruling].)
Section 1473, subdivision (e)(1) clarifies that “[a]ny and all
definitions and legal thresholds specified in Section 745 are
controlling for purposes of claims alleging a violation of
subdivision (a) of Section 745 contained within a habeas petition
filed under this section.” (§ 1473, subd. (e)(1).) Similarly,
subdivision (e)(2) of section 1473 employs the following language
to incorporate by reference the discovery procedures provided in
section 745: “A petitioner, or their counsel, may file a motion for
relevant evidence under subdivision (d) of Section 745 upon the
prosecution of a petition under this subdivision, or in preparation
to file a petition.” (§ 1473, subd. (e)(2)). Subdivision (d) of
section 745 in turn permits a defendant to move for
“disclosure . . . of all evidence relevant to a potential violation of
subdivision (a) [of section 745] in the possession or control of the
state,” which motion is subject to a “good cause” standard. (See
§ 745, subd. (d).)
Regarding appointment of counsel for a habeas petition
raising a Racial Justice Act claim, section 1473, subdivision (e)(5)
provides: “The petition shall state if the petitioner requests
appointment of counsel and the court shall appoint counsel if the
petitioner cannot afford counsel and either the petition pleads a
plausible allegation of a violation of subdivision (a) of Section 745
or the State Public Defender requests counsel be appointed.
13
Newly appointed counsel may amend a petition filed before their
appointment.” (§ 1473, subd. (e)(5), italics added.)
The statute requires the trial court to “issue an order to
show cause why relief shall not be granted and hold an
evidentiary hearing” “[i]f the petitioner makes a prima facie
showing . . . .” (See § 1473, subd. (e)(7)(B).)
The statute also restricts the trial court’s authority to
invoke procedural bars to a habeas petition raising a Racial
Justice Act claim: “A petition raising a claim of this nature for
the first time, or on the basis of new discovery provided by the
state or other new evidence that could not have been previously
known by the petitioner with due diligence, shall not be deemed a
successive or abusive petition.” (§ 1473, subd. (e)(3).)
Lastly, “[i]f the court finds a violation of subdivision (a) [of
section 745], the court shall impose one or more of the applicable
remedies outlined in subdivision (e) of Section 745.” (See § 1473,
subd. (e)(8).) As we observed in our Standards of Review and
Applicable Law, part B.1, ante, section 745, subdivision (e)
authorizes a court to, inter alia, reduce the sentence imposed on
the defendant.
3. The Legislative Findings Accompanying the
Amendments to Section 1473, Subdivision (e)
and McIntosh’s Interpretation of the Statute
As we noted above, section 1473, subdivision (e)(5) requires
the trial court to appoint counsel for an indigent habeas
petitioner if he or she “pleads a plausible allegation of a violation
of subdivision (a) of Section 745 . . . .” (See § 1473, subd. (e)(5).)
This text is terse. Accordingly, we consider the findings included
in the legislation that added this provision to the Racial Justice
Act as an aid in interpreting the “plausible allegation” standard
14
set forth in the statute. (See ibid.; see also Carter, supra, 97
Cal.App.5th at pp. 967–968 [“If the [statutory] language ‘ “
‘permits more than one reasonable interpretation, courts may
consider other aids, such as the statute’s purpose, legislative
history, and public policy.’ [Citation.] . . .” ’ [Citation.] [¶] ‘In
considering the purpose of legislation, statements of the intent of
the enacting body contained in a preamble, while not conclusive,
are entitled to consideration.’ [Citation.] Although such
uncodified statements do not confer power, they ‘properly may be
utilized as an aid in construing a statute.’ ”].)
In the legislation amending section 1473, subdivision (e)
effective January 1, 2026, the Legislature emphasized the
“extremely low” showing a petitioner must make to obtain
counsel: “The [Act’s] threshold to secure counsel is extremely
low, and yet courts have denied counsel to litigants raising
R[acial Justice Act] claims far more than they have appointed
counsel. . . . The Legislature reaffirms that the threshold
showing for appointment of counsel does not require a prima facie
showing, as correctly held by McIntosh v. Superior Court (2025)
110 Cal.App.5th 33, and should be construed as a minimal
pleading requirement.” (See Stats. 2025, ch. 721, § 1, subd. (b)
[Assem. Bill No. 1071, filed with Sec’y of State on Oct. 13, 2025];
see also Stats. 2025, ch. 721, § 3 [amending Pen. Code, § 1473].)
Because the Legislature cited McIntosh with approval, we
detail its analysis of the pleading standard governing requests for
appointment of counsel. (Cf. People v. Brown (2016)
247 Cal.App.4th 1430, 1436 [“If the Legislature amends or
reenacts the statute without changing the interpretation placed
on that statute by the courts, ‘ “the Legislature is presumed to
have been aware of, and acquiesced in, the courts’ construction of
15
that statute.” ’ ”].) In McIntosh, a Black criminal defendant filed
a habeas petition raising claims under the Racial Justice Act, and
sought appointment of counsel to help him prosecute his petition.
(McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 39–40.) The defendant
maintained, among other things, that the San Diego District
Attorney’s Office violated the Act by “charg[ing] gang
enhancements (§ 186.22, subd. (b)) and enhancements for
personal use of a firearm (§ 12022.53, subd. (d)) more frequently
against similarly situated people who share [the defendant’s] race
than others . . . .” (See McIntosh, at p. 40.) The trial court denied
the defendant’s request for counsel based on its finding that he
had not made the prima facie showing required for issuance of an
order to show cause. (Id. at p. 39.) The defendant subsequently
filed a habeas petition in the Court of Appeal, which the
appellate court construed as a petition for writ of mandate
concerning the trial court’s denial of the defendant’s request for
counsel. (See id. at pp. 40–41, 46–47.)
The McIntosh court issued a writ of mandate directing the
trial court to vacate its order denying the habeas petition and
reconsider the defendant’s request for appointment of counsel.
(See McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 39–40, 46, 48.) The
Court of Appeal held, “[T]he plain language of section 1473[,
subdivision] (e) imposes a duty on trial courts to consider whether
indigent petitioners who request counsel . . . are entitled to
appointed counsel based on an assessment of the adequacy of the
factual allegations in the habeas corpus petition, not an
assessment of the overall sufficiency of the prima facie showing
that must be met to obtain an [order to show cause].” (McIntosh,
at pp. 39–40.) McIntosh explained the version of section 1473,
subdivision (e) in effect prior to January 1, 2026 “require[d]
16
courts to determine whether ‘the petition alleges facts that would
establish a violation of [the Act].’ ” (See McIntosh, at p. 44.) On
the other hand, that prior version of the statute “require[d] courts
to determine whether ‘the petitioner has made a prima facie
showing of entitlement to relief.’ ” (See ibid.) 10
McIntosh held, “[S]ection 1473[, subdivision] (e) limits the
inquiry before the appointment of counsel to an assessment of the
facial sufficiency of the factual allegations in the petition, and to
consideration of whether they adequately allege a violation of the
[Act]. By contrast, the inquiry before issuance of an [order to
show cause] is manifestly broader than mere review of the
adequacy of the factual allegations that appear in the petition.”
(McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 44–45.) The court found
the two inquiries differ in these respects, regardless of whether
“the prima facie showing that has long governed when an [order
to show cause] w[ould] issue . . . [in] habeas corpus proceedings”
applies to Racial Justice Act habeas petitions or the “definition of
‘prima facie showing’ . . . found in section 745, subdivision (h)(2)”
instead governs. (See McIntosh, at pp. 41, 43–45.) 11 “The trial
10 Conversely, the statute now requires the appointment of
counsel for an indigent habeas petitioner if “the petition pleads a
plausible allegation of a violation of [the Racial Justice Act,]” (see
§ 1473, subd. (e)(5)), and obligates the court to “determine if the
petitioner has made a prima facie showing” (see id.,
subd. (e)(7)(A)), instead of “ ‘a prima facie showing of entitlement
to relief’ ” (see McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at p. 44, some
italics omitted).
11 Section 745, subdivision (h)(2) states a “ ‘[p]rima facie
showing’ ” has been made if “the defendant produces facts that, if
true, establish that there is a substantial likelihood that a
violation of subdivision (a) occurred. For purposes of this section,
17
court therefore erred when it denied counsel on the ground that
[the defendant] failed to meet the prima facie showing that is
required to obtain an [order to show cause].” (Id. at p. 46.)
The McIntosh court also provided guidance to the trial
court for its reassessment of the defendant’s request for counsel.
(McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 47–48.) Specifically,
“The purpose of the informal first stage[ ]where . . . the court
decides whether to appoint counsel when R[acial Justice Act]
claims are raised[ ]is to allow for the ‘identification of facially
deficient petitions,’ ones that are so clearly lacking in merit the
court is justified in ‘reject[ing] them summarily, without
requiring formal pleadings.’ [Citations.]” (Id. at p. 47.) Although
“ ‘ “[c]onclusory allegations made without any explanation of the
basis for the allegations” ’ are inadequate to establish a
petitioner’s initial pleading burden in habeas proceedings[,]
[citation]” “the initial pleading requirements . . . ‘do[ ] not place
upon an indigent prisoner . . . any burden of complying with
technicalities; [they] simply demand[ ] of him a measure of
frankness in disclosing his factual situation.’ [Citation.]” (Id. at
p. 48.)
“ ‘[T]o assist the court in determining the petition’s
sufficiency, the court may request an informal response from the
petitioner’s custodian or the real party in interest.’ [Citation.]”
(McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 42–43; see also id. at
p. 47 [“The informal response and reply, if requested, serve to
assist the court in this ‘screening function.’ ”].) Further, as we
note in greater detail in Discussion, part B, post, McIntosh
a ‘substantial likelihood’ requires more than a mere possibility,
but less than a standard of more likely than not.” (§ 745,
subd. (h)(2).)
18
recognized the trial court has discretion at the informal first
stage to permit amendment of the petition or deny the petition
without prejudice. (McIntosh, at p. 47.)
DISCUSSION
As we noted earlier, section 1473, subdivision (e)(5)
provides in relevant part that a habeas petition raising a claim
under the Racial Justice Act “shall state if the petitioner requests
appointment of counsel and the court shall appoint counsel if the
petitioner cannot afford counsel and . . . the petition pleads a
plausible allegation of a violation of subdivision (a) of
Section 745 . . . .” (See § 1473, subd. (e)(5).) The District
Attorney “do[es] not dispute that Lynex cannot afford counsel.”
The District Attorney nonetheless argues we should deny writ
relief to Lynex because he did not plead a plausible allegation of a
violation of the Act. The District Attorney further maintains the
trial court correctly found that Lynex’s habeas petition is
procedurally barred.
In our Discussion, parts B and C, post, we reject these
arguments. Before turning to those issues, we explain that the
trial court applied the wrong legal standard in assessing Lynex’s
request for counsel. (Discussion, part A, post.) 12
12 In a letter filed on May 23, 2025, Lynex requested
judicial notice of a notice of filing of a notice of appeal seeking
review of an order the trial court issued on February 28, 2025.
We deny Lynex’s request for judicial notice because he fails to
explain what relevance this document has on our review of the
trial court’s February 13, 2025 order denying his habeas petition.
(Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, supra,
94 Cal.App.5th at p. 792, fn. 23 [noting that an appellate court
19
A. The District Attorney Concedes, and We Agree, the
Trial Court Erred In Requiring Lynex To Make a
Prima Facie Showing of Entitlement to Relief To
Secure Appointment of Counsel
The District Attorney acknowledges the trial court “applied
the wrong legal standard” (boldface omitted) when it denied
Lynex’s request for counsel based on its conclusion he “failed to
make a prima facie showing that he was entitled to relief.” The
District Attorney maintains Lynex’s entitlement to counsel
hinges on whether he pleaded a “ ‘plausible allegation of a
violation of [the Racial Justice Act] . . . .’ ” (Quoting § 1473,
subd. (e)(5).) We agree. (Procedural Background, ante [noting
the trial court denied Lynex’s request for counsel on the ground
he failed to make a prima facie showing of entitlement to relief].)
B. We Reject the District Attorney’s Contention We
Should Deny Lynex Writ Relief on the Ground He
Failed To Plead a Plausible Racial Justice Act Claim
Notwithstanding the trial court’s employment of the wrong
legal standard to assess Lynex’s request for appointment of
counsel, the District Attorney argues we should not remedy this
error by way of a writ of mandate because Lynex failed to
“plead[ ] ‘a plausible allegation of [a Racial Justice Act
violation]’ ” for purposes of section 1473, subdivision (e)(5). In
particular, the District Attorney maintains, (1) “The bare racial
breakdown of offenders in a given period does not raise any
inference of bias,” and (2) Lynex “made no showing that there
was any charging rate disparity between similarly situated
may deny a request for judicial notice of materials not relevant to
its determination of the issues on review].)
20
suspects, i.e., that some significant number of White people (or
some other group) who murdered someone with a gun could have
been charged with murder with [a] gun allegation [under
section 12022.53, subdivision (d)], but were not.”
By arguing that Lynex cannot secure appointment of
counsel “even under the correct standard,” the District Attorney
seems to be invoking the following rule of appellate procedure:
“ ‘ “ ‘[A] ruling or decision, itself correct in law, will not be
disturbed . . . merely because [it was] given for a wrong
reason.’ ” ’ ” (See People v. Camacho (2022) 14 Cal.5th 77, 124.)
That rule is inapplicable here. As we explain below, regardless of
whether Lynex pleaded a plausible allegation of a Racial Justice
Act violation, the trial court’s denial of Lynex’s request for
appointment of counsel was erroneous because the court was
unaware of its discretion to permit Lynex to amend his petition to
satisfy the minimal pleading burden governing his request for
counsel.
“ ‘ “If the court’s decision is influenced by an erroneous
understanding of applicable law or reflects an unawareness of the
full scope of its discretion, the court has not properly exercised its
discretion under the law. [Citation.] Therefore, a discretionary
order based on an application of improper criteria or incorrect
legal assumptions is not an exercise of informed discretion and is
subject to reversal.” [Citation.] Simply stated, “an abuse of
discretion arises if the trial court based its decision on
impermissible factors [citation] or on an incorrect legal
standard.” ’ [Citation.]” (People v. K.D. (2025) 110 Cal.App.5th 1,
19 (K.D.).)
In asserting we may review the sufficiency of Lynex’s
pleading in the first instance under section 1473,
21
subdivision (e)(5), the District Attorney overlooks a key
discretionary component of a trial court’s ruling on a request for
appointment of counsel in this context. Specifically, the McIntosh
court explained, “During this initial, informal stage,” the trial
court “ ‘has the authority to invite amended or supplemental
habeas corpus petitions in the interests of justice.’ [Citation.]”
(See McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 46–47.) McIntosh
observed that “the policy of ‘[l]iberality in permitting amendment
is the rule’ as it is in civil cases,” and “[t]he availability of
procedures permitting amendment of an unrepresented
petitioner’s petition is exceptionally important in the context of
R[acial Justice Act] claims given the stated objective of the
Legislature that litigants have meaningful opportunities to
present their claims.” (See id. at pp. 47–48.) 13 Thus, before
ruling on a request to appoint counsel, a trial court may exercise
its discretion to permit a defendant to amend his or her petition
to satisfy section 1473, subdivision (e)(5)’s pleading standard.
As we explained in our Discussion, part A, ante, the trial
court faulted Lynex for failing to make a prima facie showing of
entitlement to relief under the Act, which is a more exacting
showing than that required by subdivision (e)(5) of section 1473.
The trial court’s ruling predated: (1) McIntosh’s clarification that
(a) a request for appointment of counsel does not call for “an
assessment of the overall sufficiency of the prima facie showing
that must be met to obtain an [order to show cause]” and (b) a
13 McIntosh further explained, “An inexpertly drafted
petition may also appropriately be denied without prejudice to
filing a new petition that meets the requirements for stating a
habeas corpus claim.” (See McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at
p. 47.)
22
trial court has discretion to permit a defendant to amend his or
her petition to allege sufficient facts to secure appointment of
counsel (see McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 40, 46–48
[opinion issued on Mar. 28, 2025]); and (2) the Legislature’s
findings that (a) McIntosh “correctly held” “the threshold showing
for appointment of counsel does not require a prima facie
showing” and (b) the standard for appointment of counsel is
“extremely low” and “should be construed as a minimal pleading
requirement” (see Stats. 2025, ch. 721, § 1, subd. (b) [Assem. Bill
No. 1071, filed with Sec’y of State on Oct. 13, 2025]).
Accordingly, when the trial court denied Lynex’s request for
appointment of counsel, the court was unaware of its discretion to
allow him to amend his petition to meet a pleading standard that
is lower than the prima facie showing required for issuance of an
order to show cause. Because a “ ‘ “decision . . . influenced by . . .
an unawareness of the full scope of [the court’s] discretion” ’ ” or
“ ‘ “incorrect legal assumptions” ’ ” is erroneous and “ ‘ “subject to
reversal” ’ ” (see K.D., supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at p. 19), we do not
agree with the District Attorney’s apparent argument that in
denying Lynex’s request for counsel, the trial court merely cited
an erroneous reason for arriving at the legally correct result.
If the trial court ultimately determines after issuance of
our writ of mandate that Lynex has not “plead[ed] a plausible
allegation of a violation” of the Racial Justice Act (see § 1473,
subd. (e)(5)), the court may then consider whether to exercise its
discretion to grant Lynex leave to amend his petition. 14
14 Anticipating that Lynex may allege facts showing “the
existence of a large disparity in charges compared to a group’s
percentage of the population,” the District Attorney argues such
averments would not “inherently raise[ ] a plausible allegation of
23
C. The Trial Court Erred In Denying Lynex’s Habeas
Petition on the Ground It Was Procedurally Barred
In its February 13, 2025 ruling denying Lynex’s habeas
petition, the trial court acknowledged that Lynex claimed to have
offered data “ ‘show[ing] a pattern of higher charging for people
sharing his race in Los Angeles County.’ ” The court found that
Lynex’s Racial Justice Act claim predicated on this data was
“successive” and therefore “procedurally barred” because the
court had rejected a similar claim in its April 2024 order denying
his prior habeas petition.
The District Attorney argues the trial court “properly
invoked [this] procedural bar[ ] to deny” Lynex’s habeas petition
because he “has shown no justification for his successive claims.”
(Boldface omitted.) The District Attorney further contends the
Legislature impliedly preserved this procedural bar in the Act by
carving out of the definition of “ ‘successive or abusive
petition[s]’ ” only those pleadings “ ‘raising a claim of this nature
for the first time, or on the basis of new discovery provided by the
bias.” Specifically, the District Attorney maintains (1) “no one
reasonably believes that gun murders are evenly distributed
throughout the county”; and (2) “there is no reason to presume, in
the absence of evidence, that the . . . District Attorney . . . was not
charging virtually every gun homicide as a murder with the
appropriate gun allegation during th[e] time” period in question.
We decline to render an advisory opinion as to the viability
of allegations Lynex may include in an amended petition. If
Lynex later alleges facts indicative of a large disparity in charges
compared to a racial group’s percentage of the population, then
the trial court may pass upon the sufficiency of those averments
at the appropriate juncture.
24
state or other new evidence that could not have been previously
known by the petitioner with due diligence . . . .’ ” (Quoting
§ 1473, subd. (e)(3).) In essence, the District Attorney maintains
that at the “initial” “ ‘screening’ ” stage of the habeas proceedings
(see McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at p. 47), Lynex was
required to anticipate the bar on successive petitions and explain
why he did not previously offer the aforementioned data to
support his Racial Justice Act claim. We disagree.
McIntosh held that habeas petitioners raising Racial
Justice Act claims are not required to “address and explain
potential procedural bars” “to obtain appointment of
counsel . . . .” (See McIntosh, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at p. 45.)
McIntosh explained that “section 1473[, subdivision] (e) limits the
inquiry before the appointment of counsel to an assessment . . . of
whether [the petition] adequately allege[s] a violation of the
R[acial Justice Act,]” and does not call for a “broader” assessment
of whether the petitioner is “ ‘entitle[d] to relief’ ” under the
statute. (See McIntosh, at pp. 44–45.) Accordingly, the trial
court erred in denying Lynex’s request for counsel on account of
his failure to anticipate and refute the potential applicability of
the procedural bar on successive petitions.
We further note that whether the District Attorney’s data
is “evidence that could . . . have been previously known by the
petitioner with due diligence” (see § 1473, subd. (e)(3)) is far from
clear. The trial court did not make any findings on Lynex’s due
diligence as to discovery of this evidence. Furthermore, the
District Attorney acknowledges: (1) Lynex obtained the data in
question through “a Public Records Act request” “from the Los
Angeles County District Attorney’s Office,” and (2) the District
Attorney responded to this Public Records Act request via
25
correspondence dated April 11, 2024. In any event, as we
explained above, whether Lynex diligently sought discovery of
this evidence is not relevant to the trial court’s initial
“assessment of the facial sufficiency of the factual allegations in
the petition[ ] and . . . whether they adequately allege a violation
of the R[acial Justice Act].” (See McIntosh, supra,
110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 44–45.)
DISPOSITION
Let a writ of mandate issue directing the trial court to
(1) vacate its February 13, 2025 order denying petitioner Tommie
Lawson Lynex’s petition for writ of habeas corpus, and
(2) conduct further proceedings consistent with this opinion. We
deny the request for judicial notice Lynex filed on May 23, 2025.
BENDIX, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
M. KIM, J.
26
Filed 2/19/26
CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re B344569
TOMMIE LAWSON LYNEX, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. PA034126)
on Habeas Corpus.
CERTIFICATION AND
ORDER FOR
PUBLICATION
[NO CHANGE IN
JUDGMENT]
The opinion in the above-entitled matter filed on
January 27, 2026 was not certified for publication in the
Official Reports. For good cause, it now appears that the opinion
should be published in the Official Reports, and it is so ordered.
There is no change in the judgment.
CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION.
____________________________________________________________
ROTHSCHILD, P. J. BENDIX, J. M. KIM, J.
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.